You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Climate Change Activists
November 21 2026 9.35pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Climate Change Activists


Page 12 of 29 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 26 Jul 23 8.43pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

It's not so much the dates as the cost.
If you're that keen you can pay my share.

Two lines, what a rare treat.

It's relative though, isn't it.

You're paying for new energy sources to be built all the time. Have done for the last 50 years or more.

The government will not want to be in a situation where they're moving too fast and it's costing their electorate. Hence the world 'transition' and dates that will need to be reappraised to suit. Similar to the cost of owning and running an EV – it can't be more expensive than what we pay now for combustion cars, otherwise the whole thing falls apart.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Teddy Eagle Flag 26 Jul 23 8.59pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

Two lines, what a rare treat.

It's relative though, isn't it.

You're paying for new energy sources to be built all the time. Have done for the last 50 years or more.

The government will not want to be in a situation where they're moving too fast and it's costing their electorate. Hence the world 'transition' and dates that will need to be reappraised to suit. Similar to the cost of owning and running an EV – it can't be more expensive than what we pay now for combustion cars, otherwise the whole thing falls apart.


Heat pumps are already more expensive and according to some reports not particularly effective at 4 degrees or less which in Scotland isn't very effective at all.


[Link]

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 26 Jul 23 9.22pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle


Heat pumps are already more expensive and according to some reports not particularly effective at 4 degrees or less which in Scotland isn't very effective at all.


[Link]

I've already covered my issue with banning gas boilers (and why that won't happen in the timeframes they've given) above. It will cost too much, consumers will reject it and isn't practical in the short term. The Scots Govt. will find that out soon enough – it's up there with the just as brilliant idea of 'simply convert everything to Hydrogen'. Inevitable massive recent windback... Moronic.

There are far bigger environmental fish to fry than that anyway. Would be a good move from an energy security perspective though. The sooner we can practically wean off Gas the better.

In terms of heat pumps, specifically, some operate down to -22 with pretty good efficiency from what I can see. They'll be installed in new builds where they have far better insulation and need to be used less (so more cost efficient).

Edited by SW19 CPFC (26 Jul 2023 9.26pm)

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Behind Enemy Lines Flag Sussex 26 Jul 23 9.31pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

I've already covered my issue with banning gas boilers (and why that won't happen in the timeframes they've given) above. It will cost too much, consumers will reject it and isn't practical in the short term. The Scots Govt. will find that out soon enough – it's up there with the just as brilliant idea of 'simply convert everything to Hydrogen'. Inevitable massive recent windback... Moronic.

There are far bigger environmental fish to fry than that anyway. Would be a good move from an energy security perspective though. The sooner we can practically wean off Gas the better.

In terms of heat pumps, specifically, some operate down to -22 with pretty good efficiency from what I can see. They'll be installed in new builds where they have far better insulation and need to be used less (so more cost efficient).

Edited by SW19 CPFC (26 Jul 2023 9.26pm)

It’s difficult for consumers to reject heat pumps (or anything else), if the Government makes it against the law to do so. You place far too much trust in the authorities giving us a say in the process.

 


hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 27 Jul 23 12.05am

Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines

It’s difficult for consumers to reject heat pumps (or anything else), if the Government makes it against the law to do so. You place far too much trust in the authorities giving us a say in the process.

Trust has nothing to do with it. Simple market economics. Too expensive = rejection/unaffordable = business model fail

Hence the hydrogen wind back.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

dreamwaverider Flag London 27 Jul 23 4.42am

Is there anybody else out there who thinks all this global warming green energy brigade is all overkill, Who believes oil and gas still have a big place on the planet and will continue to fuel fast loud cars and bikes and aeroplanes.
And who turns their lights on at night and has a very warm house in the winter ventilated by opening windows? Hot showers and baths and traditional cookers fridges etc.
Loves log and coal fires and garden bonfires and the smell of them. Flies on commercial planes regularly.
Think the vast majority of the green peace, stop oil etc groups are hypocrites, because they must turn their lights on and heat their homes when it goes cold and night time comes.
Doesn't wipe/wash their hands every 5 minutes with disposable cloths, and pees behind trees in a park when the need arises.
Is their anybody else out there who admits they live their life like this?
Only, come winter whenever I go walking at dusk, I see lights on everywhere and the vast majority of people still living the comfort life.
When I walk down from Grange Park where I park up before winter games and the night sky is lit up by the Selhurst floodlights long before the match (and after) no doubt for health and safety reasons, and Sky cameras and machines are everywhere beaming the games out into peoples warm houses that on my walk to and from the ground are all very well lit
And none of them appear guilty about it or planning a change from it.
Just asking

Edited by dreamwaverider (27 Jul 2023 4.50am)

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 27 Jul 23 6.17am

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

I've already covered my issue with banning gas boilers (and why that won't happen in the timeframes they've given) above. It will cost too much, consumers will reject it and isn't practical in the short term. The Scots Govt. will find that out soon enough – it's up there with the just as brilliant idea of 'simply convert everything to Hydrogen'. Inevitable massive recent windback... Moronic.

There are far bigger environmental fish to fry than that anyway. Would be a good move from an energy security perspective though. The sooner we can practically wean off Gas the better.

In terms of heat pumps, specifically, some operate down to -22 with pretty good efficiency from what I can see. They'll be installed in new builds where they have far better insulation and need to be used less (so more cost efficient).

Edited by SW19 CPFC (26 Jul 2023 9.26pm)

You are correct in operating at low temperatures. The problem is that the water that heats your radiators and your hot water in most systems (depending on the refrigerant used) only gets to around 50*c. This means that your current radiators are not big enough. They need to be approximately 50%-60% bigger in surface area to allow the same amount of heat into the space. The pipework will probably need modernising for both zoning and dynamic flow due to the bigger radiators. Your hot water cylinder will need an electric element fitted to get the water past 60* c ( the L8 recommendation).
All this alongside your house or flat etc being over a certain U value. That is just some of the changes needed to get a heat pump to be viable. ( what’s the carbon footprint to manufacture and install that lot). Then you have the tricky calculation of how many KW would your heat pump need to operate; many people have a fuse board able to deliver 60-80 amps. Divide that by 4 (ohmms law) roughly and that’s really the KW that your incoming power cable can safely deliver through the fuse board. ( dependent on the type of load) This might need a bigger cable installed as well. ( diggers, tarmac etc) Your heat pump may be 18Kw so bung an electric shower of say 8 kw on and you do the math.
So yes heat pumps would be electric only and if produced cleanly would be better for the dolphins but it’s not the silver bullet when allied to the above. A rough guesstimate to upgrade the uk electric grid is 4-6 trillion pounds over many years. That’s 3 x our GDP. That’s not goner happen any time soon.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 27 Jul 23 12.55pm

Originally posted by cryrst

You are correct in operating at low temperatures. The problem is that the water that heats your radiators and your hot water in most systems (depending on the refrigerant used) only gets to around 50*c. This means that your current radiators are not big enough. They need to be approximately 50%-60% bigger in surface area to allow the same amount of heat into the space. The pipework will probably need modernising for both zoning and dynamic flow due to the bigger radiators. Your hot water cylinder will need an electric element fitted to get the water past 60* c ( the L8 recommendation).
All this alongside your house or flat etc being over a certain U value. That is just some of the changes needed to get a heat pump to be viable. ( what’s the carbon footprint to manufacture and install that lot). Then you have the tricky calculation of how many KW would your heat pump need to operate; many people have a fuse board able to deliver 60-80 amps. Divide that by 4 (ohmms law) roughly and that’s really the KW that your incoming power cable can safely deliver through the fuse board. ( dependent on the type of load) This might need a bigger cable installed as well. ( diggers, tarmac etc) Your heat pump may be 18Kw so bung an electric shower of say 8 kw on and you do the math.
So yes heat pumps would be electric only and if produced cleanly would be better for the dolphins but it’s not the silver bullet when allied to the above. A rough guesstimate to upgrade the uk electric grid is 4-6 trillion pounds over many years. That’s 3 x our GDP. That’s not goner happen any time soon.

That was literally my point.

New builds > heat pumps

Older houses/flats > very slow process of upgrading over decades either to heat pumps or electric boilers, ideally timed with the grid transition to cheaper and more secure electricity (long term)

In this country at least, it's the only practical, affordable (and logical) solution.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

The groover Flag Danbury 27 Jul 23 5.54pm

I've been doing some number crunching re. Solar panels.

I worked out that having enough panels to give a decent number of hours in the winter months would mean there being a massive excess from spring to autumn.

I came to the conclusion that enough panels to give enough electricity during spring to autumn and batteries that would provide cover for those winter months would be the best way to go.

I was advised that Octopuss energy are offering overnight rates at 10p per unit for 4 hours. Which is enough to charge two 5KW batteries. Thus during those months with less sun you can charge the batteries overnight at a good rate from the grid and use them during the day.

I've installed underfloor electric heating in two rooms and now have 3 electric rads and rest are boiler rads.

I believe this will mean using only overnight rates for 90% of the time. It will also reduce my gas usage as the electric underfloor heating and electric rads will reduce the need for the boiler.

In terms of heat pumps, unless the property is a new build the required modifications will make them uneconomical. Plus as has been said unless they are the type that sources heat from below ground, they don't work under 4 degrees c.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 27 Jul 23 10.13pm

Originally posted by The groover

I've been doing some number crunching re. Solar panels.

I worked out that having enough panels to give a decent number of hours in the winter months would mean there being a massive excess from spring to autumn.

I came to the conclusion that enough panels to give enough electricity during spring to autumn and batteries that would provide cover for those winter months would be the best way to go.

I was advised that Octopuss energy are offering overnight rates at 10p per unit for 4 hours. Which is enough to charge two 5KW batteries. Thus during those months with less sun you can charge the batteries overnight at a good rate from the grid and use them during the day.

I've installed underfloor electric heating in two rooms and now have 3 electric rads and rest are boiler rads.

I believe this will mean using only overnight rates for 90% of the time. It will also reduce my gas usage as the electric underfloor heating and electric rads will reduce the need for the boiler.

In terms of heat pumps, unless the property is a new build the required modifications will make them uneconomical. Plus as has been said unless they are the type that sources heat from below ground, they don't work under 4 degrees c.

Finally some sense

Battery storage is going to be massively important as part of the energy mix yes. Your example is a good one.

Isn’t the octopus cheaper 4 hour rate for EVs only though? Thought you had to prove you had an EV and a 7kw charger to get it.

Heat pumps spot on. This is why they will only make sense for new builds and or legacy properties that are sufficiently insulated.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 27 Jul 23 10.32pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

Finally some sense

Battery storage is going to be massively important as part of the energy mix yes. Your example is a good one.

Isn’t the octopus cheaper 4 hour rate for EVs only though? Thought you had to prove you had an EV and a 7kw charger to get it.

Heat pumps spot on. This is why they will only make sense for new builds and or legacy properties that are sufficiently insulated.

Legacy properties are still not insulated enough and digging up a floor for underfloor heating is not at all practical. Your heating will be max 50*c. Have you got the space for k4 rads or 1.5 x longer than the current ones you have. ( you as in anyone btw) also replacing all of your pipework. If hmg is sooo worried why not make it law or fit all this for free, and give EV cars for free and upgrade our power supply for free and and and….

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 27 Jul 23 11.43pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Legacy properties are still not insulated enough and digging up a floor for underfloor heating is not at all practical. Your heating will be max 50*c. Have you got the space for k4 rads or 1.5 x longer than the current ones you have. ( you as in anyone btw) also replacing all of your pipework. If hmg is sooo worried why not make it law or fit all this for free, and give EV cars for free and upgrade our power supply for free and and and….

Jesus wept. How drunk are you exactly?

Let me repeat what I said for you

‘Legacy properties that are sufficiently insulated’

ie those that have been renovated to the appropriate standard (of which there are plenty), or newer properties in the 10-20 years old range (of which there are plenty) that also conform to the standard.

Also your point regarding underfloor being impractical only applies if you are not already renovating and extending a property. Otherwise it’s a no brainer. More throwaway dross

As already stated, banning gas boilers is for the birds. Everyone else who can’t move to heat pumps will remain on gas (or convert to electric at the point of energy becoming cheaper towards the end of the transition) for many many years to come, the remainder will be upgraded or renovated up to standard over time.

It helps to read the context of a thread before posting.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 28 Jul 23 5.41am

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

Jesus wept. How drunk are you exactly?

Let me repeat what I said for you

‘Legacy properties that are sufficiently insulated’

ie those that have been renovated to the appropriate standard (of which there are plenty), or newer properties in the 10-20 years old range (of which there are plenty) that also conform to the standard.

Also your point regarding underfloor being impractical only applies if you are not already renovating and extending a property. Otherwise it’s a no brainer. More throwaway dross

As already stated, banning gas boilers is for the birds. Everyone else who can’t move to heat pumps will remain on gas (or convert to electric at the point of energy becoming cheaper towards the end of the transition) for many many years to come, the remainder will be upgraded or renovated up to standard over time.

It helps to read the context of a thread before posting.

So giving the actual figures of heat pumps and their operation isn’t worth mentioning then. Are you personally allowing gas boilers to stay then as the SNP didn’t get the memo !

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 28 Jul 23 11.02pm

Europe seems plagued with an outbreak of arsonists, is that due to carbon emissions affecting behaviour? Same problem not prevalent in India or China.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Wilesy01 Flag Bristol 28 Jul 23 11.17pm

Originally posted by HKOwen

Europe seems plagued with an outbreak of arsonists, is that due to carbon emissions affecting behaviour? Same problem not prevalent in India or China.

And the extraordinarily hot and dry weather conditions don't exacerbate arson to disastrous consequences?

Plenty of arsonists in the UK but the fires don't spread as it's been pissing it down all month.

What an odd comment.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 28 Jul 23 11.43pm

The proximate cause of many of the fires is arson is my point.

The main sources of carbon emissions are China, India and the USA.

The Yosemite park fire was caused by a recently convicted arsonist so in that case a main emitter did have a serious arson.

My post was not meant to be taken verbatim but as an observation on the difference between climatic effect facts and climatic effect fiction.

Of course hot and dry conditions effect the spread of fire as they have done since the first fire .

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 29 Jul 23 5.43am

Originally posted by Wilesy01

And the extraordinarily hot and dry weather conditions don't exacerbate arson to disastrous consequences?

Plenty of arsonists in the UK but the fires don't spread as it's been pissing it down all month.

What an odd comment.

They arnt that extraordinarily hot if you look back more than five minutes. 50 years ago Europe had a hotter, longer period of weather with less fires. Just maybe nature doesn’t always start them !

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 29 Jul 23 8.57am

Hairy Scottish Historian Neil Oliver. He seems to think the whole 'Climate Emergency' is little more than a blatant Power-grab from the Elites.
However, like any good academic.....he is willing to listen to stop shrieking and to listen to both sides of the argument.

And most of the time his arguments are well couched in History.

[Link]
.
[Link]
.
[Link]

Edited by PalazioVecchio (29 Jul 2023 9.19am)

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Wilesy01 Flag Bristol 29 Jul 23 9.24am

Originally posted by cryrst

They arnt that extraordinarily hot if you look back more than five minutes. 50 years ago Europe had a hotter, longer period of weather with less fires. Just maybe nature doesn’t always start them !

Did you miss the news that this July has been the hottest on record?

Or the records broken in Europe for consecutive days over 40 degrees? Or that these records are being consistently broken almost year on year?

Arson greatly exacerbates the consequences of climate change. I can't quite understand people who are trying to use it to suggest there is no issue in the first place.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 29 Jul 23 11.01am

Originally posted by Wilesy01

Did you miss the news that this July has been the hottest on record?

Or the records broken in Europe for consecutive days over 40 degrees? Or that these records are being consistently broken almost year on year?
.

Dinosaurs once wandered lush tropical lands that are now a frozen tundra. Climate change is a normal part of History.

The Netherlands of Peter Bruegal paintings is a frozen World compared to the Netherlands of today. The Amstel & the Thames used to freeze over.

We can all agree the Climate is changing. We cannot agree on it being the end of the World.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Page 12 of 29 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Climate Change Activists