You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Sorloth thread
November 16 2026 5.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Sorloth thread


Page 16 of 54 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 >
TheBigToePunt Flag 02 Nov 18 11.43pm

Buying an effective goalscorer is the hardest part of football management, as it's the most competitive part of the market. Some will get lucky with who they sign, but the vast majority of forwards bought and sold will fall short of the magic threshold of 20 goals a season for the simple reason that (and here's the thing we sometimes forget) scoring is the hardest part of the game. There's only so many human beings alive who can get 20 premier league goals a year, why on earth does anyone think we should be entitled to one?

In fairness to the club they've tried pretty much every approach to it, ranging from speculative punts at reasonable prices (Wickham and sorloth) to loaning guys who have done OK at this level before but who you might want to reserve judgment on (ayew and remy) to a balls out record signing (that one) but none of them have worked out. All were potentially good signings in a very difficult market, and I really don't see what else they could have done.

 

manwitheagletattoo Flag Somewhere in England 03 Nov 18 5.23am

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

tbf ive never thought about his record in the danish leagues as it isnt comparible to england, stephen dobbie is averaging over a goal a game in scotland this season...haha.

i dont think he has had enough gametime to properly settle into this league...hes had what? 12 appearances, lets guess at 4 in the cup comps, so roughly 8 sub appearances, probably totalling less than 200 minutes of PL football.

with regards to seeing what sort of player he is, i would say thats pretty easy, hes a targetman who should be able to bring others into play, and set up chances for somebody quick playing off him, basically in the mould of bentekkers.

so the lad has had approx 2 matches worth of gametime, from the bench, in a team that doesnt create chances for strikers & he is being written off by some people.

unbeleivable...he may turn out rubbish, but lets give him a proper chance 1st.

I am all for giving players a chance I am not disputing that, what I was trying to put across was. I have like a many on Hols have seen a lot of strikers come and go at this club since the middle sixties. Over the years we have had some good strikers at the club. Allan Birchnell, Don Rogers, Mike Elwiss, Tommy Langley ( he he )
Ian Wright, Mark Bright, Andy Johnson to name a few.

Palace have also had their fair share of disappointing failures. At present the strikers we have at Palace are not game winners or game changing players. Ayew did very well for his last club Swansea but what has he done here, nothing. If Hodgson saw something in Sorlorth in training that he thought would start him in front of Ayew then don’t you think Sorlorth would start and be involved in more games. Totally agree that Sorlorth is a target man no question about that and in one or two matches he has held the ball up very well, but being a striker is all about reading and being one step ahead of the game losing your marker finding and making goal scoring positions out of nothing. On those foundations I have not seen from Sorlorth. Maybe he could do with some personal coaching from Andy Johnson but in today’s game the pressures of being a striker you have to hit the ground running and these huge price tags that clubs pay for players don’t help.

 


South London & Proud
Sometimes I really wonder if family are really worth it.
Because it doesn’t matter how time and affection you give
It’s never enough

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 03 Nov 18 7.56am

Originally posted by premier fan

9m for Sorloth? who the hell scouted him? they should be sacked immediately.

What makes this even worse is that we paid £9m for him only 8 months after F.C. Midtjylland bought him for £450k from F.C. Groningen, following a failed spell in the Eredivisie!


Edited by Phil’s Barber (03 Nov 2018 7.56am)

Edited by Phil’s Barber (03 Nov 2018 8.00am)

 

slubglurge Flag welling 03 Nov 18 1.33pm

I would imagine there are clauses in the deal appearances and goals etc so by the looks of things they wont be getting anywhere near 9m

 

Jacey Flag 03 Nov 18 1.57pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Buying an effective goalscorer is the hardest part of football management, as it's the most competitive part of the market. Some will get lucky with who they sign, but the vast majority of forwards bought and sold will fall short of the magic threshold of 20 goals a season for the simple reason that (and here's the thing we sometimes forget) scoring is the hardest part of the game. There's only so many human beings alive who can get 20 premier league goals a year, why on earth does anyone think we should be entitled to one?

In fairness to the club they've tried pretty much every approach to it, ranging from speculative punts at reasonable prices (Wickham and sorloth) to loaning guys who have done OK at this level before but who you might want to reserve judgment on (ayew and remy) to a balls out record signing (that one) but none of them have worked out. All were potentially good signings in a very difficult market, and I really don't see what else they could have done.

Glenn Murray has scored 8 goals so far,more than our entire team.
Perhaps we should have retained his services???

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 03 Nov 18 3.15pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Glenn Murray has scored 8 goals so far,more than our entire team.
Perhaps we should have retained his services???

Yawwwwn

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 03 Nov 18 3.44pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Glenn Murray has scored 8 goals so far,more than our entire team.
Perhaps we should have retained his services???

Parish explained that fully. We couldn't afford to keep him and also make new signings without falling foul of financial fair play.

I was going to say 'Remember, it's not fantasy football', but even in fantasy football you have a maximum budget, and often have to sell in order to buy.


Edited by TheBigToePunt (03 Nov 2018 3.46pm)

 

the.universal 03 Nov 18 4.17pm

Originally posted by slubglurge

I would imagine there are clauses in the deal appearances and goals etc so by the looks of things they wont be getting anywhere near 9m

Unfortunately not. We put £9m down initially, with another £2m odd for each season we stay up.

So, £13m or so spent already. There really aren’t enough facepalms to describe this deal.

Hopefully ship him off to Turkey in the close season for anything £6m+ and just try to learn the lessons of a woeful transfer.

 


Vive le Roy!

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 03 Nov 18 9.26pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Parish explained that fully. We couldn't afford to keep him and also make new signings without falling foul of financial fair play.

I was going to say 'Remember, it's not fantasy football', but even in fantasy football you have a maximum budget, and often have to sell in order to buy.


Edited by TheBigToePunt (03 Nov 2018 3.46pm)

But he'd been a beast in the preceding few months and one of the biggest reasons we turned from relegation certs to being safe with five games left. To hear FFP as a reason for not keeping him is pathetic.

 

chateauferret Flag 03 Nov 18 9.46pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Parish explained that fully. We couldn't afford to keep him and also make new signings without falling foul of financial fair play.

I was going to say 'Remember, it's not fantasy football', but even in fantasy football you have a maximum budget, and often have to sell in order to buy.

Which considering what we paid for and are still paying for people who couldn't score in a brothel is bollocks.

 


============
The Ferret
============

dreamwaverider Flag London 04 Nov 18 3.51am

All I know is that both Benteke and now Sorloth have been a disaster for us. Neither have lived up to expectations. Would be ok cover if we could find someone proper but that is not easy

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 04 Nov 18 7.47am

What concerns me about Sorloth is his lack of physical presence as a target man. Has anyone ever see him battle past a defender to win a header? As a target man your job is to hold the ball up and win headers, he doesn’t do that well. If he could, his lack of goals wouldn’t be such an issue.

Against Boro there were several good crosses into the box, towards Sorloth, that he simply didn’t even challenge for. It looks to me either he’s scared to get hurt or lazy.

 

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 04 Nov 18 9.06am

Originally posted by Goal Machine

What concerns me about Sorloth is his lack of physical presence as a target man. Has anyone ever see him battle past a defender to win a header? As a target man your job is to hold the ball up and win headers, he doesn’t do that well. If he could, his lack of goals wouldn’t be such an issue.

Against Boro there were several good crosses into the box, towards Sorloth, that he simply didn’t even challenge for. It looks to me either he’s scared to get hurt or lazy.

This I shall unfair.

I have watched him up close a few times. He is just not having the rub of the green and has been involved in the assists for a few goals. He offers quite a lot more than stats show. I would rather have him than bentekesaurus.

 

Jacey Flag 04 Nov 18 9.28am

Originally posted by BarEagle

This I shall unfair.

I have watched him up close a few times. He is just not having the rub of the green and has been involved in the assists for a few goals. He offers quite a lot more than stats show. I would rather have him than bentekesaurus.

Such disrespectful rubbish.
Benteke scored 19 goals for Villa in his first season and 15 goals for us likewise.
Sam seemed to have got the best out of him if others have failed.
Class Belgium International with 37 caps.
Cannot recall how many goals Sorloth has scored in the Premiership by way of comparison.

 

chateauferret Flag 04 Nov 18 1.33pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Such disrespectful rubbish.
Benteke scored 19 goals for Villa in his first season and 15 goals for us likewise.
Sam seemed to have got the best out of him if others have failed.
Class Belgium International with 37 caps.
Cannot recall how many goals Sorloth has scored in the Premiership by way of comparison.

You can't select a player on the basis that he's scored a bunch of goals two or three years ago. For the last fifteen months at least he's been consistently either injured or s***e. Yes, he was a class player once; he may or may not be again. Belgium dropped him for the world cup because whatever his "class", his form has been appalling for ages. I hope he hasn't lost it for good, but there's a distinct possibility that that's the case.

Edited by chateauferret (04 Nov 2018 1.34pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Jacey Flag 04 Nov 18 2.17pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

You can't select a player on the basis that he's scored a bunch of goals two or three years ago. For the last fifteen months at least he's been consistently either injured or s***e. Yes, he was a class player once; he may or may not be again. Belgium dropped him for the world cup because whatever his "class", his form has been appalling for ages. I hope he hasn't lost it for good, but there's a distinct possibility that that's the case.

Just to make a point,Benteke was actually recalled to the Belgium Squad and it was while in training with them that he suffered his rather unfortunate injury.
There is absolutely no comparison between the high scoring Benteke record up against Mr" No Goal " Sorloth!!

Edited by chateauferret (04 Nov 2018 1.34pm)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 04 Nov 18 8.04pm

He needs to be loaned out but this wont happen because we need him to make up the numbers and i dont expect us to be signing some one else in his playing position any time soon.

the amount we paid for him and the rising rate is another dumb business move from the club

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Maine Eagle Flag USA 04 Nov 18 8.31pm

Originally posted by grumpymort

He needs to be loaned out but this wont happen because we need him to make up the numbers and i dont expect us to be signing some one else in his playing position any time soon.

the amount we paid for him and the rising rate is another dumb business move from the club

We must sign a striker in January, even Parish has to realize this.

Sorloth going out on loan is tied to Wickham’s health.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

chateauferret Flag 04 Nov 18 8.57pm

Originally posted by Jacey

But there's a pretty close comparison between the new couldn't hit a cow's arse Benteke and the couldn't hit a cow's arse Sørloth.

Adebsyor had a long history of being class but dud very little for us. Ayew scored 10 goals for a Swansea side that got relegated but now seems utterly useless. Schlupp has a PL title winner's medal. Even Puncheon used to score at a decent rate. And would you like Yannick Bolasie back?

 


============
The Ferret
============

Rogers Don Flag Horsham 05 Nov 18 12.04pm

Sorloth needs to start games with Meyer in the hole behind him. He is not an impact player and shouldn't be used as a last minute substitute.

 


Let's keep the ball this season!

Page 16 of 54 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Sorloth thread