You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Topic
November 22 2026 1.13pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Rhian Brewster (rumour) (LOCKED)


Page 12 of 14 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
Teddy Eagle Flag 30 Sep 20 1.44am


But are they really selling him? It’s more like a loan to let another team help his development.

 

EddieMac Flag 30 Sep 20 7.42am

Buy back clauses have been inserted into contracts for a long time but Iv never actually heard of a team activate one. Nathan Ake is a good example.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 30 Sep 20 8.14am

Originally posted by mattteo

Spurs arw probably getting Milik from Napoli. Used to be really giod too, but looks trash after having broken his leg.

Can't imagine they would actually prefer Benteke though.


You never know
[Link]

 

taylors lovechild Flag 30 Sep 20 8.50am

Personally I think we need someone in the mould of Mitrovic who can score but who is also capable of bullying defenders and holding the ball up to bring others into play. From all the accounts I've read Brewster is a pure fox in the box striker, which apparently is also why Liverpool are willing to let him go. For me, £17-20m is a big risk on someone with very little senior experience and none of it at PL level. The only way I'd go that high is if half of it was based on targets such as appearances and goals.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 30 Sep 20 9.05am

According to the media Brewster's advisors are telling him that Sheffield would be better for his development than either ourselves or Villa and to be honest it's hard to disagree with them.

It's interesting what all of the ITK people make of this as Brewster to Palace was as good as done. I'm not just referring to dazza but to all those journalists who are supposedly close to the club

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 30 Sep 20 9.13am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

According to the media Brewster's advisors are telling him that Sheffield would be better for his development than either ourselves or Villa and to be honest it's hard to disagree with them.

It's interesting what all of the ITK people make of this as Brewster to Palace was as good as done. I'm not just referring to dazza but to all those journalists who are supposedly close to the club

My hope is that the added bonus from Sorloths sale, and perhaps now a bit more incoming dosh means we have set sights higher.

I said my 'hope' remember... nothing more than that!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

taylors lovechild Flag 30 Sep 20 9.14am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

According to the media Brewster's advisors are telling him that Sheffield would be better for his development than either ourselves or Villa and to be honest it's hard to disagree with them.

It's interesting what all of the ITK people make of this as Brewster to Palace was as good as done. I'm not just referring to dazza but to all those journalists who are supposedly close to the club

Parish's unusual outburst suggests either it was media twaddle, or we were possibly being used by Liverpool or Brewster's team to drive up interest/the fee. Weren't we previously linked with Solanke before he eventually signed for 20m with Bournemouth? Maybe Parish is getting fed up with Palace being used like a ghost bidder on eBay.

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 30 Sep 20 9.32am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

According to the media Brewster's advisors are telling him that Sheffield would be better for his development than either ourselves or Villa and to be honest it's hard to disagree with them.

It's interesting what all of the ITK people make of this as Brewster to Palace was as good as done. I'm not just referring to dazza but to all those journalists who are supposedly close to the club

Yes it does look like the balance is tilting towards Sheffield 'according to rumour'

[Link]

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 30 Sep 20 9.51am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

According to the media Brewster's advisors are telling him that Sheffield would be better for his development than either ourselves or Villa and to be honest it's hard to disagree with them.

It's interesting what all of the ITK people make of this as Brewster to Palace was as good as done. I'm not just referring to dazza but to all those journalists who are supposedly close to the club

Isn't it just lovely that teams such as ours are seen as a development route for a player rather than a home? Jeez he is only a kid and plenty of them have failed to produce the goods at this level over the years.

"Yeh, I'll sign", he says resignedly, "I'll hang around for a couple of years and then feck off"

Best left alone I reckon. I am with taylors lovechild, I reckon we need a CF who can bully defences and attract both centre halfs to him, Mitrovic certainly fits the bill there.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 30 Sep 20 10.19am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Isn't it just lovely that teams such as ours are seen as a development route for a player rather than a home? Jeez he is only a kid and plenty of them have failed to produce the goods at this level over the years.

"Yeh, I'll sign", he says resignedly, "I'll hang around for a couple of years and then feck off"

I must admit that I didn't read it like that as I saw it that Brewster had a lot of potential that Sheffield United were more likely to bring out in him than we were and nothing at all about only staying for a short while.

Originally posted by Eaglecoops


I am with taylors lovechild,

Does Taylor know?

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 30 Sep 20 10.49am

I wonder if the board believe that Wilf will remain with us and is happy to play in a front two role. If he does stay and play up front with (currently) Ayew or (probably soon) Batshuayi, where would Brewster fit in? Although we have Bats on loan, it appears we have an option to buy at a fixed price, so presumably we will want to play him as one of our main strikers.

What we need is a young striker who's prepared to be back-up for this year and I don't see Brewster in that role (nor for that matter Edouard, whose name has surfaced again in rumours linking him to us).

Brewster's advisors are probably right if they are indeed suggesting Sheff U as the better option. Sheff U are in danger of doing a Palace of 3 years ago (3 games played no points and no goals so far and it's not as if they've played any top clubs), so need a striker.

I suspect we'll be left with Wickham, so in theory we would have another striker option.

Finally, I think Liverpool want to retain some hold over Brewster for the future but need to get some funds in having bought Thiago and Jota.

Edited by doombear (30 Sep 2020 10.50am)

 

taylors lovechild Flag 30 Sep 20 5.11pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Does Taylor know?

 

est1905 Flag 30 Sep 20 5.32pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Isn't it just lovely that teams such as ours are seen as a development route for a player rather than a home? Jeez he is only a kid and plenty of them have failed to produce the goods at this level over the years.

"Yeh, I'll sign", he says resignedly, "I'll hang around for a couple of years and then feck off"

Best left alone I reckon. I am with taylors lovechild, I reckon we need a CF who can bully defences and attract both centre halfs to him, Mitrovic certainly fits the bill there.

I think most people would agree that Sheffield United are currently either punching above their weight or at best at the pinnacle of where they can reach whereas Palace, with the players we have are underperforming. Our potential is certainly greater than that of Sheffield United.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 30 Sep 20 7.18pm

Originally posted by est1905

I think most people would agree that Sheffield United are currently either punching above their weight or at best at the pinnacle of where they can reach whereas Palace, with the players we have are underperforming. Our potential is certainly greater than that of Sheffield United.

But where is he more likely to play?

 

Elphers40 Flag Sunny South Coast 30 Sep 20 7.49pm

Originally posted by est1905

I think most people would agree that Sheffield United are currently either punching above their weight or at best at the pinnacle of where they can reach whereas Palace, with the players we have are underperforming. Our potential is certainly greater than that of Sheffield United.

Disagree. They are a well supported similar sized club to us with potential to improve. I agree that the players they have exceeded expectations in the first season in the Prem - but that is very much linked to having an excellent manager who was able to get the maximum out of them all. A few good additions to that squad could see them do okay again this season Brewster would be a start.

The buy back deal is not suited to us - so good luck to Sheffield , except when they play us!

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 30 Sep 20 7.54pm

Originally posted by Elphers40

Disagree. They are a well supported similar sized club to us with potential to improve. I agree that the players they have exceeded expectations in the first season in the Prem - but that is very much linked to having an excellent manager who was able to get the maximum out of them all. A few good additions to that squad could see them do okay again this season Brewster would be a start.

The buy back deal is not suited to us - so good luck to Sheffield , except when they play us!

Just curious, why isn't a buy back clause suitable to us? The buying club would still make a decent profit?

 

Knightstar Flag Guildford 30 Sep 20 11.03pm

Exactly. Buying for £17-20M and getting two good seasons out of a player before selling him back for £40M and making a £20M profit sounds like a good deal to me. The £20M would then contribute to purchasing a decent replacement. However, I suspect our hesitation is more to do with Brewster having to compete with Bats and that might present some difficult issues re game time etc. In any event I'd like to see us pursuing him or a decent alternative as we need extra cover up front.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 01 Oct 20 7.33am

I think a major part of our strategy needs to be buying good young players, getting them to a good standard, and then flogging them for huge profit.

Look at Leicester. Mahrez, Maguire, Drinkwater, Chillwell, even Kante...brilliant work. They will surely sell Maddison soon enough for big bucks. And then no doubt find somebody even better.

Palace simply are not made to be a career home for up amd coming talent. Better to understand that.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

EddieMac Flag 01 Oct 20 8.16am

Originally posted by Knightstar

Exactly. Buying for £17-20M and getting two good seasons out of a player before selling him back for £40M and making a £20M profit sounds like a good deal to me. The £20M would then contribute to purchasing a decent replacement. However, I suspect our hesitation is more to do with Brewster having to compete with Bats and that might present some difficult issues re game time etc. In any event I'd like to see us pursuing him or a decent alternative as we need extra cover up front.

We are more than likely not even bidding for Brewster. 20 million for a player who could turn out to be the next Dominic Solanke.

 

Elphers40 Flag Sunny South Coast 01 Oct 20 8.34am

Originally posted by Petereagle

Just curious, why isn't a buy back clause suitable to us? The buying club would still make a decent profit?

As I understand it Pete - It leaves us with no control or say in the timing of the buy back, which impacts negatively on our ability to build a squad for the longer term. If Brewster tears it up for a season Liverpool can pay £40 million and take him back. We wouldn’t be able to keep him longer or sell him for more to another club.
Okay we’d have made £20 million quid - but imo as a now established premier league club we need to be planning for the longer term and most importantly not be beholden to the big boys. They have always cherrypicked our best players - we must at least be able to control the timing and terms if they try to do so.
There is always a counter argument - but this is my view.

 

Page 12 of 14 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Topic