You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace v Fulham Match thread
November 16 2026 3.27am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Crystal Palace v Fulham Match thread


Page 14 of 14 << First< 10 11 12 13 14
Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 28 Dec 22 8.05pm

Originally posted by Willo

I have not seen the Nottm Forest incident.In terms of Fulham's second goal,the ball clearly hit Mitrovic's hand but it was deemed "accidental" and as he was not the player who scored, the goal was allowed to stand.

I have just perused the following :

"After initial question marks over whether or not it struck his arm, the goal was actually ruled out for offside after a touch from Willy Boly at the back post. He had strayed into an offside position as VAR stepped in for its routine check, meaning United saw their clean sheet preserved at that time in the showdown"

Edited by Willo (28 Dec 2022 3.41pm)

It's one of those frustrating incidents where the outcome varies depending on when it took place. There was definitely a time when any handball en route to a goal was deemed an unfair advantage, regardless of intent. In this instance, I still maintain it aided the goal, even if it was accidental.

Add to that the fact that VAR was ignored... which never bloody happens. Just a bum hole situation really.

Still... we were too s*** to deserve better luck. When a team has 70% possession, they're 70% more likely to get the good fortune. I'd have felt pretty sheepish if we'd scraped a 1:1 from that game. Which given Ayew hit the bar at 0:1, it wasn't a million miles off happening.

 

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 28 Dec 22 8.09pm

Originally posted by Willo

There was no doubt that the ball made contact with Mitrovic's arm.
It would appear that there was a difference of opinion as to whether it was accidental or not.
Subjectivity and all that !

Edited by Willo (28 Dec 2022 5.58pm)

Exactly. I think it's fair for VAR to say to the ref, 'look, it's hit his arm, you might want to take a second look.' It's fair for the ref to make a decision with all the information available. Personally, I'm frustrated with the outcome, but can respect the decision, even if I don't agree with it. I get it. I can see why he gave it. It's tough s*** on us.

We failed because we did so little to control our destiny.

 

tonymikejoe Flag UK 28 Dec 22 9.57pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

If we had beaten forest and Fulham we would be 7th
Fine lines.


"Fine lines"! We got stuffed 0-3.

 

daven Flag Hailsham 28 Dec 22 10.48pm

It seems that we have an invisible thermostat set at 7th, and we cannot go any higher. I think that we are where we deserve to be,some of the football that we played against Fulham was no better than bottom three.Lets just enjoy the ride and not go all Bolton or Stoke. Just ask their fans now if they regret trying to go to the next level.
I am not saying that we shouldn't, but that we should try when the time is right,I.e when we get a good crop of youth players or get strength in depth of young players, but that is near impossible.

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 29 Dec 22 4.20am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

If Marco Silva had have been our manager we would have beaten them comfortably with our players, its not the players its the tactics

Silva can coach an attack. There's no sign that Vieira actually can in my opinion. Before anyone mentions last season, our chance creation mostly came from transitions and pressing - if you look into it (or even just think about what we watched) we didn't do much when we had to break a defence down. This season our numbers are appalling wherever I look. Bottom 3 in many metrics. Some will say so what, we're not in the bottom 3 of the table but the signs are not good as we are currently and whether Vieira can translate his principles (whatever they actually are - has anyone actually worked out the plan for how to create chances beyond play out from the back, get it out wide and hope for the best) into consistent end product remains to be seen.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 29 Dec 22 10.49am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

I have slept on it but it doesn't get any better.
As soon as I saw the team sheet with no centre forward I knew it would be a long afternoon - dreadful error by the Manager when playing at home.
Fulham were on it from the off while we were slow and looked tired.
Tomkins had a half to forget and given that we were down to 10 men by half time he should have been subbed because he was one mistake away from a sending off and so it came to pass - this is not hindsight - it was our half time discussion point and so another bad mistake by the Manager.
The ref was trigger happy and for once gave us nothing at all.
Mitrovic is a vile cheat as well - despicable to get a fellow pro sent off - albeit too many players do it nowadays.
He also fell over at the drop of a hat - quite pathetic.
An afternoon to forget but I am beginning to doubt PV's tactical acumen and his heart to make big decisions because it was obvious inside 15 mins that he had cocked up.
A worrying start to the rest of the season to be honest!

A good summary - i was amazed with the team he put out, the same as Forest except for a suspension. Unbelievable.

After 6 weeks off, 4 weeks working with the players, how has PV and Roberts not learnt from the Forest debacle?

Zaha upfront in away games when the opposition push up is a decent call, it doesn't work when teams sit deep (Forest) or at home.

Tomkins in defence must have been known about 6 weeks ago but it looked like he was confused by his role. Both bookings were stupid and avoidable - yes Mitrovic made a meal of it, but was this much different from Andersen at Liverpool? Tomkins could have been 'smart' and run across his line, making it look like he was being fouled, instead he was lazy and just tried to block with an arm.

After the sending off surely one of Eze and Olise needed to be taken off - neither were doing much (again) and clearly we needed to 10 to work hard and be organised, something neither are great at.

But must worrying for me what is our attacking strategy? Goalie rolls it out to a defender, the midfield rarely come to collect and so we end up going long despite having not one of the front 4 capable of winning a header (Zaha is 6 ft FFS - it's about time he learnt).

Also, when Mitrovic is their greatest threat from set pieces why did we not put our best header up against him? Even in open play he drifted to the back to attack Clyne and repeatedly neither centre back went with him.

Their first goal was nicely worked by showed our limitations.
We gave the ball cheaply trying to pass it out of defence and then Mitrovic went wide to receive a pass - no one goes with him.
When he crossed it a small midfielder runs in and scores a good header - neither centre back or a midfielder tracked the run.

Just out of interest when has say Olise, Eze or Zaha made this type of run? Maybe Eze v Wolves. Zaha usually just hides at the back post, rather than gambling and making a run (play off goal v Brighton run has never been repeated).

Overall a really disappointing performance


 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 29 Dec 22 10.56am

Originally posted by palace99

A good summary - i was amazed with the team he put out, the same as Forest except for a suspension. Unbelievable.

After 6 weeks off, 4 weeks working with the players, how has PV and Roberts not learnt from the Forest debacle?

Zaha upfront in away games when the opposition push up is a decent call, it doesn't work when teams sit deep (Forest) or at home.

Tomkins in defence must have been known about 6 weeks ago but it looked like he was confused by his role. Both bookings were stupid and avoidable - yes Mitrovic made a meal of it, but was this much different from Andersen at Liverpool? Tomkins could have been 'smart' and run across his line, making it look like he was being fouled, instead he was lazy and just tried to block with an arm.

After the sending off surely one of Eze and Olise needed to be taken off - neither were doing much (again) and clearly we needed to 10 to work hard and be organised, something neither are great at.

But must worrying for me what is our attacking strategy? Goalie rolls it out to a defender, the midfield rarely come to collect and so we end up going long despite having not one of the front 4 capable of winning a header (Zaha is 6 ft FFS - it's about time he learnt).

Also, when Mitrovic is their greatest threat from set pieces why did we not put our best header up against him? Even in open play he drifted to the back to attack Clyne and repeatedly neither centre back went with him.

Their first goal was nicely worked by showed our limitations.
We gave the ball cheaply trying to pass it out of defence and then Mitrovic went wide to receive a pass - no one goes with him.
When he crossed it a small midfielder runs in and scores a good header - neither centre back or a midfielder tracked the run.

Just out of interest when has say Olise, Eze or Zaha made this type of run? Maybe Eze v Wolves. Zaha usually just hides at the back post, rather than gambling and making a run (play off goal v Brighton run has never been repeated).

Overall a really disappointing performance


A poor goal to concede.Mitchell got drawn out to an advanced position and when Mitrovic received the ball out wide, Eze never made any attempt to close him down and the Fulham forward had time to cross the ball.Decordova-Reid got between our two central defenders and was in acres of space when he headed the ball into the net.He has only scored 4 headed goals in his PL career.

Edited by Willo (29 Dec 2022 11.18am)

 

Jacey Flag 29 Dec 22 12.15pm

Appears that all the early optimism regarding Vieira appointment has disappeared and that we are struggling to see where the next win is coming.
Are we in a fight for survival this season so soon and exactly what are our American owners going to do to simply ensure our survival,given that Zaha is surely out the door???
[Link]

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 29 Dec 22 12.26pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Appears that all the early optimism regarding Vieira appointment has disappeared and that we are struggling to see where the next win is coming.
Are we in a fight for survival this season so soon and exactly what are our American owners going to do to simply ensure our survival,given that Zaha is surely out the door???
[Link]

I've said it before and I'll keep saying it, we have two major problems atm:

1. PV - There was rightly a lot of optimism surrounding him and his start, he plays good football, can attract players to the palace and there was a general good feel about the gaff. Does scream to me, however, of the ol' saying 'When it's good it's good, but when it's bad it's BAD!!'. He has his faults (subs etc.) of course but which manager doesn't? My concern is that our downhill form could start to accelerate with no signs of halting lest reversing this trajectory in sight. I have reservations over PV's ability to deal with this.

2. Ownership - when we say ownership, we usually refer to 'funding'. As it stands, we have two good CBs and some nice 'flair' players in the squad. That's lovely. However, what is less so, is possibly our best player of all time may soon be leaving, we have gaps in the starting XI let alone the lack of depth in the squad, and our star players can look somewhat lightweight when the stomach for a fight is needed.

My fear is that we will not see any new incoming players (and when I say that, I mean individuals who will come in and make a difference to the first team, not yet more 'one for future, Moldovan Maradonas etc etc) , our slump will continue and PV will not have the answers for this. I fear the latter may be true but the former is almost guaranteed.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 29 Dec 22 12.34pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I've said it before and I'll keep saying it, we have two major problems atm:

1. PV - There was rightly a lot of optimism surrounding him and his start, he plays good football, can attract players to the palace and there was a general good feel about the gaff. Does scream to me, however, of the ol' saying 'When it's good it's good, but when it's bad it's BAD!!'. He has his faults (subs etc.) of course but which manager doesn't? My concern is that our downhill form could start to accelerate with no signs of halting lest reversing this trajectory in sight. I have reservations over PV's ability to deal with this.

2. Ownership - when we say ownership, we usually refer to 'funding'. As it stands, we have two good CBs and some nice 'flair' players in the squad. That's lovely. However, what is less so, is possibly our best player of all time may soon be leaving, we have gaps in the starting XI let alone the lack of depth in the squad, and our star players can look somewhat lightweight when the stomach for a fight is needed.

My fear is that we will not see any new incoming players (and when I say that, I mean individuals who will come in and make a difference to the first team, not yet more 'one for future, Moldovan Maradonas etc etc) , our slump will continue and PV will not have the answers for this. I fear the latter may be true but the former is almost guaranteed.

If the slump continues and we are on the slippery slope to relegation, I suspect that PV will be jettisoned and perhaps Dyche approached, if indeed he is not at another club.He also has a promotion to the PL on his CV !

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 29 Dec 22 12.48pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I've said it before and I'll keep saying it, we have two major problems atm:

1. PV - There was rightly a lot of optimism surrounding him and his start, he plays good football, can attract players to the palace and there was a general good feel about the gaff. Does scream to me, however, of the ol' saying 'When it's good it's good, but when it's bad it's BAD!!'. He has his faults (subs etc.) of course but which manager doesn't? My concern is that our downhill form could start to accelerate with no signs of halting lest reversing this trajectory in sight. I have reservations over PV's ability to deal with this.

2. Ownership - when we say ownership, we usually refer to 'funding'. As it stands, we have two good CBs and some nice 'flair' players in the squad. That's lovely. However, what is less so, is possibly our best player of all time may soon be leaving, we have gaps in the starting XI let alone the lack of depth in the squad, and our star players can look somewhat lightweight when the stomach for a fight is needed.

My fear is that we will not see any new incoming players (and when I say that, I mean individuals who will come in and make a difference to the first team, not yet more 'one for future, Moldovan Maradonas etc etc) , our slump will continue and PV will not have the answers for this. I fear the latter may be true but the former is almost guaranteed.

Perhaps a loan for Mohamed Elneny might be under consideration, a player who brings energy,enthusiasm and commitment in the midfield 'Engine room'.

Edited by Willo (29 Dec 2022 12.48pm)

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 29 Dec 22 12.49pm

Originally posted by Willo

If the slump continues and we are on the slippery slope to relegation, I suspect that PV will be jettisoned and perhaps Dyche approached, if indeed he is not at another club.He also has a promotion to the PL on his CV !

That would be 'oh so Palace' Willo so dare I say not an outlandish prophecy at all.

I sincerely hope not however, again, could well play out as such.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

dreamwaverider Flag London 29 Dec 22 2.27pm

Originally posted by Goalpost1

I don't agree with that. I think by and large Viera has been very good for us. Attacking, exciting young players but we are under performing and were comprehensively outplayed by Fulham. My only question was the absence of either Edouard or Mateta in attack which I think would have made a big difference against the excellent Diop, even if only to allow more space for Zaha and Olise. Something clearly gone on in the background with these two.

When French heads drop all hell can let loose.

 

eaglesdare Flag 29 Dec 22 3.00pm

if we win our next game it will go back to "can we finsish top 6?" then loose to spurs and its doom and gloom again! then beat southampton and how far in the fa cup we go....

snooze snooze snooze

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 29 Dec 22 3.04pm

Originally posted by eaglesdare

if we win our next game it will go back to "can we finsish top 6?" then loose to spurs and its doom and gloom again! then beat southampton and how far in the fa cup we go....

snooze snooze snooze

Sort of the point of being a football fan though isn't it?

If that is 'snooze snooze snooze' then perhaps football isn't for you.

Big 'ifs' though, and that's the point. The smarter betting is surely for us to lose to Bournemouth, further despair, but then beat Spurs unexpectedly and dream once more!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Den1923 Flag 29 Dec 22 4.45pm

Originally posted by eaglesdare

if we win our next game it will go back to "can we finsish top 6?" then loose to spurs and its doom and gloom again! then beat southampton and how far in the fa cup we go....

snooze snooze snooze

Pigs may learn to fly first!

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 29 Dec 22 5.46pm

Originally posted by eaglesdare

if we win our next game it will go back to "can we finsish top 6?" then loose to spurs and its doom and gloom again! then beat southampton and how far in the fa cup we go....

snooze snooze snooze

After the poor team effort and absence of management nous we saw earlier this week the only thing we might win is the toss of a coin. It was an inexcusable home performance after 6 weeks off. I never walk out of games before the final whistle but I was glad to get out of the ground after the third goal. People gave up their time and cash to get to the ground to support their team. They were entitled to see a competitive game of football. Let's hope it was a one off!

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Page 14 of 14 << First< 10 11 12 13 14

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace v Fulham Match thread