This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
Not confused at all; it's more likely you've misunderstood the point.
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn |
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
Not confused at all; it's more likely you've misunderstood the point. A very good post, well reasoned and accurate.
|
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
Not confused at all; it's more likely you've misunderstood the point. Top post Mate - agree entirely..!! Last nights game was there for the taking - we pressed well first half - but second half for whatever reason - Roy reverted to old Roy and just tried to hang on to/for the win..!! Why change something that is working - just don’t get it..!! IMO - problem you have is that I’m fairly sure - Parish sees Southgate as next Manager - he ain’t going to be available until after the Euros..!! In my mind this was always Parish’s plan - Roy for another season then Southgate - think Roy knows it too - hence he’s comments his done with Palace at the end of the season. We ain’t going to go down - but Roy’s tactics and selections - mean we ain’t going forward either - if anything we’re going backwards..!! So question - does Parish rip up the plan and appoint someone like Cooper - or stick with it - in the knowledge that it’s going to be more of the same for the rest of the season - but we’ll stay up - then change in the summer..?? If it’s the latter - it’s going to be painful for the rest of the season..!! Personally - think time for change is now - but depends on how Parish sees it..!! COYP
|
|
|
Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle
Top post Mate - agree entirely..!! Last nights game was there for the taking - we pressed well first half - but second half for whatever reason - Roy reverted to old Roy and just tried to hang on to/for the win..!! Why change something that is working - just don’t get it..!! IMO - problem you have is that I’m fairly sure - Parish sees Southgate as next Manager - he ain’t going to be available until after the Euros..!! In my mind this was always Parish’s plan - Roy for another season then Southgate - think Roy knows it too - hence he’s comments his done with Palace at the end of the season. We ain’t going to go down - but Roy’s tactics and selections - mean we ain’t going forward either - if anything we’re going backwards..!! So question - does Parish rip up the plan and appoint someone like Cooper - or stick with it - in the knowledge that it’s going to be more of the same for the rest of the season - but we’ll stay up - then change in the summer..?? If it’s the latter - it’s going to be painful for the rest of the season..!! Personally - think time for change is now - but depends on how Parish sees it..!! COYP Against a strong team that creates plenty of chances in a game, for the first half Palace played well. Tactically sound and the plan being well executed by the players. We just about deserved the lead. Now here's where you and I differ. You resort to your usual Hodgson is to blame for everything position. Do you seriously think he instructed his players to play deeper and deeper in the second half ? If it truly was a case of just hanging on for the win then he would not have brought Eze on, it would have been Schlupp. Having said that, I would not have taken Ayew off in the first place. Brighton got a rocket from de Zerbi at half time and sent his players back out early as well as making substitutions. It worked for them. They moved the ball quicker and were a vast improvement on their first half performance. If we outplayed them first half, they did the same to us second half. Even then, if Eze had showed more composure in front of goal he could have made it really hard for them by putting us 2-0 up. I'm glad to see it's slowly dawning on some on here that the real ' Villain of the Piece ' is the man that elected for another year of Hodgson. And that's Steve Parish. His public utterances and what he actually does rarely seem to tally these days. You talk of '' ripping up the plan '' but I'm not convinced there is a plan. Not beyond just continuing to stay in the PL. You're making guesses about Southgate ( for a few reasons I think it's highly unlikely ) and as for Cooper, his main attraction in my opinion is his availability should we wish to appoint now. If we can keep Olise and Eze fit and - maybe i'm being over optimistic here - we have a good transfer window, then the second half of the season can be better than what we have seen so far.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
Leaving aside for a moment Roy’s methods which we are all familiar with. Yes much has been of the new Academy. The infrastructure looks superb and the club can be rightly proud of it. But once the players step onto the field just what is the quality of coaching they are receiving ? And as you say, usually the Academy teams follow the first team’s blueprint in terms of playing style - little evidence of that from the games I watch. So I think it’s down to the short term thinking at the top which ( understandably ) has Premier League survival as it overriding priority. If we do a comparison with Brighton from last night’s performance, it looks apparent that all of their teams are coached in the same way. But then they have been better at planning and implementing than Palace for a while now.
It's a point I've made on numerous other threads but I don't actually blame Roy for much of what is going on, I regard him as a symptom, rather than the cause. Reappointing him was effectively deferring squad investment and a long term strategy until next summer, under the assumption that he'd keep us up. Looking at the table following that Luton win, it's a decision which could come back to haunt us. He has some mitigation for our poor form and the injuries have been bad but I would say that his apparent acceptance of our lack of investment this summer means he does share culpability. A new manager would have demanded a deeper squad. You have completely correctly identified Brighton's superior planning and implementation as the reason that they have overtaken us and that is what the club is lacking at the moment. In an ideal world I'd like to see us appoint a new manager for the second half of the season whose own ideology matches our own of promoting academy youngsters as well as buying young players and developing them. Give them six months to implement a philosophy and identify areas of the squad that need strengthening (even though we all already know them). We should be planning which of our key players we are going to sell this summer to fund a squad overhaul and who we are going to buy with the money. Then have a proper go next season. What I suspect will actually happen is that Roy will just do enough to get us through until the end of the season, at which point we'll sort of see which managers and players are available and hope it pans out.
We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold... |
|
|
Originally posted by Brinscalleagle2
Hodgson in my view plays according to the opposition, which is an obvious thing to say but what I mean by that is if we are playing top sides he sets up to stifle them and hope for a break , like most sides at the bottom . When we play teams around us he sets us up with the intention of winning . However you can only win if you have quality attacking players . We do have some but unfortunately we have hardly been able to field them thus making us less effective against these teams. On the contrary, it is my impression that Roy sets up with the same defensive plan for every game, and given our league position of 15th, it would appear that his natural negative caution is in part caused by a majority of teams being above us.
|
|
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
On the contrary, it is my impression that Roy sets up with the same defensive plan for every game, and given our league position of 15th, it would appear that his natural negative caution is in part caused by a majority of teams being above us. I must admit, I rarely see us setting up to play with attacking intent, with the exception of the last 15 minutes of the City match when we were 2-0 down.
|
|
|
And did quite well, with players Roy neither trusts or plays regularly.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Gribbo
And did quite well, with players Roy neither trusts or plays regularly. Indeed
|
|
|
We need a result against Chelsea, if we don't he should walk end of
|
|
|
Originally posted by Canterbury Palace
It's a point I've made on numerous other threads but I don't actually blame Roy for much of what is going on, I regard him as a symptom, rather than the cause. Reappointing him was effectively deferring squad investment and a long term strategy until next summer, under the assumption that he'd keep us up. Looking at the table following that Luton win, it's a decision which could come back to haunt us. He has some mitigation for our poor form and the injuries have been bad but I would say that his apparent acceptance of our lack of investment this summer means he does share culpability. A new manager would have demanded a deeper squad. You have completely correctly identified Brighton's superior planning and implementation as the reason that they have overtaken us and that is what the club is lacking at the moment. In an ideal world I'd like to see us appoint a new manager for the second half of the season whose own ideology matches our own of promoting academy youngsters as well as buying young players and developing them. Give them six months to implement a philosophy and identify areas of the squad that need strengthening (even though we all already know them). We should be planning which of our key players we are going to sell this summer to fund a squad overhaul and who we are going to buy with the money. Then have a proper go next season. What I suspect will actually happen is that Roy will just do enough to get us through until the end of the season, at which point we'll sort of see which managers and players are available and hope it pans out. Most of the young players touted by the fans in recent seasons have turned out to be crap including signings like Riedewald, Meyer etc. De Boer put Lumeka and Lokilo in and they were pony as well.
|
|
|
We have only won 1 more game than Luton and Burnley, its Embarrassing
|
|
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
I often feel as though we could sign Mbappe, Vini Jr, Haaland, Bellingham, KdB etc. in January and Roy would still set up the same way, with the same game plan. My impression of Hodgson has often been that he looks to keep every game pretty tight with the hope that Wins, Losses and Draws will all come with an even enough spread to see us secure our 12-16th placed finish. Riveting it is not however I think his continued employment and our desperation to reinstate him was borne from an inability to do anything better, whether that be through financial investment or strategic planning. He will been gone soon though and although our PL status is in no way guaranteed this season I hold reservations nonetheless as to our ability to genuinely move on from him. Makes for grim reading that but I am just trying to reflect the reality and not be a deliberately miserable fecker! We are precariously close though and perhaps the Chelsea game will give us some indication as to the direction of travel.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I often feel as though we could sign Mbappe, Vini Jr, Haaland, Bellingham, KdB etc. in January and Roy would still set up the same way, with the same game plan. My impression of Hodgson has often been that he looks to keep every game pretty tight with the hope that Wins, Losses and Draws will all come with an even enough spread to see us secure our 12-16th placed finish. Riveting it is not however I think his continued employment and our desperation to reinstate him was borne from an inability to do anything better, whether that be through financial investment or strategic planning. He will been gone soon though and although our PL status is in no way guaranteed this season I hold reservations nonetheless as to our ability to genuinely move on from him. Makes for grim reading that but I am just trying to reflect the reality and not be a deliberately miserable fecker! We are precariously close though and perhaps the Chelsea game will give us some indication as to the direction of travel.
I have no allegiance to Roy but your reservations about moving on from him whilst we are in danger of relegation is my point. He is more likely to maintain our premiership status than any new incoming manager. It is just my view. To take things forward we not only need a new manager with a new approach but new players to achieve it.COYP
|
|
|
Originally posted by Brinscalleagle2
I have no allegiance to Roy but your reservations about moving on from him whilst we are in danger of relegation is my point. He is more likely to maintain our premiership status than any new incoming manager. It is just my view. To take things forward we not only need a new manager with a new approach but new players to achieve it.COYP Why do we even talk about relegation at this time?? Some teams below aus would happily swap with us, I suppose.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.