You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Vieira vs Roy V2.0
November 16 2026 2.16am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Vieira vs Roy V2.0


Page 1 of 11 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
thetopgeezer Flag Streatham Hill 17 Apr 23 8.09pm

I'm not sure we'll ever got to the bottom of the "end of a difficult run, Vieira would have won these games anyway" debate. We are fortunate enough to only have to live one life so not having to try living through all the possibilities suits me fine. However I've become a bit sensitive to some chatter led by Viera's fan club (e.g. Garth Crooks) which is starting to grate.

So here are some facts that I have noticed.

1. Vieira was one of the coolest managers in the league
2. Roy is one of the uncoolest
3. A lot of pundits are Vieira era
4. We have had a bit of luck to win all 3 games
5. But we are playing a few yards higher up the pitch with masses more shots
6. We are not indulging in "ticcy tacky look at how impressive our possession stats are" boring nonsense at the back
7. The last 3 teams played are weaker than the previous bunch
8. Eze and Olise are on fire. Admittedly only when they put down their PlayStation reenactments or whatever is in their heads in the first half

But for me the clincher was "patterns". When we lost to City, Gary Neville said he couldn't see any patterns to our play. That's the moment I thought that Vieira might not be that good. A few patterns came to mind. Our pacey wingers crossing in to centre forwards running on. Balls through a high line with our forwards running on to them. Corners to the back post headed back in. Corners to the near post for a flick on (who remembers Andy Thorn).

I don't know enough about football to know if Neville meant this but I know there were no obvious plans apart from what appeared to be defense. Maybe that's what a defensive midfielder gets you.

I can't help but wish Vieira well and thank him for some fun times but thank God Roy came back to put a but of process in place. And to have enough flair to put Ebe back out there.

How cool is that?

 

palaceexile Flag hastings 17 Apr 23 8.41pm

Good post.
But maybe a more interesting question than 'Would we have won these 3 games under Vieira' is 'would we have won these 3 games under the old Roy?'
We seem so much more adventurous than under his previous managership. I know we have had an injection of new players - but Roy also seems to have changed his approach to games.
Long may it continue.

 

Red & Blue Pharaoh Flag South London 18 Apr 23 4.57pm

We also have better players now compared to when he was last with us... that will make a big difference to his approach to games.


Originally posted by palaceexile

Good post.
But maybe a more interesting question than 'Would we have won these 3 games under Vieira' is 'would we have won these 3 games under the old Roy?'
We seem so much more adventurous than under his previous managership. I know we have had an injection of new players - but Roy also seems to have changed his approach to games.
Long may it continue.

 


Meatball Header

silvertop Flag Portishead 18 Apr 23 5.15pm

The thing that maddened me under PV was that we had plenty possession and plenty attack but the final pass was always rubbish. Direct to defender and then back to trying to get the ball back.

We are now putting in more dangerous passes leading to more shots [as opposed to none].

Same players.

You tell me if that is down to playing weaker teams who are not set up as good defensively, or down to better coaching?

 

ripleyeagle Flag Ripley Surrey 18 Apr 23 5.18pm

I know it’s not PC but Garth Crooks comments and Ian Wright not giving Roy any credit for our turn around points to the usual ( not enough black managers) being appointed.I personally like Patrick and thought he was a tad unlucky but we all know that in this day and age it is very much a result based business.Managers have been sacked for less poor runs than what we were on when SP pulled the trigger.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 18 Apr 23 5.29pm

Originally posted by ripleyeagle

I know it’s not PC but Garth Crooks comments and Ian Wright not giving Roy any credit for our turn around points to the usual ( not enough black managers) being appointed.I personally like Patrick and thought he was a tad unlucky but we all know that in this day and age it is very much a result based business.Managers have been sacked for less poor runs than what we were on when SP pulled the trigger.

You are right about his backup boys, the fact is that if a manager is top class he will get a top job, whatever colour he is, just like a player, unfortunately, Vieira, Ince, Campbell etc haven't been very good.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Red & Blue Pharaoh Flag South London 18 Apr 23 6.20pm

I think the argument is that black managers aren't readily given as many opportunities. If there were more opportunities for black managers, there'd be more chance of some succeeding.

And when there are obvious examples like Frank Lampard, who seems to fail upwards, you can probably understand some of the frustration.


Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

You are right about his backup boys, the fact is that if a manager is top class he will get a top job, whatever colour he is, just like a player, unfortunately, Vieira, Ince, Campbell etc haven't been very good.

 


Meatball Header

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 18 Apr 23 10.45pm

Originally posted by palaceexile

Good post.
But maybe a more interesting question than 'Would we have won these 3 games under Vieira' is 'would we have won these 3 games under the old Roy?'
We seem so much more adventurous than under his previous managership. I know we have had an injection of new players - but Roy also seems to have changed his approach to games.
Long may it continue.

The 'old Roy' was rotating whichever of his 35 year old centre backs were fit alongside a central midfielder... He had Ayew, Riedewald and Luka in his top 7 appearance makers in his last season.

Some of it was turgid but he played the way that was sensible with the team he had.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 19 Apr 23 12.51am

The words coming out of players is all I need to know that PV wasn't the manager we needed...

 


This was once a quality forum....

Wilbraham413 Flag 19 Apr 23 3.52am

For whatever reason, mostly lack of investment, Roy's last tenure got very stale by the time he left. PV was a breath of fresh air last season, but again, maybe just because of better investment. It all went off the rails this season, to the point where we were as bad as we were under FdB, maybe worse.

We hadn't won a home match since October. We didn't win any match in what, 10+ tries? No shot on goal in 3 straight games, a new record. Worst running stats in the league by far, no one else close. Named on one website as the worst club to watch in all of Europe, and no argument from any of us fans. How much worse could it get?

All things considered, it seems obvious now that Roy is a significantly better PL manager than PV is. True, we've had some good fortune in the 3 games under Roy, and we had some sh-t luck in some games under PV. That being said, would anyone seriously argue that they want to go back in time and retain PV, and not replace him with Roy? Hiring Roy was a difficult, uncomfortable, and absolutely correct decision.

Edited by Wilbraham413 (19 Apr 2023 3.53am)

 


2017 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Middlesboro
2018 Jan. (Sako) Palace 1 - 0 Burnley
2019 May (Batshuayi, Batshuayi, OG, Van Aanholt, Townsend) Palace 5 - 3 Bournemouth
2020 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Newcastle

VinceHilaire Flag London 19 Apr 23 6.53am

Interesting video on YouTube about how some of the players were not happy under the management of PV and Zaha went to the board to ask for a change.

Here is the link:
[Link]

 

thetopgeezer Flag Streatham Hill 19 Apr 23 8.28am

Thanks for the link. It makes sense. I did some research and of the new "ball" players Roy only had Eze (injured by the end of course). Signed with or after PV:

Andersen
Guhei
Doucoure
Olise

That's a substantially different team to Roy's last one and identical to the one that had zero shots, zero patterns of play and zero wins in a load of games and has just won three on the bounce. Throw in the dressing room nonsense and the verdict is in.

Crooks is an idiot.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 19 Apr 23 9.22am

Originally posted by thetopgeezer

Thanks for the link. It makes sense. I did some research and of the new "ball" players Roy only had Eze (injured by the end of course). Signed with or after PV:

Andersen
Guhei
Doucoure
Olise

That's a substantially different team to Roy's last one and identical to the one that had zero shots, zero patterns of play and zero wins in a load of games and has just won three on the bounce. Throw in the dressing room nonsense and the verdict is in.

Crooks is an idiot.

Indeed.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 19 Apr 23 9.31am

So Crooks and Wright reckon we would have won our last three games with PV because they were poor teams below us in the table.

Yet with the same players under PV we played:

Everton 0=2 Lost
Notts Forest 0-1 Lost
Leicester 0-0 Draw

I rest my case.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 19 Apr 23 10.28am

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

So Crooks and Wright reckon we would have won our last three games with PV because they were poor teams below us in the table.

Yet with the same players under PV we played:

Everton 0=2 Lost
Notts Forest 0-1 Lost
Leicester 0-0 Draw

I rest my case.


even worse - it was 0-3 and the game that led to Derry's infamous rant in the dressing room.

I was at that Leicester game and we were so timid against a team that had lost game after game and was clearly lacking confidence. Our performance helped them to start the mini revival they had prior to the World Cup.

Edited by doombear (19 Apr 2023 10.30am)

 

leejaneagles Flag 19 Apr 23 11.11am

I can't see much argument for Vieira when there are massive differences in players left out and in under both Managers.

Let's start with players that stayed in the starting 11 under Roy:

Olise - One of the best 2 players. Looked aimless previously under Vieira.
Schlupp - Winning second balls and driving at back-lines. Looked like the worst Prem player under Vieira.
Edouard - Turns out can hold a ball up and finish.

Players new in Roy's 11:

Ward - More a tried and trusted. I'd personally pick Clyne but he hasn't done much wrong. You couldn't argue that Vieira playing Clyne would signifcantly improve us.

Eze - Literally our best player. In the last 3 wins, he would've been on the bench under Vieira.

I think Schlupp and particularly Eze are the biggest reasons why you can't just say Roy got an easy run of games. One wouldn't have been in the team before and Schlupp has looked like turd against all the bottom clubs all season until now.

Edited by leejaneagles (19 Apr 2023 11.11am)

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 19 Apr 23 12.19pm

So far everything Roy appears to have done makes sense. Team selection, substitutions and game plan. Plus he is apparently hitting the right drum with players confidence and attitude. 100% wins so far supporting his beat.
PV was at best coming up with some eye brow raising decisions which appeared to be muddling most, players included. His plans had become very cloudy and confusing and regardless of the opposition were clearly not working.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 19 Apr 23 1.51pm

Vieira supporters have made much of the difficult run we had post-New Year as if that's all the problem was.

Since the beginning of our latest spell in the PL we have had no fewer than 19 league victories over the so-called 'Big 6' - an average of virtually 2 such wins a year. We usually manage at least one such win each season.

Indeed, last year, we managed no fewer than 4, beating Arsenal, Spurs, Man U and Man C.

This season, not only have we failed to beat any of the 'Big 6', the only top TEN team we've beaten is Villa and that was whilst they were struggling near the bottom of the table under the clueless Gerrard.

It's not as if these top teams can't be beaten by us lesser mortals - just look at what Bournemouth have done in recent weeks against Liverpool and Spurs and even the dross that is Everton managed a win against Arsenal.

 

thetopgeezer Flag Streatham Hill 20 Apr 23 9.00am

Anyone care to remember when we were 2 1 up at Arsenal and cruising. He took Edouarde off for Tomkins on 82 and effectively invited them on. Oh, then a 95th minute winner from Lacazette.

I really hated that sub as soon as it happened.

Defensive midfielder.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 20 Apr 23 9.20am

Was disappointed with Vieira's sacking but, the more I read about it, the more it seems as though there was stuff going on behind the scenes and a level of unhappiness within the squad.

Also, given the uplift in performance levels and results, you have to say Parish has made a completely correct decision replacing him with Roy. And I say that having slated the decision on Twitter at the time.

If Roy wins every remaining game this season, however, I still don't want him in the role next season. I feel if we're going to progress we need to stumble across a De Zerbi / Frank who can rebuild the squad with the long term in mind.

Also I'm skeptical as to how long the attacking football will last.

Roy in a senior role in the background would be ideal, as long as it doesn't undermine any new manager. Then we'd potentially have him as a safety net if things go tits up.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Page 1 of 11 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Vieira vs Roy V2.0