You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Max Meyer thread
November 16 2026 6.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Max Meyer thread


Page 13 of 27 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >
MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 07 Jan 19 7.49am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Because it didn't happen.

He collected the ball short a couple of times and played a couple of pases wide which he then followed in on, slowing the game up. That's when he wasn't taking one touch too many and being closed down and forced to play an obvious, albeit success, pass which was easily tracked.

Spent most of the time ghosting about in the middle not affecting anything when not in possession.

Interesting how people see different things in the game. Thought his performance was an example of why Roy has not been playing him. Anonymous for most of the game. Not surprising he was taken off. I doubt we will be seeing much more of Jairo.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 07 Jan 19 8.49am

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

Interesting how people see different things in the game. Thought his performance was an example of why Roy has not been playing him. Anonymous for most of the game. Not surprising he was taken off. I doubt we will be seeing much more of Jairo.

Agree. He looks comfortable on the ball and isn't shy to go and collect close in which often gets mistaken for being a good footballer, although it's not without merit, especially when your back is to the wall and all of a sudden nobody else wants the ball.

Scott Parker made a career out of it, although to his credit his transitional play in his prime for a couple of seasons was good and he could read the game out of posssesion.

Jairo isn't close to that level. I always judge a central player by the next ball after the one they play and their movement thereafter. Meyer gets some stick and is partial to a sideways pass, but when he does it, it's got pace and he moves forward to take players and create space, therefore allowing the recipient to either run with the ball or pass forward.

At best Jairo's passes either end up going backwards from the recipient, closed down because he follows the pass to receive a one two and gets tracked or he moves behind the ball, back to his sitting position which invites the opposition forward. Off the ball, there's seemingly no comprehension of how his positioning will affect an attack. You can't always sit deep and central when you don't have wing backs stretching the play (in that phase) and bringing the line forward.

He looks like an old school centre half who needs to play in a fluid 3 as the break man between two centre backs. I think De Boer signed him for this speciality skill (which it is) and played him there Vs Huddersfield which was a disaster, but that was probably more down to coaching.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 07 Jan 19 10.46am

On the subject of Max. Hes a nice tidy player but just think we could do with a bit more. The way I see his game is he just keeps the ball moving but without any real penetration. Takes the easy sideways and backwards pass too often for me. Think he would fit very nicely into a Man City midfield just think we need more from him. I know they are different player and an unfair comparison but We really miss RLC driving from midfield. Having said that RLC took time to warm up too.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 07 Jan 19 10.58am

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

On the subject of Max. Hes a nice tidy player but just think we could do with a bit more. The way I see his game is he just keeps the ball moving but without any real penetration. Takes the easy sideways and backwards pass too often for me. Think he would fit very nicely into a Man City midfield just think we need more from him. I know they are different player and an unfair comparison but We really miss RLC driving from midfield. Having said that RLC took time to warm up too.

He's got to start dictating where the run is made and playing the ball into it. Hopefully this will click in time as it relies on his teammates being on the same wavelength. Also, I'd like to see him shoot more.

He's got himself into some excellent positions where he should pull the trigger and you can see him weighing it before playing a pass instead. It's easy to forget that he spent a long period grounded at Schalke. I think he's just now adjusted to the pace of the league, hopefully the rest will follow now.

 

Mr Fenandes Flag 07 Jan 19 11.41am

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

On the subject of Max. Hes a nice tidy player but just think we could do with a bit more. The way I see his game is he just keeps the ball moving but without any real penetration. Takes the easy sideways and backwards pass too often for me. Think he would fit very nicely into a Man City midfield just think we need more from him. I know they are different player and an unfair comparison but We really miss RLC driving from midfield. Having said that RLC took time to warm up too.

TBF we should be taking full advantage of this simple passing, we cannot attack through the middle so players like Luka and Meyer who can pass the ball quickly and accurately should be switching the play with their technique. But even when we have it on the wing and a decent cross does get put in (as Townsend has done time and time again this season) there's no one with any kind of positional sense to finish it!

 


Check out our Croydon-based football comedy series 'Road to F.A. Cup'!
All episodes available FREE here: [Link]

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 07 Jan 19 11.54am

Originally posted by Mr Fenandes

TBF we should be taking full advantage of this simple passing, we cannot attack through the middle so players like Luka and Meyer who can pass the ball quickly and accurately should be switching the play with their technique. But even when we have it on the wing and a decent cross does get put in (as Townsend has done time and time again this season) there's no one with any kind of positional sense to finish it!

Sorloth has dreadful positional sense. He tends to go back post when he should be going in the middle and vice versa. He just doesn’t seem to have a proper striker instinct. Benteke and Wickham are much better at reading the game and even Ayew read the delivery for his Grimsby header well. I sincerely hope that with Wickham fit, Benteke on his way back and Ayew finding the net we are going to improve in the area you refer to.

 

davenotamonkey Flag 13 Jan 19 1.37am

Needs to start next match IMO

 

PatrickA Flag London 20 Jan 19 1.54pm

Meyer is a good footballer and offers something different to our other midfield options.
I can’t see how he’s going to be a regular under Hodgson though.
On the assumption that Wilf reverts to the left with Benteke or another striker down the middle and Townsend on the right I can’t see Meyer getting ahead of Luka, Mcarthur or Kouyate for midfield positions.
Even in 4-4-2 with Benteke and Zaha up front it looks like it would be between Meyer, Mcarthur and Schlupp for the position on the left of midfield.
Mcarthur is one of Hodgson’s favourites and a very steady player so I can’t see him being left out.
May be another case of another good player that just doesn’t suit the system.

 

AERO Flag 20 Jan 19 2.03pm

Might regret the day he goes because he can’t get a game . Believe me he is quality would find a place for him if we don’t one of the premiership teams will and we will live to regret it .

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 20 Jan 19 2.04pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Meyer is a good footballer and offers something different to our other midfield options.
I can’t see how he’s going to be a regular under Hodgson though.
On the assumption that Wilf reverts to the left with Benteke or another striker down the middle and Townsend on the right I can’t see Meyer getting ahead of Luka, Mcarthur or Kouyate for midfield positions.
Even in 4-4-2 with Benteke and Zaha up front it looks like it would be between Meyer, Mcarthur and Schlupp for the position on the left of midfield.
Mcarthur is one of Hodgson’s favourites and a very steady player so I can’t see him being left out.
May be another case of another good player that just doesn’t suit the system.

Meyer on the bench is okay with me, the three you mention, Luka, McCarthur and Kouyate are worth their first team start in my opinion. Problem I had yesterday was Schlupp coming on ahead of Meyer. Found that hard to fathom and has happened a few times recently. Schlupp lost possession a few times yesterday and seemed to make wrong decisions when in good positions? Meyer on the other hand is a more skilful player and should have been brought on earlier? Still a good performance yesterday, just disappointed with the first substitution?

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 20 Jan 19 2.13pm

At home against average opposition Meyer is a must, Wilf left, Townsend right, Meyer behind Benteke/Wickham, Two holding midfielders, Luka and Kouyate, job done

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Jefroc Flag Crete 20 Jan 19 2.53pm

Originally posted by AERO

Might regret the day he goes because he can’t get a game . Believe me he is quality would find a place for him if we don’t one of the premiership teams will and we will live to regret it .

Spot on!

 


Always remembering walking from the Holmesdale to the Whitehorse end at half time!

southnorwoodhill Flag 20 Jan 19 3.01pm

Find it difficult to understand haw Schlupp gets a game over Meyer. Hodgson lost the plot a good while ago whilst on England duty, time to retire. Thanks for the service, but you have no clue.

 

PatrickA Flag London 20 Jan 19 4.13pm

There is also the economic factor unfortunately.
The three highest earners in the club are reputedly Zaha, Benteke and Meyer.
Can a club of Palace’s stature afford to have two of them not starting?
I know Benteke’s absence is largely due to injury but he was left out last season even when fit.
If Meyer continues to be a bit part player under Hodgson his wages will be difficult to justify and I think he’ll go without us really seeing what he’s capable of.

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 20 Jan 19 5.04pm

In my opinion if we had any other manager Meyer would be starting every week.

 

TomThePalaceFanatic Flag 20 Jan 19 5.21pm

You have to fit this around Zaha and Meyer. Zaha on the left, Meyer in the middle. Any good manager would see this.

 

moylerg Flag Cofton Hackett, Worcestershire 20 Jan 19 5.23pm

Originally posted by pompeyeagle

In my opinion if we had any other manager Meyer would be starting every week.

Christian Heidel?

 


Most certainly not European.

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 20 Jan 19 10.50pm

It would be complete madness if he doesn’t play against Fulham...

 

Caleagle Flag 21 Jan 19 12.08am

If we don’t attack Fulham behind Meyer, we will have to endure the combined, constant threat of Mitrovic, Schurle, Babel and Sessegnon. I don’t want to watch us defend all game with the odd counter attack and save our ‘fresh legs’ until the 80th minute. That’s not working. Give Meyer, Benteke and Wickham a chance by giving them some decent minutes.

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 21 Jan 19 12.58am

Originally posted by Caleagle

If we don’t attack Fulham behind Meyer, we will have to endure the combined, constant threat of Mitrovic, Schurle, Babel and Sessegnon. I don’t want to watch us defend all game with the odd counter attack and save our ‘fresh legs’ until the 80th minute. That’s not working. Give Meyer, Benteke and Wickham a chance by giving them some decent minutes.

Haha yeah, sure. What have they proved all season? I’m not saying their rubbish players, nor am I saying we’ll beat them easy. But aside from Mitrovic being better than what we have up front (benteke first season at palace was better imo) our players are better.

Much better


Plus our men behind the ball game plan was only against Chelsea. All other games at home we have mainly dominated

Edited by matthau (21 Jan 2019 1.00am)

 

Page 13 of 27 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Max Meyer thread