This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Ched Evans' by jamiemartin721 Originally posted by dannyh
can't remember if this was talked about at the time (few weeks ago) however I was highly criticised for suggesting the girl involved was a gold digging slag who new exactly what she was doing. It would seem I may have been right. I wouldn't slag you off for that as I had the same thoughts myself, what with the recent story about the girl at the May ball who had a three way and then accused the blokes of rape despite having a history of doing that kind of thing.
|
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Ched Evans' by jamiemartin721 topic is here:
Optimistic as ever |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Ched Evans' by jamiemartin721 Originally posted by We are goin up!
Didn't she say she couldn't remember anything and yet had 3 units of alcohol? Thought it sounded very very dodgy at the time, still think the same. The grounds on which the appeal has been accepted haven't yet been published, and won't be pending the retrial. Its unlikely to be any evidence that was presented at the original trial or in the failed appeal previously. So I'd imagine its new witnesses, and likely about the time line or reliability of a witnesses that was key to the prosecution. Nor does it automatically equate to her being guilty of lying. It may only point towards the reliability of 'reasonable doubt' verdict by its omission.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Ched Evans' by jamiemartin721 Originally posted by fed up eagle
I wouldn't slag you off for that as I had the same thoughts myself, what with the recent story about the girl at the May ball who had a three way and then accused the blokes of rape despite having a history of doing that kind of thing.
Which three ways? or accusing people of rape after sex. Only one of those is a viable defence in a rape case.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Ched Evans' by jamiemartin721 Originally posted by dannyh
Call me old fashioned, but I thought rape was forcing yourself onto a women by foul means against her will. I'll call you old fashioned. Originally posted by dannyh
Not her waking up in the morning, realising she's been a right slag, saying I was too pissed to remember consenting, and then then ruining a guys life for some fast cash whilst in the process of updating your facebook page with all the money your going to get. Actually, consent in law places responsibility on both parties. As such, its not the actions of a reasonable man, who is sober, to accept consent from someone who is really pissed up. Its reasonable to say no, rather than think 'technical consent' for the win. Especially when, as the prosecution demonstrated, you turned up at the hotel, and took advantage of the situation in an manner that it wasn't reasonable to assume consent. Originally posted by dannyh
He was hung out to dry by the bint at the CPS who has a track record of this type of thing, I have no doubt (if you read his website) that any new evidence will be effective in reversing the original decision, and I hope all the clubs that sacked him have to pay out compensation. The job of the CPS in an accusatory system is to put the prosecutions case, their best case. Same goes with the defence. Now the prosecution has a responsibility to make sure that it doesn't withhold evidence of someone's innocence. But it doesn't have a responsibility to expose weaknesses in its case, that's the job of the defence. I'm happy that the judge has decided that new evidence requires a mistrial. But his website also proclaimed his innocence when he was found guilty. Oddly the family and friends of people do tend to be rather biased. Its down to a jury of peers, on reviewing the evidence of the prosecution and defence, to decide, beyond reasonable doubt, whether someone is guilty. Presently, Evans, is not guilty, pending retrial. But that doesn't automatically make the alternative true. Now if it turns out she has committed perjury etc. then certainly, she deserves to face charges and libel - but its important to remember that a 'not guilty' also means reasonable doubt. One of the most common reasons why people accused of rape, don't sue, is because the lower balance of probability in civil court, leads to determining in the respondents (defences) favour.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Ched Evans' by jamiemartin721 Originally posted by jamiemartin721
The job of the CPS in an accusatory system is to put the prosecutions case, their best case. Same goes with the defence. Now the prosecution has a responsibility to make sure that it doesn't withhold evidence of someone's innocence. But it doesn't have a responsibility to expose weaknesses in its case, that's the job of the defence. I'm happy that the judge has decided that new evidence requires a mistrial. But his website also proclaimed his innocence when he was found guilty. Oddly the family and friends of people do tend to be rather biased. Its down to a jury of peers, on reviewing the evidence of the prosecution and defence, to decide, beyond reasonable doubt, whether someone is guilty. Presently, Evans, is not guilty, pending retrial. But that doesn't automatically make the alternative true. Now if it turns out she has committed perjury etc. then certainly, she deserves to face charges and libel - but its important to remember that a 'not guilty' also means reasonable doubt. One of the most common reasons why people accused of rape, don't sue, is because the lower balance of probability in civil court, leads to determining in the respondents (defences) favour. She was able to walk straight, and squatted low down to pick up her purse without falling over, a known coke user who had been on the devils dandruft that very night. not a chance she didnt know what she was doing. Gold digger, said it from day one.
"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Ched Evans' by jamiemartin721 Originally posted by dannyh
She was able to walk straight, and squatted low down to pick up her purse without falling over, a known coke user who had been on the devils dandruft that very night. not a chance she didnt know what she was doing. Gold digger, said it from day one. Possibly. Although its interesting that the defence couldn't make that case. As someone who's been known to dabble in el diablos scalpings, I'd say that it can give you the illusion of being sober (when in fact your still drunk, you're just high and drunk). People also make very bad decisions when coked up (and the same law applies, regarding informed consent when intoxicated to drugs). Of course this could be used as a reasonable doubt defence by Evans, because the use of cocaine, if he didn't know she was taking it, could make her appear to be sober. For me, the issue really revolves around Evans actions prior to sex and whether or not the girl was intoxicated. McDonald, I believe is innocent still, his actions seem reasonable - he travelled back with the girl - Evans, by the prosecutions case, lacks that reasonableness. The case really hinges on intoxication and how Evans came to the hotel, rather than sex. If he can show its reasonable to doubt her account or the events, or show that it was reasonable for him to turn up at the hotel, then he could well win the case. Or if he can show, that after the event, she admitted lying about the events in question, he could establish reasonable doubt. His problem is a) evidence of intoxication b) it was not reasonable for him to assume consent by the prosecutions case c) he admitted to having sex with her. Even if she was coked up, it still is questionable in the time frame that his actions were reasonable. I think its an interesting case, largely because there is no evidence that sex actually occurred, other than his own admission (which is an important lesson to people when interviewed by the police, never admit to anything that could be used against you always make them prove the events). Edited by jamiemartin721 (09 May 2016 4.17pm)
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Ched Evans' by jamiemartin721 That said, I did buy into the prosecutions case which was quite elegantly constructed to avoid becoming about he said / she said. Now I'm not so sure, given the appeal being granted. It'll be interesting to see what happens if he is found not guilty on retrial, given his career is already 'down the swanny'.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Ched Evans' by jamiemartin721 Originally posted by jamiemartin721
For me, the issue really revolves around Evans actions prior to sex and whether or not the girl was intoxicated.
Maybe he needs to move to Oklahoma.
We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football. |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Ched Evans' by jamiemartin721 Originally posted by Ray in Houston
Maybe he needs to move to Oklahoma. Flight booked.
|
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Ched Evans' by jamiemartin721 Originally posted by dannyh
Call me old fashioned, but I thought rape was forcing yourself onto a women by foul means against her will. Not her waking up in the morning, realising she's been a right slag, saying I was too pissed to remember consenting, and then then ruining a guys life for some fast cash whilst in the process of updating your facebook page with all the money your going to get. He was hung out to dry by the bint at the CPS who has a track record of this type of thing, I have no doubt (if you read his website) that any new evidence will be effective in reversing the original decision, and I hope all the clubs that sacked him have to pay out compensation. The tart in question should have to pay all the money back and be named and shamed, not to mention jailed for perjury and lying like a 10 dollar crack whore. Thing is every time one of these tarts does this it just makes the already horrendous crime of rape that much more difficult to convict on, and until the wolf criers are punished it will still be an easy way for unscrupulous tarts to ruin lives for money.
As far as I'm concerned that is rape. Nowadays though we have this more than real scenario where some flighty tart decides that she didn't want to do what she did the night before so ruins some poor sod's life by crying rape. Unscrupulous lawyers are taking these cases on and they are hell bent on destroying the blokes life with character assassination and all sorts of other dirty tricks. It doesn't help when the blokes name is printed everywhere in the press, and then, already presumed guilty in the court of public opinion, the poor bugger loses everything, including his liberty. Edited by fed up eagle (09 May 2016 6.51pm) Edited by fed up eagle (09 May 2016 6.53pm)
|
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Ched Evans' by jamiemartin721 Originally posted by dannyh
Call me old fashioned, but I thought rape was forcing yourself onto a women by foul means against her will. Not her waking up in the morning, realising she's been a right slag, saying I was too pissed to remember consenting, and then then ruining a guys life for some fast cash whilst in the process of updating your facebook page with all the money your going to get. He was hung out to dry by the bint at the CPS who has a track record of this type of thing, I have no doubt (if you read his website) that any new evidence will be effective in reversing the original decision, and I hope all the clubs that sacked him have to pay out compensation. The tart in question should have to pay all the money back and be named and shamed, not to mention jailed for perjury and lying like a 10 dollar crack whore. Thing is every time one of these tarts does this it just makes the already horrendous crime of rape that much more difficult to convict on, and until the wolf criers are punished it will still be an easy way for unscrupulous tarts to ruin lives for money.
I couldn't agree with you more dannyh! I AM old fashioned, and frankly I am appalled at this modern idea that everyone else is responsible for someone's behaviour, whilst they bear none at all. Whatever the rights and wrongs of the individuals involved in this case, the facts remain that she (by her defence) was so drunk that she was unaware that she was being penetrated sexually by a man she had just met. Did your mother never warn you? No? - Well love, perhaps you should take a bit of responsibility for yourself and not drink so much then! Perhaps you'd be in a fit state then to say no to something you don't want. - And, whatever made you think that footballers generally stay at Travelodge hotels, eh? did no little alarm bells ring in your tiny brain that these guys earn enough to at least warrant a Holiday Inn? - Why go back to a hotel room with (I believe) more than one newly met male - did you never consider that you just might be running yourself into a bit of trouble, or did you just not care anyway? - or did you see yourself as the next Abbey Clancy or Colleen Rooney? made up for life on a share of an income that most can only dream about if you could just snag yourself a footballer? - and where was your self respect eh? rolled up and stuck under the elastic of your tiny lacy thong? Well get it back out and give it an airing, because if there is one true fact in all this, it's that no-one is going to give you any respect if you don't respect yourself! Finally, please don't give me all that blaming the victim crap because the world IS a big bad old place, and if you don't look out for yourself, then you really have no entitlement to expect everyone else to do it for you when you choose to behave like a total idiot.
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Ched Evans' by jamiemartin721 Entertaining talk through it all at the link below.
|
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Ched Evans' by jamiemartin721 Originally posted by becky
I couldn't agree with you more dannyh! I AM old fashioned, and frankly I am appalled at this modern idea that everyone else is responsible for someone's behaviour, whilst they bear none at all. Whatever the rights and wrongs of the individuals involved in this case, the facts remain that she (by her defence) was so drunk that she was unaware that she was being penetrated sexually by a man she had just met. Did your mother never warn you? No? - Well love, perhaps you should take a bit of responsibility for yourself and not drink so much then! Perhaps you'd be in a fit state then to say no to something you don't want. - And, whatever made you think that footballers generally stay at Travelodge hotels, eh? did no little alarm bells ring in your tiny brain that these guys earn enough to at least warrant a Holiday Inn? - Why go back to a hotel room with (I believe) more than one newly met male - did you never consider that you just might be running yourself into a bit of trouble, or did you just not care anyway? - or did you see yourself as the next Abbey Clancy or Colleen Rooney? made up for life on a share of an income that most can only dream about if you could just snag yourself a footballer? - and where was your self respect eh? rolled up and stuck under the elastic of your tiny lacy thong? Well get it back out and give it an airing, because if there is one true fact in all this, it's that no-one is going to give you any respect if you don't respect yourself! Finally, please don't give me all that blaming the victim crap because the world IS a big bad old place, and if you don't look out for yourself, then you really have no entitlement to expect everyone else to do it for you when you choose to behave like a total idiot. Excellently put Becks...bang on the money
|
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Ched Evans' by jamiemartin721 Originally posted by becky
I couldn't agree with you more dannyh! I AM old fashioned, and frankly I am appalled at this modern idea that everyone else is responsible for someone's behaviour, whilst they bear none at all. Whatever the rights and wrongs of the individuals involved in this case, the facts remain that she (by her defence) was so drunk that she was unaware that she was being penetrated sexually by a man she had just met. Did your mother never warn you? No? - Well love, perhaps you should take a bit of responsibility for yourself and not drink so much then! Perhaps you'd be in a fit state then to say no to something you don't want. - And, whatever made you think that footballers generally stay at Travelodge hotels, eh? did no little alarm bells ring in your tiny brain that these guys earn enough to at least warrant a Holiday Inn? - Why go back to a hotel room with (I believe) more than one newly met male - did you never consider that you just might be running yourself into a bit of trouble, or did you just not care anyway? - or did you see yourself as the next Abbey Clancy or Colleen Rooney? made up for life on a share of an income that most can only dream about if you could just snag yourself a footballer? - and where was your self respect eh? rolled up and stuck under the elastic of your tiny lacy thong? Well get it back out and give it an airing, because if there is one true fact in all this, it's that no-one is going to give you any respect if you don't respect yourself! Finally, please don't give me all that blaming the victim crap because the world IS a big bad old place, and if you don't look out for yourself, then you really have no entitlement to expect everyone else to do it for you when you choose to behave like a total idiot. This with massive big king kong knobs on.
"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'" |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Ched Evans' by jamiemartin721 Originally posted by Cucking Funt
Flight booked. Jamie Martin said he'll see you at the bar.
"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Ched Evans' by jamiemartin721 Originally posted by becky
I couldn't agree with you more dannyh! I AM old fashioned, and frankly I am appalled at this modern idea that everyone else is responsible for someone's behaviour, whilst they bear none at all. Whatever the rights and wrongs of the individuals involved in this case, the facts remain that she (by her defence) was so drunk that she was unaware that she was being penetrated sexually by a man she had just met. Did your mother never warn you? No? - Well love, perhaps you should take a bit of responsibility for yourself and not drink so much then! Perhaps you'd be in a fit state then to say no to something you don't want. - And, whatever made you think that footballers generally stay at Travelodge hotels, eh? did no little alarm bells ring in your tiny brain that these guys earn enough to at least warrant a Holiday Inn? - Why go back to a hotel room with (I believe) more than one newly met male - did you never consider that you just might be running yourself into a bit of trouble, or did you just not care anyway? - or did you see yourself as the next Abbey Clancy or Colleen Rooney? made up for life on a share of an income that most can only dream about if you could just snag yourself a footballer? - and where was your self respect eh? rolled up and stuck under the elastic of your tiny lacy thong? Well get it back out and give it an airing, because if there is one true fact in all this, it's that no-one is going to give you any respect if you don't respect yourself! Finally, please don't give me all that blaming the victim crap because the world IS a big bad old place, and if you don't look out for yourself, then you really have no entitlement to expect everyone else to do it for you when you choose to behave like a total idiot. Which is why McDonald was found not guilty in the original case. I think a lot of people don't understand the prosecution case, or want to frame it in to a different context. The difference between the two is that Evans was held responsible for his own behaviour. In that he turned up at the hotel specifically to take advantage of a situation on finding that McDonald had a woman there. The prosecution demonstrated that it was unreasonable for him to believe her capable of consenting, and that he knew she was intoxicated to a degree of being able to give willing consent, and that he left soon after sex. Or are we just to assume that men always want sex, have no self control, responsibility for their actions or that is somehow the actions of a reasonable man. Its different that the scenario across the land were drunk people hook up, and end up f**king each other and regretting it, because their behaviour is such that its reasonable for them to believe they have consent. But on the case proven in court, which is currently under appeal, its unreasonable to assume that the accused didn't engineer a situation in which he had decided he was going to have sex, prior to meeting the woman (is it reasonable to turn up in the middle of the night, to a hotel room, have sex with a very drunk girl you have never met who came back with someone else, then leave). Remember that rape is just based around several factors of consent, including the ability of the perpetrator to believe they have consent, and the intentions of the perpetrator (both in their actions before and after the alleged crime). Now the appeal might change that case. But I think people seem to have the misguided idea that responsibility for actions only lies with one party in sex crimes, in this case the woman. Responsibility for consent cuts both ways, or in this case three ways. Of course, the accused is now entitled to a retrial, on the basis of evidence that its reasonable for judges to believe may have influenced a jury's decision.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.