This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by pssguy
We have Ayew, Zaha, Olise and Edouard to play across the front. Mateta could also feature if we need a big man and can, I believe, still appear in up to half the remaining premier league games without triggering a permanent move. Rak-Sakyi also looks like the most likely Academy prospect to step forward, if required. It seems to me that Gallagher will leave such a big hole next year that funds should be spared for that area. In midfield, unless they move Andersen there as the defensive guard - in which case a new central defender will be critical - We have Eze and Hughes who can be regarded as premier league quality going forward. McArthur cannot last at this level much longer and Kouyate is also long in the tooth and a liability on the ball. Schlupp is a handy sub, Milivojevic and Riedewald barely that Very sound reasoning ... we have some potentially interesting youth players coming through and may see more from them in the coming weeks especially if we have a decent Cup run. Potential sales of Benteke, and possibly Wilf, could help to fund some recruitment but I doubt we'll see either go before the end of this season.
Denial is not just a river in Egypt |
|
|
Originally posted by pssguy
We have Ayew, Zaha, Olise and Edouard to play across the front. Mateta could also feature if we need a big man and can, I believe, still appear in up to half the remaining premier league games without triggering a permanent move. Rak-Sakyi also looks like the most likely Academy prospect to step forward, if required. It seems to me that Gallagher will leave such a big hole next year that funds should be spared for that area. In midfield, unless they move Andersen there as the defensive guard - in which case a new central defender will be critical - We have Eze and Hughes who can be regarded as premier league quality going forward. McArthur cannot last at this level much longer and Kouyate is also long in the tooth and a liability on the ball. Schlupp is a handy sub, Milivojevic and Riedewald barely that Are you Bentekes agent?
|
|
|
Originally posted by monkey
I’ve never taken to Benteke anyway. Whatever the argument about him not getting the service, whether that’s wrong or right, he just hasn’t got that fire in his belly. He doesn’t work hard enough to make things happen, he doesn’t attack the ball in the area and he certainly doesn’t put himself about and let defenders know he’s there. Many a pundit has commented on this over the last two or three years. A gentle giant as martin Tyler called him recently. He wants the ball on a plate all the time and as for best header in Europe as Pardew labelled him?? Do me a favour!! I’d rather keep Mateta So basically I’d get shot of him tomorrow if it was my decision Here here!!
|
|
|
Originally posted by pssguy
We have Ayew, Zaha, Olise and Edouard to play across the front. Mateta could also feature if we need a big man and can, I believe, still appear in up to half the remaining premier league games without triggering a permanent move. Rak-Sakyi also looks like the most likely Academy prospect to step forward, if required. It seems to me that Gallagher will leave such a big hole next year that funds should be spared for that area. In midfield, unless they move Andersen there as the defensive guard - in which case a new central defender will be critical - We have Eze and Hughes who can be regarded as premier league quality going forward. McArthur cannot last at this level much longer and Kouyate is also long in the tooth and a liability on the ball. Schlupp is a handy sub, Milivojevic and Riedewald barely that There seems to be an obsession with some on here around selling players for fear of them walking away for nothing at the end of their contracts. We already have evidence from last summer that the club do not view this as a matter for concern. Currently we have two players of similar style in Benteke and Mateta. If you subscribe to the view that they don't suit our style of play then surely it's more cost effective to not play the £13m for Mateta , send him back and keep Benteke as we don't need both. And if Newcastle want to buy him, let them make an offer - or any other club for that matter ! Why would you move an established defender in Andersen, to a position he's untried at and then go into the market for a new central defender ? Why not look to replace the midfield player ?? The squad needs further work and that will come in the summer. I think we are largely ok with what we have to get us through this season. The main question seems to be around exiting Mateta and possibly bringing in Nketiah.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
There seems to be an obsession with some on here around selling players for fear of them walking away for nothing at the end of their contracts. We already have evidence from last summer that the club do not view this as a matter for concern. How much of that lack of concern was due to the fact that John Textor was waiting in the wings with a substantial sum available for squad rebuilding
|
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Funnily enough, I was thinking he would suit Newcastle. They cross a lot but have no centre forward without Wilson. Just imagine their fans' reactions yeah they’re crap as well
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
How much of that lack of concern was due to the fact that John Textor was waiting in the wings with a substantial sum available for squad rebuilding We'll never know of course. Those contracts were allowed to wind down over a long period and I have no idea when contact was first made with Textor. And it's entirely possible that his investment enables the club to continue to be unconcerned when it comes to Zaha, Benteke etc. Interestingly, the media ( and/or JP's agent ) are now trying to link Newcastle with a move for Mateta Edited by NEILLO (11 Jan 2022 10.00am)
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
The squad needs further work and that will come in the summer. I think we are largely ok with what we have to get us through this season. The main question seems to be around exiting Mateta and possibly bringing in Nketiah.
2. I agree with your comments re our current squad being able to see us through the season and that the main question is the one about Mateta v Nketiah. Re the latter, I'm wondering if he's delaying in the hope he'll feature in the two Carabao cup semis against Liverpool. If Arsenal win, he may want to stay in the hope of featuring in the final and possibly winning a cup medal. If they lose he may then leave in what remains of this window.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Phil’s Barber
Nketiah is not the answer to our striker issues and lack of goals and I hope to high heaven that he isn’t being lined up as Benteke’s replacement (even though I am more than happy for Benteke to be off loaded). Edited by Phil’s Barber (11 Jan 2022 11.40am) If PV is trying to develop a Man City II team then we are looking for a mobile tricky striker who can play across the front. Benteke certainly doesn't fill that role. I haven't seen enough of Nketiah but presumable PV has so we have to trust his judgement.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
I think Amazon are recruiting at the moment, but he probably drop everything He'd be ok until it got to the box
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by Speronilover69 8=D~~
I don't agree that Benteke and Mateta don't suit our style of play. We have plenty of nippy, skilful strikers at the club (Zaha, Ayew, Edouard) yet PV continually opts to go with a target man. It seems like the plan under PV is to build up possession in the wide areas and get plenty of crosses into the box for Mateta/Benteke to eat up. PV favours target men so if Mateta and/or Benteke do leave, we should try and replace them with better versions of Benteke and Mateta. Ben Bereton at Blackburn is the kind of striker we should be looking at imo (although we have probably missed the boat with him as Newcastle seem to be sniffing around) or the Swiss international Breel Embolo. I don't think Nketiah is the answer to our problems tbh, although I would happily be proven wrong. I reckon PV would just end up playing Nketiah out wide and lord knows we have more than enough wide players atm. Benteke doesn't suit anybody's style (sorry i cant help myself)
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
If PV is trying to develop a Man City II team then we are looking for a mobile tricky striker who can play across the front. Benteke certainly doesn't fill that role. I haven't seen enough of Nketiah but presumable PV has so we have to trust his judgement. I fully accept your point Badger, you have to be concerned though that respected people in the club have allegedly done previous due diligence on the likes of Sorloth, Sanogo, Shola Ameobi & Jordan Mutch!
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.