You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Another black man shot by police in USA
November 22 2026 12.23am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Another black man shot by police in USA


Page 15 of 36 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 21 Jul 16 11.25am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Headline in today's Mirror shouts "Horrifying picture shows moment unarmed black carer was shot by police as he tried to calm autistic patient"

Headline in News Shopper shouts "Residents' shock after teenage girl gang-raped in Church House Gardens, Bromley"

In one newspaper it is deemed important that the person shot by police was black whilst in the other the colour of the people who gang raped a teenage girl isn't deemed important at all

Quite, but that's the media for you. It has no problem with highlighting certain elements of a story that aren't relevant such as black, muslim etc to help 'push its copy'.

Either you list all the details, or some. By the use of race, religion etc serves to sell the story to 'the market bias'. If it was White Police officer Shoots Black Man' then that's neutral, but Police officer shoots black man, immediately pegs the story to certain prejudicial biases in public opinion.

Its why you often hear of Muslim child sex offender, and not white or Christian, because in the object here is not to report the facts, but to feed into bias and popularism, to sell copy.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 21 Jul 16 11.32am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I may have jumped the gun slightly in my judgement, but you're never going to get a fair ruling from any inquest of this sort, so waiting for an official verdict is pretty pointless.

I struggle to understand why a 32 year old with no criminal history, who's been pulled over for a broken brake light, would inform the officer he's armed and then proceed to draw for his weapon against police orders, and his girlfriend would then live stream the fall-out, having the awareness to make up a story as she does, while the policeman stands there clearly rattled as s*** at what he's done - that's not a logical sequence of events as far as I'm concerned.

Could you come up with a story about being asked to produce your license as your partner is dying next to you with your young child in the back? Because I certainly couldn't.

Quite, I'm also curious as to how the US gets to a situation where so many routine police activities such as a traffic stop etc result in fatal shootings.

I'd imagine, he informed the police officer that he had a carry permit and a licenced gun, in order to not get shot if the copper saw the gun, and the police officer acted as if a gun was in play, rather than possession.

Given that gun transport, carry permits etc are legal, its curious that the officer clearly exhibited no reasonable experience or training of having to deal with someone in a routine situation where someone has a legally owned fully licenced firearm.

Especially given the prevalence of firearms in the states.

I know there have been some incidents where police officers have been shot during such events. But they aren't common place, and would be better resolved with process and procedural changes, to how officers deal with a routine car stop, rather than being in a position where you can shoot someone like this.

I'm also very sceptical of the police on the basis that people seem to be able to go to restaurants with assault rifles, and airports in some states, without being shot.

I suspect that race plays a part, in that police officers may well be institutionalised towards seeing black males as gangbangers and criminals first, and citizens second.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 21 Jul 16 11.41am

I also believe that Police officers should be held to higher standards than ordinary citizens and criminals, when it comes to issues relating to the law and law enforcement. Same as with any organisation, whether its the military or professional body - the expectation is of competence, training and professionalism to situations the rest of us are not.

And I think that's reasonable expectation in any professional, and I also believe they should be at least just as accountable as any one else, not less, because of the job they do, and the training they receive.

I suspect that a lot of police forces in the US are lowly paid, understaffed, have a poor candidate pool to select from, and have a high turn over of quality staff into other more lucrative and rewarding professions. I also suspect that training standards for acceptance are very low in some areas and that officers who may well have been rejected in other more discerning districts and forces, will be accepted by more desperate forces, resulting in people who really shouldn't be in uniform, carrying a lethal fire arm, with authority, being in the field with poor oversight.

I also suspect that officers are exposed far to quickly to too much responsibility, without sufficient experience, due to budgetary reasons - resulting in officers being 'unsupervised' and in positions they are not experienced enough to cope with.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 21 Jul 16 11.43am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Quite, I'm also curious as to how the US gets to a situation where so many routine police activities such as a traffic stop etc result in fatal shootings.

I'd imagine, he informed the police officer that he had a carry permit and a licenced gun, in order to not get shot if the copper saw the gun, and the police officer acted as if a gun was in play, rather than possession.

Given that gun transport, carry permits etc are legal, its curious that the officer clearly exhibited no reasonable experience or training of having to deal with someone in a routine situation where someone has a legally owned fully licenced firearm.

Especially given the prevalence of firearms in the states.

I know there have been some incidents where police officers have been shot during such events. But they aren't common place, and would be better resolved with process and procedural changes, to how officers deal with a routine car stop, rather than being in a position where you can shoot someone like this.

I'm also very sceptical of the police on the basis that people seem to be able to go to restaurants with assault rifles, and airports in some states, without being shot.

I suspect that race plays a part, in that police officers may well be institutionalised towards seeing black males as gangbangers and criminals first, and citizens second

Agreed - I don't think this cop was a conscious racist, I just think he's been ill-trained to do the job, and as you say, has had all sorts of preconceptions about black males imposed on him, and this combination is what meant he ended up killing the guy.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 21 Jul 16 12.13pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Quite, but that's the media for you. It has no problem with highlighting certain elements of a story that aren't relevant such as black, muslim etc to help 'push its copy'.

Either you list all the details, or some. By the use of race, religion etc serves to sell the story to 'the market bias'. If it was White Police officer Shoots Black Man' then that's neutral, but Police officer shoots black man, immediately pegs the story to certain prejudicial biases in public opinion.

Its why you often hear of Muslim child sex offender, and not white or Christian, because in the object here is not to report the facts, but to feed into bias and popularism, to sell copy.

Erm... How many countless stories of kiddy fiddling within the catholic church has there been again?

 


Optimistic as ever

7mins Flag In the bush 21 Jul 16 12.43pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I may have jumped the gun slightly in my judgement, but you're never going to get a fair ruling from any inquest of this sort, so waiting for an official verdict is pretty pointless.

I struggle to understand why a 32 year old with no criminal history, who's been pulled over for a broken brake light, would inform the officer he's armed and then proceed to draw for his weapon against police orders, and his girlfriend would then live stream the fall-out, having the awareness to make up a story as she does, while the policeman stands there clearly rattled as s*** at what he's done - that's not a logical sequence of events as far as I'm concerned.

Could you come up with a story about being asked to produce your license as your partner is dying next to you with your young child in the back? Because I certainly couldn't.

If my partner was dying I wouldn't dream of picking up a phone, starting a Facebook app and then live streaming.
I am not saying who is telling the truth, anyone that forms a opinion from that clip, clearly has a agenda.
What we do know.. The dude had a legally owned firearm.
The lady says he informed the officer of the gun, and then went to get his license.
The police officer says once informed that the guy had a gun, he repeatedly tells the guy don't move.
You can see how this tragedy can unfold given the evidence above.
This doesn't make it murder or an execution.
Read this thread from the beginning... Some of the assumptions people have made is dangerous, it shows how we're all influenced by media. My personal opinion is... Look at facts, try to ignore biased opinions and put yourself in the position of the people in the situation you're judging.
Also... I'm very big on personal responsibility... If a copper tells you to not to move... Don't move... America isn't the country to be belligerent. If you inform a copper you have a gun at a traffic stop, he is gonna get you out of the car... Make sure you can't reach for the gun, then get your license. Don't tell him you have a gun, then make a movement to get your license (which is next to your gun) while he shouts "don't move"
If you do the above, you don't deserve to die, but in a country flooded with guns, and high crime it increases the chance of a misunderstanding happening.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 21 Jul 16 12.52pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I also believe that Police officers should be held to higher standards than ordinary citizens and criminals, when it comes to issues relating to the law and law enforcement. Same as with any organisation, whether its the military or professional body - the expectation is of competence, training and professionalism to situations the rest of us are not.

And I think that's reasonable expectation in any professional, and I also believe they should be at least just as accountable as any one else, not less, because of the job they do, and the training they receive.

I suspect that a lot of police forces in the US are lowly paid, understaffed, have a poor candidate pool to select from, and have a high turn over of quality staff into other more lucrative and rewarding professions. I also suspect that training standards for acceptance are very low in some areas and that officers who may well have been rejected in other more discerning districts and forces, will be accepted by more desperate forces, resulting in people who really shouldn't be in uniform, carrying a lethal fire arm, with authority, being in the field with poor oversight.

I also suspect that officers are exposed far to quickly to too much responsibility, without sufficient experience, due to budgetary reasons - resulting in officers being 'unsupervised' and in positions they are not experienced enough to cope with.

Jamie.
You have described the incidents as "murder" and "execution" do you stand by it?
Even the cousin of one of the victims has said he was trying to get rid of the gun.
Genuine question, how do you come to that conclusion with so little evidence? You have already stated that you have no idea how the police saw the gun, and have said they were probably happy to have found it, as it justifies their approach. What makes you qualified to make this judgement? Do you think you're influenced by media/separate incidents??

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 21 Jul 16 12.54pm

Originally posted by 7mins

If my partner was dying I wouldn't dream of picking up a phone, starting a Facebook app and then live streaming.

Sign of the times I'm afraid

 

7mins Flag In the bush 21 Jul 16 12.54pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I refer you to the post above.

In any other 'free' country, that's murder.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 21 Jul 16 12.54pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I don't think there is any doubt that if a suspect is armed and dangerous, shooting is acceptable. However, if your restrained by two big police officers, and incapable of drawing a weapon, then you're clearly not dangerous, as two burly guys seem to have felt safe enough to physically tackle you to the ground and pin you.

I'd imagine that they were happy to find the gun after shooting him and the report covers that as a significant factor in the actions. It doesn't explain why two police officers restrained him first, before another shot him.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 21 Jul 16 12.55pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Which would explain shooting him, prior to physically restraining to the point he couldn't pose a threat.

Context is important. Shooting restrained prisoners is a crime, even in a warzone. When the representative of state authority of the use of force undertakes that role, its vital for the safety of citizens, that force is proportional to the situation not to their personal prejudices or fears.

I can see shooting being justified prior to physically engaging the suspect and restraining him. Shooting him once restrained, is an execution (not to mention the danger it could pose to the officers restaining him).

Its also relevant that in such a situation, the use of pepper spray, batton or taser would have been justified. Lethal force, certainly not.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 21 Jul 16 1.08pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Jamie.
You have described the incidents as "murder" and "execution" do you stand by it?
Even the cousin of one of the victims has said he was trying to get rid of the gun.
Genuine question, how do you come to that conclusion with so little evidence? You have already stated that you have no idea how the police saw the gun, and have said they were probably happy to have found it, as it justifies their approach. What makes you qualified to make this judgement? Do you think you're influenced by media/separate incidents??

No I think that was more the emotional feeling arising from reading the accounts and watching the videos.

Of course I'm influenced by media and incidents, everyone is. Over time, from then, through discussion my thoughts and feelings have changed. I've considered the situation, and the arguments, which have been varied, and its resulted in a change, as well as reading around the story (about police pay, recruitment, training etc).

I think it could be murder, and an execution style one - But that's an opinion, it would need to be determined before a impartial jury of peers (Murder).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 21 Jul 16 1.11pm

Originally posted by Stuk

Erm... How many countless stories of kiddy fiddling within the catholic church has there been again?

It was an example, its of course notable how much emphasis is on Catholic Priests, rather than protestant priests in news stories (given that the UK and US are predominately Protestant Christian countries etc).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 21 Jul 16 1.21pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

It was an example, its of course notable how much emphasis is on Catholic Priests, rather than protestant priests in news stories (given that the UK and US are predominately Protestant Christian countries etc).

You are intolerable with your insistence that there must be bias in everything.

Your point was it's always about emphasising the Muslim aspect, now it's about always about Catholics if it's not about Muslims.

I can't stand any of the religions, I just picked a highly proven example to point out how daft your assertion was.

 


Optimistic as ever

7mins Flag In the bush 21 Jul 16 1.22pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

No I think that was more the emotional feeling arising from reading the accounts and watching the videos.

Of course I'm influenced by media and incidents, everyone is. Over time, from then, through discussion my thoughts and feelings have changed. I've considered the situation, and the arguments, which have been varied, and its resulted in a change, as well as reading around the story (about police pay, recruitment, training etc).

I think it could be murder, and an execution style one - But that's an opinion, it would need to be determined before a impartial jury of peers (Murder).

Fair play.... People changing their opinions is a rare thing on this site...and life in general.

My point has always been...this could be unjustified or justified... I can see how police tackling a criminal see him reach for a gun and assume the worst... It becomes (in their mind) a matter of life and death.
My worry is this trial by media and lies are dangerous, which has led to 8 coppers dead ... One who had a four month old baby, that will never know his dad.

The Michael Brown killing was totally justified in my opinion. Black witnesses backed the cops story, forensics backed the cops story, yet because the lie of "hands up, don't shoot" was repeated so often, people thought it must be true... You had NBA stars wearing t-shirts with that slogan, you had Beyonce saying it during a concert... And it was a massive lie... And all of this was before the trial... The media are f***ing insane.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 21 Jul 16 1.24pm

Originally posted by 7mins

If my partner was dying I wouldn't dream of picking up a phone, starting a Facebook app and then live streaming.

What would you do if someone was shot right in front of you, by a police officer? I'm going to guess, like me, you don't know.

Originally posted by 7mins

I am not saying who is telling the truth, anyone that forms a opinion from that clip, clearly has a agenda.
What we do know.. The dude had a legally owned firearm.
The lady says he informed the officer of the gun, and then went to get his license.
The police officer says once informed that the guy had a gun, he repeatedly tells the guy don't move.

So we can assume that part of her story is correct, as he must have informed the police officer he had a gun.

I quite agree, that the facts and evidence must be established. Shamefully that isn't how these things generally play out - Which is why independent enquiries are needed.

Originally posted by 7mins
If a copper tells you to not to move... Don't move... America isn't the country to be belligerent. If you inform a copper you have a gun at a traffic stop, he is gonna get you out of the car...
If you do the above, you don't deserve to die, but in a country flooded with guns, and high crime it increases the chance of a misunderstanding happening.

Of course if you do have a gun, and don't tell the police, they could shoot you... If you tell them you have a legal gun and a licence, they could shoot you.

Which to me, suggests a degree of acceptance of incompetency, professionalism, information and poor training. Interestingly, the NRA can accept some responsibility here for preventing the ATF national database of legal guns being established, which of course would allow police officers to determine from cross reference if a person was in potentially in possession of a legal fire arm and or licence.

But, and here is a big point of separation, the police must surely be trained to deal with people who have concealed carry permits, in states where such things are legal, without shooting them. Having seen some '2nd Amendment' protests, there is a definite tolerance of people with guns in public, that isn't exampled here.

I think these cases, bring up a number of issues in the US, that have largely gone unchecked and are tied into stupid popularism. Gun Control, Racism, Police Oversight, Public Service funding, Taxation, Social Divisions and the massive power of the Gun Lobby.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 21 Jul 16 1.40pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Fair play.... People changing their opinions is a rare thing on this site...and life in general.

My point has always been...this could be unjustified or justified... I can see how police tackling a criminal see him reach for a gun and assume the worst... It becomes (in their mind) a matter of life and death.
My worry is this trial by media and lies are dangerous, which has led to 8 coppers dead ... One who had a four month old baby, that will never know his dad.

The Michael Brown killing was totally justified in my opinion. Black witnesses backed the cops story, forensics backed the cops story, yet because the lie of "hands up, don't shoot" was repeated so often, people thought it must be true... You had NBA stars wearing t-shirts with that slogan, you had Beyonce saying it during a concert... And it was a massive lie... And all of this was before the trial... The media are f***ing insane.

I don't, the use of a gun on a suspect, who does not have nor is it reasonable to believe, has a lethal weapon, is overkill, as is firing 13 shots of which 8 hit, completely irresponsible.

I don't think its necessarily murder or manslaughter, either. Our police here regularly deal with even potentially violent suspects, without resorting to immediately shooting them (in fact police rarely shoot anyone in the UK). Even people with knives and less lethal weapons, are dealt with, without putting 8 rounds in them, and five shots wide into public space.

Because we have a trained and professional police force, equipped to do the job, with sufficient training and confidence to deal with aggressive suspects, without shooting them.

And there in lies the crux I feel, not that Brown was a justified shooting under US law, but that it was unnecessary and unlikely to have occurred anywhere in the west except the US.

I get that the officer in pursuit, found himself facing a larger, possibly more capable suspect, and its scary (I'd probably shoot, but then I am not a police officer - I should be confident, sufficiently trained and aware of support to deal with the situation without emptying my gun).

And this is the problem, the US approach seems to be where ever possible to make the idea of self defence and killing people easier and more acceptable, something almost to be celebrated, rather than something of a last resort.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

7mins Flag In the bush 21 Jul 16 2.06pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I don't, the use of a gun on a suspect, who does not have nor is it reasonable to believe, has a lethal weapon, is overkill, as is firing 13 shots of which 8 hit, completely irresponsible.

I don't think its necessarily murder or manslaughter, either. Our police here regularly deal with even potentially violent suspects, without resorting to immediately shooting them (in fact police rarely shoot anyone in the UK). Even people with knives and less lethal weapons, are dealt with, without putting 8 rounds in them, and five shots wide into public space.

Because we have a trained and professional police force, equipped to do the job, with sufficient training and confidence to deal with aggressive suspects, without shooting them.

And there in lies the crux I feel, not that Brown was a justified shooting under US law, but that it was unnecessary and unlikely to have occurred anywhere in the west except the US.

I get that the officer in pursuit, found himself facing a larger, possibly more capable suspect, and its scary (I'd probably shoot, but then I am not a police officer - I should be confident, sufficiently trained and aware of support to deal with the situation without emptying my gun).

And this is the problem, the US approach seems to be where ever possible to make the idea of self defence and killing people easier and more acceptable, something almost to be celebrated, rather than something of a last resort.

Michael Brown tried to get the officers gun. The first shot was discharged while MB was holding the gun, the 2nd shot hit the car door. The police officer didn't unload a clip in to him. He shot at a man attacking him. MB charged him after attacking him.. That copper knew if MB got his gun, he was probably a dead man. Witnesses say the officer stopped firing as soon as MB dropped to the floor.

 

nairb75 Flag Baltimore 21 Jul 16 3.19pm

guy shot today helping his job helping an autistic patient. hands were up.

[Link]

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 21 Jul 16 3.32pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

So anyone who poses with guns on facebook is fair game for police to kill? Great policy.

On the plus side, it gives us the option to rid the world of Donald Trump Jr.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Page 15 of 36 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Another black man shot by police in USA