You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Aston Villa Match Thread
November 16 2026 6.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Aston Villa Match Thread


Page 16 of 17 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 >
cryrst Flag The garden of England 01 Sep 19 3.35pm

Grealish was dragging his foot like he had a dead leg.
Like wilf these 'fouls' eventually catch up with you.
He dragged his foot out for a full 3yards on a clip I've seen so karma gets you in the end.
If K friend has been duped before he ain't goner get done twice.
3 points get in and f*** the inbred t***s

 

Noz Flag North Hampshire 01 Sep 19 5.27pm

Grealish is a clever player: he does this thing when he has the ball at his feet and running, and from the slightest touch he stumbles, then pretends to keep his balance - eventually the referee gets sympathetic "oh he's trying to stay on his feet", and gives the foul. Saw that about 5 or 6 times during this game.

On the flip side: Luka did a blatant pull of the shirt in about the 4th or 5th minute and didn't get a yellow card. It was an absolute miracle that he didn't get it until late on the game.

Friend also carded Kouyate, indicating it was for multiple fouls, which, for the life of me, I can't remember.....

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 01 Sep 19 6.49pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I've looked at the incident time and time again. If there is any contact at all it is Wilf outside the box and that is minimal. Cahill withdraws his leg before Grealish goes to ground.

What the ref saw was Grealish going down easily on 3 or more occasions during the match which probably influenced his decision to call the free kick for simulation.

It is irrelevant whether the ball goes in the net as the ref has already blown his whistle. The fact it did go into the net is why the pundits are blaming VAR for not intervening. The only time I could see VAR coming into play on this passage of play was if they could clearly see Cahill bring down Grealish which would then mean a penalty. You cannot allow a goal to stand regardless of VAR if the whistle has been blown as this signifies a stoppage in play and will have been heard by the players which then, may or may not influence how they challenge for the ball. In this instance I don't think hearing the whistle would have stopped the shot or the goal, but that is not the point, the play has been stopped.

The VAR would have reviewed the challenge by Cahill and taken the same view as the ref that he did not make contact and therefore it was a reasonable decision by the ref to blow up against Grealish for simulation.

At the end of the day this is one of those decisions that can go against you just as easily as it goes for you. I am pleased that we have had the rub of the green against both Utd and now Villa as we had our fair share of poor calls last year.

Just my take on it but I thought Lineker and Co were bang out of order on MOTD last night.

I have looked at this several times and agree with everything you say. Why so many high profile characters are willing to question Friend, who was right behind Grealish, is strange, from that angle he got a light touch from Zaha, didn’t go down, ran straight into Cahill, leaving his foot, and then doesn’t fall, but clearly leaves the ground diving. He might have got it, but Friend could clearly see he was looking to hit the deck anyway. Lineker , and Co, are crap. Not a word of how Villa, didn’t get a smell outside of the Grealish, dive.

 

YT Flag Oxford 01 Sep 19 7.00pm

Anyway; all games completed and we remain 4th in the Prem. Yay!

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

ger20 Flag London 01 Sep 19 7.41pm

No point even discussing the Gearlish incident, swings and roundabouts, how many times has a decision gone against us in the past and how many will go against us in the future, these things even themselves out over the course of a season

 

You What Flag se25 01 Sep 19 8.01pm

Originally posted by dg1937

If Jenas thinks that was the worst refereeing decision ever then he clearly hasn't been to many Palace matches.

He hasn’t seen a certain hand of God incident either!!!!

 

Painter Flag Croydon 01 Sep 19 8.10pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Just heard Mark Halsey on Talksport the referee could have allowed play to continue and then checked with VAR after the goal was scored.

Once he blew the whistle the only decision VAR could consider is did Grealish dive or was it a penalty. Halsey felt it wasn't a dive.

This whole thing is totally blown up by the media, because of the time in the match, they went on to score after our players stopped for the whistle and it was media darling Grealish. There hasn't been a mention how Ayew was taken down in the box in the first half, which should of been a penalty.

Anyway, who cares they lost, all the column inches and so called pundits opinions isn't going to change the result.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 01 Sep 19 8.22pm

Originally posted by Painter

This whole thing is totally blown up by the media, because of the time in the match, they went on to score after our players stopped for the whistle and it was media darling Grealish. There hasn't been a mention how Ayew was taken down in the box in the first half, which should of been a penalty.

Anyway, who cares they lost, all the column inches and so called pundits opinions isn't going to change the result.


And so say all of us. 3 points to us which I am very happy with.

 

ItsCPFCforme Flag 01 Sep 19 9.05pm

Originally posted by Painter

This whole thing is totally blown up by the media, because of the time in the match, they went on to score after our players stopped for the whistle and it was media darling Grealish. There hasn't been a mention how Ayew was taken down in the box in the first half, which should of been a penalty.

Anyway, who cares they lost, all the column inches and so called pundits opinions isn't going to change the result.

Exactly. They wouldn't have given a s***e if it had happened in the 70th minute, in a game that we definitely deserved the win. Villa looked poor I thought and will find it tough to stay up.

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 01 Sep 19 11.08pm

Originally posted by ger20

No point even discussing the Gearlish incident, swings and roundabouts, how many times has a decision gone against us in the past and how many will go against us in the future, these things even themselves out over the course of a season

Absolutely. We got lucky but who cares.

 

pssguy Flag 01 Sep 19 11.30pm

Originally posted by ger20

these things even themselves out over the course of a season

Not exactly. Didn't you study the binomial distribution?

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 01 Sep 19 11.50pm

Great result and well played

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 02 Sep 19 8.40am

Villa’s manager saw a very different game than the one I was at. It’s gonna be a very long season for Villa.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 02 Sep 19 9.41am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Villa’s manager saw a very different game than the one I was at. It’s gonna be a very long season for Villa.

Garth Crooks jumps on the bandwagon and selects Grealish in his team of the week and saying it was an outrageous decision to book him for a dive saying it was a penalty for a foul by Zaha. Only thing in GC's favour he does also pick Ayew.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Sep 19 9.48am

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Garth Crooks jumps on the bandwagon and selects Grealish in his team of the week and saying it was an outrageous decision to book him for a dive saying it was a penalty for a foul by Zaha. Only thing in GC's favour he does also pick Ayew.

He needs to take a trip to 'Specsavers'.

Grealish, as he is prone to do,resembled a swimmer diving into a pool or even a dolphin rising out of the water before re-entering it and was rightly booked by the referee who had a good view of the incident.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 02 Sep 19 9.53am

Apparently in the match report the VAR officials said they would not have changed the referee's decision anyway.

Crooks Lineker Jenas all jumped in and got stuck.

We never won a thing when they were playing, and they don't even know the rules.

 

EddieMac Flag 02 Sep 19 10.48am

Jack Grealished dived and that is a fact.

He may have been nudged on his way through but he lost himself the goal by trying to make the fall more dramatic by exagerating his fall and that is what they call in this world, CHEATING.

He only has himself to blame. They could feel hard done by if they deserved a point but they deserved nothing from that match.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 02 Sep 19 10.50am

Anyone who didn't watch the game could be forgiven in thinking that 'plucky' Villa's £100m squad missed out on a heard earned point. They may however have missed McGinn stamping on Schlupp's knee, Grealish collapsing and whining throughout and Palace completely dominating the midfield (boys v men). Or the fact we had twice as many chances while their only real effort on goal was after the referee had blown (rightly or wrongly).

Villa will do better against teams who are more open, but any opposition manager who watched the game will see how easily they are bullied, so I expect them to struggle against more physical opposition like Burnley, Watford and Sheffield United.

 

askyourself Flag 02 Sep 19 11.42am

Just watched slow-mo replays as I was unsure what had happened...
There is contact with Wilf outside the box but Grealish drags his toe into the ground immediately before this contact taking him into Wilf's leg.
Grealish stumbles on, Gary Cahill sticks out his leg and pulls it back immediately and a horizontal Grealish goes over the "ghost-leg" with both his own legs trailing behind him. The ref blows for simulation.

I am available to be a MOTD footy pundit and would save the BBC cash but I'm not sure that I'd fit in.


 


We move in the direction of our thoughts.
Just think a little.

askyourself Flag 02 Sep 19 11.50am

Further to my recent post,
Exhibit A (the video with Villa commos)
[Link]

 


We move in the direction of our thoughts.
Just think a little.

Page 16 of 17 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Aston Villa Match Thread