You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hodgson has to go
November 16 2026 7.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Hodgson has to go


Page 13 of 18 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 16 Jan 19 3.58pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Yes, he isn’t quick, he isn’t particularly skilful or tricky, but he knows where to position himself and doesn’t miss many opportunities. I would have liked us to have signed him several times in the past. He would be my choice of an ‘older’ player to sort out Roy’s scoring woes.

Penalty box scorer who scores most of his goals from inside the 6-yard box.Has that ability to hang in the air and attacks the near post at crosses.Paul Merson thinks he is better coming off the bench.

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 16 Jan 19 4.54pm

Originally posted by Willo

Southampton had (And might still have)a dossier of potential managers that was constantly updated, with intelligence on those considered the best fits for Southampton.

They appointed Puel who only lasted a season, then Pellegrino who never lasted a season and he was followed by Hughes who wasn't there that long.

so it's better to have no plan at all?

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 16 Jan 19 7.15pm

If there is one thing this club has had too many of it's managers.

All we need is a goalscorer and we are a mid table team.

Without one, you lose games you should win like against Watford.

Roy Hodgson is a quality manager and man.
Who do we think Palace are going to get as a club who can't compete for Europe?

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 16 Jan 19 8.39pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

If there is one thing this club has had too many of it's managers.

All we need is a goalscorer and we are a mid table team.

Without one, you lose games you should win like against Watford.

Roy Hodgson is a quality manager and man.
Who do we think Palace are going to get as a club who can't compete for Europe?

Well said.

 

Kant Flag exeter 16 Jan 19 9.35pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Well said.

Seconded.

 

ThatPetrolRelation Flag Ottawa 16 Jan 19 9.38pm

This is an interesting article in the Independent about European Clubs hunting young English players, and while it mentions the trap top Premier League clubs are in, I think it nicely explains Roy's challenge with giving youth a chance:

"the fundamental question put to any scout regarding a player is whether “he’s better than what we’ve got?” This goes to a deeper level with the highest-level English clubs, though. The question is not just whether a player is better, but whether he is ready enough that there is minimal risk of dropping points if he is used. Those clubs will know a young foreign player is ready, because he has already been given top-division experience in another league. They won’t know whether their own young player is, because they won’t risk that experience, creating this curious circular problem."

[Link]

 

.TUX. Flag 16 Jan 19 11.12pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

If there is one thing this club has had too many of it's managers.

All we need is a goalscorer and we are a mid table team.

Without one, you lose games you should win like against Watford.

Roy Hodgson is a quality manager and man.
Who do we think Palace are going to get as a club who can't compete for Europe?

This.

 


Buy Litecoin.

Mapletree Flag Croydon 16 Jan 19 11.17pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

If there is one thing this club has had too many of it's managers.

All we need is a goalscorer and we are a mid table team.

Without one, you lose games you should win like against Watford.

Roy Hodgson is a quality manager and man.
Who do we think Palace are going to get as a club who can't compete for Europe?

As always we are in total agreement

And he went to Ruskin.

 

Mathers Flag 17 Jan 19 1.54am

Since 2000, CPFC managers in charge of 20+ prem matches;

Pulis Pl 29 Win % 41
Allardyce Pl 20 Win % 40
Pardew Pl 87 Win % 40
Hodgson Pl 45 Win % 35

The Hodgson brigade want to explain?

 

Kant Flag exeter 17 Jan 19 3.40am

Originally posted by Mathers

Since 2000, CPFC managers in charge of 20+ prem matches;

Pulis Pl 29 Win % 41
Allardyce Pl 20 Win % 40
Pardew Pl 87 Win % 40
Hodgson Pl 45 Win % 35

The Hodgson brigade want to explain?

1. Roy cannot physically put the ball in the back of the net himself. You can hardly blame him for the extreme profligacy of the team this season. If a few of the sitters like Jimmy Mac’s last Saturday had gone in those stats would be very different.
2. Roy has not yet had the same financial backing as the others.
3. Two of the three managers you mention embarrassingly walked out on us.
4. I prefer having a manager who has natural love and affection for our club than some money grabbing, here today-gone tomorrow mercenary who ‘retires’ to a better paid job or leaves you in the lurch on the eve of a new season.
5. The style of football played under Roy has been very pleasing on the eye. We are a decent side and play some of the most attractive football I’ve seen as a Palace fan. We are far better than our results suggest and with the addition of a goal scorer those stats will inevitably improve.
6. The only alternatives are to either appoint a newbie who will use us as a stepping stone in the unlikely event of success or one of the serial failures from the manager-go-round.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 17 Jan 19 8.12am

Originally posted by Willo

Southampton had (And might still have)a dossier of potential managers that was constantly updated, with intelligence on those considered the best fits for Southampton.

They appointed Puel who only lasted a season, then Pellegrino who never lasted a season and he was followed by Hughes who wasn't there that long.

Are those dossier compilers now the Palace scouts

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 17 Jan 19 8.21am

Originally posted by rikz

Only table that matters is the league and that shows hodgson is doing a s*** job.

You obviously were not around in the days of Taylor and Francis and quite a few more , you don't know that a s**t job is, In 50 years plus of following Palace. Hodgson would be in the top 6.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 17 Jan 19 8.30am

Originally posted by matthau


Yeah yeah now let’s talk about the injury he was carrying which we couldn’t afford for him to undertake an op cos we had no other strikers but when we realised he was s***e as a result of carrying that injury we put him in for the op.

Let’s not ignore this small detail eh


Which takes us back to - not roys fault

And what would you have done, played one of the youth team, but anyway, it was good of the Palace managment to give you all the facts.


 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 17 Jan 19 8.35am

Originally posted by Mathers

Since 2000, CPFC managers in charge of 20+ prem matches;

Pulis Pl 29 Win % 41
Allardyce Pl 20 Win % 40
Pardew Pl 87 Win % 40
Hodgson Pl 45 Win % 35

The Hodgson brigade want to explain?

Sure, Hodgson has been playing without a striker, what would your other 3 have "scored" without a striker?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Jan 19 8.47am

It’s far from exciting but it’s as close to stable we’ve had since promotion, and that’s why we’re sticking with Roy for now. I just wish we had armchairs to watch it. It’s of course frustrating during the match where plan A won’t work and there’s no chance of trying a plan B, but over the course of several games we’ll average enough points.

We must be aware of plenty of managers out there this time rather than the previous farce of FDB or relying on there being an escape artist. This is where Parish will be judged even more because if we’re doing nothing now or the ex Palace players by his side get it wrong then no spin on any fan radio or podcast will pull the wool over our eyes, no matter what is said about how long we’ve been in the top league (largely because we’ve spent massive amounts on wages and the first 11 but not the squad, incidentally because we did nothing leading up to it and by that I mean a couple of months to 2 years leading up to needing player positions filled)

 


COYP

jeeagles Flag 17 Jan 19 9.27am

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

Sure, Hodgson has been playing without a striker, what would your other 3 have "scored" without a striker?

Benteke scored under Pardew and BFS.
The rest of the time. We still didn't really have a striker.

 

premier fan Flag BR4 17 Jan 19 9.38am

I've been happy with the football we've played under Hodgson and I wouldn't want him to go. I truly believe we've been unlucky in front of goal and suffering from strikers being injured. The Sorloth purchase may well not have been under Roy's control in which we should therefore being sacking the scout that recommended this deal.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 17 Jan 19 9.38am

Originally posted by Mathers

Since 2000, CPFC managers in charge of 20+ prem matches;

Pulis Pl 29 Win % 41
Allardyce Pl 20 Win % 40
Pardew Pl 87 Win % 40
Hodgson Pl 45 Win % 35

The Hodgson brigade want to explain?

Hodgson is a reformist, the first two were dictators and Pardew was insane.

Football has changed since the first two hasn't it, something the club wanted and something that Mr Hodgson is in the process of doing, our players are better on the ball then they were and are not just boooting it, so the main big difference to your post is this.
Pardew attempted to do it but in the process of it forgot how great Murray was at doing the right thing in front of goal and then spent his whole time relying and trying to outscore teams, it was entertaining but increasingly at the wrong end and not for us when strikers became a problem, defending was always secondary for him ..hence he shot himself, in the arse.

The first two are unmentionable.

I imagine the people at the very top of our club are very happy with the way the football is progressing on and off the grass.

Goalscoring opportunities are I bet just as good as the other three ..if not better. Look that up!

 

fledgling Flag Beckenham 17 Jan 19 9.44am

Originally posted by Mathers

Since 2000, CPFC managers in charge of 20+ prem matches;

Pulis Pl 29 Win % 41
Allardyce Pl 20 Win % 40
Pardew Pl 87 Win % 40
Hodgson Pl 45 Win % 35

The Hodgson brigade want to explain?

the fact he's not a c*nt makes up the 5% for me.

 

Dean_CPFC Flag South london 17 Jan 19 10.27am

Originally posted by fledgling

the fact he's not a c*nt makes up the 5% for me.

Haha yes agreed

 

Page 13 of 18 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hodgson has to go