You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Ukraine Situation - Should We Be Worried?
November 22 2026 5.05am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ukraine Situation - Should We Be Worried?


Page 148 of 280 < 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 >
steeleye20 Flag Croydon 25 May 22 2.20pm

Originally posted by W12

"all the sudden" Russia is winning? This would only surprise or shock you if you believed the Western media and dismissed alternative sources telling you Russia was making steady progress toward inevitable victory since this began.

If you mean inevitable victory is occupying Eastern Ukraine they will probably grind it out without western military intervention.

It doesn't end the conflict though its still war through clenched teeth, the location being further into Ukraine itself.

It looks like Russia's 'Dad's Army' will have to do the job, age limit lifted, the Russian military super-power a bit of a joke.

Just a faint hope something dramatic might happen in Russia itself.


 

W12 26 May 22 11.38am

Originally posted by steeleye20

If you mean inevitable victory is occupying Eastern Ukraine they will probably grind it out without western military intervention.

It doesn't end the conflict though its still war through clenched teeth, the location being further into Ukraine itself.

It looks like Russia's 'Dad's Army' will have to do the job, age limit lifted, the Russian military super-power a bit of a joke.

Just a faint hope something dramatic might happen in Russia itself.


The situation in the East would appear to be militarily impossible for the Ukranians. Despite initial success with stinger missiles against Russian air power the Russians quickly adapted to that and on the ground, the Javelins provided were apparently found to be fairly useless as they were old and their batteries failed .The Ukranians cannot bring much heavy equipment into the battlefield as this largely has to come by train and the Russians have complete air superiority. They are left with not very portable (i.e. not self propelled) howitzers and this is a war that's primarily about artillery.

The Russians are advancing although fairly slowly as the Ukranians are dug in but I expect that will change as they move further east past the Ukrainian defensive positions. The main question for me do they plan to cross the river into eastern Ukraine.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 26 May 22 1.25pm

Originally posted by W12

The situation in the East would appear to be militarily impossible for the Ukranians. Despite initial success with stinger missiles against Russian air power the Russians quickly adapted to that and on the ground, the Javelins provided were apparently found to be fairly useless as they were old and their batteries failed .The Ukranians cannot bring much heavy equipment into the battlefield as this largely has to come by train and the Russians have complete air superiority. They are left with not very portable (i.e. not self propelled) howitzers and this is a war that's primarily about artillery.

The Russians are advancing although fairly slowly as the Ukranians are dug in but I expect that will change as they move further east past the Ukrainian defensive positions. The main question for me do they plan to cross the river into eastern Ukraine.

Apparently you only appear to be listening to people in basements and not thinking for yourself. Strange that your analysis appears more accurate than the supposedly accepted sources have been for months.

The sources who told us that the Ukrainians were 'evacuated' out of Azov instead of surrendered....A media that essentially just repeats whatever the Ukrainians say.

It's not good but don't think the situation is quite dire for the Ukrainians (militarily I mean...the country is completely fecked economically now...but hey they have a s***e load of weapons). Let's remember that the Ukraine is a massive country and the contested areas are the borderland regions. The further in the Russians go the more the extended line they have to cover and the more troops and equipment is required.

In their 'wisdom' the west have thrown about 60 billion at defending this none Nato country and that equates to a long war. It's the very opposite thing you would do if you were supporting a negotiated settlement.

The speed of the Russian progress will depend upon over coming heavily entrenched positions that have had since 2014 to prepare but after months those breaches are being made....and once in retreat further in the entrenchments are less effective.

However, any large city brings a full stop to that advance....unless you are going to knock it down.

The problem with making this war an existential war without any realistic 'out' for Russia except victory or defeat is that you encourage the 'all or nothing' mindset and that means far more people will die and negotiation becomes harder.

Just about everything in the war has been the opposite of reason.


Edited by Stirlingsays (26 May 2022 1.38pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 27 May 22 12.53am

According to Lavrov both Saudi Arabia and Argentina want to join the BRICS format.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Matov Flag 27 May 22 7.28am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays


The sources who told us that the Ukrainians were 'evacuated' out of Azov instead of surrendered....A media that essentially just repeats whatever the Ukrainians say.

Edited by Stirlingsays (26 May 2022 1.38pm)


If there is a single smidgen of the tiniest silver linings in the tragedy that is the terrible, terrible war, it is the fact that we no longer have to even masquerade around the illusion that our mainstream media is unbiased.

From the Snake Island fiasco at the beginning to the 'Ghost' of Kiev to this 'evacuation', then the notion that our media even attempts to be balanced has just gone.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Stirlingsays Flag 27 May 22 12.57pm

Some time back I posted that a vocal critic of the Ukrainian government called Gonzalo Lira, who had been in hiding in Kharkiv had been detained by the Ukrainian security services and killed.

It has since emerged that while he had been detained by those security services that he hadn't been killed and has since re-emerged and is, according to him, on apparent investigation.

I apologise for that misinformation.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

W12 27 May 22 1.20pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Some time back I posted that a vocal critic of the Ukrainian government called Gonzalo Lira, who had been in hiding in Kharkiv had been detained by the Ukrainian security services and killed.

It has since emerged that while he had been detained by those security services that he hadn't been killed and has since re-emerged and is, according to him, on apparent investigation.

I apologise for that misinformation.

To be fair he was arrested and missing for several days. Most people assumed the worse.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 27 May 22 1.30pm

Originally posted by W12

To be fair he was arrested and missing for several days. Most people assumed the worse.

Agreed and thanks.

I had put forward Scott Ritter's analysis and that was later proven incorrect so I want to correct the record.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

W12 27 May 22 4.43pm

It seems reality is coming out. The Ukrainian people have been led down the garden path by Zelenski and NATO:

[Link]

 

Stirlingsays Flag 27 May 22 5.07pm

Originally posted by W12

It seems reality is coming out. The Ukrainian people have been led down the garden path by Zelenski and NATO:

[Link]

I think that while the 'Washington Post' is left wing I have recently been impressed by its objectivity in reporting. I found its reporting of the Bucha killings to be convincing and yes, I do think Russian troops killed civilians who they thought were in defending militias...and I regard that as war crimes regardless of which side does it.....But here I'm finally seeing an admission of realities being posted from the Ukrainian battlefield available to anyone who hasn't been only following talking heads on mainstream news....seemingly having to follow select narratives rather than actually investigating themselves.

More objective journalists are out there, it's just that they are far less common now.

Edited by Stirlingsays (27 May 2022 5.10pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

BlueJay Flag UK 27 May 22 5.12pm

Originally posted by W12

It seems reality is coming out. The Ukrainian people have been led down the garden path by Zelenski and NATO:

[Link]

Ukranians held their own for a good while in many areas. Even BBC and co well acknowledge that Russia are making a lot of gains now. It's not a secret, and the vast majority of people either on here, or media outlets haven't suggested that Ukraine will perpetually repel Russian forces. It was always more a matter of limiting progress. Let's not forget that Putin appeared to think he could make his way to the Capital and win this within days. Maybe you'd have prefered that? Arming people to give them the ability to defend themsleves and their country isn't leading them down the garden path. It is what we would all hope for in the same situation..


Edited by BlueJay (27 May 2022 5.30pm)

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 27 May 22 5.20pm

Originally posted by W12

It seems reality is coming out. The Ukrainian people have been led down the garden path by Zelenski and NATO:

[Link]

Really fighting to defend your country is being led down the garden path?

 


One more point

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 27 May 22 5.24pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Really fighting to defend your country is being led down the garden path?

Exactly. W12 is full of it.

 

Matov Flag 27 May 22 5.39pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Really fighting to defend your country is being led down the garden path?


If your country has been used by others to provoke the invasion in the first place, then yes, very much.

Given my own political viewpoint, then to see Europeans fighting Europeans in this manner is heartbreaking in the extreme. But the reality is that Ukraine has been used by other powers to prod and provoke Russia now for decades and as soon as it decided to strike, those self-same powers only helped out by way of helping delaying the inevitable.

Now I am a conspiracy loon so see this war in a wider context of a very deliberate and determined effort to destabilise the West, going on since the 'liberation' of Libya, and now the coming grain shortage is going to induce mayhem and violence that the world cannot even begin to contemplate so it all fits a pattern but these brave souls in Ukraine have been conned.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 27 May 22 5.46pm

Originally posted by Matov

If your country has been used by others to provoke the invasion in the first place, then yes, very much.

Given my own political viewpoint, then to see Europeans fighting Europeans in this manner is heartbreaking in the extreme. But the reality is that Ukraine has been used by other powers to prod and provoke Russia now for decades and as soon as it decided to strike, those self-same powers only helped out by way of helping delaying the inevitable.

Now I am a conspiracy loon so see this war in a wider context of a very deliberate and determined effort to destabilise the West, going on since the 'liberation' of Libya, and now the coming grain shortage is going to induce mayhem and violence that the world cannot even begin to contemplate so it all fits a pattern but these brave souls in Ukraine have been conned.

All nonsense. The Russians are the bad guys here. They have invaded another country without provocation while spewing out nonsense 'justifications' in a manner very similar to Hitler when he started invading his neighbours. All the apologists for the fascist Putin make me sick - why don't you just come out and say that you want Putin to win.

Edited by georgenorman (27 May 2022 5.48pm)

 

Matov Flag 27 May 22 8.21pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

All the apologists for the fascist Putin make me sick - why don't you just come out and say that you want Putin to win.

Edited by georgenorman (27 May 2022 5.48pm)


Yes, I want him to 'win'. I believe Russia has been prodded and poked by the West for decades, at the behest of vested interests, none of whom care a single jot for me and my family. I believe Putin has been the most far-seeing leader of a modern country for the last 30 years and if you actually listened to what he had to say, suspect you might end up agreeing.

But this war has broken my heart. The destruction, the sight of Europeans killings each other, people from Christian cultures doing this to each other...horrible on every level.

We are lied to in the West. About so so many things and this war has been one of them. Does that mean Putin is some kind of angel? Of course not. But he acts as he does because he believes it is in the best interests of the Russian people. Unlike our leaders. Who act in the best interests of whatever corporate or foreign paymasters pulls their strings.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

BlueJay Flag UK 27 May 22 9.14pm

Originally posted by Matov


Yes, I want him to 'win'. I believe Russia has been prodded and poked by the West for decades, at the behest of vested interests, none of whom care a single jot for me and my family. I believe Putin has been the most far-seeing leader of a modern country for the last 30 years and if you actually listened to what he had to say, suspect you might end up agreeing.

But this war has broken my heart. The destruction, the sight of Europeans killings each other, people from Christian cultures doing this to each other...horrible on every level.

We are lied to in the West. About so so many things and this war has been one of them. Does that mean Putin is some kind of angel? Of course not. But he acts as he does because he believes it is in the best interests of the Russian people. Unlike our leaders. Who act in the best interests of whatever corporate or foreign paymasters pulls their strings.

In the West you're able to make statements like this. Try being in Putin's Russia and having a daily mantra against him and his leadership and see where that gets you...

That you've reached a point where you want Putin to 'win' is unfortunate. Anyone in business or politics there who doesn't tow the line winds up dead or poisoned, and speaking out against the war - or acknowledging it even is a war - has led to countless arrests. Most likely you just like his politics and you don't much care what it takes or who is snuffed out to further propogate it. Navalny is a Russian civizen with a view on his nation too (just as you have a view on yours). A brave one at that. Has and is Putin acting in his best interests? Is poisoning and imprisoning someone for their opinion reasonable if it furthers politics you agree with? Careful what you wish you.


Edited by BlueJay (27 May 2022 9.31pm)

 

Matov Flag 27 May 22 9.59pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

Is poisoning and imprisoning someone for their opinion reasonable if it furthers politics you agree with? Careful what you wish you.


Edited by BlueJay (27 May 2022 9.31pm)


19 years ago the US and the UK invaded Iraq based on lies. They killed 100,000's of people. NATO bombed Serbia, including full-on war crimes by hitting TV stations as opposed to transmitters. The West lied about Syria gassing its own people and then tried to bomb them, all whilst supporting Islamic extremists trying to overthrow the regime at the same time that Islamic extremists were killing British soldiers on British streets and driving cars into people on bridges.

The West has locked up people for decades without trial in Guantanamo bay. We send people to jail all the time in the UK for expressing opinions that the Establishment does not like. We spent the best part of 5 years having British politicians doing their very best to have the votes of over 17 millions Brits rendered useless.

You want to proclaim that Putin is the new anti-Christ, then fill your boots but you need to take a bloody good look at what the supposed 'Civilised' West is doing in the name of freedom. The self-same West that is still buying Russian gas and now even paying for it in Russian currency.


 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

BlueJay Flag UK 27 May 22 10.27pm

Originally posted by Matov


19 years ago the US and the UK invaded Iraq based on lies. They killed 100,000's of people. NATO bombed Serbia, including full-on war crimes by hitting TV stations as opposed to transmitters. The West lied about Syria gassing its own people and then tried to bomb them, all whilst supporting Islamic extremists trying to overthrow the regime at the same time that Islamic extremists were killing British soldiers on British streets and driving cars into people on bridges.

The West has locked up people for decades without trial in Guantanamo bay. We send people to jail all the time in the UK for expressing opinions that the Establishment does not like. We spent the best part of 5 years having British politicians doing their very best to have the votes of over 17 millions Brits rendered useless.

You want to proclaim that Putin is the new anti-Christ, then fill your boots but you need to take a bloody good look at what the supposed 'Civilised' West is doing in the name of freedom. The self-same West that is still buying Russian gas and now even paying for it in Russian currency.


I didn't say Putin is the anti christ. I offered an accurate portrayal of his conduct and leadership, to contrast your love-in - you seem not to care who he orders dead or poisoned on account that you like his leadership style and politics. He silences people you want silencing.

I certainly strongly disagreed with the Iraq war (from day one) and Guantanamo. You were commenting on Putin's treatment of Russian citizens. I stated how he actually treats Russian citizens, in Russia, who oppose him. His treatment of Navalny for instance, which is horrific. This nation doesn't have to be perfect to point out that Russia is clearly steps beyond it in the wrong direction.

As for Brexit, I voted for it... but do seem to recall that you proudly cut off many of your friends who were against the result or didn't want to accept it. Again fine then, so if democracy truly matters you to, then it would be nice if you started acting like it rather than solely demonising your own nation to excuse another when it's the focus. I've been very critical of erosion of civil liberties here. That doesn't mean I can't and shouldn't highlight a country with a markedly worse, ongoing record of treating its citizens and neighbours.


Edited by BlueJay (27 May 2022 11.14pm)

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 27 May 22 10.28pm

Originally posted by Matov


Yes, I want him to 'win'. I believe Russia has been prodded and poked by the West for decades, at the behest of vested interests, none of whom care a single jot for me and my family. I believe Putin has been the most far-seeing leader of a modern country for the last 30 years and if you actually listened to what he had to say, suspect you might end up agreeing.

But this war has broken my heart. The destruction, the sight of Europeans killings each other, people from Christian cultures doing this to each other...horrible on every level.

We are lied to in the West. About so so many things and this war has been one of them. Does that mean Putin is some kind of angel? Of course not. But he acts as he does because he believes it is in the best interests of the Russian people. Unlike our leaders. Who act in the best interests of whatever corporate or foreign paymasters pulls their strings.

Ironically Russia pulling the strings!

 

Page 148 of 280 < 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Ukraine Situation - Should We Be Worried?