You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Window Summing Up
November 16 2026 7.58am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Transfer Window Summing Up


Page 16 of 18 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 >
silvertop Flag Portishead 02 Feb 18 9.43am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

You don't know that. We might have bid 24m for Sakho and Liverpool, mindful it was our best price, mightn't have tried to screw us for a few more mill. Total price of 17m or so for Sorloth? I'll eat my arse if we didn't over pay given he cost them about 350k and was still very green (No matter how good he was looking for his team).

Something very fundamental needs to be adjusted in how we operate.

Your not really applying a fair comparison. Inter-Nordic transfers for an untested player will always appear peanuts compared with buying into the premier league with its prices wholly inflated by TV money and the filter-down effect of mega transfers within premier European clubs.

As to whether Sorloth meets his value, at today's prices circa 10 goals and 10 assists a season will probably do it [or something?].

 

aquickgame2 Flag Beni = summer,Caribbean = winter 02 Feb 18 9.54am

Originally posted by alaneagle1

Well for a club that does not know how to do transfers we currently sit unlucky for some 13th.
The highest we will get in the foreseeable future is 7th.
So in my book we are doing ok.
And yes I would support your Gran,hopefully she doesn’t moan as much as her Grandson.


[/blue

Classic...pure class answer.....well done Al

 

Tom R Flag Huddersfield 02 Feb 18 9.56am

Whilst the three additions will hopefully start to improve the back up strength in the squad, we did not fully address the two key areas of a striker and a goalkeeper. In addition we have 7 players out of contract in the summer, of which at least 3 due to age/ability should not be retained, and Ward has stated he will not be signing a new contract. There are also 2 loan players that will return to their clubs. Consequently in summer we will need to bring in quite a large number of players, and in some positions ie goalkeeper and right back we need more than one signing in both positions.
With this dilution of the squad we have to start making signings early in summer to integrate them in to the squad. Overall on this basis I believe it was not a good window and is stacking up problems for further down the line

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Feb 18 10.05am

Originally posted by Tom R

Whilst the three additions will hopefully start to improve the back up strength in the squad, we did not fully address the two key areas of a striker and a goalkeeper. In addition we have 7 players out of contract in the summer, of which at least 3 due to age/ability should not be retained, and Ward has stated he will not be signing a new contract. There are also 2 loan players that will return to their clubs. Consequently in summer we will need to bring in quite a large number of players, and in some positions ie goalkeeper and right back we need more than one signing in both positions.
With this dilution of the squad we have to start making signings early in summer to integrate them in to the squad. Overall on this basis I believe it was not a good window and is stacking up problems for further down the line

We don't know what Division we will be playing in next season.
If we are relegated, which is a distinct possibility, that revolving door will be very much in use.

In terms of our activity in this 'Window' it would appear that we have brought in squad players who are not really challenging for a starting berth as opposed to the likes of WBA,Swansea,Newcastle and Brighton etc etc.

Edited by Willo (02 Feb 2018 10.06am)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 02 Feb 18 10.29am

Originally posted by europalace

lot's of supposition as usual from many on here. The only fact is that the same making all of this supposition weren't at any of the negotiations or any of the club management meetings regarding any prospective players coming to the club and hence knew absolutely nothing about what was being done to bring new players in.

We know the price wanted of these players and we know we tried to do deals last minute. Are you confident this keeper will choose us over the rest of our league or will we end up signing someone else for the same price or possibly more? That's a fairly possible outcome.

 


COYP

Tom R Flag Huddersfield 02 Feb 18 10.33am

Continuation of our current run of form would see us secure our Premier League status for another season. However, we have only 4 attacking players (including a striker untried in this League and not match fit as he has not played since early December. Injuries/suspensions to any of these 4 will leave us short of players and that in itself could make relegation very likely!

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 02 Feb 18 10.39am

Originally posted by Willo

We don't know what Division we will be playing in next season.
If we are relegated, which is a distinct possibility, that revolving door will be very much in use.

In terms of our activity in this 'Window' it would appear that we have brought in squad players who are not really challenging for a starting berth as opposed to the likes of WBA,Swansea,Newcastle and Brighton etc etc.

Edited by Willo (02 Feb 2018 10.06am)

I can help you there Willo,if we are relegated we will return to The Championship,however there is a distinct possibility that we will stay up for a 6th Season in The Premiership.
Either way the poster raises excellent points,which i’ve Seen Rudi post a few times about the “out of contract” players and the “loanees “.
Those decisions do need to be finalised ASAP.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Happiness Stan Flag Itchycoo Park 02 Feb 18 10.45am

Originally posted by Dangermouse

We're Crystal Palace. We make up the numbers in this division along with 12 others. We're gonna get relegated in the foreseeable future no matter what.

In other news, we are all going to die, as are all our loved ones, and in the fullness of time the sun will burn out, destroying all life on earth.

 


"How can I remember to keep it all together when half the moon is taken away?"

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Feb 18 10.45am

Originally posted by Tom R

Continuation of our current run of form would see us secure our Premier League status for another season. However, we have only 4 attacking players (including a striker untried in this League and not match fit as he has not played since early December. Injuries/suspensions to any of these 4 will leave us short of players and that in itself could make relegation very likely!

Indeed, a continuation of our current form should see us 'Over the line' but we might not be able to sustain this.As you mentioned, a couple of our signings haven't played recently (Since Nov & Dec) and if we have further injuries, these players are called upon and found wanting, there will be an almighty outcry amongst our supporters about our transfer activity.

As I have mentioned, WBA,Brighton, Newcastle,Swansea have all signed players who will either play in the first team straight away or will be challenging for a place based on their previous experience.Don't think ours are in that category.

 

PremierPalace Flag 02 Feb 18 10.58am

Originally posted by silvertop

If you can furnish evidence to prove that we only approached at the 11th hour then you will win this mini argument. If not, then you will not.

My guess: we try to do business under the radar given the number of poaches we suffer. I suspect Dougie et al have been forced to sweat for months waiting to see if the hoped linked deal will come off at Brondby. For no fault of our own it did not.


It was widely reported that we were still after and bidding for Guaita on deadline day. Ronnow came about when we couldn’t get him, and it was simply too late for Brøndby to get a replacement.

[Link]

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 02 Feb 18 11.25am

Originally posted by PremierPalace

It was widely reported that we were still after and bidding for Guaita on deadline day. Ronnow came about when we couldn’t get him, and it was simply too late for Brøndby to get a replacement.

Apparently we did exactly the same thing to the same club and player in the August transfer window with exactly the same result so it appears that we don't learn from our mistakes

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 02 Feb 18 11.31am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Apparently we did exactly the same thing to the same club and player in the August transfer window with exactly the same result so it appears that we don't learn from our mistakes

I think it was as simple as he was our second choice and when it became apparent that Guaita wasn't going to get over the line in this window we turned our attention to Ronnow but too late. To be honest buying both wouldn't be a bad shout but it may be that they thought Amadou was going to go through and money was an issue, so they were juggling balls and unfortunately dropped them!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Feb 18 11.38am

Originally posted by alaneagle1

I can help you there Willo,if we are relegated we will return to The Championship,however there is a distinct possibility that we will stay up for a 6th Season in The Premiership.
Either way the poster raises excellent points,which i’ve Seen Rudi post a few times about the “out of contract” players and the “loanees “.
Those decisions do need to be finalised ASAP.

Really ? Never worked that out.How very remiss of me.


Edited by Willo (02 Feb 2018 11.39am)

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 02 Feb 18 11.42am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Apparently we did exactly the same thing to the same club and player in the August transfer window with exactly the same result so it appears that we don't learn from our mistakes

Midlands what is the latest on this lad ?
Has he signed a pre-contract.?

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Midlands Eagle Flag 02 Feb 18 12.42pm

Originally posted by alaneagle1

Midlands what is the latest on this lad ?
Has he signed a pre-contract.?

I have no idea as I haven't seen anything about it in the media

 

The Dolphin Flag 02 Feb 18 1.00pm

This kind of thing is my only complaint about the way we sometimes appear to deal with transfer targets.
If we wanted him in the Summer (and it appears that we still wanted him at the end of this latest window) then why not just buy him at the beginning of January?
We seem to huff and puff sometimes and maybe miss out because we are in the market for too many players at the same time.
This Goalkeeper must wonder if it is worth coming to Palace as we seem to look at him as a last resort!

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 02 Feb 18 1.01pm

Originally posted by Willo

Indeed, a continuation of our current form should see us 'Over the line' but we might not be able to sustain this.As you mentioned, a couple of our signings haven't played recently (Since Nov & Dec) and if we have further injuries, these players are called upon and found wanting, there will be an almighty outcry amongst our supporters about our transfer activity.

As I have mentioned, WBA,Brighton, Newcastle,Swansea have all signed players who will either play in the first team straight away or will be challenging for a place based on their previous experience.Don't think ours are in that category.

Let's just look at transfera into teams around us...Bournemouth bought no one.
BHA broke their transfer record for Locadia, and we know what fans on here think of Dutch players, and Ulloa who can't get in the Leicester team and hasn't played much this season
Swansea have brought back Ahew, who seems to be injured.
Newcastle have got slamani, who can't get a game for Leicester, has yet to prove himself and seems to be injured.
WBA have got Sturridge who is a huge injury risk and has hardly played this season.
And Burnley have got Aaron lennon...
All in all, I'd rather have our new Danish player than most of those to be honest...

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 02 Feb 18 1.05pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Your not really applying a fair comparison. Inter-Nordic transfers for an untested player will always appear peanuts compared with buying into the premier league with its prices wholly inflated by TV money and the filter-down effect of mega transfers within premier European clubs.

As to whether Sorloth meets his value, at today's prices circa 10 goals and 10 assists a season will probably do it [or something?].


I am merely stating that based on what they paid -- and what he did in a lopsided, third-tier European league -- i believe we could have got him cheaper. that applies no matter what he does for us.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 02 Feb 18 1.10pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Let's just look at transfera into teams around us...Bournemouth bought no one.
BHA broke their transfer record for Locadia, and we know what fans on here think of Dutch players, and Ulloa who can't get in the Leicester team and hasn't played much this season
Swansea have brought back Ahew, who seems to be injured.
Newcastle have got slamani, who can't get a game for Leicester, has yet to prove himself and seems to be injured.
WBA have got Sturridge who is a huge injury risk and has hardly played this season.
And Burnley have got Aaron lennon...
All in all, I'd rather have our new Danish player than most of those to be honest...

Agreed but I believe he is Norwegian.
You might be thinking of Per Bartram.?

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 02 Feb 18 1.23pm

Based on what?
I agree it seems massively overpriced for an unproven player who has only very briefly done something in a lowly rated league. However: sellers know the PL is where the money is, so they ask for excessive fees. For instance Feyenoord wanted 22m for Jorgensen, that is almost 40 percent of last season's Turnaround!! Unbelievable figures but English clubs are getting pressurized in overpaying huge fees, simply because they have the spending power and everybody knows it.

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig


I am merely stating that based on what they paid -- and what he did in a lopsided, third-tier European league -- i believe we could have got him cheaper. that applies no matter what he does for us.


 

Page 16 of 18 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Window Summing Up