This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by dave64
I understand Parish and co took a long time interviewing managers before deciding on fdb .They must have fully understood his qualities and the style of play. The necessity for new players to fit in to this style. I would suggest he has been rather thrown to the wolves. not fully supported in transfer market. And when new style (as agreed and supported by parish)isn't immediately effective....parish throws him to the wolves. To be fair his style of play in the past has been 433 which you would argue suites our players, and he talked about evolution not revolution. So our start must have taken AP a little by suprise. ..
|
|
|
Originally posted by dave64
I understand Parish and co took a long time interviewing managers before deciding on fdb .They must have fully understood his qualities and the style of play. The necessity for new players to fit in to this style. I would suggest he has been rather thrown to the wolves. not fully supported in transfer market. And when new style (as agreed and supported by parish)isn't immediately effective....parish throws him to the wolves. By 'taking some responsibility', what do you want Parish to do? Resign? I'm not sure how that would help tbh. Some acknowledgement of things going wrong? He can't really speak out on that now as that is a complete admission of failure and throwing FDB under the bus. If Frank leaves we may get something though.
Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link] Twitter: [Tweet Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by spartakev2
To be fair his style of play in the past has been 433 which you would argue suites our players, and he talked about evolution not revolution. So our start must have taken AP a little by suprise. .. That and we over £30 mil net and were prepared to spend over £10 mil on Niasse. It's not a lack of funds, 'or backing', which is a loose term and doesn't explain the situation or relationship. What the op do if as an employer his employee went and changed his plans after getting the job to something the workplace doesn't suit? Would you throw the full £40 mil at it when you know it'll take £100 mil. We could've ended up with 9 CB's and 14 defenders and the manager without a clue as to how to make the transition or changeover.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by dave64
I understand Parish and co took a long time interviewing managers before deciding on fdb .They must have fully understood his qualities and the style of play. The necessity for new players to fit in to this style. I would suggest he has been rather thrown to the wolves. not fully supported in transfer market. And when new style (as agreed and supported by parish)isn't immediately effective....parish throws him to the wolves. Parish has to solely responsible for the sorry state we find ourselves in, his slowness in appointing a Manager after Sam left is just the tip of the iceberg, the lack of investment in new players after the shambles of last season when it was clear to most that the squad was not up to PL standards and needed a major overhaul. The insecurity within the club as a result of Manager turnover in the period of the last four and a bit seasons, dismal home records over the same period, inability to attract players or decent managers to show any interest in coming to the club, bad decisions on transfers in the past with a lot of them spending more time on treatment table that actually playing or they are just not PL standard, emphasis on expanding ground capacity which will be absolutely pointless unless we can consolidate our PL status, meddling in football matters without the necessary skills or expertise. It is true that SP ET-AL, did a lot in saving the club in 2010 but that is all in the past and its is now time for him to move on hand over to a better leader for the future wellbeing of the club.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Den1923
Parish has to solely responsible for the sorry state we find ourselves in, his slowness in appointing a Manager after Sam left is just the tip of the iceberg, the lack of investment in new players after the shambles of last season when it was clear to most that the squad was not up to PL standards and needed a major overhaul. The insecurity within the club as a result of Manager turnover in the period of the last four and a bit seasons, dismal home records over the same period, inability to attract players or decent managers to show any interest in coming to the club, bad decisions on transfers in the past with a lot of them spending more time on treatment table that actually playing or they are just not PL standard, emphasis on expanding ground capacity which will be absolutely pointless unless we can consolidate our PL status, meddling in football matters without the necessary skills or expertise. It is true that SP ET-AL, did a lot in saving the club in 2010 but that is all in the past and its is now time for him to move on hand over to a better leader for the future wellbeing of the club. Walking out of the play off at Wembley, I couldn't see us staying up the next season, but here we are 4 years later still there. I think Parish deserves a little credit for that at least. Edited by Painter (08 Sep 2017 5.15pm) Edited by Painter (08 Sep 2017 5.15pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
Walking out of the play off at Wembley, I couldn't see us staying up the next season, but here we are 4 years later still there. I think Parish deserves a little credit for that at least. Edited by Painter (08 Sep 2017 5.15pm) Edited by Painter (08 Sep 2017 5.15pm) Because we lurched from one safe pair of hands to the next and paid through the nose to do it. Many of us could/would have appointed Pulis, Pardew, Allardyce at the times the club did.
|
|
|
Originally posted by est1905
Because we lurched from one safe pair of hands to the next and paid through the nose to do it. Many of us could/would have appointed Pulis, Pardew, Allardyce at the times the club did. It wasn't long ago, tables weren't produced until 6 games gone. Now after 3 games, you think we are in a relegation battle, a bit over dramatic with 35 games to go!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
Walking out of the play off at Wembley, I couldn't see us staying up the next season, but here we are 4 years later still there. I think Parish deserves a little credit for that at least. Edited by Painter (08 Sep 2017 5.15pm) Edited by Painter (08 Sep 2017 5.15pm) Living in the past is just that, it is the future now, we should be more than capable living in the PL, just like Stoke and Southampton, bad leadership is what this is all about, the fact that Parish has promoted himself to a level of incompetence is his problem, live for the now not in history1
|
|
|
We need a proper experienced director of football and Parish to take notice of him. Not Freedman. Not a yes man.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Den1923
Living in the past is just that, it is the future now, we should be more than capable living in the PL, just like Stoke and Southampton, bad leadership is what this is all about, the fact that Parish has promoted himself to a level of incompetence is his problem, live for the now not in history1 Why do you compare us to Southampton, they have been in the top flight for years, apart from a blip a few years ago. I am afraid history does count, all the top 7 clubs have been top teams for many years, so will always end up near the top. We are currently punching above our weight, it won't last for long, unless a billionaire takes a fancy to us, as financially we cannot compete, that isn't Parishs fault.
|
|
|
No One is asking Originally posted by Painter
for us to be a top 7 club, I think the general census of opinion is that after 5 years we should of moved on slightly, Not year after year, One of the favourites for relegation, And not safe until the final couple of games. And to be honest if its not Parish's fault who is it, Only with 7 managers over the past few years, I cant see anyone else in t he frame for our position apart from Parish? Generally his appointments have been awful Why do you compare us to Southampton, they have been in the top flight for years, apart from a blip a few years ago. I am afraid history does count, all the top 7 clubs have been top teams for many years, so will always end up near the top. We are currently punching above our weight, it won't last for long, unless a billionaire takes a fancy to us, as financially we cannot compete, that isn't Parishs fault.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
Why do you compare us to Southampton, they have been in the top flight for years, apart from a blip a few years ago. I am afraid history does count, all the top 7 clubs have been top teams for many years, so will always end up near the top. We are currently punching above our weight, it won't last for long, unless a billionaire takes a fancy to us, as financially we cannot compete, that isn't Parishs fault. I think I said there is no reason why we can't be a stable PL team like Soton and Stoke all we need is the leadership that can bring stability and consistency to the team. Having the number of managers we have had during the last four and a bit seasons has created the complete opposite. Like it or not managerial appointment are in the hands of SP and I'm afraid his people skills are really questionable as is some of the transfers he has approved of as we have a rather higher than normal number that seem to injury prone prior to joining us but for some reason they still seem to pass medicals. As far as financial competence is concerned if we have the 9th highest wage bill in PL then we do seem to have some financial clout it is therefore just not being used to best efficiency. After all it was SP who brokered the deal with the Americans and therefore it was down to him to ensure that had the right investment clout for the club to compete in the PL. i'm sorry i know some people think SP can walk on water but in reality he has promoted himself above the level of his competence as far as running a top flight football club is concerned and he should give up his 650K salary that he takes each year and handover to someone with better skills in that area, which is of course not Freedman who has no proven success as a manager andI'm still aghast as to why on earth SP has appoint him as sporting director!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Den1923
I think I said there is no reason why we can't be a stable PL team like Soton and Stoke all we need is the leadership that can bring stability and consistency to the team. Having the number of managers we have had during the last four and a bit seasons has created the complete opposite. Like it or not managerial appointment are in the hands of SP and I'm afraid his people skills are really questionable as is some of the transfers he has approved of as we have a rather higher than normal number that seem to injury prone prior to joining us but for some reason they still seem to pass medicals. As far as financial competence is concerned if we have the 9th highest wage bill in PL then we do seem to have some financial clout it is therefore just not being used to best efficiency. After all it was SP who brokered the deal with the Americans and therefore it was down to him to ensure that had the right investment clout for the club to compete in the PL. i'm sorry i know some people think SP can walk on water but in reality he has promoted himself above the level of his competence as far as running a top flight football club is concerned and he should give up his 650K salary that he takes each year and handover to someone with better skills in that area, which is of course not Freedman who has no proven success as a manager andI'm still aghast as to why on earth SP has appoint him as sporting director! Ok, I get you think Parish is incompetent, but put forward a viable alternative?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
Ok, I get you think Parish is incompetent, but put forward a viable alternative? I think i said SP had probably reached his level of incompetency as clearly he is now out of depth due to his lack of experience in leading a PL club evidenced by the points I have already made. It is not for me as a non shareholder to make decisions about who should succeed him that has to for the current board and shareholders. As you rightly say in 2010 he and the rest of his board members saved the club but sadly since we have arrived in PL we have made little or no forward progress and you could even argue that we have gone backwards. If the team loses it PL as seems likely we will be heading back to the championship and will lose all the money that comes with PL status and we will have wasted the last four and a bit seasons because the good players we currently have will not want to play in that league. I for one like our PL status and i'm not prepared to accept the current shambles and therefore I use this forum to express my views, sorry you do not like them but we all have our own expectations it just that some are higher than others. We can't keep banging on about passed successes because it the future that counts!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Den1923
I think i said SP had probably reached his level of incompetency as clearly he is now out of depth due to his lack of experience in leading a PL club evidenced by the points I have already made. It is not for me as a non shareholder to make decisions about who should succeed him that has to for the current board and shareholders. As you rightly say in 2010 he and the rest of his board members saved the club but sadly since we have arrived in PL we have made little or no forward progress and you could even argue that we have gone backwards. If the team loses it PL as seems likely we will be heading back to the championship and will lose all the money that comes with PL status and we will have wasted the last four and a bit seasons because the good players we currently have will not want to play in that league. I for one like our PL status and i'm not prepared to accept the current shambles and therefore I use this forum to express my views, sorry you do not like them but we all have our own expectations it just that some are higher than others. We can't keep banging on about passed successes because it the future that counts! So you have no alternative, just not prepared to accept, what you call a shambles of a 5th season in the Premier.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
So you have no alternative, just not prepared to accept, what you call a shambles of a 5th season in the Premier. I thinkI said that is not for me to decide or you come to that it is a results business as SP has already said himself and the results are not there and therefore he has to stand up and be counted like anybody else. Please give your views on why SP should stay and the aspirations you have for the future of the club` but please don't look back as the past cannot be changed tell us what you think should happen?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.