This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
As for this poor woman of conscience, I hear she's been charged with four counts of violating an abortion clinic 'buffer zone'. I do agree that there is a difference between protest and harassment. There is a difference between protest and seeking to economically damage people.....Just stop oil's actions for example. The woman in question, Ms Vaughan-Spruce has commented on these charges: 'It’s abhorrently wrong that I was arrested, brought into cells, searched and humiliated by police simply for praying in the privacy of my own mind. Censorship zone legislation purports to ban harassment, which is already illegal and obviously justifiable as nobody should be subject to harassment. But what I did was the furthest thing from harmful – I was exercising my freedom of thought, my freedom of religion, inside the privacy of my own mind. Nobody should be criminalised for thinking, for praying, in a public space in the UK. I have devoted much of my life to supporting women in crisis pregnancies with everything that they need to make an empowered choice for motherhood. I am also involved in supporting women who have had abortions and are struggling with the consequences of it. I’ve grown close to many of the women I’ve been able to support over the years, and it breaks my heart to know that so many more go through this every day. My faith is a central part of who I am, so sometimes I’ll stand or walk near an abortion facility and pray about this issue. This is something I’ve done pretty much every week for around the last 20 years of my life. I pray for my friends who have experienced abortion, and for the women who are thinking about going through it themselves.' Edited by Stirlingsays (29 Dec 2022 2.11pm) The lady has a perfect right to hold and express these views and to campaign for the law to be changed. She can protest outside police stations and council offices, get elected or go on TV. What she cannot do is break the law.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The lady has a perfect right to hold and express these views and to campaign for the law to be changed. She can protest outside police stations and council offices, get elected or go on TV. What she cannot do is break the law. She wasn't protesting. She was standing silently in a public street and perhaps silently praying. If that is breaking the law, then that law is repressive and people should support those who are being persecuted under it. Donations to her defence fund can be made at: [Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The lady has a perfect right to hold and express these views and to campaign for the law to be changed. She can protest outside police stations and council offices, get elected or go on TV. What she cannot do is break the law. We have discussed this at length before. While I don't support harassment (not the make believe forms you have suggested) physical nor economic I don't in any way agree with you that all laws are forms of secular divinity that cannot be broken. I contend that within your lifetime you would have broken many laws, from the speed limit perhaps to paying someone for something that wasn't on the cards. I bet you never took yourself down the station. Indeed, sometimes the Police choose not to enforce laws for whatever reason. No, in my view it depends upon what the law is, the situation and the conscience of the individual.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
. I am very glad to read that in subsequent posts you confirm that you accept this lady was in the wrong and that your real issue is police priorities. Which is another issue, which you can engage in via many channels. I am though intrigued on your suggestion that my narrative is somehow different to Maple’s. From all I can see we are both on the same page over this. If you think I have ignored your argument then I apologise but it was unintentional and must of been the result of it being unclear. It was not a reference to anything on this thread Wisbech. I am referring to past instances where you have sort of swayed from a point being made, or contorted it to represent something/someone else (an imagined enemy) and points differing to that which I am articulating. I'm not saying that as an insult, my inclination is to believe that you have clubbed together several posters into one grouping and misrepresented/conflated my posts with others. Maple has alluded to this and I whilst very mildly annoying, I hold no resentment over a simple and perhaps understandable mistake. My beef is solely with the Police approach on this one and more so perhaps the contrast to their lack of action elsewhere. Noting Stirling's post, it's a very interesting and very good response from the woman in question however has done little to convince me other than she knew full well what she was doing and intending. It's not somebody, with no previous whatsoever, being arrested for praying whilst waiting a bus stop, as one hypothetical example. It's somebody with a history of such antics deliberately causing a nuisance, to be polite. Whilst worthy of condemnation etc, even if just for the sheer arrogance, it's hardly the crime of the century. The fact such a law is in place and that the Police so enthusiastically enforced it contrasted with other, more serious crimes going oft unpunished, is quite ludicrous in my eyes. It's not a defence of the woman, quite the opposite in fact unless I have missed something (not impossible). But, once more, the response for me is representative of 'thought crime' being prioritised far above 'actual' crimes. I'm not sure what my preferable handling of the situation is TBH. Perhaps explain to her that what she was doing was in conflict with the law and demand she desist and move on, (that may well have been the case and I'm unaware of it must add)? Then after x amount of time an arrest? I don't support the arrest considering the action, regardless of the individual, as it is dependant on subjective reasoning but neither do I support the aforementioned individual's actions or general raison d'etre.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
We have discussed this at length before. While I don't support harassment (not the make believe forms you have suggested) physical nor economic I don't in any way agree with you that all laws are forms of secular divinity that cannot be broken. I contend that within your lifetime you would have broken many laws, from the speed limit perhaps to paying someone for something that wasn't on the cards. I bet you never took yourself down the station. Indeed, sometimes the Police choose not to enforce laws for whatever reason. No, in my view it depends upon what the law is, the situation and the conscience of the individual. If he broke the same law 5 times then either he is incredibly thick (which he ain't) or he did it on purpose to publicise his business. Innit. And by the way, would you like to go to her Coffee Morning? Lots of lovely young people there apparently. Addendum March for Life was founded in Washington DC. Edited by Mapletree (29 Dec 2022 4.48pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
If he broke the same law 5 times then either he is incredibly thick (which he ain't) or he did it on purpose to publicise his business. Innit. And by the way, would you like to go to her Coffee Morning? Lots of lovely young people there apparently. Addendum March for Life was founded in Washington DC. Edited by Mapletree (29 Dec 2022 4.48pm) When it comes to dodgy origins of funding for political activism I don't think anyone on the left has a leg to stand on. The left whored out their principles to the corporations. Your guys are so corrupt they'd get 10 percent from Santa Claws if they could.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I'm not sure what my preferable handling of the situation is TBH. Perhaps explain to her that what she was doing was in conflict with the law and demand she desist and move on, (that may well have been the case and I'm unaware of it must add)? Then after x amount of time an arrest? Good comments except this part which is risible. This lady has spent 20 years hanging about outside abortion clinics and had already been arrested and convicted for breach at this site 4 times. She is fully aware that there is a Council imposed buffer zone around this clinic (following detailed consultation). At the moment there is no law in place but that is coming shortly because of the actions of these kinds of people. And as stated, this is not a thought crime, she just set up a copper to make it look like it was. It was a clear breach of a Council's Public Spaces Protection Order if you look at the scope of the consultation documents. To give an insight, here is a young woman telling her story: She worried throughout the 12 hours she spent on the ward. “All I could think about was the fact I’d have to go past them again. It gave me a sinking feeling in my stomach.” One of the protesters tried to hand her then-partner a leaflet when he went to get some fresh air. “It was a feeling of surveillance,” she says, “like they were keeping tabs on who was going in and out of the clinic. It felt very calculated and intentional.”
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
When it comes to dodgy origins of funding for political activism I don't think anyone on the left has a leg to stand on. The left whored out their principles to the corporations. Your guys are so corrupt they'd get 10 percent from Santa Claws if they could. Who are my guys? Why do you say I am Left, albeit I know that Genghis Khan was left in comparison to you and your HOL cronies? What makes you think the Left is more corrupt than the Right anyway? Have you not been paying attention to what has been going on in Parliament? And as for being in the pocket of Corporations (a US term), you are absolutely controlled by huge vested interest in the USA as are your Republican idols. For information, there are 8 types of companies in the UK: public limited company (PLC); private company limited by shares (LTD); company limited by guarantee; unlimited company (UNLTD); Limited Liability Partnership (LLP); Community Interest Company; Industrial and Provident Society (IPS) and finally, Royal Charter (RC). Not a single Corporation in sight.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Good comments except this part which is risible. This lady has spent 20 years hanging about outside abortion clinics and had already been arrested and convicted for breach at this site 4 times. She is fully aware that there is a Council imposed buffer zone around this clinic (following detailed consultation). At the moment there is no law in place but that is coming shortly because of the actions of these kinds of people. And as stated, this is not a thought crime, she just set up a copper to make it look like it was. It was a clear breach of a Council's Public Spaces Protection Order if you look at the scope of the consultation documents. To give an insight, here is a young woman telling her story: She worried throughout the 12 hours she spent on the ward. “All I could think about was the fact I’d have to go past them again. It gave me a sinking feeling in my stomach.” One of the protesters tried to hand her then-partner a leaflet when he went to get some fresh air. “It was a feeling of surveillance,” she says, “like they were keeping tabs on who was going in and out of the clinic. It felt very calculated and intentional.” I was not aware of previous arrests this woman had at these sites nor was I aware of a multiple decade history of this. If this is, and I am presuming is, indeed true, then there is more to it than just arresting somebody for a perceived protest and 'praying silently in her head'. I think to describe my concerns over a person being arrested, in a public space, for praying silently as 'risible' is unfair and deliberately provocative. Again, I feel I have made clear my grievance with regards to the policing and therefore my comments. I also do not hold much value for how people 'feel' when it comes to enforcement of the law. Yes, I can empathise with those expressing hurt and therefore condemn individuals such as this woman for such actions, but that should have very little impact on the application of law. There's plenty in the world that makes me uncomfortable and unhappy but I have to accept other's rights, if not their thoughts and actions. I had to visit a relative dying of cancer not so long ago, I didn't call for the arrest of everybody standing outside having a fag. Finally, and once again, if somebody is arrested 'on the spot' for praying silently in their head, that does constitute a very worrying, authoritarian, dystopian view of the world. If this individual has been previously warned, has a long old history of such action, was well known to and was dealt with appropriately by the Police then that is something else. Quite frankly, if I was asked as to whether or not I'd prefer very limited Police resources to be spent on catching burglars, drug dealers, fraudsters etc etc or on some lone nut bothering people with her mere presence at an abortion clinic, I'd choose the former.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Who are my guys? Why do you say I am Left, albeit I know that Genghis Khan was left in comparison to you and your HOL cronies? What makes you think the Left is more corrupt than the Right anyway? Have you not been paying attention to what has been going on in Parliament? And as for being in the pocket of Corporations (a US term), you are absolutely controlled by huge vested interest in the USA as are your Republican idols. For information, there are 8 types of companies in the UK: public limited company (PLC); private company limited by shares (LTD); company limited by guarantee; unlimited company (UNLTD); Limited Liability Partnership (LLP); Community Interest Company; Industrial and Provident Society (IPS) and finally, Royal Charter (RC). Not a single Corporation in sight. No one is my 'crony' on Hol, I can't help it that your 'hollyweird' type politics feels under siege on Hol....anyway how can you go on about cronies, when you were panting over your 'granite shoreline'? Anyway, It's hardly as though your type of politics is under catered for elsewhere is it. Well, ok if I were going to better define you I'd say you're a champagne neo liberal with 'progressive' traits with an obsessional love of pedantry.....as we see with your rather quaint annoyance with me using 'corporations'.....which is fine as a general description by the way. I don't know that I would say that the left is more corrupt than the right, I suspect it's even, but as the left is in control of the corporations and institutions most of the corruption is coming from them. Republican idols? Well, I like DeSantis somewhat, but the GOP is mostly a dumpster fire....to use an American phrase you no doubt deplore. Edited by Stirlingsays (29 Dec 2022 5.31pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
No one is my 'crony' on Hol, I can't help it that your 'hollyweird' type politics feels under siege on Hol....anyway how can you go on about cronies, when you were panting over your 'granite shoreline'? Anyway, It's hardly as though your type of politics is under catered for elsewhere is it. Well, ok if I were going to better define you I'd say you're a champagne neo liberal with 'progressive' traits with an obsessional love of pedantry.....as we see with your rather quaint annoyance with me using 'corporations'.....which is fine as a general description by the way. I don't know that I would say that the left is more corrupt than the right, I suspect it's even, but as the left is in control of the corporations and institutions most of the corruption is coming from them. Republican idols? Well, I like DeSantis somewhat, but the GOP is mostly a dumpster fire....to use an American phrase you no doubt deplore. Edited by Stirlingsays (29 Dec 2022 5.31pm) I am not pedantic. By the way, the norm is three dots...
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I was not aware of previous arrests this woman had at these sites nor was I aware of a multiple decade history of this. If this is, and I am presuming is, indeed true, then there is more to it than just arresting somebody for a perceived protest and 'praying silently in her head'. I think to describe my concerns over a person being arrested, in a public space, for praying silently as 'risible' is unfair and deliberately provocative. Again, I feel I have made clear my grievance with regards to the policing and therefore my comments. I also do not hold much value for how people 'feel' when it comes to enforcement of the law. Yes, I can empathise with those expressing hurt and therefore condemn individuals such as this woman for such actions, but that should have very little impact on the application of law. There's plenty in the world that makes me uncomfortable and unhappy but I have to accept other's rights, if not their thoughts and actions. I had to visit a relative dying of cancer not so long ago, I didn't call for the arrest of everybody standing outside having a fag. Finally, and once again, if somebody is arrested 'on the spot' for praying silently in their head, that does constitute a very worrying, authoritarian, dystopian view of the world. If this individual has been previously warned, has a long old history of such action, was well known to and was dealt with appropriately by the Police then that is something else. Quite frankly, if I was asked as to whether or not I'd prefer very limited Police resources to be spent on catching burglars, drug dealers, fraudsters etc etc or on some lone nut bothering people with her mere presence at an abortion clinic, I'd choose the former. I called risible the concept that you have a quiet word with a woman that has already been convicted four times for the self same offence. That is neither unfair nor provocative. It is a shame you post as if with authority when you haven't looked into the basics of the case in question.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
I called risible the concept that you have a quiet word with a woman that has already been convicted four times for the self same offence. That is neither unfair nor provocative. It is a shame you post as if with authority when you haven't looked into the basics of the case in question. What should the sentence be? She could be facing two years.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
I am not pedantic. By the way, the norm is three dots...
Rebel me.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
What should the sentence be? She could be facing two years. Do I look like a Magistrate? What on Earth makes you think she could be facing two years? PSPOs put conditions or restrictions on an area which apply to everyone. They can be enforced by the police, council enforcement officers or any other authorised officers. Councils can issue a fine of £100 to anyone who breaches the PSPO. If they do not pay the fine they can take further action with a maximum fine of £1000. I am sure that Washington DC will be happy to pay on each occasion.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
No one is my 'crony' on Hol, I can't help it that your 'hollyweird' type politics feels under siege on Hol....anyway how can you go on about cronies, when you were panting over your 'granite shoreline'? Anyway, It's hardly as though your type of politics is under catered for elsewhere is it. Well, ok if I were going to better define you I'd say you're a champagne neo liberal with 'progressive' traits with an obsessional love of pedantry.....as we see with your rather quaint annoyance with me using 'corporations'.....which is fine as a general description by the way. I don't know that I would say that the left is more corrupt than the right, I suspect it's even, but as the left is in control of the corporations and institutions most of the corruption is coming from them. Republican idols? Well, I like DeSantis somewhat, but the GOP is mostly a dumpster fire....to use an American phrase you no doubt deplore. Edited by Stirlingsays (29 Dec 2022 5.31pm) I don't pant over anyone other than the missus. I did, of course, enjoy the way WE kept knocking you back with a straight bat. Amusement at your expense I assure you. In UK politics, they don't come any more corrupt than the right wing of the Conservative party. If you can't see that then maybe you should stop ejaculating over Tucker Carlson and start reading the papers. Show me where it is appropriate to use 'Corporations' for any UK company. I had a bottle of 1990 Krug for Christmas lunch by the way.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
What should the sentence be? She could be facing two years. As this will be a modern witch trial, perhaps her guilt as to whether she was silently praying could be determined by the traditional trial by water. If she sinks to the bottom she is innocent, if she floats she is guilty. Then they could proceed to burning her at a stake. That should be a deterrent to any other people in the vicinity of a clinic whose thoughts might involve God. Edited by georgenorman (29 Dec 2022 6.48pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Do I look like a Magistrate? What on Earth makes you think she could be facing two years? PSPOs put conditions or restrictions on an area which apply to everyone. They can be enforced by the police, council enforcement officers or any other authorised officers. Councils can issue a fine of £100 to anyone who breaches the PSPO. If they do not pay the fine they can take further action with a maximum fine of £1000. I am sure that Washington DC will be happy to pay on each occasion. I don't know if you look like a magistrate.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
I don't pant over anyone other than the missus. I did, of course, enjoy the way WE kept knocking you back with a straight bat. Amusement at your expense I assure you. Sounds like panting to me....If you're going to WE fanboy you should really get a tissue and wipe your mouth it's unsightly....you get bonus points if you do it whilst sitting at a gay nudist beach. Originally posted by Mapletree
In UK politics, they don't come any more corrupt than the right wing of the Conservative party. If you can't see that then maybe you should stop ejaculating over Tucker Carlson and start reading the papers. Is this political poornhub or something? Originally posted by Mapletree
Show me where it is appropriate to use 'Corporations' for any UK company. I can't be bothered, besides I wasn't even being UK specific. Originally posted by Mapletree
I had a bottle of 1990 Krug for Christmas lunch by the way. You posho.....I had eggnog. Edited by Stirlingsays (29 Dec 2022 7.51pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
I called risible the concept that you have a quiet word with a woman that has already been convicted four times for the self same offence. That is neither unfair nor provocative. It is a shame you post as if with authority when you haven't looked into the basics of the case in question.
I post as I feel others should, within the context of a discussion. I try to keep an open mind, put forward my thoughts on discussion topics and happily debate or explore where necessary. I’m happy to strongly assert my opinion but also to concede when appropriate, something others including yourself never, ever do. I also often post very light heartedly or with crap jokes, you know, it’s a palace fans’ forum. I usually take most things, within reason, for granted as truth no matter the source when it is posted on a fans’ forum. If this is proved incorrect I’m really not that fussed, says something about the source and not my laid back approach to such things. If you wanted a definition of the word ‘risible’ it is your accusation of another poster’s intention to contribute ‘with authority’. You’ve done nothing, from my experience, but try to patronise, attack and denigrate others. As I have mentioned numerous times previously, and recently, the act of actively seeking, to the extent of fabricating an enemy, as you did with me, to try and assert an imagined cognitive authority, is often the very weak sign of a failure. My thoughts were on the policing of this matter but in your hysteria to defend those seeking to abort their children you started harping on about ‘Muslims’ which had not been previously mentioned, not by me at least, alongside attacking a narrative I hadn’t provided. This demonstrates at best that you did not read what I had written, or at worst you were desperately seeking opposition to ‘hate’ upon. I would suggest you look inwards for your anger if you are looking to resolve this situation,” and not become dramatic with others on the internet, safely hidden behind a screen. So you carry on picking virtual verbals on the internet, if it makes you feel as though you achieved something, or a big man etc. which I would suggest is in lieu of that reflecting in reality. I tried to be fair and reasoned but I may as well converse with the cat given your responses.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.