You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hodgson has to go
November 16 2026 7.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Hodgson has to go


Page 12 of 18 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >
southnorwoodhill Flag 15 Jan 19 3.27pm

All I can say is, Roy, be more attack minded at home. Don't make excuses that you have no options. Options are there but you do not take them, because your mindset is narrow. No plan B? Try alternatives. When you are 2-1 down at home to the likes of Watford what is there to lose?

 

rikz Flag Croydon 15 Jan 19 5.49pm

Originally posted by Painter

Huddersfield have spent over £100m since they were promoted, we haven’t the 9th biggest. Check your facts first.
Roy’s teams have performed well except for maybe 2-3 games, just not had the rub of the green in some and poor finishing in most.
Why aren’t we going to be battling Fulham, Huddersfield and Newcastle for survival, they are in the bottom 3 now.

[Link]

 

Painter Flag Croydon 15 Jan 19 7.36pm

Budget and salaries are not the same. Your little chart shows average salary, so that would depend on how many players on the pay roll. Obviously a club can way below us in your chart, but if they have more players then their wage bill could be higher.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 15 Jan 19 7.40pm

Only table that matters is the league and that shows hodgson is doing a s*** job.

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 15 Jan 19 7.54pm

Originally posted by rikz

Only table that matters is the league and that shows hodgson is doing a s*** job.

Our only issue is not scoring

He inherited benteke and Wickham was already injured. We need a striker. We have no money

What part of this is roys fault? He’s presented a team that attacks at will but need decent front men.

Yes he fkd up with sorloth but only had 10 m to spend and who knows, that Norwegian club May had accepted 1m up front cos we are skint. Not many teams would accept the money we have available after big January spends in recent years

None of this is roys fault.

My only gripe would be has should make earlier subs but even if that happened I’d bet it wouldn’t have made that much of a major difference

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 15 Jan 19 8.25pm

Originally posted by Painter

What is your definition of a bad manager?

A number of ex international players have publicly stated Roy was the best club manager they played under. When have you ever met him or played for him?


..I was playing a bit of irony to the post above, if you read the posts on here it's quite obvious the way I feel.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 15 Jan 19 8.31pm

Originally posted by rikz

Only table that matters is the league and that shows hodgson is doing a s*** job.

Is it the one that show's we are 14th in the best league in the world?

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 15 Jan 19 8.36pm

Originally posted by matthau

Our only issue is not scoring

He inherited benteke and Wickham was already injured. We need a striker. We have no money

What part of this is roys fault? He’s presented a team that attacks at will but need decent front men.

Yes he fkd up with sorloth but only had 10 m to spend and who knows, that Norwegian club May had accepted 1m up front cos we are skint. Not many teams would accept the money we have available after big January spends in recent years

None of this is roys fault.

My only gripe would be has should make earlier subs but even if that happened I’d bet it wouldn’t have made that much of a major difference

Yes, quite right.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 15 Jan 19 8.48pm

Originally posted by steven_t92

Think he should retire in the summer, has struggled to make decisions this year with subs and we always seem to make them after we have gone behind instead of when we can all see the tide turning in matches.

We need a manager with top league experience but still with some youth on their side.

Like it did against Wolves?

 

johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 15 Jan 19 9.03pm

Roy is a good man, knowledgable manager. He works pragmatically with the players. The players give their all. what more can be done.

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 15 Jan 19 9.05pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Which games exactly in your eyes were boring then?

Newcastle, Saints, Chelsea, Watford (mostly), Wolves (h), Leicester arguably as despite us winning the football was dreadful

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 15 Jan 19 11.21pm

Originally posted by iheartcpfc

Newcastle, Saints, Chelsea, Watford (mostly), Wolves (h), Leicester arguably as despite us winning the football was dreadful


Martin Dubravka motm, Alex McCarthy motm, Chelsea were too good on the day for us, Ben Foster motm, we created enough chances against Wolves but their keeper although very good on the day wasn't motm, in the first half against Leicester we were good and tested Schmeichel very well, but the second steadily got worse and we were not good to watch.
Other keeper motm's was gainst Spurs at home Hugo Lloris and away at Everton with Jordan Pickford.

 

jeeagles Flag 15 Jan 19 11.30pm

Originally posted by matthau

Our only issue is not scoring

He inherited benteke and Wickham was already injured. We need a striker. We have no money

What part of this is roys fault? He’s presented a team that attacks at will but need decent front men.

Yes he fkd up with sorloth but only had 10 m to spend and who knows, that Norwegian club May had accepted 1m up front cos we are skint. Not many teams would accept the money we have available after big January spends in recent years

None of this is roys fault.

My only gripe would be has should make earlier subs but even if that happened I’d bet it wouldn’t have made that much of a major difference

He inherited a £30M striker who scored 17 goals the season before Roy arrived?

 

jhillman Flag USA 16 Jan 19 12.45am

Originally posted by johnmcormick8

Roy is a good man, knowledgable manager. He works pragmatically with the players. The players give their all. what more can be done.

I couldn't agree more. It's funny how as soon as we lose a game, the usual crew wants a new manager. It's football - some you win and some you lose.

Who else are we going to get that has the experience and know-how of Roy? Personally, I think we have one of the fittest and most skillful teams I can remember. The organisation of the team is so much better now - not by accident, but by Roy's hands-on approach on the training ground. I think he's done wonders with the options that he has - and when it comes to subs, I reckon Roy's in a better position to know who's fit and performing well than any of the "pundits" on this message board.

We're still hovering around the point-a-game average, which, by the way, might have been better had some clown not sold Murray.

 


As a kid in the mid-1950s, seeing the old floodlights from our kitchen window in Whitworth Road, the writing was on the wall.

Maine Eagle Flag USA 16 Jan 19 2.40pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

He inherited a £30M striker who scored 17 goals the season before Roy arrived?

You can blame Hodgson for many, MANY things, and believe me I do, but he is not responsible for Benteke missing sitter after sitter.

It was as if someone had put a curse on, it was painful, chance after chance went begging.

It is RH's responsibility to fashion the chances through his tactical choices and personnel choices. It is the job of any striker at a premier league club to score realistic goal chances more often than not.

I will agree that RH did not seemingly deploy a system to work to Benteke's strengths, but I personally sat and watched him miss countless clear cut goal chances. You cant blame Roy for that.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 16 Jan 19 3.39pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

You can blame Hodgson for many, MANY things, and believe me I do, but he is not responsible for Benteke missing sitter after sitter.

It was as if someone had put a curse on, it was painful, chance after chance went begging.

It is RH's responsibility to fashion the chances through his tactical choices and personnel choices. It is the job of any striker at a premier league club to score realistic goal chances more often than not.

I will agree that RH did not seemingly deploy a system to work to Benteke's strengths, but I personally sat and watched him miss countless clear cut goal chances. You cant blame Roy for that.

Javier Hernandez (Chicarito) is a terrific finisher !

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 16 Jan 19 3.49pm

Originally posted by Willo

Javier Hernandez (Chicarito) is a terrific finisher !

Yes, he isn’t quick, he isn’t particularly skilful or tricky, but he knows where to position himself and doesn’t miss many opportunities. I would have liked us to have signed him several times in the past. He would be my choice of an ‘older’ player to sort out Roy’s scoring woes.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 16 Jan 19 3.49pm

Can't believe there's even a discussion. Roy has done a perfectly good job with what he's had, would have had us in the top ten if he was able to call upon a decent striker, and may yet get us there or thereabouts even without one.

A couple of additional points...

1. Roy plainly doesn't handle scouting and transfers, Dougie and the chairman do. So even if you don't like Roy, you can't use any perceived failings in the market against him.

2. Who exactly does anyone think we would get instead of Roy? Guardiola perhaps? Pochettino? Mourinho is at a loose end, perhaps him? Oh hang on, my alarm clock has just woken me up....

3, I really do wonder if some people posting on here actually go to the games, or if they do, whether they are suffering with memory issues. We may not always sparkle under Roy, but the football is plainly better than that produced under allardyce and Pulis, who played overtly negative football. Having also had our fingers burnt trying to over play with de boer and Holloway, we finally have a manager who gets the balance about right between defence and attack (ie. about 60/40).

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 16 Jan 19 3.54pm


Yeah yeah now let’s talk about the injury he was carrying which we couldn’t afford for him to undertake an op cos we had no other strikers but when we realised he was s***e as a result of carrying that injury we put him in for the op.

Let’s not ignore this small detail eh


Which takes us back to - not roys fault


Originally posted by jeeagles

He inherited a £30M striker who scored 17 goals the season before Roy arrived?

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 16 Jan 19 3.58pm

I Agree, Roy does have to go....to Anfield with the rest of the players.

He then has to come back and carry on with his job.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Page 12 of 18 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hodgson has to go