You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Parish unable to progress us
November 16 2026 7.58am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Parish unable to progress us


Page 13 of 16 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >
alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 15 Feb 18 5.57pm

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

I tend to agree with a lot in this post ^^^
Parish needs Football business people to advise him and perhaps not so much from ex-Palace players. It seems Steve Parish could do with some well-informed impartial advice on some aspects of running the club.

You don't buy a dog and continue barking yourself, and you also don't surround yourself with 'yes' people.

New stadium/stand plans are a case in point. Did Steve get proper experienced football architects to do the plans ?
Or did he get Andy Johnson to scribble something on the back of a McDonalds box ?
Steve needs a proper set of advisors.

C'mon Steve, sort your 5hlt out.

Hi Ali,

Hope your well,Steve used KSS Architects.
They did the New Stand project for Liverpool.
And I believe they designed Brighton’s State Of The Art Training complex.

Andrew didn’t do it.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 15 Feb 18 6.33pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Hysteria rules

Me?

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 15 Feb 18 7.57pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Huh? So not firing Pardew soon enough (by several months) allowing all confidence to erode and players like Puncheon and Dann suffer majorly form wise was down to having too much ambition?

Not signing a goalkeeper thus leaving us with 1 fit keeper (as Jules immediately got injured) is down to too much ambition?

Not signing a striker last time around leaving us with 1 fit striker (who immediately got injured) was down to too much ambition?

Not properly addressing glaring squad depth issues like left back before Souare went down was down to too much ambition?

Not firing Holloway sooner....hiring Neil Warnock (wtf)....down to too much ambition?

Nah mate, these errors are down to Parish being a weak chairman in the context of other men in this league. Very, very poor chairman with poor judgement and poor planning skills. Only someone with a bizarre sense of judgement would laud themselves for signing a goalkeeper 6 months from now, when we desperately need one now.

I was referring the attempts to move us to the next level / look upwards playing possession football with Pardew and De Boer which have actually set us back.

Holloway walked and we punched way above our weight for two and half years. Safe with games to spare first three seasons.

Whilst some of the mistakes you refer to have some relevance they're insignificant by comparison and IMO not really bitten (yet touch wood) aside from our £120k a week £30m marquee signing having competition after losing his shooting boots.

BTW almost forgot there's £80k a week marquee signing Yohan Cabaye who can't score. Not forgetting England international Andros Townsend who has managed one goal and highly rated international Loftus-Cheek who has turned out to have injury issues and poor end product.

Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (15 Feb 2018 7.58pm)

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 15 Feb 18 10.21pm

What an absolute load of tosh. Why not being clear on where in your opinion the "progress" is ? Possesion football right? Get away from the long ball? Can't you see we are making up the numbers in the entertainment industry of the PL? You honestly believe careful management from the top takes care of a club our size to sort things out?

And the amount of money is relative. the whole of the PL has the ridiclous amount of tv money coming in.
How do you create a base where you can safely say you are likely to bounce back once you go down?
Where we fail as a club, and I seem to be one of a few on here in thinking that, is youth development and bringing our own players through to the first team. Unfortunately modern football seems not mainly, but pretty much only about transfers, transfers transfers. SP main fault may be to not have the right football people on youth development and scouting jobs but to blame him for all football/transfer decisions going wrong seems rather unfair to me. We seem to lack the decent back up stuff in terms of scouting lower leagues and internationally.

quote=Mstrobez;3310661]

People who keep banging in about this being our longest spell in the top flight in our history miss the point of threads like this completely. It’s been nothing but scraping survival at all costs. Now, I completely understand that approach in the first few years, but the reason so many of us harp on about progression isn’t because we’re getting too big for our boots, it’s because if we go down we will literally have nothing to show for the 5 years we’ve been here. We’ve come nowhere as a club.

The problem with parish is every decision he makes is based on appeasing people short term & hoping he can get a tv appearance portrayed as a footballing guru, but he’s not even very good at achieving that. He normally gets about 3 weeks work a season because the rest of the time he’s back to desperately pulling off some great escape again.

Our priorities are completely wrong, and it’s utterly pointless not to target progression with the amount of money you take in as a premier league club. Unless something changes, we’re goinf down anyway. Going down isn’t the worrying part, what worries me more is going down, having not progressed the footballing culture at the club at all meaning that coming back up quickly will be extremely difficult.

Being in the premier league for 5 years is great, but we will hugely regret being so short sighted & failing to capitalise on what is a once in a history opportunity.

Edited by Mstrobez (15 Feb 2018 10.02am)


 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 15 Feb 18 11.54pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Its totally wild speculation and typical newspaper crap and tells you nothing, thats what. It's a nothing quote. It doesn't tell you anything about what was said, to who, or about who. It just says he was shocked. It could actually mean anything, FDB was crap? Well we know that. He didn't get on with the players? Well there were lots of rumours on here about that. Couldn't believe Parish got rid of him? We all know the reason for that, even Parish admitted it. Does it also mean that Sammy Lee goes around spreading malicious gossip about 'behind the scenes' stuff at other clubs, well that wouldn't be good for his management career if that is true.

Finally if, as the Mirror is perhaps trying to suggest, that Koeman is disturbed by the turnover of managers at Palace then he should have a little look closer to home at his own career as a manager. 8 clubs and now sacked in 16 seasons is not what I call a manager who should be appalled by the turnover of managers especially when you consider one of his appointments was 4 seasons long.

Now if you think I am completely wrong in my interpretation, then you will have rather answered your own question, as it could mean literally anything, hence my post.

My post was in fact supposed to be pretty lighthearted and a little jibe at Willo's "I know" posts, so why did you feel the need to post on behalf of Midlands Eagle. Are you two a tag team?

Blimey. I was just answering your question on what his sentence or post meant and youmpost all that. Actually I'll give one answer.

Sammy Lee wasn't 'spreading any malicious gossip.' He had dinner with Koeman and as football men and friends, they talked football. It's likely that it was, as usual, in confidence. If this happened, who is Koeman more loyal to? Firstly saving himself, and after that at some point possibly De Boer before Sammy Lee. Therefore any loyalty to Sammy Lee may have gone out of the window when trying to save his own skin. Sammy Lee may not even be that fussed.

We don't know if any of what Koeman said happened but his intentions and loyalty to himself is very possible.

 


COYP

Maine Eagle Flag USA 16 Feb 18 1.54am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

I was referring the attempts to move us to the next level / look upwards playing possession football with Pardew and De Boer which have actually set us back.

Holloway walked and we punched way above our weight for two and half years. Safe with games to spare first three seasons.

Whilst some of the mistakes you refer to have some relevance they're insignificant by comparison and IMO not really bitten (yet touch wood) aside from our £120k a week £30m marquee signing having competition after losing his shooting boots.

BTW almost forgot there's £80k a week marquee signing Yohan Cabaye who can't score. Not forgetting England international Andros Townsend who has managed one goal and highly rated international Loftus-Cheek who has turned out to have injury issues and poor end product.

Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (15 Feb 2018 7.58pm)

Insignificant? Totally disagree.

Letting us have only 1 fit striker in the premier league was completely reckless and ridiculous to boot. Lo and behold Benteke got injured not long after that p&ss poor decision was made to not sign Niasse/A. N. other.

Not replacing Mandanda is such a glaring mistake that it is literally costing us points per season, which we cannot afford.

Listening to Hodgson harp on about the pressing need to sign a goalie, messing around with Guaita, and not signing a keeper in the last window is also reckless and once again Parish is playing a foolish and senseless game with squad depth. He is also annoying the manager into the bargain, who clearly isnt happy with our 2 keepers, and the fact that we only have 2 in the first place.

Parish doesnt exactly have a strong history of keeping managers overly happy. Somehow Allardyce "retired from football" on his watch.

Lo and behold Jules immediately gets injured and now we have 1 fit keeper.

Whats your point about our signings not being good enough? That is once again Parish' fault as he has the ultimate say on who we buy, so you are making my point for me there mate.

Holloway had to beg to get fired/be ALLOWED to walk which was a nonsense.

As for Parish's attempts to move us forward and play on the front foot more, notice a pattern there? We tried it with Pardew to our ruination, and then Parish goes and makes the same mistake again with FDB, but on a spectacularly stupid scale, I must admit.

The pattern is Parish making the same bonehead mistakes year after year after year.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

silvertop Flag Portishead 16 Feb 18 10.45am

I am loath to speak for another poster, but where I read "insignificant" I read relatively trivial in the scheme of where this club is going.

I don't agree with everything you have said - much opinion filtered through red mist? - but you make some good points about the way SP has managed the squad and the fact that we have lost 2 managers who - unheard of in the Prem - have walked rather than be fired. Because of the money and prestige of Prem management, I suspect most head coaches will tolerate just about anything to stay in post. So why did 2 middle-ranking managers leave? Something is not right.

Then again - and I know a lot of posters are annoyed that this is raised each time SP is criticised - there is still the small fact that we are a club that has gone from c.10p in value that owned only its name to £150M and ownership of its whole capital infrastructure... in only 8 years.

As a small unfashionable club, we are still expanding in terms of enriching the brand image and non-TV commercial revenue. We are rebuilding the ground in a sensible progressive way - stand by stand. We do not have the funds of Liverpool or Spurs to do the whole lot in one go. We will improve the training facilities and academy but, unlike most of our competition, we are having to attempt this within the M25 where land is very scarce and very expensive.

At the playing end we give the appearance of an organisation still finding its way. At the corporate end recovery from near liquidation to a sound business unit is ongoing with the trajectory still upward. As anyone in commerce will tell you, we will see improvements in the former as the latter continues to grow.

Trouble is, the pace is probably too slow for most football fans.

 

SeagullHunter Flag Reading 16 Feb 18 11.37am

It is quite astounding the amount of yes-men proclaiming Parish's innocence in this season's debacle. If we get relegated, although part of the blame will fall on the players and management staff, the brunt of it will fall on SP's shoulders. Prior to the start of the season many neutral would have tipped us for 9th-13th placed finish. Instead what has followed is poor Summer recruitment, an embarrassing January transfer window, and to not to forget a lack of addressing academy issues whilst using the 'new stadium' as a smokescreen.

 


Dont let Cabaye go

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 16 Feb 18 11.48am

Originally posted by SeagullHunter

It is quite astounding the amount of yes-men proclaiming Parish's innocence in this season's debacle. If we get relegated, although part of the blame will fall on the players and management staff, the brunt of it will fall on SP's shoulders. Prior to the start of the season many neutral would have tipped us for 9th-13th placed finish. Instead what has followed is poor Summer recruitment, an embarrassing January transfer window, and to not to forget a lack of addressing academy issues whilst using the 'new stadium' as a smokescreen.

No what followed was a managerial cock up .
Rectified after 4 games.
This January’s transfer window,we will have to wait and see.
Remind me what are the Academy Issues.?
It’s a “New” stand.
Last time I looked we are on schedule for 13th.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

michaelpearce Flag grays 16 Feb 18 12.12pm

same things being repeated over and over again, not one person who complains about parish has come up with a alternative or put there millions into the club to buy him out.
Parish is no different to any other chairman balancing the books is a must, we are starting work hopefully on new stand that is a must, and tidying up other parts of the ground and training ground.
Parish is not a footballer we can sell on and replace, he would cost alot more to replace,so unless you can think of someone to take over, stop complaining about him, because if the yanks didnt rate him he would have been gone by now

 

It's only a game Flag Praa Sands 16 Feb 18 12.30pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce

same things being repeated over and over again, not one person who complains about parish has come up with a alternative or put there millions into the club to buy him out.
Parish is no different to any other chairman balancing the books is a must, we are starting work hopefully on new stand that is a must, and tidying up other parts of the ground and training ground.
Parish is not a footballer we can sell on and replace, he would cost alot more to replace,so unless you can think of someone to take over, stop complaining about him, because if the yanks didnt rate him he would have been gone by now

Spot on and what a short memories some posters have.

 


A stockbroker urged me to buy a stock that would triple its value every year. I told him, at my age, I don't even buy green bananas!


silvertop Flag Portishead 16 Feb 18 4.40pm

[quote=It's only a game;3310926]

Spot on and what a short memories some posters have.

Many haven't been supporters long enough

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 Feb 18 4.44pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce

same things being repeated over and over again, not one person who complains about parish has come up with a alternative or put there millions into the club to buy him out.
Parish is no different to any other chairman balancing the books is a must, we are starting work hopefully on new stand that is a must, and tidying up other parts of the ground and training ground.
Parish is not a footballer we can sell on and replace, he would cost alot more to replace,so unless you can think of someone to take over, stop complaining about him, because if the yanks didnt rate him he would have been gone by now

We have.

Listen to football people who know and appreciate that starting a season with 1 striker is negligent lunacy. The whole world thinks it is, unless they're all wrong and the sun will always rise tomorrow is the answer to that lot.

Listen to the manager when he has huge concerns over things like 1 keeper.

Actually take on what the football people are saying rather than listen and let your own business approach discard what the sport on the pitch requires.

Maybe overturn any American choices to sign high transfer fee players and maybe scout a bit more when we've been aware of the position for 9,12, 15 months. This is possibly happening now.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 Feb 18 4.51pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Many haven't been supporters long enough

I think you'll find many of us providing constructive criticism have been supporting for a long time and it's because we know how precious prem status is. We know we're not as likely to bounce back and our stay back in the championship could be a decade. What happens to the new stand then? What happens if it is built and we're running at a loss? It's the Americans' loss until we bounce back but these things are taken a bit lightly when such things as a 2nd striker and lack of keeper back up are easily excused, and being repeated mistakes.

Just respect football people who are presumably respected when hired.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (16 Feb 2018 4.53pm)

 


COYP

michaelpearce Flag grays 16 Feb 18 5.25pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

We have.

Listen to football people who know and appreciate that starting a season with 1 striker is negligent lunacy. The whole world thinks it is, unless they're all wrong and the sun will always rise tomorrow is the answer to that lot.

Listen to the manager when he has huge concerns over things like 1 keeper.

Actually take on what the football people are saying rather than listen and let your own business approach discard what the sport on the pitch requires.

Maybe overturn any American choices to sign high transfer fee players and maybe scout a bit more when we've been aware of the position for 9,12, 15 months. This is possibly happening now.

no you haven't Parish is the issue with the ones who complain,you want parish out but cant say who will take his place, we all all know what we want but we are not the ones funding it,

so who is going to change things to everyone that complains ,none of yous have come up with a name,as i said he is not a player we can sell,he helps to bank roll the club, we dont see the books, we dont see whats going on behind the scenes,so its blind judgement,you dont have a full picture so unless you can prove different and i mean with real proof, not my neighbors aunt uncle best mate said,

yes i would like to see us signing everyone i want,but real world we cant, We are a big club in the waiting but need major money to get up there, so ground improvements is a major start getting a manager in we wont sack tomorrow or leave because we cant fund what they want or fans who cant wait to see them improve the team because they dont like them,

i think i have covered most things have headache now, but if anyone can come up with better ways to fund the club,sure parish&co would be interested along with the rest of us

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 16 Feb 18 5.28pm

I agree on the striker situation Rudy, unsure about the keeprs as for all I know Henry may be ready for PL action. What is the point of any youth develepmont if beforehand we exclude the option of actually playing them?

And how do we know it's SP that made all the cock ups? How are we to know if SA's, FdB and Roy's "lists" of players wanted were realistic and achievable? Is it SP's fault that noone in the whole club structure seems able to scout a decent lower League or lesser know international player? I feel there is a lot of assumption in asiging the blame. Having said that I felt the squad was thin when the season started and surely is not better after the window so I get people's frustration. It's just that I feel it's only partly SP's fault, and I see little proof he is actually pulling all the strings on "football matters".

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I think you'll find many of us providing constructive criticism have been supporting for a long time and it's because we know how precious prem status is. We know we're not as likely to bounce back and our stay back in the championship could be a decade. What happens to the new stand then? What happens if it is built and we're running at a loss? It's the Americans' loss until we bounce back but these things are taken a bit lightly when such things as a 2nd striker and lack of keeper back up are easily excused, and being repeated mistakes.

Just respect football people who are presumably respected when hired.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (16 Feb 2018 4.53pm)


 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 16 Feb 18 5.31pm

He can and will progress us. Anyone who is currently questioning and doubting him will also be claiming the earth is flat and should be ignored at all costs.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 Feb 18 5.39pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce

no you haven't Parish is the issue with the ones who complain,you want parish out but cant say who will take his place, we all all know what we want but we are not the ones funding it,

so who is going to change things to everyone that complains ,none of yous have come up with a name,as i said he is not a player we can sell,he helps to bank roll the club, we dont see the books, we dont see whats going on behind the scenes,so its blind judgement,you dont have a full picture so unless you can prove different and i mean with real proof, not my neighbors aunt uncle best mate said,

yes i would like to see us signing everyone i want,but real world we cant, We are a big club in the waiting but need major money to get up there, so ground improvements is a major start getting a manager in we wont sack tomorrow or leave because we cant fund what they want or fans who cant wait to see them improve the team because they dont like them,

i think i have covered most things have headache now, but if anyone can come up with better ways to fund the club,sure parish&co would be interested along with the rest of us

No I do not want Parish 'out.' In your headached head I do. The transfers need addressing. He's a major shareholder anyway. Transfers transfers transfers transfers transfers.

'Sign everyone we want.' More extreme nonsense. Just a 2nd striker we were aware of for 9 months. Same for the keeper and any others.

 


COYP

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 16 Feb 18 5.42pm

Originally posted by SeagullHunter

It is quite astounding the amount of yes-men proclaiming Parish's innocence in this season's debacle. If we get relegated, although part of the blame will fall on the players and management staff, the brunt of it will fall on SP's shoulders. Prior to the start of the season many neutral would have tipped us for 9th-13th placed finish. Instead what has followed is poor Summer recruitment, an embarrassing January transfer window, and to not to forget a lack of addressing academy issues whilst using the 'new stadium' as a smokescreen.

I think that the argument is slightly more nuanced than that. The question is whether he is the man to take us forward, not whether he has made mistakes. He has made plenty, show mw a chairman that hasn't.

As you say, many would tip us to finish 9-13th (which is interesting given the criticism of our transfer windows). We are currently 15th, 4 points of 10th, not exactly off target.

Five points between 10th and relegation places. Teams down there include Stoke, 10 yrs in the Prem,Swansea 7 yrs and West Brom 8 yrs. Two of those teams have recently been taken over. Huw Jenkins was viewed as the model chairman. Also in a current relegation place are Southampton. The club everyone should mimic, the cub that is the template for PL success. Apparently


Edited by Y Ddraig Goch (16 Feb 2018 5.48pm)

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 Feb 18 5.44pm

Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan

I agree on the striker situation Rudy, unsure about the keeprs as for all I know Henry may be ready for PL action. What is the point of any youth develepmont if beforehand we exclude the option of actually playing them?

And how do we know it's SP that made all the cock ups? How are we to know if SA's, FdB and Roy's "lists" of players wanted were realistic and achievable? Is it SP's fault that noone in the whole club structure seems able to scout a decent lower League or lesser know international player? I feel there is a lot of assumption in asiging the blame. Having said that I felt the squad was thin when the season started and surely is not better after the window so I get people's frustration. It's just that I feel it's only partly SP's fault, and I see little proof he is actually pulling all the strings on "football matters".

Any sane football person would make a lot of noise leading up to the start of the season with 1 striker. I include freedman here...

Or in January, again with 2 keepers ready to become 1. Sounds like the spice girls. 'When 2 become 1.' I include Roy here as well.

No sane football man would let through if they had a big say. Not a chance.

 


COYP

Page 13 of 16 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Parish unable to progress us