This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
That is the point to which I am drawn, hence I used the word 'obfuscate' (ooh la la!). I'm quite ignorant of any 'sensible approach' so if there has been one and it's failed, point taken. However, I do not see the current approach as effective. The population, at large, will work off stereotypes. The stereotypes that exist around the green approach for me do therefore dilute and distort any message, regardless of the actual issue at hand. The issue for me is the constant green taxation. It doesn't change anything, it just makes things cost more.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I'm not offering an opinion - I don't pretend you can just scratch your arse and decide an 'opinion' on a complicated science. I listen to people who are qualified to offer an opinion on these topics - their opinion is absolutely more accurate and correct than yours, yes. Again, are there any other scientific fields where you feel you know better than the people who study it, or just this one? Look do you know the answer or not. Wissie was the one who my reply was for but you jumped in. I have an opinion like you, which clearly differs from yours. Make my opinion a bad one and I will admit I am wrong but from where I am sitting not one scientist has put this answer in writing, only the cancelled ones maybe but the eminent ones you believe haven’t. us v nature. It’s quite simple really .
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Look do you know the answer or not. Wissie was the one who my reply was for but you jumped in. I have an opinion like you, which clearly differs from yours. Make my opinion a bad one and I will admit I am wrong but from where I am sitting not one scientist has put this answer in writing, only the cancelled ones maybe but the eminent ones you believe haven’t. us v nature. It’s quite simple really . It’s not simple at all, that’s the point I’m making - you’re trying to condense a hugely complex question into a one word answer. If you’re actually interested, there are loads of studies online attempting to discuss exactly your question - here’s one by the EPA for starters: [Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Look do you know the answer or not. Wissie was the one who my reply was for but you jumped in. I have an opinion like you, which clearly differs from yours. Make my opinion a bad one and I will admit I am wrong but from where I am sitting not one scientist has put this answer in writing, only the cancelled ones maybe but the eminent ones you believe haven’t. us v nature. It’s quite simple really . Irrespective of the science, the new drive towards green is mostly about creating new business. The punter will have to pay for all sorts of new 'green' technology, no doubt, either via tax or by being forced to replace existing technology. Labour are all about a bigger state. More layers of administration, the welfare state and setting up ridiculous quangos. If it is as well thought as their house building ideas then it is doomed to fail.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
The government have just announced two very good initiatives.
I have been saying for a long time that the potential workforce in England has to be better utilised and that huge amounts of revenue is lost through dodgy foreign businesses avoiding tax. I don't buy the idea that this will reduce illegals arriving here. Now what we need is incentives for women to have more children. Ensuring that those they will have the children with are modern, caring and responsible potential fathers prepared to take their share of the load would be a good first step.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
So senior members of the new government have all said and I paraphrase that : The economy is a disaster We can argue whether this is all true or whether it is political hyperbole but my point is this. Having identified that pretty much everything the Tories did has wrecked this country Labour are actually setting themselves up to fail. At some point towards the end of their term the public will start to judge Labour on their performance. If they have not built enough houses for example the public and the opposition would be right to point out that they knew this was a problem from day one and did nothing. Personally I would agree that the NHS and Migration is a disaster but Rachel Reeves comments on the economy are a little over the top. It can always be better but most of the key numbers are not bad. Some of the other sectors need improving but are not as bad as they have said. Anyway this is the risk of over exaggerating that if you do not fix it then it will blow up in your face. Perhaps they should have been a bit more prudent about what they said. I fully expect the opposition parties to throw these comments back in their face in 4 years time.
They have spent every waking moment telling us that the Tories left a mess and are concentrating far too much on that.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Climate change hysteria is very much a middle class and above phenomenon. They can afford the implications. I detect a lot of narcissism and general hubris within that movement. When you see the protests it's always the same kind of white liberal activists...mostly women or effeminate men. They largely ignore the tiny affect that the British isles has towards any climate change and instead insist that we become an example to the world in general and lead the way. Because in truth it's far less about any real affect it would have and has more to do with their saviour complex. Again, these people are a minority within the country who bully and dictate to others who never had anything to do with how we got here. It's an often made observation but the real 'polluters' aren't here but in China/India/US. If they were serious about tackling the issue they would direct all their resources into movements there. But again, that would mean they didn't get to display and virtue signal here....They say they want to save the earth, but that obviously doesn't mean moving to the countries where that change would be required. Pious, but not that pious. I agree the substance of this post but it is not always nice people who get us to where we want to be. CEOs, pioneering scientists, philosophical giants, leaders in the creative arts - you wouldn't want to spend 10 seconds with any of them. If the outcome of all this protest is a better British Isles, I don't give a hoot how pious and unwashed the folk are who helped us get there.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
I agree the substance of this post but it is not always nice people who get us to where we want to be. CEOs, pioneering scientists, philosophical giants, leaders in the creative arts - you wouldn't want to spend 10 seconds with any of them. If the outcome of all this protest is a better British Isles, I don't give a hoot how pious and unwashed the folk are who helped us get there. Therein lies the rub. Is it the right path energy or cost wise? Personally I think renewables can't cut it and will prove a massively inefficient investment....the technology just isn't there yet. That said, as it looks like this is what's happening anyway let's hope that those like me are wrong. Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Jul 2024 11.42am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I like some of the ideas and obviously not others, but it just seems like big commitments with no obvious means of paying for it. Like they are spending (borrowing) on the projection of growth they haven't got. Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Jul 2024 11.22am) I was watching something earlier that said that the state pension could become non viable by as early as 2035. It is essential that the magic ratio of tax paying workers to state payouts is achieved. Let's be honest, that some Brits have become far too entitled and others disenfranchised in their own country. England has to be for the English again, and we English have to raise our standards.
|
|
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
Also - how are they going to fund the over inflation public sector pay rises, which if they go out across the board, will cost £23billion apparently. Yup this is a real problem for Labour and would have been for the Tories as well. I noticed that the universities have been bleating that they are about to go bust because the student loan cap is not enough and there are now restrictions on foreign students. Annoyingly the media articles I have read have all been sympathetic with talk of more money or relaxing the foreign student restrictions, none have raised the obvious question which I hope this government will do. What cutbacks have you made? Any business, and universities are just that, would cut back in their situation. How many useless degrees have they now cancelled? How many useless lecturers who spend all their time doing personal research and avoiding teaching students have they let go? If they have cancelled courses have they been able to sell off surplus buildings etc. Have they considered cancelling their sabbatical schemes where lecturers get paid leave of absence for months (nice work if you can get it). The answer I suspect is very little of this has happened. Universities seem to think they are above belt tightening. I'm not anti university far from it but they should not get a blank check from Labour.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
There are a lot of people who spent much of the election campaign objecting to every and any suggestion of increasing tax revenues who are now concerned that we cannot fund the things we would like our society to have. It feels very contradictory. I think people are just pointing out that Labour will have a big tax hole to fill if they plan to keep their promises. I hope they succeed I think we would all love to see a better society but unfortunately this costs money and labour keep saying that they will not put up the key taxes whilst promising more spending. It's a difficult circle to square. Going after tax dodgers will only bring in so much.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Climate change hysteria is very much a middle class and above phenomenon. They can afford the implications. I detect a lot of narcissism and general hubris within that movement. When you see the protests it's always the same kind of white liberal activists...mostly women or effeminate men. They largely ignore the tiny affect that the British isles has towards any climate change and instead insist that we become an example to the world in general and lead the way. Because in truth it's far less about any real affect it would have and has more to do with their saviour complex. Again, these people are a minority within the country who bully and dictate to others who never had anything to do with how we got here. It's an often made observation but the real 'polluters' aren't here but in China/India/US. If they were serious about tackling the issue they would direct all their resources into movements there. But again, that would mean they didn't get to display and virtue signal here....They say they want to save the earth, but that obviously doesn't mean moving to the countries where that change would be required. Pious, but not that pious. Don't you just love it... Green Party MP Adrian Ramsay is resisting plans for new pylons in his East Anglian constituency of Waveney Valley, which would transport electricity from offshore windfarms to homes onshore, despite his party calling for the most ambitious decarbonisation targets.
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I think people are just pointing out that Labour will have a big tax hole to fill if they plan to keep their promises. I hope they succeed I think we would all love to see a better society but unfortunately this costs money and labour keep saying that they will not put up the key taxes whilst promising more spending. It's a difficult circle to square. Going after tax dodgers will only bring in so much. It’s not really about Labour keeping their promises - it’s about the country being able to continue to afford things like a state pension - this is not about a specific government or party, the current economic model cannot function with the population dynamics we have. It seems like everyone accepts that reality, but don’t like any attempt to remedy it - people were drastically opposed to pretty tame measures like the private school VAT exemption, never mind any significant increase in taxes for a majority of people.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.