You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Topic
November 22 2026 1.13pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Rhian Brewster (rumour) (LOCKED)


Page 13 of 14 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
Badger11 Flag Beckenham 01 Oct 20 8.36am

Originally posted by Knightstar

Exactly. Buying for £17-20M and getting two good seasons out of a player before selling him back for £40M and making a £20M profit sounds like a good deal to me. The £20M would then contribute to purchasing a decent replacement. However, I suspect our hesitation is more to do with Brewster having to compete with Bats and that might present some difficult issues re game time etc. In any event I'd like to see us pursuing him or a decent alternative as we need extra cover up front.

If we good guarantee that I agree it's good business. The problem is that we might pay £23 (current rumour) for a player who is a dud and has no track record in the PL.

The risk therefore is all ours if he fails Liverpool have a laugh at our expense if he succeeds they buy him back. Under that deal the buying price would have to be a lot lower for me to be interested.

Edited by Badger11 (01 Oct 2020 8.37am)

 


One more point

BelfastEagle Flag 01 Oct 20 8.47am

Originally posted by Badger11

If we good guarantee that I agree it's good business. The problem is that we might pay £23 (current rumour) for a player who is a dud and has no track record in the PL.

The risk therefore is all ours if he fails Liverpool have a laugh at our expense if he succeeds they buy him back. Under that deal the buying price would have to be a lot lower for me to be interested.

Edited by Badger11 (01 Oct 2020 8.37am)

The same could be said about Eze a player with only limited championship experience no PL experience and who could turn out to be a dud.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 01 Oct 20 8.52am

Originally posted by Elphers40

As I understand it Pete - It leaves us with no control or say in the timing of the buy back, which impacts negatively on our ability to build a squad for the longer term. If Brewster tears it up for a season Liverpool can pay £40 million and take him back. We wouldn’t be able to keep him longer or sell him for more to another club.

That's not my understanding of a buyback clause as I thought that it only came into operation if we decided to sell the player and in those circumstances Liverpool would have first option at the pre agreed price

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 01 Oct 20 9.04am

Originally posted by BelfastEagle

The same could be said about Eze a player with only limited championship experience no PL experience and who could turn out to be a dud.

It's certainly a risk however he is our player to play or sell unlike the Liverpool deal.

 


One more point

silvertop Flag Portishead 01 Oct 20 9.55am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

That's not my understanding of a buyback clause as I thought that it only came into operation if we decided to sell the player and in those circumstances Liverpool would have first option at the pre agreed price

Not sure that's right either. I understand they are pretty complex provisions that will say whatever the contracting parties want it to say. Unless there are rules governing their terms (?), they could easily say that Liverpool have a right to demand the buy back at any time. That would be after a certain period - but not in the same season as that isn't allowed. In such a case, even the player has no say in that decision.

I would imagine a team with the financial clout of Liverpool would seek to impose such a clause. Which could explain - together with our not too distant history with that club - why we were put off; but the Blades may be happy to take a punt on those terms.

They will learn, as we did - twice. Pity, as had we been the only suitor, we could have negotiated better terms.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 01 Oct 20 10.05am

Originally posted by silvertop


Not sure that's right either. I understand they are pretty complex provisions that will say whatever the contracting parties want it to say.

I've done a bit of belated research and it appears that you are correct

 

slubglurge Flag welling 01 Oct 20 7.58pm

Not in Liverpool squad tonight so Blades deal must be close

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 02 Oct 20 12.15am

Originally posted by slubglurge

Not in Liverpool squad tonight so Blades deal must be close

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 02 Oct 20 9.27am

Another one gone:

'Sheffield United have agreed a deal to sign Liverpool's England Under-21 forward Rhian Brewster.

The deal, which is worth £23.5m, includes a buy-back option for three years and the Reds will get 15% of any sell-on fee':

[Link]

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 02 Oct 20 10.00am

Originally posted by Sportyteacher

Another one gone:

'Sheffield United have agreed a deal to sign Liverpool's England Under-21 forward Rhian Brewster.

The deal, which is worth £23.5m, includes a buy-back option for three years and the Reds will get 15% of any sell-on fee':

[Link]

as much of a talent as he is/could be, I wouldn't agree to those terms. It's really stacked in Liverpool's favour - 'give us loads of money for a young player with potential, but if he's any good we can get him back or receive a further big payment'. It's the sort of deal a desperate club takes, and we need to move beyond being that club.

 

Chubskip Flag 02 Oct 20 10.04am

Was we ever really interested? Not sure? I think better value in SB and the lad from Ipswich with no buy back. JMO

 

AERO Flag 02 Oct 20 10.08am

Agreed better value elsewhere. Don't want too be stiched up by the scousers again !!!

 

davehuggins Flag 02 Oct 20 10.35am

For me at the reported price and all the clauses that have to be included think we are best out of it. SP will not invest money in such a deal, TBH I don't blame him,

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 02 Oct 20 10.44am

Originally posted by Chubskip

Was we ever really interested? Not sure? I think better value in SB and the lad from Ipswich with no buy back. JMO

Roy actually mentioned the club's interest in a pre match press conference and he also said that another striker is his priority

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 02 Oct 20 10.57am

Originally posted by davehuggins

For me at the reported price and all the clauses that have to be included think we are best out of it. SP will not invest money in such a deal, TBH I don't blame him,

Couldn’t agree to this deal. Liverpool can buy back within 3 years for a set price! And you know full well it won’t be over £30m. Shame as I believe he wanted to come to us. Looks like Sheffield Utd must be desperate to agree to this terms.
Where does this leave us in search of a striker though?

 

jeeagles Flag 02 Oct 20 11.28am

Parish did keep saying we were never in for him in the first place.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 02 Oct 20 11.30am

Originally posted by jeeagles

Parish did keep saying we were never in for him in the first place.

No he didn't. He said that we hadn't placed a bid whether formal or informal which is completely different

 

EddieMac Flag 02 Oct 20 11.41am

Risky signing in my opinion. I’m not fussed that we didn’t sign him.

 

CPFC1965 Flag Warrington 02 Oct 20 11.58am

Have we at any point approached Liverpool about a transfer? If not, a formal or informal bid is irrelevant and SP's original statement on the matter would stand. Semantics aside it's a lot of money to spend on potential especially with a buy back option attached

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 02 Oct 20 12.10pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

Risky signing in my opinion. I’m not fussed that we didn’t sign him.

Roy does seem to want another striker in, but I am sure the club has other options in mind

 

Page 13 of 14 < 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Topic