This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Portuguese
Good point but neverthless this review needs to be context in a way like Ortega y Gasset says: "I am plus my circumstances." Which is exactly what you'd want from a manager. All this stuff about our style is simply trying to create a coherent narrative from different pragmatic solutions arrived at by different managers. Pulis' 'style' was not the same as Allardyce nor what one would expect if you had expected him to recreate the way Stoke played under him. Silva does have limited experience but has made the teams he has gone to better than they were, in different contexts. That seems like a very good start point to consider him seriously and, to my non-expert mind, the best option of those touted.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Seth
Silva took over at Hull when they had just 13 points from 20 games and had only managed 6 points in their previous 17. They had the worst defence and worst attack in the league and sold their two best players in January. Under Silva they went on to get 34 points; 21 in 18 matches. Over a season that would have been enough for around 44 points, one away from the top half, and that was with a load of loan signings and a squad of about 15 players. On top of what he achieved in Portugal and Greece, I'd say that was a pretty impressive record. What really has he achieved in Portugal and Greece ? Edited by Willo (25 May 2017 7.24pm)
|
|
|
Just a question: are Willo and Croydonlad related?
|
|
|
SP has Luka as a due diligence reference point for the quality of Marco Silva during their time at Olympiacos.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Come to Daddy
Which is exactly what you'd want from a manager. All this stuff about our style is simply trying to create a coherent narrative from different pragmatic solutions arrived at by different managers. Pulis' 'style' was not the same as Allardyce nor what one would expect if you had expected him to recreate the way Stoke played under him. Silva does have limited experience but has made the teams he has gone to better than they were, in different contexts. That seems like a very good start point to consider him seriously and, to my non-expert mind, the best option of those touted. Mate I guess you don't read my previous posts!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
What really has he achieved in Portugal and Greece ? Didn't you read this from earlier in the thread? Originally posted by twist
Silva has an excellent track record when you look at the resources he had to work with at the clubs he managed. Managing Estoril in Portugal, he took them to new heights they had never seen before. Won the second division, got them qualified for Europa league for 2 seasons straight after promotion. Went on to manage Sporting, where he won them the cup, finished 3rd, but was fired at season end for not wearing the clubs official suit at a game ! At Olympiacos he had an 80% win rate, including a memorable 3-2 win at Arsenal. Like people have said before, he had the worst team in the league to work with, and came close to saving them. This guy would be fantastic to have here. Edited by Seth (25 May 2017 7.37pm)
"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down" |
|
|
Originally posted by Seth
Edited by Seth (25 May 2017 7.37pm) Yes of course I read it ! I totally accept that he won titles in Portugal and Greece so well done to him but were the achievements that great when one looks at the bigger picture ? So he arrived as a relative "Unknown" on the back of what I deem to be modest achievements (Bigger picture again!) he then has a "Negative" in that he gets relegated (Albeit extenuating circumstances) and all of a sudden he is lauded, is "Flavour of the month", the next Pochettino, the next Mourinho etc etc. I just think many have gone "Overboard" in their praise of him based on his record.I'm NOT saying that he couldn't do really well in the future but let's NOT get carried away at the present time. Edited by Willo (25 May 2017 7.51pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Yes of course I read it ! I totally accept that he won titles in Portugal and Greece so well done to him but were the achievements that great when one looks at the bigger picture ? So he arrived as a relative "Unknown" on the back of what I deem to be modest achievements (Bigger picture again!) he then has a "Negative" in that he gets relegated (Albeit extenuating circumstances) and all of a sudden he is lauded, is "Flavour of the month", the next Pochettino, the next Mourinho etc etc. I just think many have gone "Overboard" in their praise of him based on his record.I'm NOT saying that he couldn't do really well in the future but let's NOT get carried away at the present time. Edited by Willo (25 May 2017 7.51pm) It's context. People are praising him in comparison to the other options not compared to the whole football managing world.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Yes of course I read it ! I totally accept that he won titles in Portugal and Greece so well done to him but were the achievements that great when one looks at the bigger picture ? So he arrived as a relative "Unknown" on the back of what I deem to be modest achievements (Bigger picture again!) he then has a "Negative" in that he gets relegated (Albeit extenuating circumstances) and all of a sudden he is lauded, is "Flavour of the month", the next Pochettino, the next Mourinho etc etc. I just think many have gone "Overboard" in their praise of him based on his record.I'm NOT saying that he couldn't do really well in the future but let's NOT get carried away at the present time. Edited by Willo (25 May 2017 7.51pm) I am reliably informed by one of my contacts that Silva I say one of my contacts, HLTCO on Twitter
|
|
|
He has just officially resigned as Hull manager [Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch
I am reliably informed by one of my contacts that Silva I say one of my contacts, HLTCO on Twitter I too was reliably informed by a source that Silva is better than Willo claims. That same source indicates that Willo is Trolley. Obviously I cannot betray a confidence but I have reason to believe, via reliable means, he also supports Brighton.
If you come to a fork in the road, take it. |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Yes of course I read it ! I totally accept that he won titles in Portugal and Greece so well done to him but were the achievements that great when one looks at the bigger picture ? So he arrived as a relative "Unknown" on the back of what I deem to be modest achievements (Bigger picture again!) he then has a "Negative" in that he gets relegated (Albeit extenuating circumstances) and all of a sudden he is lauded, is "Flavour of the month", the next Pochettino, the next Mourinho etc etc. I just think many have gone "Overboard" in their praise of him based on his record.I'm NOT saying that he couldn't do really well in the future but let's NOT get carried away at the present time. Edited by Willo (25 May 2017 7.51pm) In the position Palace are at present the club wouldn't be able to attract a manager like Mourinho or Pochettino,or anyone else who has a fantastic track record of high achievment, but it IS possible that the club could attract the "next Mourinho"; someone with the potential to achieve beyond what, so far, his track record in England has shown. The problem is identifying that man. The indications are that Marco Silva may well have what it takes. Hull were able to attract him as he wanted to manage in the Premiership to further his career, and clubs in the top six or seven were able to attract a bigger mane, so he had to settle for a club willing to take a chance on him. Pochettino was in a similar position when he first took over at Southampton and he didn't do too badly there. The only real problem is that if he were to be successful at Palace it is quite probable that a top six club would be in the market for him in a couple of years and he would be off. That's worth a risk though, in my view. Edited by crystal balls (25 May 2017 9.02pm)
I used to be immortal |
|
|
Originally posted by crystal balls
In the position Palace are at present the club wouldn't be able to attract a manager like Mourinho or Pochettino,or anyone else who has a fantastic track record of high achievment, but it IS possible that the club could attract the "next Mourinho"; someone with the potential to achieve beyond what, so far, his track record in England has shown. The problem is identifying that man. The indications are that Marco Silva may well have what it takes. Hull were able to attract him as he wanted to manage in the Premiership to further his career, and clubs in the top six or seven were able to attract bigger names, so he had to settle for a club willing to take a chance on him. Pochettino was in a similar position when he first took over at Southampton and he didn't do too badly there. The only real problem is that if he were to be successful at Palace it is quite probable that a top six club would be in the market for him in a couple of years and he would be off. That's worth a risk though, in my view.
I used to be immortal |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
What really has he achieved in Portugal and Greece ?
Really - why on earth would we want a manager who 'wins things'? Much better to get in a old hack like Hodgeson :-/ Silva looks the best of the bunch and has the potential to take us forward. Or we could keep doing the same thing. I know which I prefer....
|
|
|
Presumably Luka played under him at
|
|
|
If Willo doesn't rate him that means he must be great!! Gets my vote !!!
|
|
| bobby mimms |
|
|---|---|
|
Still aint impressed.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.