You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Window Summing Up
November 16 2026 7.58am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Transfer Window Summing Up


Page 15 of 18 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 >
Palace in the Blood Flag 01 Feb 18 8.22pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Not a Parish basher but if the report in The Independent is true and we actually lowered our bid to Getafe yesterday then that’s poor and indefensible.

We’ve seen that Hennessey struggles to retain form and has twice pulled out of games with knocks this season. Jules is coming up thirty nine which makes it all the tougher to step in after not playing and Roy has said several times we need a third keeper.

Not really prior to us having a precontract agreement he was there player and they could ask whatever figure they wanted. After that was signed he only had value to us as we could be only buyer and we were buying out a dead contract ie early release. So at start of January that was 3.5-4 million Yesterday probably nearer 1. Today zero

Edited by Palace in the Blood (01 Feb 2018 8.23pm)

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 01 Feb 18 8.39pm

Originally posted by TheArmaniCode

You want the big boys, you gotta pay big money. We're more unprepared every season and we're running out of get out of jail free cards. Mark my words, we carry on like this, we will get relegated sooner or later.

We're Crystal Palace. We make up the numbers in this division along with 12 others. We're gonna get relegated in the foreseeable future no matter what.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 01 Feb 18 9.04pm

We badly needed a GK, we didn’t get one. This will come back to bite us in the arse for sure.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 01 Feb 18 9.29pm

Originally posted by Palace in the Blood

Not really prior to us having a precontract agreement he was there player and they could ask whatever figure they wanted. After that was signed he only had value to us as we could be only buyer and we were buying out a dead contract ie early release. So at start of January that was 3.5-4 million Yesterday probably nearer 1. Today zero

Edited by Palace in the Blood (01 Feb 2018 8.23pm)

Made us look Mickey Mouse and didn't get us the GK we need now. Then we're scrambling around trying to sign one from Brondby.

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 01 Feb 18 10.15pm

I think SP did the best he could, it was mostly down to the other clubs not playing ball. SP did get in sakho and said at the time we are pushing the boat out. We got 3 players in and 2 goalkeepers on the way in the summer so onwards and upwards.

 

traevor Flag 01 Feb 18 11.10pm

I think this transfer window could have been worse and it's never easy to get the right players in. But I can understand some of the frustrations aimed at Parish's transfer strategy and that it can certanly be improved upon. I recall him saying that clubs will realize they are not going to get better offers nearer to the end of the window and that raises the chance of getting players at a good value but it could work in reverse as this transfer windows shows us with clubs jacking up prices at the dead because they know we are desperate to sign players. And as I remember, we didn't really get Benteke or Sakho for significantly cheaper from their initial value.

Also, found a couple of interesting reads that I thought may shed some lights on our other transfer alternatives.
[Link]
[Link]

All in all, I believe we should put the window behind us and get behind the team and new signings. Hopefully they will turn out to be real gems and at least do their bit to help us stay up. We could then look forward to a better Summer window.

Edited by traevor (01 Feb 2018 11.11pm)

Edited by traevor (01 Feb 2018 11.12pm)

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 02 Feb 18 12.25am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Swimming with the Sharks ' by Midlands Eagle

Having just gone through another mad January I thought it apt for a moment of balanced reflection ....
FOR
Man City are able to fish in their own private pond (so to speak) targeting a player months in advance and knowingly without virtually any fear of the deal being hijacked due to their wealth and the attraction of the manager and coming into a hugely successful team.
Coming down the water ways the rest of the top 4 have the next rich pickings some with competition but most of the time getting a free route.
Then you come to the likes of us going after many players for one position on the basis that they may have competition from numerous clubs and with it a bidding war and in January the risk of paying above the odds. The days of the likes of CP earmarking a player and conducting exclusive negotiations are IMO gone. It is now very much swimming with the Sharks and by that I mean AGENTS. It is not in their interests not so much their clients to have this situation as they want the best price possible as their % based commission rockets.
So we become one of a number going after the same players.
A set budget that was intended to cover say 4 players suddenly gets whittled to 2 as also the wages increase as well. The latter probably a bigger consideration.
How much our budget was I don't know but I feel that this maybe one of the reasons why we went into the sweet shop wanting a kilo of wine gums, only to end up with a couple of aniseed balls!
So I appreciate that the board and recruitment staff would have hard huge challenges.
AGAINST
As I have said previously dealing with us must be akin to pulling teeth and must put as at an initial disadvantage. I agree that we have to be watchful of our financial position but not at the expense of losing key targets. What happened to Guita the GK, this went on for the whole of January and in the end we allegedly have another in for a medical with it all going pear shaped at literally the 11th hour. Net result no new keeper.
From the outside our policy seems muddled and this has been the case for a few Windows. We have covered 3 positions which is a positive and barring more injuries I feel this will be enough to get us through.
Summary - in the.circumstances a decent job from the board but as always it won't please all.

 


Bring back Brolin

chateauferret Flag 02 Feb 18 12.31am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Swimming with the Sharks ' by Midlands Eagle

You can't liken agents to sharks because the shark is an alpha predator, not a parasite. More like leeches I think.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 02 Feb 18 12.48am

Originally posted by Nobbybm

I tend to disagree re the keeper. We did everything reasonable to get Guaita & it was Getafe that put up a wall. Once it had been reported in Spain that we had a deal for him to join us on a free when his contract expires they changed their tune & tried to get a replacement in. They failed to do this (the replacement they found won't be joining until next season) so said a final 'no' to the deal. Hopefully their loss & our gain in the medium term - assuming there is an agreement & he does actually join us.

Plan B was Ronnow & that was simply too late for Brondby to get someone in for which you can lay blame with Parish/Dougie but it is probably fair to say they were operating within a budget & FFP constraints & confident the Amadou situation would've been resolved.

Hindsight's a wonderful thing, let's just hope WH starts performing better with a decent back four in front of him like he has in the past, although that relies on Sakho & Tomkins staying fit for the rest of the season...

The Independent reported we tried to lower the price by £2 mil. This could explain the stall and then acceptance of our offer but then too late regarding a replacement. Sounds plausible and very Parish. We'll probably sign an inferior keeper for even more in the summer.

Agreement to join us? As he's a free agent in the summer he's allowed to speak to us now but join the highest payer in June, whereas we'll be trying to sign someone 2 months later.

Probably our best manager wanted a keeper and we could've got a highly rated one. Let's hope this isn't the final thing to put Roy off the job.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 02 Feb 18 12.51am

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle

I guess he will be disappointed about the goalkeeping situation but we have managed so far with only two so let us hope our luck holds for the remaining games.

Parish likes to rely on luck in at least 1 position.

 


COYP

europalace Flag Europe 02 Feb 18 2.13am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The Independent reported we tried to lower the price by £2 mil. This could explain the stall and then acceptance of our offer but then too late regarding a replacement. Sounds plausible and very Parish. We'll probably sign an inferior keeper for even more in the summer.

Agreement to join us? As he's a free agent in the summer he's allowed to speak to us now but join the highest payer in June, whereas we'll be trying to sign someone 2 months later.

Probably our best manager wanted a keeper and we could've got a highly rated one. Let's hope this isn't the final thing to put Roy off the job.

lot's of supposition as usual from many on here. The only fact is that the same making all of this supposition weren't at any of the negotiations or any of the club management meetings regarding any prospective players coming to the club and hence knew absolutely nothing about what was being done to bring new players in.

 

antipodeagle Flag Wellington 02 Feb 18 3.54am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Swimming with the Sharks ' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by chateauferret

You can't liken agents to sharks because the shark is an alpha predator, not a parasite. More like leeches I think.

Agreed. Sharks add some value to the ecosystem. Agents however...

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 02 Feb 18 6.49am

Originally posted by europalace

lot's of supposition as usual from many on here. The only fact is that the same making all of this supposition weren't at any of the negotiations or any of the club management meetings regarding any prospective players coming to the club and hence knew absolutely nothing about what was being done to bring new players in.

True ... but we can all see the outcome and tbf it's not overwhelming is it? A case of fighting the good fight for another 4 months whereas we might have cruised it.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 02 Feb 18 6.49am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Swimming with the Sharks ' by Midlands Eagle

I'd like to see us implement a well publicized rule that we make one take-it-or-leave-it bid that must accepted and finalized with the player within 48 hours. It doesn't preclude us warning clubs that we will bid for x player.

But it just feels like we try to be clever and it backfires.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Username Flag Horsham 02 Feb 18 7.52am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Swimming with the Sharks ' by Midlands Eagle

I'd like to see us implement a well publicized rule that we make one take-it-or-leave-it bid that must accepted and finalized with the player within 48 hours. It doesn't preclude us warning clubs that we will bid for x player.

But it just feels like we try to be clever and it backfires.

That's not a particularly effective way of negotiating. With that rule we wouldn't have signed Sorloth or Sakho this season for example.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 02 Feb 18 8.24am

Originally posted by Username

That's not a particularly effective way of negotiating. With that rule we wouldn't have signed Sorloth or Sakho this season for example.

You don't know that. We might have bid 24m for Sakho and Liverpool, mindful it was our best price, mightn't have tried to screw us for a few more mill. Total price of 17m or so for Sorloth? I'll eat my arse if we didn't over pay given he cost them about 350k and was still very green (No matter how good he was looking for his team).

Something very fundamental needs to be adjusted in how we operate.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

europalace Flag Europe 02 Feb 18 9.10am

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

True ... but we can all see the outcome and tbf it's not overwhelming is it? A case of fighting the good fight for another 4 months whereas we might have cruised it.


The club have signed 3 new players, more than many other clubs in the PL. Just because people on here haven't heard of the names before means nothing. Clearly those whose profession is the football industry have heard of them, which is far, far more important. Many on hear would like to hear the club take on big well known names just like they probably buy smartphones and clothes because they have a brand label. Well, there are many lesser or unknown brands that are far superior that provide much more value for money and are often superior in functionality.

Too many fall for the hype of big names in football and I'm very glad the club's management doesn't.

Edited by europalace (02 Feb 2018 9.13am)

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 02 Feb 18 9.14am

Us mere mortals can only go on what is reported in the Press.

If you believe what has been reported to be true then you could conclude that ;

1. The club seems to expend a lot of energy pursuing players without doing sufficient due diligence. Example -Ibrahim...how can it only emerge at the last moment that the player won't be released as they can't recall another of their players from a loan ?

2. We leave it too late to implement a possible ' plan B ' and then fail to sign a player than wasn't even our initial first choice.

3. We seem unable to reach a price compromise with other clubs.For Guaita for instance.

Completing transfers, especially in today's global market,is a minefield and I suspect we don't know the half of what really goes on.

But if we are looking at our business in terms of players than can make an immediate contribution and compete for a starting place, I would have to say it's been a poor window as I don't believe the issues that Roy had with the squad have been addressed.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

silvertop Flag Portishead 02 Feb 18 9.34am

Originally posted by antipodeagle

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Swimming with the Sharks ' by Midlands Eagle

Agreed. Sharks add some value to the ecosystem. Agents however...

Ha, I know what you're saying. But to be a bit devil's advocate, even high level professionals use recruitment consultants to steer their careers. In the case of footballers the majority are a bit dim; some are absolute morons. They absolutely need someone to negotiate for them in a very difficult and highly lucrative market.

(It's a pity they are all cnuts.)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Feb 18 9.40am

A win on Sunday with some other results going in our favour and any criticism of our transfer activity will disappear into the ether.

A defeat on the back of an indifferent performance and there will be foam-flecked frenzy wih great dollops of hissing and snarling.

 

Page 15 of 18 < 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Window Summing Up