You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy Hodgson just announced as CPFC manager
November 16 2026 3.36am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy Hodgson just announced as CPFC manager


Page 14 of 20 < 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 >
YT Flag Oxford 21 Mar 23 9.13pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

I'd be more interested in understanding why Hodgson has taken the role. A candid statement from Hodgson would be welcome. I'm pretty sure he said that the Watford role was his last, understandable given his time in the game. No need to answer Parish's call, he'd left Palace and done his bit. Why come back for 10 games that could tarnish his reputation?
Also I'd like to know for how long negotiations were going on for between him and the club behind Patrick Vieira's back.

Why is any of the above relevant to anything? He's been offered a temporary job and he's decided to take it. End of story.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

southnorwoodhill Flag 21 Mar 23 9.20pm

Originally posted by YT

Why is any of the above relevant to anything? He's been offered a temporary job and he's decided to take it. End of story.

Touchy subject? If that's good enough for you, that's fine. Me, I'm curious about motivation and such like. Human interaction, psychology, that sort of thing. Areas of interest. Hodgson will have a good grasp of them as he attempts to knock these players into shape.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 21 Mar 23 9.24pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill


Also I'd like to know for how long negotiations were going on for between him and the club behind Patrick Vieira's back.

Some of the papers said productive talks took place between Parish and Hodgson over the weekend, after Vieira was sacked.

Whether initial talks took place earlier or not we will probably never know but Parish, like all club owners or chairmen, is damned either way. If he didn't speak to Hodgson before sacking Vieira then he's taken a reckless gamble that Roy would say yes, if he's spoken to Roy first then he's taken a reckless gamble that Patrick wouldn't find out in an industry that cannot keep anything important secret!

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 21 Mar 23 9.31pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I guess it is Roy's second coming.

That's a bit optimistic. At 75 I'd be happy to come once.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

southnorwoodhill Flag 21 Mar 23 9.40pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Some of the papers said productive talks took place between Parish and Hodgson over the weekend, after Vieira was sacked.

Whether initial talks took place earlier or not we will probably never know but Parish, like all club owners or chairmen, is damned either way. If he didn't speak to Hodgson before sacking Vieira then he's taken a reckless gamble that Roy would say yes, if he's spoken to Roy first then he's taken a reckless gamble that Patrick wouldn't find out in an industry that cannot keep anything important secret!

Well call me Mr Incredulous. Parish has decided PV must go, and before anyone can say "Royball" he's on the blower to Roy with an offer he can't refuse. Roy is happy to drop his retirement plans for another 10 game stint in survival football management. Remarkable. I guess stranger things have happened.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (21 Mar 2023 9.45pm)

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 21 Mar 23 10.43pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Touchy subject? If that's good enough for you, that's fine. Me, I'm curious about motivation and such like. Human interaction, psychology, that sort of thing. Areas of interest. Hodgson will have a good grasp of them as he attempts to knock these players into shape.

Same. I wonder if he doing Parish a favour?

Or if he didnt want his career to end on a relegation, so this is redemption.

Maybe we'll see the most fired up Roy of all time

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 21 Mar 23 10.59pm

Well, I suppose after Osian Roberts, it'll be nice for the players to have a coach who's in good enough shape to move nimbly around the training ground even if he is 75. All those donuts VG brings to work...pretty f***ing obvious where they've been ending up, isn't it?

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

PJEagle Flag London 21 Mar 23 11.15pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill ome

I'd be more interested in understanding why Hodgson has taken the role. A candid statement from Hodgson would be welcome. I'm pretty sure he said that the Watford role was his last, understandable given his time in the game. No need to answer Parish's call, he'd left Palace and done his bit. Why come back for 10 games that could tarnish his reputation?
Also I'd like to know for how long negotiations were going on for between him and the club behind Patrick Vieira's back.

I'm sure he'll be interviewed by Linneker on MOTD at some stage, posssibly after the Leicester match!

 

radicalsteve Flag ottawa 21 Mar 23 11.29pm

If you think about it PV gets off being responsible for the end result and walks into the sunset with a package and all the media (and many here) saying how he was wronged, not supported by the board, and how he would have kept us up for sure (because we have a bunch of soft fixtures coming our way).

Then Roy comes in and only has his personal pride to loose, which is somewhat ameliorated by a not too shabby pay cheque for a few weeks work, notwithstanding a handsome bonus if we stay up. I actually don't begrudge him any of that, because he is a decent bloke and actually has a real connection with the club and he will work his bollocks off to get the team performing as best he can.

Then the players "arrive in style" so do they really give a sh*t, other than Wardy, Wilf and Maca, although I think Luca, Guehi Doucouré, and a couple of others really do their best.

Then Parish, preens himself in Soho, fails to do a press conference and sips macchiato with Dougie, recalling how he saved the club from extinction, while the other board members dial in to a zoom call and turn up to a match in a blue moon.

So who the f*ck is accountable? What a weird business .....

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 22 Mar 23 12.48am

What happens if by some miracle we win 5 or 6 games.
Stick or twist!
After all he has better players now than he had 2 years or so ago.
Just playing devils advocate really, not in the good or bad choice camp.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 22 Mar 23 5.35am

Originally posted by cryrst

What happens if by some miracle we win 5 or 6 games.
Stick or twist!

if that happens it leaves the club in a far better position to attract a more modern forward thinking manager

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 22 Mar 23 5.37am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

if that happens it leaves the club in a far better position to attract a more modern forward thinking manager

I think winning those games would mean exactly that we had that though.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 22 Mar 23 6.51am

Originally posted by cryrst

I think winning those games would mean exactly that we had that though.

Although Roy appears to have combatted the stresses and strains of being a modern day football manager and looks in reasonably good shape for his age, I would be concerned how another season of Royball would affect him, the players, and the fans.
The last two seasons with us saw him staring blankly at the patch of grass in front of him, he didn't look particularly lively at Watford either. I'm concerned how Roy is going to make it through these 10 games and remain in one piece.
Perhaps Roy is just the friendly face behind the PR, and Lewington and McCarthy will be the real engine.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 22 Mar 23 7.03am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Looking forward to a bit of 442 instead of no 6s, no 8s "pivots", "double pivots" CDMs and all the other tedious rubbish.

The stuff on social media about Roy not being the future, "embarrassment" etc. How fvcking dense or thick can you get.

Fair enough. Personally I stopped looking forward to any of our games under Roy by halfway through his third season. After 75 minutes of eye-wateringly awful football (using that word in the loosest terms) we'd then spend either the last 15 minutes hanging on for a draw/narrow win or we'd throw the kitchen sink at the opposition having not laid a glove on them for most of the game.

I'm laying my hopes on Roy recognising that our best hopes are not conceding possession rather doing more with the possession we have. Less sideways passing at the back is something I'd be glad to see the back of. I also think we'll stick with 4-3-3, just with three defensive midfielders

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 22 Mar 23 7.41am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Fair enough. Personally I stopped looking forward to any of our games under Roy by halfway through his third season. After 75 minutes of eye-wateringly awful football (using that word in the loosest terms) we'd then spend either the last 15 minutes hanging on for a draw/narrow win or we'd throw the kitchen sink at the opposition having not laid a glove on them for most of the game.

I'm laying my hopes on Roy recognising that our best hopes are not conceding possession rather doing more with the possession we have. Less sideways passing at the back is something I'd be glad to see the back of. I also think we'll stick with 4-3-3, just with three defensive midfielders

I agree re the parking the bus - I think we’ll go down if that’s what he does.

We haven’t got a decent forward who can play up front on his own and the only way I see us getting goals is with Zaha in a front two perhaps with Mateta who at least makes some effort to stretch our opponents (pains me to say it).

We played some decent football when Roy had ball playing cente backs ty previously. All of the players have to start taking responsibility in the final third.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 22 Mar 23 8.50am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Looking forward to a bit of 442 instead of no 6s, no 8s "pivots", "double pivots" CDMs and all the other tedious rubbish.

The stuff on social media about Roy not being the future, "embarrassment" etc. How fvcking dense or thick can you get.

In many ways, I hear you. "Possession-based" football when the possession involves only sending the ball sideways or backward is no more palatable than counter-attacking 4-4-2. And it always struck me that for all PV's tactical modernisation of Palace, we were only ever threatening when the long ball became involved. We'd crab twenty passes together going nowhere, and only when Andersen humped it upfield did we suddenly become dangerous. If you have someone with Andersen's ability to hit an accurate long-ball then you have a weapon. The possession-based game once Conor was gone (or still here but off-the-boil) was toothless and, by the end, not even pleasant to watch.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

rikz Flag Croydon 22 Mar 23 9.14am

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

For those unhappy with the appointment of Hodgson, I'd be interested to know who exactly you think we should have gone for. Keep in mind that the incoming manager has to find out about the players, the league, the club etc, will not have time to radically change the style of play, and that any medium to long term ambition pales into insignificance next to the urgent need to get about a point per game for the next couple of months.

The biggest sport in the world, the richest sport and richest league and this is the best possible option out there ?

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 22 Mar 23 9.22am

The logic in asking Roy to help out is fairly obvious, and I'd think even those very much against it will accept that it is likely only for the next ten games.

The strongest case against his appointment is also self-evident; the team have been quite good at the things Roy brings, we are struggling with the things he is unlikely to improve.

All of which casts the change of manager in an even more intruiging light. When making previous mid-season managerial changes Parish has tended to replace a more open style of play with a more conservative one. That is his comfort blanket, for understandable reasons.

In this case though Vieira has been playing Royball already. Our team shape out of possession has been good, the back four, keeper and defensive midfielder have generally played OK, we just look tedious in possession and toothless up front. Tactically, nothing will change now.

In it's way, that is a far greater indictment on Vieira than if he'd been sacked with us losing open, high scoring games. Parish isn't even looking to change what the players do, he just thinks Roy, who isn't an impact manager or a radically different tactician, will do the same thing Vieira was already doing, just better.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 22 Mar 23 9.23am

Originally posted by rikz

The biggest sport in the world, the richest sport and richest league and this is the best possible option out there ?

Name a better one.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 22 Mar 23 9.34am

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Some of the papers said productive talks took place between Parish and Hodgson over the weekend, after Vieira was sacked.

Whether initial talks took place earlier or not we will probably never know but Parish, like all club owners or chairmen, is damned either way. If he didn't speak to Hodgson before sacking Vieira then he's taken a reckless gamble that Roy would say yes, if he's spoken to Roy first then he's taken a reckless gamble that Patrick wouldn't find out in an industry that cannot keep anything important secret!

If, as widely reported, Vieira hasn't been on speaking terms with and has been avoiding Parish more or less altogether since January, then unless he's very, very stupid (which frankly, he's not), he surely will have known that the end was coming sooner rather than later. It's not credible that a football manager whose team hasn't won in three months doesn't realise his job is under threat. And in any industry (football is hardly unique) successors are lined up when the outbound employee is still in place if the job is an important one and continuity is vital. I imagine Vieira would have been more surprised if Parish hadn't been sounding out possible successors than to learn that he was.

I have been pro-Vieira and anti-Parish throughout, but I don't think Vieira has any grounds for complaint. One has done a piss-poor job of managing a football team; the other a piss-poor job of running a football club. Which in simple terms explains why we're in the state we're in now. If absolutely nothing else, Roy is competent which is more than can be said for either Vieira or Parish. Perhaps we should be thankful for his brief return.

Edited by sydtheeagle (22 Mar 2023 9.35am)

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Page 14 of 20 < 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy Hodgson just announced as CPFC manager