This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Yep, I've given this kind of thing a lot of thought recently and I can't deny your take on it as you state it here. Maybe this is what I am. My white English identity matters to me....and by extension being a European....not massively perhaps but it does matter....and I think that the identity of all races should matter...Black, Asian and if you're mixed then that combination....I suppose they have to pick a side in a sense....or at least more of a side. I use to have your opinion on the English identity and I won't deny the cultural aspect to it. I do think someone can come here and grow into the nationality.....but essentially I do think a percentage of genes matter. But no ones inferior....genes aren't inferior, they are just genes......but for example I prefer long legged girls to short legged ones and I personally don't see what's wrong with a preference. Preference becomes a problem when it removes other people’s right to choice and free will, for example, for the sake of preservation of identity. Or to a lesser extent makes them feel marginalised or treated and viewed differently because of a choice they’ve made that is explicitly linked to race. I’m not sure you can dilute this so easily by talking about long or short legged women. There’s too much water under the bridge to make light of what used to happen (and clearly still does, just not our in the open) when it comes to inter racial marriage/relationships etc. Your point on maybe this is what I am - if you’re making statements like that which are clearly based on racial preference, then I think most people these days would ditch the maybe. Again, that’s your viewpoint but again I’d be wary of posting that on a publically search indexed forum.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Preference becomes a problem when it removes other people’s right to choice and free will, for example, for the sake of preservation of identity. Or to a lesser extent makes them feel marginalised or treated and viewed differently because of a choice they’ve made that is explicitly linked to race. I’m not sure you can dilute this so easily by talking about long or short legged women. There’s too much water under the bridge to make light of what used to happen (and clearly still does, just not our in the open) when it comes to inter racial marriage/relationships etc. Your point on maybe this is what I am - if you’re making statements like that which are clearly based on racial preference, then I think most people these days would ditch the maybe. Again, that’s your viewpoint but again I’d be wary of posting that on a publically search indexed forum. You have preference, you remove 'other people’s right to choice and free will' all the time SW19. You might just prefer the forms you choose other other's forms but it's no different. You just don't admit to it or coat it in language you deem more respectable. I'm not aware that it's illegal to have a preference for my offspring. When you suggest that this is somehow wrong you promote the disfigured ideology we currently have. You have freely called whole nations racist on here and I totally disagree with your characterization. I regard your first paragraph as disappointing and your second paragraph as insidious......Is that where we are now. Jesus. At least I and others can know where you are now as a poster. Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Mar 2019 8.05am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
You have preference, you remove 'other people’s right to choice and free will' all the time SW19. You might just prefer the forms you choose other other's forms but it's no different. You just don't admit to it or coat it in language you deem more respectable. I'm not aware that it's illegal to have a preference for my offspring. When you suggest that this is somehow wrong you promote the disfigured ideology we currently have. You have freely called whole nations racist on here and I totally disagree with your characterization. I regard your first paragraph as disappointing and your second paragraph as insidious......Is that where we are now. Jesus. At least I and others can know where you are now as a poster. Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Mar 2019 8.05am) It's not necessarily related to what I think – it's just what the majority think. What I would say is that I thought the days of racial profiling deciding who people procreate with were, at least on the whole, in the past. I'd personally never take the same stance, i.e tell my offspring that I was either disappointed in them or worse for choosing a non-anglo saxon partner. Re. free will, of course I do. But not consciously because of their race. That's the point here. Sub-conciously? Based on research probably, as much as it pains me to say it. I never said it was illegal! But writing such stuff down in a public forum is in my opinion a bit risky. The point around being careful what you write is simply a general one, not a personal threat. There are probably plenty of people in some of the more aggressive far left organisations that you despise who would no doubt love to latch onto your opinion, maybe even attempt to go further. Why risk it? It's well documented that Japan is a very xenophobic, isolationist culture, which also naturally produces a large amount of racist incidents. I'm not sure that is in any way revelatory, or even a minority view. Also the point around ditching the maybe? That's just how people will view you after talking about racial preference in that way. I can't think you would of thought any different, surely? Norms of the past don't usually hold up well in the cold hard light of the present. Edited by SW19 CPFC (20 Mar 2019 1.16pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
I thought the days of racial profiling deciding who people procreate with were, at least on the whole, in the past. Edited by SW19 CPFC (20 Mar 2019 1.16pm) you not seen any dating websites then ? many websites clearly allow people to filter by height, age, socioeconomic class, religion ....AND BY RACE.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
you not seen any dating websites then ? many websites clearly allow people to filter by height, age, socioeconomic class, religion ....AND BY RACE. Observes point sailing over head by several thousand miles.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
you not seen any dating websites then ? many websites clearly allow people to filter by height, age, socioeconomic class, religion ....AND BY RACE. I put in Afro Carribbean, professional, less than 4ft 6 and overtly Buddhist. I wanted to put in over 15 stone too but you only get the choice of slim or other. Didn't get many matches in the West of Ireland. I still await my dream girl.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
It's not necessarily related to what I think – it's just what the majority think. Is there any evidence for a statement like that. I'm not so sure. [Link] Indeed, when you consider the world I'd say your views on this topic are very much the minority. It may be what you intellectual bubble thinks and those you surround yourself with and respect think. However, that is not the same thing. Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
What I would say is that I thought the days of racial profiling deciding who people procreate with were, at least on the whole, in the past. I'd personally never take the same stance, i.e tell my offspring that I was either disappointed in them or worse for choosing a non-anglo saxon partner. Let's look at that statement logically. If people weren't 'racially profiling' as you say...Whereas I would choose different words like 'exercising preference'.... then the minorities that have been here since mass immigration began would have been far more mixed into the population than they are. The number of sexual partners available from the white community far far exceeds those from their own. The reality is that most different racial groups are choosing the same racial partners in an environment where they have ready access to different races. You are either choosing to ignore this or simply disbelieve what I feel is very obviously the case. I simply stated the same preferred choice...Not a forced one.....as I believe in an individual's mental agency and choice.....and not an exclusive choice as you then chose to take the statement. You say it's not necessarily related to what you think and then precede to give us....in my view, what amounts to a distinction without a difference. Now in this reply I will say that while I completely disagree with most of your points I have some respect for your viewpoint as I once held similar views. I'm not saying this for point scoring but simply in a recognition of your egalitarianism. That said we differ significantly and I have some things to say. Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Re. free will, of course I do. But not consciously because of their race. That's the point here. Sub-conciously? Based on research probably, as much as it pains me to say it.
I feel you are mistaken if you are suggesting that you don't or haven't made value judgements on people using criteria that the individual has no control over....for example, a good looking girlfriend over a plain one.....A smart girlfriend over a dimmer one.....and my example of preferring long legs to short legs isn't throw away at all....It lies at the very centre of that this discussion is about. You simply think your discriminations are less transgressionary than mine based purely upon arbitrary value judgements within current popular culture. When that culture changes do you think I'll be telling you to stop speaking your views because we have activist nutters out there?.....though you have a point. Anyway the fact is these preferences are normal in the world and indeed within this very country. We just have this current absurd attitude towards anyone talking about it. Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
I never said it was illegal! But writing such stuff down in a public forum is in my opinion a bit risky. The point around being careful what you write is simply a general one, not a personal threat. There are probably plenty of people in some of the more aggressive far left organisations that you despise who would no doubt love to latch onto your opinion, maybe even attempt to go further. Why risk it?
You seem to be suggesting that I should pull my horns in....perhaps you are right. However, while I think I'd prefer to post far less on this stuff I don't consider that course of action a particularly good reflection of what is meant to be a free society. I don't feel that I've said anything particularly outlandish or shocking at all. Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
It's well documented that Japan is a very xenophobic, isolationist culture, which also naturally produces a large amount of racist incidents. I'm not sure that is in any way revelatory, or even a minority view. Also the point around ditching the maybe? That's just how people will view you after talking about racial preference in that way. I can't think you would of thought any different, surely? Norms of the past don't usually hold up well in the cold hard light of the present. Edited by SW19 CPFC (20 Mar 2019 1.16pm) I don't accept how you characterise Japan......a country that is very popular with tourists and migrant workers despite your description....it isn't isolationist and is a massive trading country with cultural links all over the world. I don't consider the desire to maintain a biological existence that has maintained for many thousands of years somehow....racist. Japan is a global nation in many ways it just doesn't except the ideas on identity that you do.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I don't accept how you characterise Japan......a country that is very popular with tourists and migrant workers despite your description....it isn't isolationist and is a massive trading country with cultural links all over the world. I don't consider the desire to maintain a biological existence that has maintained for many thousands of years somehow....racist. Japan is a global nation in many ways it just doesn't except the ideas on identity that you do.
Hes back! In fairness, you could probably find evidence but yeah it’s my interpretation of the general state of play, although it’s definately wide than just my ‘bubble’. I don’t just form my views and opinions based on what people I know say. If I did I think I’d be in real trouble. I’d argue the same could be said of your opinions To cut out the waffle, I thought being anti mixed race marriage/sex/relationships was long in the past. At least in the mainstream anyway. No matter how you cut it, that is, as we discussed before, technically racist. What that doesn’t mean is you can’t have a preference, say, on a dating site, as one pleb pointed out so eloquently. Both thoughts and reasons for choice come from two very different places. No one is suggesting you can’t make choices based on race, but the crucial thing is why, how and for what reason you’re making them. From your previous replies you certainly appeared to understand this view as at the very least walking a very fine line. You place negative choice on race at the same level as choosing a girlfriend - it’s a bad comparison. One is equal no matter culture race or creed, one is not. Just because people tend to choose to stay within their racial groups as a majority trend doesn’t mean people that don’t should be penalised, or in some way made to feel inferior, ashamed or belittled. That is at the crux of the issue. Stupidity is not exclusive. Race is. Judging on stupidity is equally fair game. Judging on race in the way you are is not. It’s a subtle but very important difference. I’d be very interested to conduct a poll on whether not wanting ones child to marry or procreate with another race (Any race, whatever) was racist or not. I’d be amazed if most people said no. That’s where I think you’re out of touch. I’m not even sure that Stevey would say that. He has black friends you know. Maybe if they were a Muslim, anyway I digress. I’m not suggesting you pull your horns in, especially if this was a private forum but it’s not. If I had loads of money and didn’t need to work, had no reputation at stake etc then I’d go for it much more - but I’m not that naive. If people want to find you, they’ll find you. This is not Chatham house rules or the local Wisbech inn. And to me that says more about your interpretation of the wider world and where it is now and where it is heading being more out of touch than mine. Maybe that’s age. You might not accept the characterisation of Japan but it’s all there if you choose to read about it rather than ignore it. You often hold it up as a model of aspiration and that maybe exposes your bias. There are clearly benefits to their approach but a rounded objective person would also realise its flaws. Edited by SW19 CPFC (20 Mar 2019 10.36pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Hes back! He is....but I thought about it. Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
In fairness, you could probably find evidence but yeah it’s my interpretation of the general state of play, although it’s definately wide than just my ‘bubble’. I don’t just form my views and opinions based on what people I know say. If I did I think I’d be in real trouble. I’d argue the same could be said of your opinions Yep, bubbles of some sort are unavoidable. Few of us think our perceptions are incorrect, though purely on a statistical measure many of them must be. Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
To cut out the waffle, I thought being anti mixed race marriage/sex/relationships was long in the past. At least in the mainstream anyway. No matter how you cut it, that is, as we discussed before, technically racist. Well, I think my desire for England to remain majority biologically European has been dashed to the rocks long term....and yes I'm resentful of that...as anyone who follows my occasional rants would see. However, I wouldn't say I'm anti mixed race marriage really. They might be excellent and nice people. I'm not turning up and going 'boo hiss' as they speed away to their wedding night. If someone's mixed race then I can still regard them as English if that's how they define...because they probably are at least half English anyway. What I'm talking about is a nation not losing its genetic heritage and a desire to keep an English line......like most things it's a number's game. Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
What that doesn’t mean is you can’t have a preference, say, on a dating site, as one pleb pointed out so eloquently. Both thoughts and reasons for choice come from two very different places. No one is suggesting you can’t make choices based on race, but the crucial thing is why, how and for what reason you’re making them. From your previous replies you certainly appeared to understand this view as at the very least walking a very fine line. I just don't think it's that important. I think society has wound itself up into a ball over race in its constant need for simplistic narratives with fake heroes and villains. Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
You place negative choice on race at the same level as choosing a girlfriend - it’s a bad comparison. One is equal no matter culture race or creed, one is not. Can't say I agree with that......The plain looking girlfriend is not equal to the good looking girlfriend in how the world treats her at all. The reality is you are caught up in one form of natural discrimination while dismissing another. Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Just because people tend to choose to stay within their racial groups as a majority trend doesn’t mean people that don’t should be penalised, or in some way made to feel inferior, ashamed or belittled. That is at the crux of the issue.
That doesn't mean that a nation shouldn't look to retain its European basis.....otherwise Europe will soon not be Europe. Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Stupidity is not exclusive. Race is. Judging on stupidity is equally fair game. Judging on race in the way you are is not. It’s a subtle but very important difference.
Race isn't that exclusive anyway.....it has many mixtures.....but you have a subtle point there...just not one I personally think matters that much. Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
I’d be very interested to conduct a poll on whether not wanting ones child to marry or procreate with another race (Any race, whatever) was racist or not. I’d be amazed if most people said no. That’s where I think you’re out of touch. I’m not even sure that Stevey would say that. He has black friends you know. Maybe if they were a Muslim, anyway I digress. Mmmm...Like I said, on the basis upon how you framed it, I think most people are racist to some level......As I say the statistics on how mixed society actually isn't and how racial groups collect together is more than ample evidence. Most human beings have in built group preference.....it's just a certain demographic in power in society regard it as a negative....even though its the norm all through society.....from where people have chosen to live, work, mix and ultimately mate with. Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
I’m not suggesting you pull your horns in, especially if this was a private forum but it’s not. If I had loads of money and didn’t need to work, had no reputation at stake etc then I’d go for it much more - but I’m not that naive. If people want to find you, they’ll find you. This is not Chatham house rules or the local Wisbech inn. And to me that says more about your interpretation of the wider world and where it is now and where it is heading being more out of touch than mine. Maybe that’s age.
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
You might not accept the characterisation of Japan but it’s all there if you choose to read about it rather than ignore it. You often hold it up as a model of aspiration and that maybe exposes your bias. There are clearly benefits to their approach but a rounded objective person would also realise its flaws. Edited by SW19 CPFC (20 Mar 2019 10.36pm) What can I say....I love Japan...and I have bias. Yeah, it has flaws, and huge historic issues.....However, in the modern sense I admire it. Western left/neo liberal society needs to come back to earth in regards to race and stop treating it like a virtue signalling witch hunt exercise for imaginary mostly invented evils. We need more mature and sensible leaders. Edited by Stirlingsays (21 Mar 2019 9.51am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
The approach in New York was largely based on Broken Windows theory. Worth looking up.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
The approach in New York was largely based on Broken Windows theory. Worth looking up. Very interesting.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
17 year old in isleworth
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
My 16 year old nephew waiting for a bus to college, cornered and mugged for his watch in broad daylight outside Purley Tesco by black youths saying they had a knife. Just another stat.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
It has a bit but I just advised him to remember his life will go somewhere and their’s won’t. He said if they want to risk their future for that sh1t he wants nothing to do with it or risk himself over a £100 watch he earned doing a paper round, like I did, but they’ll never do. Another reason why the 30 something families move out, but vote MP’s from the party that’s mainly responsible for this, in. Edited by Rudi Hedman (27 Mar 2019 9.33pm)
COYP |
|
|
Hearing there's a stabbing with someone killed in West Norwood....
Pro USA & Israel |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
It has a bit but I just advised him to remember his life will go somewhere and their’s won’t. He said if they want to risk their future for that sh1t he wants nothing to do with it or risk himself over a £100 watch he earned doing a paper round, like I did, but they’ll never do. Another reason why the 30 something families move out, but vote MP’s from the party that’s mainly responsible for this, in. Edited by Rudi Hedman (27 Mar 2019 9.33pm) Yep, totally agree.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Yes, echo that. Hope he’s OK. Very sensible to hand it over; getting stabbed up over a watch isn’t worth it.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.