This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by DanH
Also worth noting Kaepernick first did this protest in August 2016. It's only since Trump's inflammatory comments has it become a huge issue with others taking a proper stand against him. Kaepernick is also without a contract this season because of his actions. From what I've read Kaepernick wasn't being picked to play regularly anyway. If his virtue signalling has made him unpopular well....them the breaks. As for your suggestion that this was some kind of small issue before Trump raised this....what planet are you on? This has been big in America since it happened. Trump just threw red meat to his base......The democrats will continue to defend not standing for the anthem....It's an easy win for him. Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Sep 2017 12.42am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
From what I've read Kaepernick wasn't being picked to play regularly anyway. If his virtue signalling has made him unpopular well....them the breaks. As for your suggestion that this was some kind of small issue before Trump raised this....what planet are you on? This has been big in America since it happened. Trump just threw red meat to his base......The democrats will continue to defend not standing for the anthem....It's an easy win for him. Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Sep 2017 12.42am) Again with the virtue signalling s***. Why are you trying to stigmatise empathy?
|
|
| wordup |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Yeah, oh how we should pity the criticism that these NFL millionaires have to endure. Bend the kneee.....bend the knee.....I feel tears coming to my eyes. Oh Please. It's hardly a great career move for them, so the money aspect is neither here nor there. The first person to do this hasn't been touched with a bargepole since he exercised this freedom of expression, something that matters to you like an on/off switch. As per usual, since you've deemed this to be about dreaded minorities and the left, you're on the attack and as stated and proved again and again, display a complete lack of attachment to the individuals involved, mocking them. Much in the same way that you shrug at neo nazi types or claim to not know what ELD stand for. 'Oh I'm unfamiliar with them'. Yes because you very selectively care about things based about your own prjeudices. Of course when it was a worker at Google, you were practically losing your mind over it, saying how you'd boycott google and how terrible it all was. Not a peep about how he was likely quite well off due to his job. Not mocking him. That all suddenly changes now though of course. I attacked both googles decision and said the guy should sue, and in this case defended these players too, yes because I don't think expressing themselves should lead to sidelining, threats and insults from a president and I think there is room for saying that, rather than pumping out your one sided approach to fairness and treatment of others. Edited by wordup (27 Sep 2017 1.31am)
|
|
| wordup |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
Again with the virtue signalling s***. Why are you trying to stigmatise empathy? No mention from him of the 'dog whistle' aspect of Trump stirring this up out of the blue in Alabama of all spaces for racial and populist reasons. That's no different to identity politics and virtue signaling and it is happening all of the time. Whether blind or ignorant to it, it doesn't detract from the reality. No mention either of the surrogate saying the players are lucky not to be shot in the head. It's all on the players. How dare these 'sons of bitches' take a knee, right? Such a laughable and hysterical reaction to the only truly peaceful action of the lot.
|
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by wordup
No mention from him of the 'dog whistle' aspect of Trump stirring this up out of the blue in Alabama of all spaces for racial and populist reasons. That's no different to identity politics and virtue signaling and it is happening all of the time. Whether blind or ignorant to it, it doesn't detract from the reality. No mention either of the surrogate saying the players are lucky not to be shot in the head. It's all on the players. How dare these 'sons of bitches' take a knee, right? Such a laughable and hysterical reaction to the only truly peaceful action of the lot.
[Tweet Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by wordup
It's hardly a great career move for them, so the money aspect is neither here nor there. The first person to do this hasn't been touched with a bargepole since he exercised this freedom of expression, something that matters to you like an on/off switch. As per usual, since you've deemed this to be about dreaded minorities and the left, you're on the attack and as stated and proved again and again, display a complete lack of attachment to the individuals involved, mocking them. Much in the same way that you shrug at neo nazi types or claim to not know what ELD stand for. 'Oh I'm unfamiliar with them'. Yes because you very selectively care about things based about your own prjeudices. Of course when it was a worker at Google, you were practically losing your mind over it, saying how you'd boycott google and how terrible it all was. Not a peep about how he was likely quite well off due to his job. Not mocking him. That all suddenly changes now though of course. I attacked both googles decision and said the guy should sue, and in this case defended these players too, yes because I don't think expressing themselves should lead to sidelining, threats and insults from a president and I think there is room for saying that, rather than pumping out your one sided approach to fairness and treatment of others.
I disagree with Kaepernick's mode of protest. So I criticise and mock it, sure....boo hoo. Shrug at neo Nazis....no you are just engaging in demonisation for your own little fantasy. Ok, listen very carefully....cause despite having said this multiple times you don't appear to be able to catch this....So I repeat it once again. Neo Nazis are bad....Get that? I'm fine with protesting Nazis. Detect any 'shrugging of the shoulders' there. Willing to actually take that in...Or does it conflict with your narrative about me too much.....I know the problems you have with face value....unless it's yourself of course. Kaepernick wasn't playing regularly before anyway. This was his choice. People have a right to disagree with him. Trump's throwing red meat to his base where the Democrats end up supporting kneeing for the flag...easy win for him at a time where getting his policies through has been frustrated. As for the EDL, I've read their mission statement and I find nothing wrong with it at all. Read it yourself and tell me what aspect of it is bad and we can debate it. I looked at them after Jamie raised them in a thread. I don't know the EDL....another face value statement which you may find difficult to accept. From Youtube clips after Nick's silly catcalling I'm aware that the EDL attract members who go beyond what that mission statement says and that's a problem....but are you calling the EDL neo nazis here? As for your 'you very selectively care about things based about your own prejudices.' Well, yes and no.....To an extent everyone is like that. We all see the world through the prism of our prejudices. But I also defend principles that are universal. So your charge here is moot. I'm glad we agree over Damore. However, if you truly are concerned about a 'one sided approach to fairness and treatment of others' perhaps you should reflect upon how you yourself engage with those who disagree with you yourself. For myself I tend to try to match the nature of the engagement. So if someone's genuine about a discussion of ideas then that's what happens. If it's abuse then it's abuse back. You appear to be a progressive but on the more liberal side. I'm anti modern progressivism so we can argue about that, but where you are liberal I mostly agree. Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Sep 2017 1.40am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| wordup |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I disagree with Kaepernick's mode of protest. So I criticise and mock it, sure....boo hoo. Shrug at neo Nazis....no you are just engaging in demonisation for your own little fantasy. Ok, listen very carefully....cause despite having said this multiple times you don't appear to be able to catch this....So I repeat it once again. Neo Nazis are bad....Get that? I'm fine with protesting Nazis. Detect any 'shrugging of the shoulders' there. Willing to actually take that in...Or does it conflict with your narrative about me too much.....I know the problems you have with taking statements at face value....unless it's yourself of course. Kaepernick wasn't playing regularly before anyway. This was his choice. People have a right to disagree with him. Trump's throwing red meat to his base where the Democrats end up supporting kneeing for the flag...easy win for him at a time where getting his policies through has been frustrated. As for the EDL, I've read their mission statement and I find nothing wrong with it at all. Read it yourself and tell me what aspect of it is bad and we can debate it. I looked at them after Jamie raised them in a thread. I don't know the EDL....another face value statement which you may find difficult to accept. From Youtube clips after Nick's silly catcalling I'm aware that the EDL attract members who go beyond what that mission statement says and that's a problem....but are you calling the EDL neo nazis here? As for your 'you very selectively care about things based about your own prejudices.' Well, yes and no.....To an extent everyone is like that. We all see the world through the prism of our prejudices. But I also defend principles that are universal. So your charge here is moot. I'm glad we agree over Damore. However, if you truly are concerned about a 'one sided approach to fairness and treatment of others' perhaps you should reflect upon how you yourself engage with those who disagree with you yourself. For myself I tend to try to match the nature of the engagement. So if someone's genuine about a discussion of ideas then that's what happens. If it's abuse then it's abuse back. You appear to be a progressive but on the more liberal side. I'm anti modern progressivism so we can argue about that, but where you are liberal I mostly agree. Oh it's the 'mode of protest' that's the problem for you now is it. Well I never Edited by wordup (27 Sep 2017 1.48am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by wordup
Oh it's the 'mode of protest' that's the problem for you now is it. Well I never
I think I've been reasonably consistent over NFL millionaires virtue signalling and what I think the consequences are. I've made my points about freedom of speech and what the consequences would be if it is extended into all areas at all times, as some have suggested....Nevertheless, I haven't called for bans...But if I'm employing someone who's constantly engaging in politics with my customers who are there for business or pleasure....well, it's not good. I think Fifa and the Olympics have their rule over politics for good reasons. Of course this is a restriction on free speech on one level....But then again I'm also against speech that endorses physical violence, pushes known libel or obscenity. I've always said this....Maybe even this needs revision to be more liberal...Recent events have given me cause to consider that as well. I don't think Jamie's contention that politics 'in everything' path is healthy for cohesion.....But we could discuss this. Maybe you or me could convince the other otherwise.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by wordup
Oh it's the 'mode of protest' that's the problem for you now is it. Well I never Edited by wordup (27 Sep 2017 1.48am) I'm aware that I annoy you and that our views on some areas are pretty divergent.....but to be honest I tend to like liberals even if my attachment to liberalism is dependent upon the area of discussion. But liberalism, in general, is a vital building block for secular societies. Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Sep 2017 2.20am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
Again with the virtue signalling s***. Why are you trying to stigmatise empathy? Empathy makes for bad politics in my view, and in plenty of other's view. I'm for fairness after analysis.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| hedgehog50 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by wordup
Oh it's the 'mode of protest' that's the problem for you now is it. Well I never Edited by wordup (27 Sep 2017 1.48am) All these daft 'protests' are more a fashion statement than a serious political action - bit like silly goal celebrations, or wearing your jeans half way down your arse.
We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell] |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I think I've been reasonably consistent over NFL millionaires virtue signalling and what I think the consequences are. I've made my points about freedom of speech and what the consequences would be if it is extended into all areas at all times, as some have suggested....Nevertheless, I haven't called for bans...But if I'm employing someone who's constantly engaging in politics with my customers who are there for business or pleasure....well, it's not good. I think Fifa and the Olympics have their rule over politics for good reasons. Of course this is a restriction on free speech on one level....But then again I'm also against speech that endorses physical violence, pushes known libel or obscenity. I've always said this....Maybe even this needs revision to be more liberal...Recent events have given me cause to consider that as well. I don't think Jamie's contention that politics 'in everything' path is healthy for cohesion.....But we could discuss this. Maybe you or me could convince the other otherwise. Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Sep 2017 2.11am) Its healthier than ascertain that only some forms of free speech and expression, related to peaceful protest is valid. Its telling that people on the right in the US seem to be very vocal about the right to protest, free speech and free expression, then immediately jump to damn someone for doing so because it doesn't mesh with their views. The protests were dignified, non-violent and non-disruptive in the extreme (they didn't even affect the game), and yet the outpouring, vitriol and outrage from the US president exceeds that of the murder of a woman in Charlottesville.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by hedgehog50
All these daft 'protests' are more a fashion statement than a serious political action - bit like silly goal celebrations, or wearing your jeans half way down your arse.
Doesn't seem like it to me, it appears to have obtain massive publicity, and got debate going on a national level - The president of the US appears to think its very political and important.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Yeah, oh how we should pity the criticism that these NFL millionaires have to endure. Bend the kneee.....bend the knee.....I feel tears coming to my eyes. Oh Please. Many of them might be 'millionaires' now, but that doesn't immediately separate you from who you were, where you come from and issues you see in society. Also, there is a problem with police fatalities in the US and the way the police respond to 'feeling threatened' as the same as being threatened. It might not be a specifically Black thing. Its just that the black community in the US has the right apparatus for raising issues. Worryingly, plenty of unarmed, questionable shootings of white and latinos occur in poor areas. When the police are regularly killing unarmed people - That is a problem.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Many of them might be 'millionaires' now, but that doesn't immediately separate you from who you were, where you come from and issues you see in society. Also, there is a problem with police fatalities in the US and the way the police respond to 'feeling threatened' as the same as being threatened. It might not be a specifically Black thing. Its just that the black community in the US has the right apparatus for raising issues. Worryingly, plenty of unarmed, questionable shootings of white and latinos occur in poor areas. When the police are regularly killing unarmed people - That is a problem. When you have a country with more guns than people you have a problem. What you raise is one of the fundamental problems within American culture that isn't going to be solved anytime soon...The right to bear arms and a fundamental suspicion of the government that goes beyond criticism and for a percent seeing it as a pseudo enemy...The seeds of that lies at the heart of their constitution....it's apart of the majority's mental make up and gives its states their independent spirit and identities.....Like everything else it's sometimes taken too far. In reality we can only hope that common sense sees them reducing the worst affects of those culturally negative beliefs. You are right.....when it's your job to deal with criminals all day you become desensitized to them. A lot of their behaviour is so low ethically that it is easy to dehumanise them because that's what plenty of criminals have already done to the Police themselves as they do their victims. As the Police are their on first principles to protect the public you can easily see why the 'them and us' mentality is inevitable. In an atmosphere like that you require a mentally strong and very importantly calm logical individual who stays calm in the heat of action......Those kind of people are ideal and not littered around the place.....and often individuals like don't want to do such a demanding and relatively low paid high hassle job like Police work. You know that reality is what often annoys me when the middle classes in the media slag off police. It's a hard but vital job that most of them wouldn't let their own children go a mile near. Yet like social workers it's a job they are happy to finger point at and smear.....Yet when they need them it's suddenly very different. It's this ongoing chance that you will come into a life and death situation that means that we will get fifty fifty situations on the appropriateness of an action as well as totally wrong reactions. Stress situations that involve instant decisions involving guns always provide for the chance of safety first reactions....safety for the officer(s) death for the criminal/victim/whatever they were. When you add this to the bad apples that every profession will get then tragedy.....well it's inevitable. It's inevitable in societies where police don't have guns so it's multiplied many times in ones that do.....Of course the institution is going to protect their own...They see outsiders who don't really understand or care about the nature of their job assigning 'evil' motives to them and know the damage to morale leaving officers out to dry would have to keeping people and recruitment.....Sometimes it turns out they are right to do it and sometimes not. It's why body cams are essential both for the Police's safety and the public. With the conspiracy theorist mentally being so popular....and with the help of attention seekers plus the democrats playing race and victim cards to get their votes you get communities treating the Police as the enemy....despite many of their own communities being within those forces. It just embeds the problem....which isn't going to change. Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Sep 2017 1.51pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| wordup |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by hedgehog50
All these daft 'protests' are more a fashion statement than a serious political action - bit like silly goal celebrations, or wearing your jeans half way down your arse.
I like end of the pier shows as much as the next man. Thanks for keeping the tradition going.
|
|
| wordup |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Its healthier than ascertain that only some forms of free speech and expression, related to peaceful protest is valid. Its telling that people on the right in the US seem to be very vocal about the right to protest, free speech and free expression, then immediately jump to damn someone for doing so because it doesn't mesh with their views. The protests were dignified, non-violent and non-disruptive in the extreme (they didn't even affect the game), and yet the outpouring, vitriol and outrage from the US president exceeds that of the murder of a woman in Charlottesville. Well said that man. A salient and fair minded take.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.