This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
That's because it's easier to mobilise liberal opinion against the police than it is to explore some of the uncomfortable truths about Black America. That said, the police do close ranks to protect the force and that should hardly be a surprise as the same sort of attitude prevails in all sorts of institutions. Each case has to be assessed individually and the law should prevail, but If the police investigate themselves then we have a problem. There will always be a conflict of interests. Its also a lot more acceptable for society to blame racism in the police, rather than the racism in society. Happened here with the MacPherson, and the 'Institutional Racism within the Police Force' which was probably true, but not just of the police, but of all of British society - Institutional racism as a concept occurs at a more unconscious and non-explicit level, being exhibited as acceptable forms of prejudice, that is considered acceptable by the majority of society. At the same time as the MacPherson report, the same accusations could have been levelled at many institutions of the UK, private and public. However by limiting it to just the police, its possible to attribute blame and ignore the elephant in the room.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by legaleagle
And it is perhaps so much easier to disparage organisations like Black Lives Matter and to trivialise and ignore the very real racism that continues to pervade the deep South,than to engage with the issue... I've spent time down around Baton Rouge and its more rural environs..To me,it was in some ways not so unlike the 60's and the prior Jim Crow days...people of one colour living on one side of the tracks,and of another colour on the other side.Local whites being openly racist with no embarrassment and not having any idea why I,as a "white", could possibly think it otherwise than "normal" and "reasonable" disparaging "black people" on the basis of race ...saturday afternoon sport in a local small town being to go out and threaten to shoot a black guy walking down main street,for having the audacity to wear his army uniform while doing so(he was home on leave).One of the perpetrators being an off duty member of the local constabulary. It may be 2016...but segregation era attitudes are far from dead ancient history... Why should people have to tolerate that sh#t? The police reflect the society they come from... ...and 2015 statistics show black people several times more likely to be shot by police than whites.. So,yes, the black community has its share of dodgy people (like any community) and some at the margins overact inappropriately by going out and shooting police (all groups,including "whites" have their share of extremists on the fringe),but there is a very real problem IMO with racism and racist attitudes in the US and this pervades the agencies of the state (as would be expected) such as the police..and the fact the police are an agency of the state and have such power is precisely why police violence on blacks should be focused upon.. And for those who diss the notion that Trump is not a negative factor (however small) in this equation...anyone (whether here or in the US) in the political arena who starts popularising and legitimising an appeal to base sentiments has some responsibility when society becomes more divisive and we begin to reap the fruits of the dirt they sow.. Exactly - I'm not sure why people are so keen to move the goalposts and focus on the obvious issues in the black community, rather than just admit an obvious truth - there is a problem with police unnecessarily killing black citizens.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
There is no doubt that racist attitudes prevail in the USA, particularly in the Southern states. There is little point in denying that. That includes a significant number of Black racists as well of course. see, that's what doesn't matter. it's the majority/dominant group racists that are the issue. if i'm a racist sikh in america, i'm just an a##hole - no one cares. if my group runs everything, then i can get away with a whole lot of racist activity, including murder in the name of police protection.
|
|
|
Originally posted by nairb75
see, that's what doesn't matter. it's the majority/dominant group racists that are the issue. if i'm a racist sikh in america, i'm just an a##hole - no one cares. if my group runs everything, then i can get away with a whole lot of racist activity, including murder in the name of police protection. Not sure the families of those policeman killed would agree. The trouble is, I don't hear too much protest about the killing of policeman or the innocent by criminals. All I hear is racist this racist that. Had it occurred to you that there might be a direct link between the very disproportionate level of crime committed by black people and the racist sentiment you describe? I know you might say that racism has caused black people to commit more crime but last time I looked, we could all make our own choices in life. Many black people are not criminals and do just fine. The President for one. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (20 Jul 2016 4.40pm)
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Not sure the families of those policeman killed would agree. The trouble is, I don't hear too much protest about the killing of policeman or the innocent by criminals. All I hear is racist this racist that. Had it occurred to you that there might be a direct link between the very disproportionate level of crime committed by black people and the racist sentiment you describe? I know you might say that racism has caused black people to commit more crime but last time I looked, we could all make our own choices in life. Many black people are not criminals and do just fine. The President for one. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (20 Jul 2016 4.40pm) Well it was all over the mainstream media, and didn't require a special interest group to highlight the fact that 5 police officers were killed in Dallas, and 3 in Baton Rouge. Also, it seems that the police are on top of it, and have it all in hand and the legal system in functioning. So not really that much need for protest or a protest group. It'd be as pointless as a heterosexual awareness program.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Well it was all over the mainstream media, and didn't require a special interest group to highlight the fact that 5 police officers were killed in Dallas, and 3 in Baton Rouge. Also, it seems that the police are on top of it, and have it all in hand and the legal system in functioning. So not really that much need for protest or a protest group. It'd be as pointless as a heterosexual awareness program. If you consider the murder of policeman to be less significant that the alleged unlawful killing of criminals then yes.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
If you consider the murder of policeman to be less significant that the alleged unlawful killing of criminals then yes. Criminals? The guy who was shot in his car with his girlfriend and her kid had nothing but driving offences on his record - to suggest that all of those being killed by police are criminals is nonsense. The scale of significance you talk about is not police v criminals, it's about police v citizens. Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (20 Jul 2016 5.45pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Well it was all over the mainstream media, and didn't require a special interest group to highlight the fact that 5 police officers were killed in Dallas, and 3 in Baton Rouge. Also, it seems that the police are on top of it, and have it all in hand and the legal system in functioning. So not really that much need for protest or a protest group. It'd be as pointless as a heterosexual awareness program. Wow
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Criminals? The guy who was shot in his car with his girlfriend and her kid had nothing but driving offences on his record - to suggest that all of those being killed by police are criminals is nonsense. The scale of significance you talk about is not police v criminals, it's about police v citizens. Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (20 Jul 2016 5.45pm) How do you know what has happened?
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Criminals? The guy who was shot in his car with his girlfriend and her kid had nothing but driving offences on his record - to suggest that all of those being killed by police are criminals is nonsense. The scale of significance you talk about is not police v criminals, it's about police v citizens. Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (20 Jul 2016 5.45pm) You are judging that incident with insufficient evidence. The video I saw did not show the shooting or the reason for it. My gut feeling was that the policeman panicked. I totally agree that any unlawful killing by the police is a matter of concern for all of us. My main cause for concern is the disproportionate response they get relative to other crime. As someone who does not involve themselves in organised crime or carry a gun, I would consider myself to me far more at risk from criminality than the police. It is that simple.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
You are judging that incident with insufficient evidence. The video I saw did not show the shooting or the reason for it. My gut feeling was that the policeman panicked. I totally agree that any unlawful killing by the police is a matter of concern for all of us. My main cause for concern is the disproportionate response they get relative to other crime. As someone who does not involve themselves in organised crime or carry a gun, I would consider myself to me far more at risk from criminality than the police. It is that simple. It's trial by media, you see a clip on Facebook and feel qualified to label people executioners/murderers. Then 8 cops get killed and people start to realise how dangerous accusations based on next to no evidence are.
|
|
|
Who knows if either are lying... It seems plausible to me, that they could both be telling the truth.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
If you consider the murder of policeman to be less significant that the alleged unlawful killing of criminals then yes. Its not the killing, its the acceptance and protectionism of those doing it that's the issue. I don't have an issue with police officers using reasonable force, even if its lethal. What I do have an issue with, is where the system protects them, when that use of force is unreasonable. To borrow an example. I don't have an issue with police officers using a nightstick. I do have an issue with the Rodney King incident, when four police officers are leathering a black man on the ground with excessive force, who clearly is long past being a threat, and then are accepted as using 'reasonable force'. Similarly, when a man is shot and killed by police, whilst in situations where they do not appear to be a threat. Then its an issue. So, yes, I do see the murder of policemen as wrong - However, the suspects aren't getting away with it. What would the protest be about in terms of Justice?
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
Who knows if either are lying... It seems plausible to me, that they could both be telling the truth. Which is why an independent enquiry is necessary - to establish, without political bias, the events. Its why we have trials, before a jury, to establish as fair and impartial a decision as possible in an open court, with arguments and evidence presented from both sides. An internal investigation, by police officers and people with a political relationship to the police and police commissioner is about as far from that as you can get. We start legally, from the basis that both sides may be telling their truth, from their point of view. A fair and impartial hearing, is to establish evidence and arguments to support convincing people who aren't on either side, of what happened. Its not necessarily about convicting a police officer - that's a separate matter, a trial, which would need to prove beyond reasonable doubt. An enquiry is about establishing what happened, why, factors that may be involved etc.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by legaleagle
And it is perhaps so much easier to disparage organisations like Black Lives Matter and to trivialise and ignore the very real racism that continues to pervade the deep South,than to engage with the issue... ...saturday afternoon sport in a local small town being to go out and threaten to shoot a black guy walking down main street,for having the audacity to wear his army uniform while doing so(he was home on leave).One of the perpetrators being an off duty member of the local constabulary. It may be 2016...but segregation era attitudes are far from dead ancient history... Why should people have to tolerate that sh#t? The police reflect the society they come from... ...and 2015 statistics show black people several times more likely to be shot by police than whites.. So,yes, the black community has its share of dodgy people (like any community) and some at the margins overact inappropriately by going out and shooting police (all groups,including "whites" have their share of extremists on the fringe),but there is a very real problem IMO with racism and racist attitudes in the US and this pervades the agencies of the state (as would be expected) such as the police..and the fact the police are an agency of the state and have such power is precisely why police violence on blacks should be focused upon.. And for those who diss the notion that Trump is not a negative factor (however small) in this equation...anyone (whether here or in the US) in the political arena who starts popularising and legitimising an appeal to base sentiments has some responsibility when society becomes more divisive and we begin to reap the fruits of the dirt they sow.. Edited by legaleagle (19 Jul 2016 8.08pm) Clearly BOTH sides fail in that respect...
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
You are judging that incident with insufficient evidence. The video I saw did not show the shooting or the reason for it. My gut feeling was that the policeman panicked. I totally agree that any unlawful killing by the police is a matter of concern for all of us. My main cause for concern is the disproportionate response they get relative to other crime. As someone who does not involve themselves in organised crime or carry a gun, I would consider myself to me far more at risk from criminality than the police. It is that simple. Putting my judgement aside, which I will respond to in a minute - the guy still wasn't a criminal. He was a law-abiding citizen, legally carrying a weapon. Criminality will always exist in society, it's very difficult to control - police behaviour is something entirely within our control, and these are people paid and professionally prepared to keep us safe - that is why there is such a 'disproportionate response'.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
It's trial by media, you see a clip on Facebook and feel qualified to label people executioners/murderers. Then 8 cops get killed and people start to realise how dangerous accusations based on next to no evidence are. Yes, but that's weighing in from a point of selection. You have to view the entire context, in which there is clearly a very serious issue with police and use of lethal force, along with oversight, that brought that story to the media in the first place. The police are equally culpable, to the protesters, for failing to properly oversee and regulate their own forces, with impartiality and openness, preferring a more politically expedient solution. This isn't a new thing, assorted Police Departments across the last 40 or 50 years in the US have had very serious issues with racism, and come into direct conflict with civil rights groups and the Federal government.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
The clip with the guy in the car has 2 witnesses (not including the child). One picks up her phone and records a message saying her boyfriend was reaching for his license, while the copper says "I told him not to move" I may have jumped the gun slightly in my judgement, but you're never going to get a fair ruling from any inquest of this sort, so waiting for an official verdict is pretty pointless. I struggle to understand why a 32 year old with no criminal history, who's been pulled over for a broken brake light, would inform the officer he's armed and then proceed to draw for his weapon against police orders, and his girlfriend would then live stream the fall-out, having the awareness to make up a story as she does, while the policeman stands there clearly rattled as s*** at what he's done - that's not a logical sequence of events as far as I'm concerned. Could you come up with a story about being asked to produce your license as your partner is dying next to you with your young child in the back? Because I certainly couldn't.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.