You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hodgson has to go
November 16 2026 6.51am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Hodgson has to go


Page 14 of 18 < 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 >
Mathers Flag 17 Jan 19 12.12pm

Originally posted by fledgling

the fact he's not a c*nt makes up the 5% for me.


Haha that’s the best response so far!

To those who say “Roy hasn’t had a striker”, well Pulis had Jerome and Chamakh but still managed a better record.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Jan 19 12.17pm

Originally posted by Mathers


Haha that’s the best response so far!

To those who say “Roy hasn’t had a striker”, well Pulis had Jerome and Chamakh but still managed a better record.

That’s what I thought but you cannot play that way with success for long. Teams will work you out or the ones you need or want to beat for 3 points may do the same.

Hodgson is the other side of the fine margins this season. That is the football and seasons strategy he plays. It’ll frustrate the hell out of you in the games he won’t do anything about it and then you get a surprise when you’re not expecting it or lost a bit of confidence, usually at home in an armchair, which is suitable for watching it.

 


COYP

southnorwoodhill Flag 17 Jan 19 12.42pm

Unfortunately Roy Hodgson has ruined our best player, as he did with the England squad. Round holes, square pegs, that kind of thing.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Jan 19 12.54pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Unfortunately Roy Hodgson has ruined our best player, as he did with the England squad. Round holes, square pegs, that kind of thing.

Some truth in this.

 


COYP

TheBigToePunt Flag 17 Jan 19 1.51pm

Originally posted by fledgling

the fact he's not a c*nt makes up the 5% for me.

This is really important actually. It matters to me that regardless of whether we've won, lost or drawn, Hodgson carries himself (and represents the club) correctly.

He speaks in an straight, articulate, sensible fashion no matter what, and that stands out for me in an age where it seems like every second person with any kind of public attention whatsoever is only capable of making a divisive, inarticulate, mad noise.

 

cpj Flag Kent 17 Jan 19 2.03pm

I think if our home and away records were the other way round it wouldn't seem so bad, but our record at Selhurst this season is just appalling. 6 goals in 11 games - 2 of which were pens. For those of us who just go to home games, we invest so much emotionally in looking forward to a home win and keep leaving so disappointed. Yes, we've had injury issues with strikers, but we had them at the end of last season and were doing well then with WZ and AT up front. I just find RH so negative with his team selections and substitutions. He just won't try anyone different - he only brought in AW-B last season because we had an injury problem at the back and he has done well, so why not try some of the other youngsters, or at least out a couple on the bench instead of the same players we have there every week? Also, the size of our squad has really gone down in the last 2 windows - is that down to RH or instructions from on high? We could have done with Cabaye and Sako this season.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 17 Jan 19 2.46pm

This thread should be called "Hodgson has to go at the end of the season".

Changing managers now would be a mistake. For all of his annoying traits and decisions, we need to stick with Roy for the time being. I am fairly confident he will once again guide us to safety.

The simple fact is that we are playing better than earlier in the season, now dont get me wrong, thats not hard as we were absolutely awful in some games like Wolves first time and Newcastle.

When we turned over Man City and Wolves, there was some real positivity about the place. Dont forget that Watford are flying high this year and it is sadly no disgrace to ship 6 points to them, and they had the luck in both games despite the OG.

Going away from home to Liverpool ironically almost represents a better chance at success than home to Watford.

The next manager, whoever he is, simply has to resolve our woeful home record and get some goals going in.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Jan 19 3.34pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

This thread should be called "Hodgson has to go at the end of the season".

Changing managers now would be a mistake. For all of his annoying traits and decisions, we need to stick with Roy for the time being. I am fairly confident he will once again guide us to safety.

The simple fact is that we are playing better than earlier in the season, now dont get me wrong, thats not hard as we were absolutely awful in some games like Wolves first time and Newcastle.

When we turned over Man City and Wolves, there was some real positivity about the place. Dont forget that Watford are flying high this year and it is sadly no disgrace to ship 6 points to them, and they had the luck in both games despite the OG.

Going away from home to Liverpool ironically almost represents a better chance at success than home to Watford.

The next manager, whoever he is, simply has to resolve our woeful home record and get some goals going in.

Hodgson performed a miracle last season when he kept us up against all the odds.If we stay up this season is there any real need to dispense with his services ? His contract runs to the end of next season.

 

jeeagles Flag 17 Jan 19 3.34pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

This is really important actually. It matters to me that regardless of whether we've won, lost or drawn, Hodgson carries himself (and represents the club) correctly.

He speaks in an straight, articulate, sensible fashion no matter what, and that stands out for me in an age where it seems like every second person with any kind of public attention whatsoever is only capable of making a divisive, inarticulate, mad noise.

When I take a lot of time to trek over to Selhurst every other Saturday and spend a fortune to watch someone who's completely set in their ways make the same mistakes week in week out, my opinion of them is not quite as generous. He may be a nice guy, but at the moment its not enjoyable to be a palace fan, and the blame for that lays squarely on him.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 17 Jan 19 4.23pm

Originally posted by Mathers


Haha that’s the best response so far!

To those who say “Roy hasn’t had a striker”, well Pulis had Jerome and Chamakh but still managed a better record.

That's what i am saying, Roy hasn't got a striker, Pulis had Jerome and Chamakh, not great strikers admittedly, but good players and a damned sit better than a Swansea loan.

 

fledgling Flag Beckenham 17 Jan 19 4.25pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

When I take a lot of time to trek over to Selhurst every other Saturday and spend a fortune to watch someone who's completely set in their ways make the same mistakes week in week out, my opinion of them is not quite as generous. He may be a nice guy, but at the moment its not enjoyable to be a palace fan, and the blame for that lays squarely on him.

But why does the blame lay solely on Hodgson? He didn't make the ball go between Jimmy Mac's legs; he didn't make Tompkins not track Cathcart, etc etc. The players have to step up.

In most games we have enough opportunities to not get beat let alone win. It's his game plan and tactics that are putting the team in that position but they aren't finishing. It's all fine margins and this season nothing has quite gone for us.

He's not completely blameless and sometimes his decisions are baffling and frustrating but he knows that playing his way over the course of a season will see us stay up.

It does seem a wasted opportunity that we haven't been able to push on for a top ten place but this year so far we've been on the wrong side of the fine margin.


 

CharlesPaterson Flag 17 Jan 19 5.17pm

Originally posted by Mathers


Hodgson Pl 45 Win % 35

The Hodgson brigade want to explain?

It's worse than that, he's been in charge of 56 league games since taking over from FdB and has 17 wins from 56 games..so about 30% win rate

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 17 Jan 19 6.57pm

Here's my view.

Roy sets the team up, plays an active part in training and come match day that group of players are ready to compete and know what they have to do.

Outside of a core of the starting eleven plus one or two others, he hasn't got too many options. We have lacked game changers on the bench because the squad is light on quality. Hence the reluctance to use subs, although I think he could change things at least to give the opposition a different player to deal with.


But you can't hold him responsible for Ward and Sakho missing free headers - potential 4 more points. Or Zaha unable to score one on one's - point lost last Saturday - and there have been others. The stats show - and we can see for ourselves - that chance creation is not an issue but the finishing.


Unless I'm mistaken, after the Solanke deal fell through we were told there were five strikers on our wanted list. Where are they ? Or is the return of Benteke mean that we aren't looking any more ?


At Selhurst this season there have been two abject performances - Southampton and Chelsea. We got what we deserved from those games.


So yes, Roy's stats don't look great but they do not reflect the overall performance of the players.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Jan 19 7.13pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Here's my view.

Roy sets the team up, plays an active part in training and come match day that group of players are ready to compete and know what they have to do.

Outside of a core of the starting eleven plus one or two others, he hasn't got too many options. We have lacked game changers on the bench because the squad is light on quality. Hence the reluctance to use subs, although I think he could change things at least to give the opposition a different player to deal with.


But you can't hold him responsible for Ward and Sakho missing free headers - potential 4 more points. Or Zaha unable to score one on one's - point lost last Saturday - and there have been others. The stats show - and we can see for ourselves - that chance creation is not an issue but the finishing.


Unless I'm mistaken, after the Solanke deal fell through we were told there were five strikers on our wanted list. Where are they ? Or is the return of Benteke mean that we aren't looking any more ?


At Selhurst this season there have been two abject performances - Southampton and Chelsea. We got what we deserved from those games.


So yes, Roy's stats don't look great but they do not reflect the overall performance of the players.

I am broadly in agreement with this excellent post.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 17 Jan 19 7.31pm

Originally posted by fledgling

But why does the blame lay solely on Hodgson? He didn't make the ball go between Jimmy Mac's legs; he didn't make Tompkins not track Cathcart, etc etc. The players have to step up.

In most games we have enough opportunities to not get beat let alone win. It's his game plan and tactics that are putting the team in that position but they aren't finishing. It's all fine margins and this season nothing has quite gone for us.

He's not completely blameless and sometimes his decisions are baffling and frustrating but he knows that playing his way over the course of a season will see us stay up.

It does seem a wasted opportunity that we haven't been able to push on for a top ten place but this year so far we've been on the wrong side of the fine margin.


Is the correct response.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 17 Jan 19 7.33pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Here's my view.

Roy sets the team up, plays an active part in training and come match day that group of players are ready to compete and know what they have to do.

Outside of a core of the starting eleven plus one or two others, he hasn't got too many options. We have lacked game changers on the bench because the squad is light on quality. Hence the reluctance to use subs, although I think he could change things at least to give the opposition a different player to deal with.


But you can't hold him responsible for Ward and Sakho missing free headers - potential 4 more points. Or Zaha unable to score one on one's - point lost last Saturday - and there have been others. The stats show - and we can see for ourselves - that chance creation is not an issue but the finishing.


Unless I'm mistaken, after the Solanke deal fell through we were told there were five strikers on our wanted list. Where are they ? Or is the return of Benteke mean that we aren't looking any more ?


At Selhurst this season there have been two abject performances - Southampton and Chelsea. We got what we deserved from those games.


So yes, Roy's stats don't look great but they do not reflect the overall performance of the players.

Precisely and after the missed header he gave away a pen in the dying moments in the next match for a silly hand ball, he alone cost us four points.

Edited by Tickled pink (17 Jan 2019 7.56pm)

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 17 Jan 19 10.38pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Here's my view.

Roy sets the team up, plays an active part in training and come match day that group of players are ready to compete and know what they have to do.

Outside of a core of the starting eleven plus one or two others, he hasn't got too many options. We have lacked game changers on the bench because the squad is light on quality. Hence the reluctance to use subs, although I think he could change things at least to give the opposition a different player to deal with.


But you can't hold him responsible for Ward and Sakho missing free headers - potential 4 more points. Or Zaha unable to score one on one's - point lost last Saturday - and there have been others. The stats show - and we can see for ourselves - that chance creation is not an issue but the finishing.


Unless I'm mistaken, after the Solanke deal fell through we were told there were five strikers on our wanted list. Where are they ? Or is the return of Benteke mean that we aren't looking any more ?


At Selhurst this season there have been two abject performances - Southampton and Chelsea. We got what we deserved from those games.


So yes, Roy's stats don't look great but they do not reflect the overall performance of the players.

Bang on. I’d add to that that for large parts of this season the football has been quite attractive as well.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Jan 19 11.18pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

Bang on. I’d add to that that for large parts of this season the football has been quite attractive as well.

Last season, yes. This season, no. And the best bits haven’t lasted for anything like large parts of the season. They’re few and far between. What has improved is the passing and ability on the ball at the back and in midfield so far up the field. It’s when it goes beyond here that we come short, and that’s because of the board, transfer policies and now being hamstrung as well as Hodgson. I’m not saying sack him, but I’m not kidding myself it’s great because it isn’t, and we should be seriously looking for a successor now for when he’s needed and not then.

 


COYP

Mathers Flag 17 Jan 19 11.38pm

It’s all well and good that a lot of people think he’ll leave at the end of the season but how much closer to the relegation zone do we need to be to take some action THIS SEASON.

We are dangerously close to be cut adrift with the the bottom 7 teams to scrap it out. I genuinely think he might only have 4 league games left (Liverpool-A, Saints- A, Fulham - H, West Ham- H) and has to get a minimum of 6 points.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Jan 19 11.43pm

Originally posted by Mathers

It’s all well and good that a lot of people think he’ll leave at the end of the season but how much closer to the relegation zone do we need to be to take some action THIS SEASON.

We are dangerously close to be cut adrift with the the bottom 7 teams to scrap it out. I genuinely think he might only have 4 league games left (Liverpool-A, Saints- A, Fulham - H, West Ham- H) and has to get a minimum of 6 points.

Parish won’t sack Hodgson in the very near future unless the Americans say so and are putting up loads for transfers, but they won’t be doing the latter so no chance.

 


COYP

Page 14 of 18 < 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hodgson has to go