This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
I haven't read every post but that game was the first time Roy just looked like a tired, cold, old man on the side lines. He mainly seemed to sit there shivering, I was waiting for someone to give him a blanket. I've nothing against old people working. But let's put it this way: I don't fancy working well into my 70s. I think, for everyone's sake, Roy needs to be thanked and replaced. Not booted out in a bad manner but you never know with us. Yea i said to my Mrs last night he looks like my Mam , Just sitting there smiling and taking it all in and happy to still be active . He looked more like a supporter than a manager .
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
It was a clear and obvious error. I didn't want to lose, but Ebs took him out inside the box and the pen award was fair and square. We did not deserve to lose that one. Difficult.
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
What the referee saw from his angle in real-time and what he viewed on the monitor were at variance.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
It was a clear and obvious error. I didn't want to lose, but Ebs took him out inside the box and the pen award was fair and square. We did not deserve to lose that one. Difficult. Correct, and even our players knew it, we broke from there with the speed of Sid the Snail and they were all glancing over their shoulders waiting for play to be stopped
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid
No complaints about the result or penalty although I thought Eze was unlucky and the Chelsea player was clever in how he drew the foul. Chelsea created the better chances and should have won by more. Plenty of honest endeavour but a chronic lack of quality aside from Olise. We really lack pace generally and also don't have the height or physicality in the side to make the most of set pieces or compete at business end of the game. Agree with the comments about fresh legs and would have been inclined to gamble on Franca earlier rather than any of the other options who aren't up to it IMO.
He definitely needs match time to develop expertise at Premier league level and can't be swaddled in cotton wool for much longer ...with the expectation that he is itching to get onto the pitch.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Henry of Peckham
Needless loss when we could so easily have got something from the game. Not sure what the little 'fracas' between Roy and the officials was about at the end but once again, his substitutions were ill timed. What further evidence is required for the need to reinforce the team next month? I’m afraid that the best that we can hope for are loan signings that will just sit on the bench.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
Redeem themselves? Their reserves just won them 3 points! I have not sat down with the abacus but I imagine that, not only do they have superior coaching and were at home where their record is good, but I imagine their B team costs more than our A team.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Den1923
The problem as some have already said we have a very poor quality squad of players, in actual fact I would go as far as to say that we only have 6/7 players who you could say are EPL quality the rest are either unproven younger players or players who would struggle to make the grade in the championship. Poor Roy, yes he does look tied and would not you if you were 76 years old and had the responsibility on your shoulders of keeping a EPL team in the league on a shoestring budget. Roy was asked to come out of retirement because as hard as Parish tried he could not persuade a quality proven, ambitious younger manager to take the job based on the quality of players and transfer budget available (or not as the case maybe). Even dear old Roy was asking for 3-5 players in the twilight of the last window and we all know what he got. SP seems not to be on the best of terms with his fellow investors and I believe that Textor is estranged over the Lyon deal which Parish was not happy about. The other American are more interested in the real estate value (Selhurst Park) than they are about EPL football or the long term future of the team. Sadly, I do not have much confidence in the next window as it is unlikely anywhere near enough funds will be available to plug the holes in our first eleven let alone the bench. As others have already said, 11 years and the first team today is not much better (or maybe worse) than the one we came up with from the championship. The latter is now very much on our route map, thank you Mr.Parish! Yes, definitely. I made a point in another thread that the first 11 has gradually been chipped away without adequate replacement, and thinking of the effect this has caused on the whole. The non replacement of Zaha for a decent left sided player being one of the most obvious examples, instead hoping that a midfielder or forward can convert to that position as required by square peg round hole Roy. It is no surprise that we find ourselves in this position.
|
|
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
Yes, definitely. I made a point in another thread that the first 11 has gradually been chipped away without adequate replacement, and thinking of the effect this has caused on the whole. The non replacement of Zaha for a decent left sided player being one of the most obvious examples, instead hoping that a midfielder or forward can convert to that position as required by square peg round hole Roy. It is no surprise that we find ourselves in this position. Definitely. Ayew can fill in that position but it is clear not his preferred or best position. He is now off to the African cup from early Jan for maybe 6 weeks - and this absence is clearly not a surprise as it's been known about for a couple of years. Schlupp has never really played as left winger, more a wide left in a 442, which we don't currently play, and he has proved an inadequate replacement in that position whilst Olise was injured (again a situation we knew about since early June). The inability to get someone in as an attacking left player is inexcusable. The guy from Leeds on loan at Bournemouth would have been an obvious low cost choice.
|
|
|
Originally posted by palace99
Definitely. Ayew can fill in that position but it is clear not his preferred or best position. He is now off to the African cup from early Jan for maybe 6 weeks - and this absence is clearly not a surprise as it's been known about for a couple of years. Schlupp has never really played as left winger, more a wide left in a 442, which we don't currently play, and he has proved an inadequate replacement in that position whilst Olise was injured (again a situation we knew about since early June). The inability to get someone in as an attacking left player is inexcusable. The guy from Leeds on loan at Bournemouth would have been an obvious low cost choice. If you asked Dougie Freedman why we didn’t sign an attacking left sided player, he would probably tell you that we did !
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid
No complaints about the result or penalty although I thought Eze was unlucky and the Chelsea player was clever in how he drew the foul. Chelsea created the better chances and should have won by more. Plenty of honest endeavour but a chronic lack of quality aside from Olise. We really lack pace generally and also don't have the height or physicality in the side to make the most of set pieces or compete at business end of the game. Agree with the comments about fresh legs and would have been inclined to gamble on Franca earlier rather than any of the other options who aren't up to it IMO.
Agree - Eze didn't take him out, but he dangled a leg and the guy made sure he made the most of the contact. As he didn't touch the ball it has to be a penalty. Was surprised Eze started. We were always going to have limited possession and he is not fully fit so i would have saved him for maybe 30 minutes at the end when the game opens up. His 1st half performance was poor. We definitely need him on Saturday. In terms of pace, yes we are lacking in that centre mid position but i also feel it is partly how we use our full backs. Most teams have at least one attacking minded full back who can cause problems when they burst forward. Young Hinselwood did that role well the other night against us and repeated it against a much better team, Spurs, yesterday. Chelsea's RB, Gusto, was probably the best attacking player in the 1st half and he's not even a regular. Other teams such as Fulham have Robinson etc, and even Coufal at West Ham who is older and more defensive minded charged forward and supplied the cross for the goal against us a few weeks ago. We have a solid 433 with only the occasional brilliance by Eze or Olise to break the boredom. It makes it easy to play against us and mark those 2. We need players charging forward when we attack to create havoc. Yes it is higher risk, but we have a very fast and talent defended, Guehi, at the back who should be able to cover.
|
|
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
If you asked Dougie Freedman why we didn’t sign an attacking left sided player, he would probably tell you that we did ! if you mean Franca, i think a 5 year old would have known that he was always going to be of limited value this season given his young age, his inexperience and the time needed to adjust to a new country and a physical league. He was also injured when we signed him. Given that we lost Zaha and Olise had a medium term injury a short term replacement should have been top of the list.
|
|
|
Originally posted by palace99
Definitely. Ayew can fill in that position but it is clear not his preferred or best position. He is now off to the African cup from early Jan for maybe 6 weeks - and this absence is clearly not a surprise as it's been known about for a couple of years. Schlupp has never really played as left winger, more a wide left in a 442, which we don't currently play, and he has proved an inadequate replacement in that position whilst Olise was injured (again a situation we knew about since early June). The inability to get someone in as an attacking left player is inexcusable. The guy from Leeds on loan at Bournemouth would have been an obvious low cost choice. You are referring to Luis Sinisterra.There is an'Option to buy' for Bournemouth.
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
If you asked Dougie Freedman why we didn’t sign an attacking left sided player, he would probably tell you that we did ! Has he not gone to Man Utd yet?
Red and Blue Army! |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.