This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
This explanation is still inexplicably passing off racism as banter. It's also complete conjecture as to whether it was taken as 'banter' at the time or just taken without complaint after constant repetition. This is exactly how bullying works – first few times the victim tries to push back and gets abused or worse, eventually gives up and just accepts it to fit in and not cause any complaint. Further, I can quite easily understand why someone whose livelihood depends on a harmonious team dynamic would not necessarily raise a complaint immediately. People aren't all confident extroverts like, as weird as it is to write, you might appear to be. And even if it was taken as banter, it's still racist, agenda or not. I'm also not taking any of this at face value, you appear to have skipped the part of my response where I clearly question his character as that is being reported but unsurprisingly not very widely. He may well be adding fuel to the fire for extra effect but ultimately have all the accusations of racism been denied? Has anyone seriously implicated mustered legal defence? Multiple defamation suits incoming? No and no. Also bizarrely from someone who hates identity politics so much you're grouping together and negatively labelling all pakistanis as unworthy of employment based on one individual. I mean, really. I think you're a bit muddled. Come off it. There are comedies currently on TV where stereotypes and nationality related jokes are used as banter and no one cares. The issue here is whether this guy was genuinely offended at the time, or whether he became retrospectively offended when it suited him. I have seen no evidence to prove that either way.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Will the word Pom now be banned? In the wider world, what about Limey? Paleface? Honkey? Round eye? What about Baldy, fatty, shorty, lanky, ginger, man, woman, big nose? I feel some retrospective offence coming on. I'm getting quite upset about what a school mate called me in 1975.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Will the word Pom now be banned? In the wider world, what about Limey? Paleface? Honkey? Round eye? What about Baldy, fatty, shorty, lanky, ginger, man, woman, big nose? I feel some retrospective offence coming on. I'm getting quite upset about what a school mate called me in 1975. If you got called all those names throughout your schooling no wonder you turned out as you did.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
If you got called all those names throughout your schooling no wonder you turned out as you did. Hrolf's complaints at being impacted by schoolyard insults really shook up some of his schoolmates. In fact to this day they are still reluctant to employ or work with white people as result of it. Edited by BlueJay (17 Nov 2021 11.07pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Again, call someone a p*ki on the field and it’s still not OK.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
They will make fun of Hrolf's point because he's white. If he wasn't you wouldn't hear a pin drop. You really just don’t get it to you? Has being called a Pom or any of the words he’s used ever systemically held you back in your life? This isn’t really about the words or language necessarily. It’s about attitudes and power. Calling someone a p*ki or a curry muncher is about putting someone in their place and making the recipient aware of where they fit in in the pecking order. You yourself have had one horrible racially motivated incident and it’s scarred you for life. Why are you so belittling of others that have faced it day in day out?
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
Again, call someone a p*ki on the field and it’s still not OK. But Pommie ******* is fine.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Come off it. There are comedies currently on TV where stereotypes and nationality related jokes are used as banter and no one cares. The issue here is whether this guy was genuinely offended at the time, or whether he became retrospectively offended when it suited him. I have seen no evidence to prove that either way. Yet again, you're mixing 'banta' stereotypes and nationality based jokes (fine) in with racist terms (not fine) and saying they're all fair game and effectively the same level. Really? Muddled. Edited by SW19 CPFC (17 Nov 2021 11.47pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
But Pommie ******* is fine. Jesus the level of ignorance on this thread is astounding
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Jesus the level of ignorance on this thread is astounding One in four people with body dysmorphia disorder have attempted suicide; having some aspect of your appearance mocked in public isn’t going to help sportspeople who might suffer from it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
But Pommie ******* is fine. Are you for real? Do you know the historical difference between P*ki and Pommie? There’s a very good reason why one is swear filtered on here and one isn’t. Would you think calling someone the N word is ‘fine’ too?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
One in four people with body dysmorphia disorder have attempted suicide; having some aspect of your appearance mocked in public isn’t going to help sportspeople who might suffer from it. Right OK, you wouldn’t call someone a sp*stic, a d*wny or anything like that these days either would you? Because that’s not ‘banter’ is it? It’s just horrible, nasty, bullying language.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
You really just don’t get it to you? Has being called a Pom or any of the words he’s used ever systemically held you back in your life? This isn’t really about the words or language necessarily. It’s about attitudes and power. Calling someone a p*ki or a curry muncher is about putting someone in their place and making the recipient aware of where they fit in in the pecking order. You yourself have had one horrible racially motivated incident and it’s scarred you for life. Why are you so belittling of others that have faced it day in day out? To say that non whites are held back in this country is a lie or said from ignorance. You have been told before but you aren't interested. The highest earning racial group in Britain are Indians.....I think Jews are amongst the highest everywhere. There are names for all groups. If being called names held people back from achieving that wouldn't be true. This cricketer wasn't held back at all....in fact I think Asian cricketers are given a step up....certainly I think Ali was wrongly identified as a test player and given far more chances than others I can think of. Yeah, I could have lost my life back as a teenager. However, it didn't change how I thought about this stuff. I always knew that different groups had preference....My conversion was in response to the kind of anti white working class stuff that I hear everyday now....and that's mainly from Guardian reading middle class whites who fetishize minorities and wouldn't know the reality of being a white teenager in 80s Brixton if it bit them in the arse. Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Nov 2021 12.31am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
To say that non whites are held back in this country is a lie or said from ignorance. You have been told before but you aren't interested. The highest earning racial group in Britain are Indians.....I think Jews are amongst the highest everywhere. There are names for all groups. If being called names held people back from achieving that wouldn't be true. This cricketer wasn't held back at all....in fact I think Asian cricketers are given a step up....certainly I think Ali was wrongly identified as a test player and given far more chances than others I can think of. Again your loose grasp of statistical understanding holds you back here. On what measure are ‘Indians’ the highest earning. And ‘Jews’ ‘highest everywhere’? On what measure is this? What metrics are you using? I am interested and I haven’t seen anything you’ve ever stated that ever offers anything that delivers backed up evidence.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
Right OK, you wouldn’t call someone a sp*stic, a d*wny or anything like that these days either would you? Because that’s not ‘banter’ is it? It’s just horrible, nasty, bullying language. Yes it is but sledging isn't generally banter. Sometimes there are genuine jokes but often comments are meant to be as hurtful and off-putting as possible.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
Again your loose grasp of statistical understanding holds you back here. On what measure are ‘Indians’ the highest earning. And ‘Jews’ ‘highest everywhere’? On what measure is this? What metrics are you using? I am interested and I haven’t seen anything you’ve ever stated that ever offers anything that delivers backed up evidence. The people who earn the most are from those groups. If this was a racist society then that wouldn't be allowed to happen. Tell me Dan, why would a 'racist' society allow that to happen. It's not allowed to happen in pakistan for example. A 'racist' society wouldn't care about what context it was....it wouldn't be allowed to happen in any. I've shown statistics related to these in the past....I'm not going to do it again and again....Do your own research. Whites are not the top racial earners. Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Nov 2021 12.32am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Yes it is but sledging isn't generally banter. Sometimes there are genuine jokes but often comments are meant to be as hurtful and off-putting as possible. This wasn’t stuff said in the heat of the moment though was it? There’s a great moment where Joe Root called out one of the West Indies bowlers for using homophobic language not that long ago between deliveries. It takes bigger balls to stand up for it than it does to try and intimidate someone with it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
Are you for real? Do you know the historical difference between P*ki and Pommie? There’s a very good reason why one is swear filtered on here and one isn’t. Would you think calling someone the N word is ‘fine’ too? Yes. Pommie is thought to come from Pomegranate which was Australian slang for immigrant.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.