This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| Invalid user 2019 |
|
|---|---|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Match of the day sh.theads' by Midlands Eagle Originally posted by dreamwaverider
So good to see a ref giving free kicks and bookings where due. 6 bookings to 1 was a fair reflection of the game. He even got it right blowing his whistle BEFORE the goal. How can VAR override that? Lineker's too busy counting his money nowadays to do his job properly
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wilbraham413
I thought we played much better, and almost everyone had a good game. I can't think of one player who played badly. We created at least 3 great chances to score. Villa was lucky we only got one, it could have been worse. The call at the end was pretty bad, but Grealish had been complaining all game long, and I think the ref was just sick of it at the end. Grealish basically got the same treatment that Wilf usually gets, the more he complains, the more calls go against him. Also, even though I think Grealish was fouled, he dramatically threw himself to the ground in the box, and I think it was that flourish that got him the yellow card. Ayew played great, worked so hard all game long. Wilf created a lot. Even Kouyate was all over the place. I have no complaints at all about this game. I think that’s harsh on Grealish, Zaha was pushing him from behind, it’s not s foul but at the pace he was running he did well to offload the ball and then he fell over. He never dived in a million years, he didn’t even appeal. Having seen Zaha get that rough end of the stick I’m not gonna give the same to Grealish, he was the most fouled player in the championship last year and has a lot of similarities to Wilf in that regards as a ball carrier. For me I mostly agree, but Kouyate and Luka although they got through a lot of work, were both lucky today and not entirely consistent, the ref could have yellowed them both about 4 times each. Kouyate is the one who I feel should drop out. He got in some good areas, but didn’t push forward enough, the Ayew ball across the box needed midfielders breaking their necks to push up and support him and he did that in patches but not enough. When he did get forward he didn’t look the most composed. On top of that, he is not great on the ball. As a physical presence he is great, but if we are gonna play two defensive midfielders, I’d have McCarthy start next time as he has a bit more about him on the ball.
|
|
|
What a moaner
|
|
|
Originally posted by coulsdoneagle
Agree that he's the one we need to drop. He was being asked to play an unfamiliar role bombing forward. He was the right choice for United away but we still lack that Cabaye creativity in midfield which I'm hopeful Camarasa can bring in an attacking midfield role. We started with essentially 2 DMs and a defensive CM which was odd, albeit understand you wouldn't want to change the team that beat united and it did pay off eventually. We looked good throughout and the ref was very good until the Grealish decision which was just wrong to be honest. We deserve some luck for a chnsge though!
|
|
|
Cahill has been very lucky in his last two games now. Should have seen red against United and he did foul Grealish at the end of the Villa game.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Match of the day sh.theads' by Midlands Eagle So good to see a ref giving free kicks and bookings where due. 6 bookings to 1 was a fair reflection of the game. He even got it right blowing his whistle BEFORE the goal. How can VAR override that? Linekar seemed to suggest it wasn't blown by the ref!!WTF. Something along the lines of "well a whistle was blown somewhere, refs hands were down at his side" He should be taken to task and asked to explain, he seems to be suggesting someone edited the whistle in. Clearly Palace stopped. Nothing about Palace at all, still at least Leicester are 3rd
|
|
|
Originally posted by Elpis
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Match of the day sh.theads' by Midlands Eagle Made me laugh when Linaker suggested it wasn't even the refs whistle , ''It came from somewhere '' What a pilchard . And yes not to focus on a man of the match performance of Ayew was strange given that's what they do for every other game . And Jenas saying it was the worst decision in the history of football
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
And Jenas saying it was the worst decision in the history of football And Tim Cahill repeated the nonsensical opinion that a ref should 'let play run on' when he thinks that an attacker has committed an offence. Why?
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Hey Originally posted by Elpis
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Match of the day sh.theads' by Midlands Eagle Made me laugh when Linaker suggested it wasn't even the refs whistle , ''It came from somewhere '' What a pilchard . That Grealish was making a meal of the challenge was enough to deem it simulation and was the correct decision and though I can see that the Villa fans would have a different opinion I don't expect 'neutral' pundits to make up a different set of rules on the summary . Made themselves look a bit daft IMO . And yes not to focus on a man of the match performance of Ayew was strange given that's what they do for every other game . Take off your red and blue specs for a minute and that’s never simulation in a million years. If it was Zaha would be booked every single week. He was clearly laying off the ball and didn’t appeal, he also had pressure on his back when running at significant speed. Im not complaining, but we absolutely got lucky with a poor call.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.