This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Palace vs Aston Villa Match Thread
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
silvertop Portishead 01 Sep 19 9.46am |
|
Originally posted by coulsdoneagle
Hey
Take off your red and blue specs for a minute and that’s never simulation in a million years. If it was Zaha would be booked every single week.
He was clearly laying off the ball and didn’t appeal, he also had pressure on his back when running at significant speed.
Im not complaining, but we absolutely got lucky with a poor call.
I watched it carefully and think grealish began his leap before the contact. I suspect his anger had as much to do with him screwing up what should have been a goal or stone penalty.
By the way no mention that a goal would have been 100% unjust smash and grab given how much better we were.
And jenas is a tool. I will elaborate if I have to.
|
Gary St.Andrews Kenley 01 Sep 19 9.51am |
|
|
We can count ourselves very lucky yesterday, that looked like a perfectly good goal chalked off for Villa. Not sure why Grealish got booked either, he was fouled. We have got to take this good fortune because you can bet there will be one that goes against us waiting around the corner.
|
Hutchyeagle Hove 01 Sep 19 9.59am |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Think it was a dive !!' by bexleydave
I have watched and watched the Grealish incident..
At first wasn’t sure but now I think ...it was a dive
Yes slight nudge from Wilf ( could be a free kick edge of box) , which speeds up Grealish momentum.... Cahill just gets his leg out the way, and no contact ...Grealish throws himself to the deck looking for a last minute penalty If the ball hadn’t gone in then VAR would be used ... and think refs decision would have been upheld
I must admit it’s close but I think the ref called it right
|
steeleye20 Croydon 01 Sep 19 9.59am |
|
|
I was expecting to see how the ref had made a howler on MOTD and Villa denied etc.etc.
So it was a surprise to see that Grealish did, in fact, dive, and the referee promptly blew for it.
That was where the game stopped, on the referee's whistle, not on what happened after.
Friend is a highly competent referee, and acted correctly.
|
Rainforest London England 01 Sep 19 10.12am |
|
|
You can hear the whistle the moment Grealish fell over
[Link]
|
taylors lovechild 01 Sep 19 10.13am |
|
|
Villa were unlucky not to get the goal, but they did not deserve a point. They were toothless and were probably lucky to end with 10 men on the pitch and not 9 given McGinn's kick with intent on Schlupp (if you can find it, it is clearly a red card offence).
As Roy said, no apologies necessary, we were clearly the better team 
|
The Dolphin 01 Sep 19 10.32am |
|
|
We were the better team and it would have been a travesty had we lost but that is what comes of not closing a game out properly and scoring when you should. We all have differing opinions of the Grealish incident but I saw he and Zaha have contact which started his fall and then Cahill stuck a leg out which it looks like he withdrew last minute. Friend had blown but to me it was at least a free kick to Villa and maybe worse. We must however take our good fortune when it comes as it will surely work against as many times as not.
|
pssguy 01 Sep 19 10.37am |
|
Originally posted by Hutchyeagle
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Think it was a dive !!' by bexleydave
I have watched and watched the Grealish incident..
At first wasn’t sure but now I think ...it was a dive
Yes slight nudge from Wilf ( could be a free kick edge of box) , which speeds up Grealish momentum.... Cahill just gets his leg out the way, and no contact ...Grealish throws himself to the deck looking for a last minute penalty If the ball hadn’t gone in then VAR would be used ... and think refs decision would have been upheld
I must admit it’s close but I think the ref called it right
spot on. Plus some kudos to Zaha for tracking back and committing the tactical foul
Edited by pssguy (01 Sep 2019 10.40am)
|
NEILLO Shoreham-by-Sea 01 Sep 19 10.39am |
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
I was expecting to see how the ref had made a howler on MOTD and Villa denied etc.etc.
So it was a surprise to see that Grealish did, in fact, dive, and the referee promptly blew for it.
That was where the game stopped, on the referee's whistle, not on what happened after.
Friend is a highly competent referee, and acted correctly.
At the time of the incident, I saw it as a dive and anyone sitting within a few rows of my seat in the Lower Holmesdale would have heard me attempt to draw this to the referee's attention by my yelling '' Grealish you diving cnut '' !
A long way from the action, yes. But I was expecting Grealish to end up on the floor because that's what he does. I'm glad, relieved and surprised that Kevin Friend called it out and I think he got it right.
Old, Ungifted and White
|
pssguy 01 Sep 19 10.42am |
|
|
Away from the controversy, Guaita has had a good start to season. Only 2 goals conceded and quick thinking that started goals in our last two games
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Sep 19 10.45am |
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
At the time of the incident, I saw it as a dive and anyone sitting within a few rows of my seat in the Lower Holmesdale would have heard me attempt to draw this to the referee's attention by my yelling '' Grealish you diving cnut '' !
A long way from the action, yes. But I was expecting Grealish to end up on the floor because that's what he does. I'm glad, relieved and surprised that Kevin Friend called it out and I think he got it right.
As I have already mentioned, Grealish does tend to spend a lot of time on the turf and I mentioned this to someone next to me prior to the incident in question.Looking forward to viewing the incident on TV.
It has been mentioned that the referee blew the whistle as soon as Grealish went to ground and perhaps Guita heard it and didn't make any effort to keep out the shot.Will need to see this on TV.At the end of the day it would have been a travesty if A.Villa got a draw as they never deserved a share of the spoils.
Edited by Willo (01 Sep 2019 10.47am)
|
dreamwaverider London 01 Sep 19 10.55am |
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
I haven't seen MoD yet so can't comment on Lineker - idiot that he can be. Yesterday I said that I thought it was time for Hodgson to go and I still stand by that even though the stats suggest very differently. We have been very successful since February and we would all have taken 7 points right now and it is not his fault that we have spent very little in the transfer window and that someone did a very silly thing by throwing a contract extension to Wickham. He has steadied our ship and we are in a relatively good place. I am sure Hodgson will still be with us until the end of the season but I would like to see someone new take the helm after that. I do not feel that we are seeing the best of Palace even though the points tally is good. I am not suggesting a Pardewesque Manager - I still can barely bring myself to mention his name - but someone to do a little more with what we have and take a chance now and again. Everton was dull, how we beat Man United I will neve know, Sheffield Utd away was an embarrassment and yesterday although we played our socks off we nearly ended up with a draw. I have a season ticket but couldn't go yesterday and wish that I had because live is better than a stream on an i pad and it seems it was a great afternoon and so maybe I should be content with where we are and the fact that we have stayed in the Prem. for a long time now. I am not a "why aren't we in Europe" fan but think - but for one goal yesterday - great goal from Ayew as well by the way - this thread would be full of bile. One goal should not blind us to the facts
Some people are so hard to please. If you are not happy with the style under Roy then what do you want? Unlikely we will deliver like Liverpool or Man City, but if you are grumbling at yesterday you will unlikely get better. We all have our thoughts on the team but if you look at the bench yesterday I reckon Roy has got his handle on it. We are 4th in the league today. I’m super happy. Look on the bright side.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Sep 19 11.02am |
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
Some people are so hard to please. If you are not happy with the style under Roy then what do you want? Unlikely we will deliver like Liverpool or Man City, but if you are grumbling at yesterday you will unlikely get better. We all have our thoughts on the team but if you look at the bench yesterday I reckon Roy has got his handle on it. We are 4th in the league today. I’m super happy. Look on the bright side.
As Bill Shankly once said "Never look at the league table until November".
On another point, Martin Samuel on today's 'Sunday Supplement' said that the traditional top 6 sides are under threat this season from the likes of Wolves,Leicester - and Crystal Palace ! He believes a side outside the normal top 6 could well gain a Champions League place.I doubt we will end up that high !
|
dreamwaverider London 01 Sep 19 11.02am |
|
|
At the end of the day, the ref blew his whistle. End of. Linekar is in denial of the basic fact. The whistle rules. Nothing else needs discussion. Don’t blame VAR if the ref has blown, what happens after is totally irrelevant. Worse case they could have got a free kick but the ref saw the dive and rightly called it Good decision. Go do one Linekar. You of all people should know the rules
|
steeleye20 Croydon 01 Sep 19 11.03am |
|
|
Move over Citeh, here we come !!!
|
dreamwaverider London 01 Sep 19 11.04am |
|
Originally posted by Willo
As Bill Shankly once said "Never look at the league table until November".
On another point, Martin Samuel on today's 'Sunday Supplement' said that the traditional top 6 sides are under threat this season from the likes of Wolves,Leicester - and Crystal Palace ! He believes a side outside the normal top 6 could well gain a Champions League place.I doubt we will end up that high !
It made the beer taste sweeter last night!
|
Eaglecoops CR3 01 Sep 19 11.05am |
|
|
I've looked at the incident time and time again. If there is any contact at all it is Wilf outside the box and that is minimal. Cahill withdraws his leg before Grealish goes to ground.
What the ref saw was Grealish going down easily on 3 or more occasions during the match which probably influenced his decision to call the free kick for simulation.
It is irrelevant whether the ball goes in the net as the ref has already blown his whistle. The fact it did go into the net is why the pundits are blaming VAR for not intervening. The only time I could see VAR coming into play on this passage of play was if they could clearly see Cahill bring down Grealish which would then mean a penalty. You cannot allow a goal to stand regardless of VAR if the whistle has been blown as this signifies a stoppage in play and will have been heard by the players which then, may or may not influence how they challenge for the ball. In this instance I don't think hearing the whistle would have stopped the shot or the goal, but that is not the point, the play has been stopped.
The VAR would have reviewed the challenge by Cahill and taken the same view as the ref that he did not make contact and therefore it was a reasonable decision by the ref to blow up against Grealish for simulation.
At the end of the day this is one of those decisions that can go against you just as easily as it goes for you. I am pleased that we have had the rub of the green against both Utd and now Villa as we had our fair share of poor calls last year.
Just my take on it but I thought Lineker and Co were bang out of order on MOTD last night.
|
The_postman Forest Row 01 Sep 19 11.11am |
|
|
I think the ref may have been more sympathetic to Grealish if he had not spent the whole game going down theatrically at the slightest touch. Apparently he has a reputation for doing it. Shame for someone so talented.
|
serial thriller The Promised Land 01 Sep 19 11.11am |
|
|
Villa can feel unjust all they want, but why the feck did they bring on a striker for a midfielder when they went down to 10? To me that shows disrespect, and the fact they conceded on the counter shows how naive a decision that was.
Like Fulham They've spent loads thinking they'll walk in to the top 10. This league doesn't favour teams with that mentality, and I thought they were bang average yesterday. Had they walked away with a point it would've been a travesty.
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4
|
NEILLO Shoreham-by-Sea 01 Sep 19 11.30am |
|
Originally posted by The_postman
I think the ref may have been more sympathetic to Grealish if he had not spent the whole game going down theatrically at the slightest touch. Apparently he has a reputation for doing it. Shame for someone so talented.
I thought Luca picked up a cheap booking for bringing Grealish down. Grealish leaned into Luca at which point I thought Luca should let him go as it was obvious that Grealish would then ease off and let it appear that he had been shoved to the ground. Which he did and Luca took a yellow for it.
We all know what happens when players get reputations, and Grealish is well on his way to getting one
Old, Ungifted and White
|