This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
That is an excellent post. conquer!
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by TheExpatEagle
You don't know very much then do you? You've only got to look at the PL players who want moves but can't leave to see they are indeed straight jackets. That, by their very nature, is what a contract is all about. Break it and you pay the penalty be it 50p or £200m. Do you know what, or if, the clause is? He might have to pay back a £6m fee. It could be £50m. Who knows. As for calling Allardyce a liar... That is a little petty, isn't it? Everyone lies the only variable is about what and by how much. The manager lies to the players to improve confidence. You can call it embellishing the truth, exaggeration or whatever. But if you want to say I think Allardyce is lying about his reasons for leaving then yes, he lied! A specious argument with no substance but a sprinkling of personal disrespect. The particular situation I was contemplating was one in which a club that wanted Allardyce put up the compensation in order to buy him out of the contractual obligation he has to us. This is something that happens all the time in football (almost every player transfer, actually) and elsewhere and I pointed out an example of this for you as well, which you chose to ignore. The clause is there to reflect due compensation to CPFC but allows Allardyce and his putative employer to exercise a choice. My argument was that if Allardyce were offered another job and wanted to take it, it would be perfectly possible for him to do so, provided someone paid the compensation to CPFC, which is eminently possible. There is no evidence to suggest that anything Allardyce said was untrue and if he wanted to work again I don't think the compensation (I think £2m was mentioned) would stop Wet Spam knocking on his door.
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by TheExpatEagle
You don't know very much then do you? You've only got to look at the PL players who want moves but can't leave to see they are indeed straight jackets. That, by their very nature, is what a contract is all about. Break it and you pay the penalty be it 50p or £200m. Do you know what, or if, the clause is? He might have to pay back a £6m fee. It could be £50m. Who knows. As for calling Allardyce a liar... That is a little petty, isn't it? Everyone lies the only variable is about what and by how much. The manager lies to the players to improve confidence. You can call it embellishing the truth, exaggeration or whatever. But if you want to say I think Allardyce is lying about his reasons for leaving then yes, he lied! Stones/ glass houses spring to mind. The Club with whom the player has a contract holds their registration and it is up to them whether they release or not. If they don't then that player cannot be registered to play for another club. The same registration does not apply to managers but their contracts will forbid them from speaking to other clubs without permission. That said, if a player wants out & is not gonna play/give 100% you have a squad of others that will. If a manager wants out who do you replace him with while he sits his contract out? Realistically, I think if that happened with a manager they'd not get paid got being in breach of contract anyway so they may as well walk. You can hardly sue them for what you would've paid them if they stayed can you.
Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five! |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
That's exactly what you were saying you did that loads of us don't do. Now you're asked to prove it, well... I don't ask people to prove things, you might be confusing me with someone else or we have had a misunderstanding. When having a conversation on here or anywhere else I take people at their word otherwise the conversation become a futile link war. Over time you get to know when someone is a b/s person and if two opinions conflict each other then maybe links have to be resorted to. My point was that I don't feel a need to prove I'm right. I contributed to the conversation so people can either think I'm correct or that I'm not. It makes no difference to me. I don't win anything by saying someone on Sky said Allardyce left over transfer funds. Because even if I can prove what I read/heard/saw is true then that person would need to show how they came to that conclusion. As you know in the media, if it isn't from the actual horse's mouth, a person can't or won't say they have been told something because it is a betrayal of a confidence. But I am getting off topic a little. I am simply trying to say if someone wants to doubt something they can doubt anyone about anything.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Expat, I saw your name in a Twitter link on the BBS strongly linking Nigel Pearson to the job. Any comments, interviews or anything to suggest this? Nope, I said in the threat that I can't comment on where I got that information. I did say it was something I was hearing not that it was fact. If you know anything about my social media, blog, etc then you'll know I rarely comment on rumours. I am not a fan of click bait articles and the like. I didn't make a post or comment on it in a vid/pod. It would be a cheap and easy way to get visits. That was why I only made a tweet. As you may have noticed I am someone who likes to explain as full as possible when answering.
|
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
A specious argument with no substance but a sprinkling of personal disrespect. The particular situation I was contemplating was one in which a club that wanted Allardyce put up the compensation in order to buy him out of the contractual obligation he has to us. This is something that happens all the time in football (almost every player transfer, actually) and elsewhere and I pointed out an example of this for you as well, which you chose to ignore. The clause is there to reflect due compensation to CPFC but allows Allardyce and his putative employer to exercise a choice. My argument was that if Allardyce were offered another job and wanted to take it, it would be perfectly possible for him to do so, provided someone paid the compensation to CPFC, which is eminently possible. There is no evidence to suggest that anything Allardyce said was untrue and if he wanted to work again I don't think the compensation (I think £2m was mentioned) would stop Wet Spam knocking on his door. Fair enough but I am not the one making a thing about Allardyce being a 'liar'. I think he is not saying the truth of the situation, based on more than my idle imagination, and I would say he is a liar for 'paying lip service', as the Americans would say.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nobbybm
Stones/ glass houses spring to mind. The Club with whom the player has a contract holds their registration and it is up to them whether they release or not. If they don't then that player cannot be registered to play for another club. The same registration does not apply to managers but their contracts will forbid them from speaking to other clubs without permission. That said, if a player wants out & is not gonna play/give 100% you have a squad of others that will. If a manager wants out who do you replace him with while he sits his contract out? Realistically, I think if that happened with a manager they'd not get paid got being in breach of contract anyway so they may as well walk. You can hardly sue them for what you would've paid them if they stayed can you. They do it in Italy all the time. Some clubs have 2 or more managers on 'gardening leave' and regularly bring them back again. As long as the club is paying the manager this is perfectly acceptable.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheExpatEagle
In the interview you mentioned he was talking about January and he has a confidentiality clause preventing him from saying anything at the moment. He is grateful for the backing the board gave him up to and including May. The summer is a different issue. I am going by interviews where I have heard him speak not by anything I've read. The last 3 weeks on Sky other ex-pros who are friendly with Sam have also illuded that he walked away because of a lack of summer funds. It's not speculation and it isn't inaccurate but you welcome to believe what ever truth gives you the most comfort. If you want to chase the speculation monkeys then go after the ones who claim he had a close friend die in the Manchester Bomb, which is totally untrue. They claim that made him retire but he decided over a week before that happened. It is this bit in bold that is where people are rightly questioning where Sam made these comments, and who else gave their opinion. People have the right to raise that. You have the right to not have to, but you can't complain if nobody takes what you've said on this seriously if you either can't remember, or whatever else. It's not that hard to remember and you're the only person I've come across who's claimed anything was said, or not said after/regarding a certain time and therefore these are his thoughts. Edited by Rudi Hedman (06 Sep 2017 7.19pm)
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by TheExpatEagle
you welcome to believe what ever truth gives you the most comfort. I must admit that I smiled when I read the above quote
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
It is this bit in bold that is where people are rightly questioning where Sam made these comments, and who else gave their opinion. People have the right to raise that. You have the right to not have to, but you can't complain if nobody takes what you've said on this seriously if you either can't remember, or whatever else. It's not that hard to remember and you're the only person I've come across who's claimed anything was said, or not said after/regarding a certain time and therefore these are his thoughts. Edited by Rudi Hedman (06 Sep 2017 7.19pm) I don't disagree with what you wrote above. Maybe I should just learn to not comment if I am not prepared to trawl through things to find quotes and whatnot. If I am the only person you've come across to say what I am saying then I'd say you can't know many Palace fans, which I doubt is true. Since day 1 when Sam left people were saying it is about transfers and it continued through the summer. It has been debated on here, the BBS, Twitter and Facebook groups. This led to someone dreaming up the rumour that he left because he had a close friend die in the Manchester bombing. This is completely untrue yet people are saying this is a fact and it's why Parish was taken by surprise. Fact is Allardyce is quoted as saying (talking to Jim White on Talksport) that he decided before the Hull game to leave which makes it strange that he had preliminary talks with Parish about transfers and agreed to "Sakho plus one", which I have not heard elsewhere, just that Parish said "one maybe two" on a US radio interview in June. One thing I can point you to is one of the talking head ex-pros on Sky's The Debate who echoed what I've been saying, can't remember which one it was but he was on with either Ian Wright or Simon Jordan but it wasn't either of those two who said it. Furthermore it has been debated on 5 Live, Talksport and other podcasts. As I said, I can't trawl through everything. I listen to shedloads of podcasts every day on my walks be it the BBC football shows, The Guardian's Football Weekly, The Game, etc. To expect me go through all media sources to satisfy your curiosity is a little silly when Palace crop up every episode (as we are currently Premier League) but I am happy to submit a list so you can listen to them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Goldfiinger
I like most if not all on here listen out for palace news, not heard one person allude to Sam leaving due to lack of funds. I did hear Sam himself big up the club over how well they did back him in Jan.. not heard a bean from anyone that the reason he left may have been from lack of funds. Other than from plenty of wallys on here.. I did however read in numerous newspapers that his wife's best friend did die in the terrorist attacks. Not sure why everyone is quick to right this off as not be a deciding factor. Complete and utter fabrication. I point you to my answer above. He decided before the Hull game to leave the club. He said in an interview to Jim White on Talksport. It appears you might be one of the Wallys for believing b/s and even if it were true Allardyce never alluded to it and said he made his decision a full days or more before the bombing.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheExpatEagle
I don't disagree with what you wrote above. Maybe I should just learn to not comment if I am not prepared to trawl through things to find quotes and whatnot. If I am the only person you've come across to say what I am saying then I'd say you can't know many Palace fans, which I doubt is true. Since day 1 when Sam left people were saying it is about transfers and it continued through the summer. It has been debated on here, the BBS, Twitter and Facebook groups. This led to someone dreaming up the rumour that he left because he had a close friend die in the Manchester bombing. This is completely untrue yet people are saying this is a fact and it's why Parish was taken by surprise. Fact is Allardyce is quoted as saying (talking to Jim White on Talksport) that he decided before the Hull game to leave which makes it strange that he had preliminary talks with Parish about transfers and agreed to "Sakho plus one", which I have not heard elsewhere, just that Parish said "one maybe two" on a US radio interview in June. One thing I can point you to is one of the talking head ex-pros on Sky's The Debate who echoed what I've been saying, can't remember which one it was but he was on with either Ian Wright or Simon Jordan but it wasn't either of those two who said it. Furthermore it has been debated on 5 Live, Talksport and other podcasts. As I said, I can't trawl through everything. I listen to shedloads of podcasts every day on my walks be it the BBC football shows, The Guardian's Football Weekly, The Game, etc. To expect me go through all media sources to satisfy your curiosity is a little silly when Palace crop up every episode (as we are currently Premier League) but I am happy to submit a list so you can listen to them. There's certainly been palace fans speculating all kinds of reasons, including, like you say, lack of funds. But I don't recall any taking any comments made by Sam to Jim White or anybody and using those to surmise it must've been because of lack of funds. And certainly not anyone taking comments from a third party on Sam's decision as gospel. He may have had a change of mind, a change of heart, a pain in the heart, another warning from the doctor because of previous health warnings. Conversations with the wife, family, anything. He may want 6 months off, maybe even 6 months off and 6 months on again. That was my guess at the time, but it's just a guess, and an outcome I've no issue with. If indeed it was due to 'lack of funds.' What lack of funds are these? £50 mil net spend last season, £30 mil net spend this season. Would e been over £40 mil if it weren't for the fvcking about. More than respectable. About 9th in the wages table with revenue at 14th? In football management there are those who think there is a bottomless pit of money to spend and can walk away from when the effect runs out and the bad times begin. In commentary there are those who can do so in a studio or paper column and forget all of it till the next 30 minutes in 3 weeks time. When Sam took the job he knew the size of the club and he knew the days of Bolton, Pompey etc are long gone. FFP has reigned spending to within what's realistic and comparable to those around you. Simplifying it is financial related to, 'lack' of funds, is far too simplistic. I'm not surprised it's been brought into question by the usual football commentary types who couldn't give a fook if we did blow up because of it when the next 25,000 prem max attendance club comes up to take their place and go through the same irresponsible process because they aren't responsible for their finger pointing cr&p again. There are issues at the club. Putting money on the table isn't in doubt. Forward planning and an experienced head doing so is.
COYP |
|
|
Allardyce is on The Debate on sky sports if interested.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
There's certainly been palace fans speculating all kinds of reasons, including, like you say, lack of funds. But I don't recall any taking any comments made by Sam to Jim White or anybody and using those to surmise it must've been because of lack of funds. And certainly not anyone taking comments from a third party on Sam's decision as gospel. He may have had a change of mind, a change of heart, a pain in the heart, another warning from the doctor because of previous health warnings. Conversations with the wife, family, anything. He may want 6 months off, maybe even 6 months off and 6 months on again. That was my guess at the time, but it's just a guess, and an outcome I've no issue with. If indeed it was due to 'lack of funds.' What lack of funds are these? £50 mil net spend last season, £30 mil net spend this season. Would e been over £40 mil if it weren't for the fvcking about. More than respectable. About 9th in the wages table with revenue at 14th? In football management there are those who think there is a bottomless pit of money to spend and can walk away from when the effect runs out and the bad times begin. In commentary there are those who can do so in a studio or paper column and forget all of it till the next 30 minutes in 3 weeks time. When Sam took the job he knew the size of the club and he knew the days of Bolton, Pompey etc are long gone. FFP has reigned spending to within what's realistic and comparable to those around you. Simplifying it is financial related to, 'lack' of funds, is far too simplistic. I'm not surprised it's been brought into question by the usual football commentary types who couldn't give a fook if we did blow up because of it when the next 25,000 prem max attendance club comes up to take their place and go through the same irresponsible process because they aren't responsible for their finger pointing cr&p again. There are issues at the club. Putting money on the table isn't in doubt. Forward planning and an experienced head doing so is. Edited by Rudi Hedman (06 Sep 2017 9.59pm) My understanding was the club would have £30m to spend and that in order to not be in a relegation battle again he'd ideally need almost double if Sakho was coming in. It was more about the number of players he wanted to bring in that was a stumbling block. He knew there was about 1/3 of the squad that needed replacing for one reason or another. For example the senior players who left in the summer (Campbell, Ledley, Flamini, etc.) and £30m wasn't going to adequately replace them and if he could only bring in 2 players to fill 5 or 6 departures it all pointed to a major struggle this season. I was led to believe he was not happy that Delaney and less so, Speroni were handed new deals over his head. By that I mean he wasn't consulted about it, Parish just went and did it. Sam felt he could have got other squad players in on less wages. We saw that Allardyce didn't fancy Delaney after the Sunderland game at home and he didn't think he had a future at the club. Over all he could tell there was no use complaining or fighting to get more money because Parish feels the squad is good enough with the right coaching. Sam felt we got out of jail. I certainly don't think we should go and spunk the cash all over the place. We saw what you can buy for £10m in January and maybe that is up to £15m this summer but even so I think we need what we need. Outside the first 11 the squad lacks quality of depth. Why did we let Ledley go? On the bench for Wales the other night. FdB did let him go, it wasn't Allardyce so it is a mystery. Same for Campbell. Might not be a great striker but he is better than nothing. On the subject of FFP, last summer Pardew and Parish said they tried everything they could to persuade Bolasie to stay. However, had he not left we could not have afforded to buy Benteke. Maybe the money we spent in January (which was part summer 2016 and part summer 2017 funds) would have been used which would have meant no bail out money which Sam used. So, did the board really try to keep Bolasie? If so maybe we should thank him for leaving because otherwise we'd not have had any money to buy players in January 2017. It seems that we have about £40m to spend each summer, plus proceeds from sales. We spent £11m net (roughly) and just under £40m in January, £10m of which was from this summer. Add the £38m (inc.. loan fees) we're just over but then we sold Mandanda. Since we've been in the PL it hasn't been how much we've spend but that we've spent it on some pretty poor players who we can't get rid of.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheExpatEagle
Complete and utter fabrication. I point you to my answer above. He decided before the Hull game to leave the club. He said in an interview to Jim White on Talksport. It appears you might be one of the Wallys for believing b/s and even if it were true Allardyce never alluded to it and said he made his decision a full days or more before the bombing. Your the wally mate. You say he made the decision before Hull and yet his decision was based on transfer budget. Before Hull he wouldn't have known the transfer budget.... My point was even if he had decided before Hull, then the tragic news of his wife's friends death may have been the deciding factor. As in, I've made my decision and I'm certainly not changing it now. Can not for the life of me imagine he'd have known before Hull game what our transfer budget was, but you are sure he did and that's why he decided to leave. Ok mate, make sense.... Oh and not one actual bit of respectable newspaper print to back up your thesis. You sir must be right. Throw in the FACT he lorded Palace for there huge backing of him in Janurary like no other club ever has. Yeah that smells like a man about to resin over a transfer budget. It's a very easy thing to say, manager leaves due to transfer budget. See I just said it.... Doesn't make it true tho. Edited by Goldfiinger (06 Sep 2017 10.58pm) Just noticed you have a blog... do you make up all your stories based on pub talk? Edited by Goldfiinger (06 Sep 2017 11.01pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheExpatEagle
Complete and utter fabrication. I point you to my answer above. He decided before the Hull game to leave the club. He said in an interview to Jim White on Talksport. It appears you might be one of the Wallys for believing b/s and even if it were true Allardyce never alluded to it and said he made his decision a full days or more before the bombing. You keep insulting people that question you but never seem to back up your comments. If you are referring to the Jim White interview I heard then he didn't actually say he'd made his mind up but that he knew his work was done. That could easily be construed as he'd achieved what he was employed to do. If that was the case then he is a bloody good actor if you look at his press conferences pre & post Manure - even taking his cryptic response at the end of the latter it was all very much about planning for the new season & players out/in. Pre: Post:
Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five! |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
'Since we've been in the PL it hasn't been how much we've spend but that we've spent it on some pretty poor players who we can't get rid of.' Maybe we agree on more than it first seems. I just think you're a bit quick to presume, right, he said this, which doesn't infer anything, then did this, which may not be a result of one thing in particular, and because some commentators are free to throw their opinion in (without it having any consequence), it must be real. The 'lack' in describing funds is poorly phrased. Poorly planned transfer strategy over time, yes. It's got me thinking, with the help of knowing Jimmy and Cabaye are free agents next summer and Mensah and Cheek will probably return, that something needs to change. Our wage bill is 9th yet the squad will rarely hit 9th,X and probably won't this or next season. We're signing players that cost what Spurs pay for them, but because of that we can't afford depth, and yet they're not as good as spurs players anyway. And this is because the scouting is poor. So what have we done? Signed Riedewald who Frank obviously knew and hired freedman who's far from qualified for such a role. It's not 'lack' of funds that's the problem. It's lack expertise and strategy that's the problem. We've gone through repetition of recruit and replace or sign and drain the wage bill. The 2 obvious ones in error were Pardew's extension and Parish signing Sakho. It's going to take time to address it all if we get the chance to in this league but one thing's for sure. The scouting will have to be pretty good next summer unless we sell big and sell top talent to maintain being a high paying and reasonably high trading club. High in first team plus a few I mean. Fair enough, I can accept what you are saying though I don't tend to rely on one person saying something in one interview. I can also accept that I tend to apply past practises when thinking of current situations. Parish has a history of being a tight sod and dressing it up with keeping the club out of trouble which he isn't wrong for doing but got away with it in his first 5 years so it is easy to believe it is about money. However, as I said I don't just go by one interview. For example, Parish said one thing in the BT Sport post match show after the Burnley home game where he spoke about how much we spent in January and that we won't be able to spend that much in the summer. As you know we spent about £30m plus Sakho's loan fee. Parish then said something else regarding the summer transfer activity (can't remember where but probably Talksport) and then in the US radio interview in June where he said he had agreed on one maybe two players coming in. Some people say Sakho plus one. Piecing the three together you can get a picture (as long as Parish is being truthful and nothing changes after the fact which it did because de Boer was appointed) and that picture is pretty much what has happened. As you rightly say the transfer policy has been poor and we have been somewhat of a time bomb waiting to go off which might happen next summer. As you say Jimmy and Cabaye are out of contract, the two loanees will return plus 'squad players' such as Speroni, Delaney, Sako, Lee and Mutch will be out of contract if not more (I think Ward, Kelly, Dann and Souare might be too). As I said before, I don't believe in throwing money around but had we invested £10m on good potential a year ago and follow Chelsea's model of loaning then out then that £10m would be recouped and we might have the next first team squad in the making. As Chelsea loaned out between 45-55 players in each of the last two seasons I can only imagine how much revenue that generated. Some would have generated over a million some a few hundred thousand. But it's income. I'm of the opinion that Wilf will be sold next summer. It's the only thing that makes sense. When he signed a new contract I was generally cool on it. Parish said he had 3 years left and wasn't going anywhere so a new contract was no indication that he was more likely to stay, just that we could command a bigger fee because of his better contract. He basically signed up to 2 extra years and trebled his waged and had a host of clauses inserted. But that is nothing against Wilf, I almost think he should leave because he deserves better than what he is having to play with.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nobbybm
You keep insulting people that question you but never seem to back up your comments. If you are referring to the Jim White interview I heard then he didn't actually say he'd made his mind up but that he knew his work was done. That could easily be construed as he'd achieved what he was employed to do. If that was the case then he is a bloody good actor if you look at his press conferences pre & post Manure - even taking his cryptic response at the end of the latter it was all very much about planning for the new season & players out/in. Pre: Post: Who did I insult and how? The interview I am referring to was on 18th July and is quoted in newspapers on 19th July. Fact: He says he made his decision before the Hull game. "Privately, I knew I was going to leave the club before the Hull game. I had made the decision privately. I had talked it over with my wife, and I have to listen to her because she wanted me to pack it in a long time ago." Fact: Parish said in a radio interview that they had agreed "1 maybe 2" transfers in the summer. Would Allardyce have had those discussions if he had already made his decision? So it must have taken place before the Hull game thus influencing his decision. "Palace owner Steve Parish had no idea and wouldn't find out until after the final day at Manchester United." Make of it what you will. I am not asking you to agree with my views on what happened but don't expect me to agree with yours.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.