You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 16 2026 8.22am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Coronavirus (LOCKED)


Page 163 of 753 < 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 >
ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 18 Apr 20 1.50pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Keir Starmer involved and of course no prosecution because fortunately the expenses rules were a bit loose and open to interpretation.

Robbing the tax payer for years and should be in prison. Was interesting how Starmer got her off. I doubt he Corbyn-Abbotted it though.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Stirlingsays Flag 18 Apr 20 2.05pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Robbing the tax payer for years and should be in prison. Was interesting how Starmer got her off. I doubt he Corbyn-Abbotted it though.

If they could make an expences claim for that as well, you just know they would.

Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Apr 2020 2.06pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 18 Apr 20 2.08pm

Originally posted by cryrst

You expect facts from china. Ha ha you cannot be that gullible to think less than 5k people died.
Look at the facts. Smaller countries have more deaths than china. Do you beleive that could be the truth.

Smaller countries without the same degree of control as China who were able to, forcibly if necessary, impose a severe lockdown. They seemingly were the first country to suffer an outbreak and, with the benefit of hindsight, look as though they reacted a little later than was ideal but when they did it was very thorough, receiving praise from everyone. Trump included.

I don't expect anything from anyone. I expect a full, unrestricted investigation to reveal the truth. Politics always has a tendency to obscure the truth.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Teddy Eagle Flag 18 Apr 20 2.12pm

China’s total is rising.

[Link]

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 18 Apr 20 2.28pm

Interesting piece addressing some misconceptions about how animals transmit diseases.

[Link]

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 18 Apr 20 2.31pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

1. And how do you know that approach won’t work? We know the calm reflective one doesn’t because that’s exactly what’s been done before. A few times. You might not like it but you don’t know.
2. What’s killing people is allowing conditions in a certain country to continue without censure.
3. On 30 March Maxine Walters criticised Trump for authorising sending 17.8 tons of P. P. E. to China to help with the crisis there. Was that the same political game being played?

Knee jerk reactions with only partial information to hand are rarely the best route to resolving problems. With something as serious as this reacting like that is simply stupid.

We haven't, so far as I am aware, carried out any internationally organised, meaningful, calm and measured investigations into the cause of these outbreaks that has resulted in the kind of effective recommendations being made and then insisted upon being followed that are now clearly needed. These have to be run by the UN with unequivocal support from all members of the security council, for a matter of security it surely is.

I had to look up the tweet from Maxine Waters as it was new to me. It reads:-

"Trump, you incompetent idiot! You sent 18 tons of PPE to China early but ignored warnings & called COVID19 concerns a hoax. You've endangered doctors, nurses, aids, orderlies, & janitors - all risking their lives to save ours. Pray 4 forgiveness for the harm that you're causing!"

The Trump administration did send the PPE, at a time when they were downplaying the risk to the USA and praising China's response.

Water's tweet seems a reasonable enough response to me, in the context of the way the crisis has been politicised by Trump. It's not the way I would like things done but if Trump starts playing politics then you must expect his opponents to respond.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 18 Apr 20 2.46pm

Originally posted by samprior

Interesting piece addressing some misconceptions about how animals transmit diseases.

[Link]

Thanks. Very interesting and informative piece.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 18 Apr 20 2.49pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Knee jerk reactions with only partial information to hand are rarely the best route to resolving problems. With something as serious as this reacting like that is simply stupid.

We haven't, so far as I am aware, carried out any internationally organised, meaningful, calm and measured investigations into the cause of these outbreaks that has resulted in the kind of effective recommendations being made and then insisted upon being followed that are now clearly needed. These have to be run by the UN with unequivocal support from all members of the security council, for a matter of security it surely is.

I had to look up the tweet from Maxine Waters as it was new to me. It reads:-

"Trump, you incompetent idiot! You sent 18 tons of PPE to China early but ignored warnings & called COVID19 concerns a hoax. You've endangered doctors, nurses, aids, orderlies, & janitors - all risking their lives to save ours. Pray 4 forgiveness for the harm that you're causing!"

The Trump administration did send the PPE, at a time when they were downplaying the risk to the USA and praising China's response.

Water's tweet seems a reasonable enough response to me, in the context of the way the crisis has been politicised by Trump. It's not the way I would like things done but if Trump starts playing politics then you must expect his opponents to respond.

Are we all rolling back then on the fact that this started in China? We must have had that flashy pen from Men in Black used on us.
China admitted it around a month or two after it started. And it was China that gave info about the source.
This isn't the first time these wet markets have been the source of a pandemic. In fact, it's the third time.
So from simple facts: WHO did not force China to stop these practices after two pandemics. China admitted being the cause of this too - yet the only thing they have done in response is reclassify dogs as pets.
I hardly think this is an appropriate or responsible response by either China or the WHO. What do you think?
As for Trump - he had this problem forced on him through the acts of others, out of his control - as have we all.

Edited by ASCPFC (18 Apr 2020 2.55pm)

 


Red and Blue Army!

Teddy Eagle Flag 18 Apr 20 3.02pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Knee jerk reactions with only partial information to hand are rarely the best route to resolving problems. With something as serious as this reacting like that is simply stupid.

We haven't, so far as I am aware, carried out any internationally organised, meaningful, calm and measured investigations into the cause of these outbreaks that has resulted in the kind of effective recommendations being made and then insisted upon being followed that are now clearly needed. These have to be run by the UN with unequivocal support from all members of the security council, for a matter of security it surely is.

I had to look up the tweet from Maxine Waters as it was new to me. It reads:-

"Trump, you incompetent idiot! You sent 18 tons of PPE to China early but ignored warnings & called COVID19 concerns a hoax. You've endangered doctors, nurses, aids, orderlies, & janitors - all risking their lives to save ours. Pray 4 forgiveness for the harm that you're causing!"

The Trump administration did send the PPE, at a time when they were downplaying the risk to the USA and praising China's response.

Water's tweet seems a reasonable enough response to me, in the context of the way the crisis has been politicised by Trump. It's not the way I would like things done but if Trump starts playing politics then you must expect his opponents to respond.

OK, so this measured response will have a different outcome because...?
Trump was wrong for sending assistance to China and he’s wrong for blaming them for the situation.
Trump’s opponents are right for responding to him but he’s wrong for responding to them.
The UN? Right. That’ll work.

[Link]


 

Stirlingsays Flag 18 Apr 20 3.04pm

Originally posted by samprior

Interesting piece addressing some misconceptions about how animals transmit diseases.

[Link]

I found it mainly to be 'meh'.

However in the conclusion it made two points I feel should be pushed back on.

'Preserving ecosystems and restoring natural habitats can ensure animals don’t need to forage near where humans live. Risky behaviours that expose people to pathogens can be reduced – not by imposing harmful bans on wild meat – but through community engagement that’s respectful of different livelihoods and cultural practices. '

The first point would result in a population increase in animals, which means the exact opposite of its suggestion.

On the second point. while 'community engagement' is fair enough, if you're going to push cultural relativism then these practices are ultimately going to continue....So it's nothing but waffle. The Chinese government need to ban these markets or regulate them tightly on animal welfare....which is almost a joke to say.

Perhaps the British should have pushed 'community engagement' on Hindu widows being sacrificed on the burning funeral pyres of their dead husbands rather than outright banning the practice....as we rightly did.

Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Apr 2020 3.07pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 18 Apr 20 3.30pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Are we all rolling back then on the fact that this started in China? We must have had that flashy pen from Men in Black used on us.
China admitted it around a month or two after it started. And it was China that gave info about the source.
This isn't the first time these wet markets have been the source of a pandemic. In fact, it's the third time.
So from simple facts: WHO did not force China to stop these practices after two pandemics. China admitted being the cause of this too - yet the only thing they have done in response is reclassify dogs as pets.
I hardly think this is an appropriate or responsible response by either China or the WHO. What do you think?
As for Trump - he had this problem forced on him through the acts of others, out of his control - as have we all.

Edited by ASCPFC (18 Apr 2020 2.55pm)

What do I think? I think you are jumping on a very overloaded band wagon. No one doubts that the first recorded cases happened in China. How is another matter. I suggest you read the link provided by samprior, which was thoughtful and contained a lot of rational good common sense.

My argument about Trump is not that he didn't have this problem forced on him. We all have. It's how he's policising it when he ought to be concentrating 100% on minimising it's impact. Whether that means structured releases of the lockdowns or anything else, is a separate issue. Using China and the WHO as scapegoats in a blame game achieves nothing and helps no-one. It just winds up his support base.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 18 Apr 20 3.44pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

OK, so this measured response will have a different outcome because...?
Trump was wrong for sending assistance to China and he’s wrong for blaming them for the situation.
Trump’s opponents are right for responding to him but he’s wrong for responding to them.
The UN? Right. That’ll work.

[Link]


No Trump wasn't wrong for sending PPE to China if he genuinely believed there was no risk to the USA. If the medical experts were warning him that there was a risk, and he ignored it, then yes he was wrong. Which do you think was true?

He is certainly wrong to blame them for the situation. It's much to early to apportion blame and pretty stupid to do at any time. No-one wants this kind of thing do they? Read the link provided by samprior. We are all in this together. There is far too much divisiveness created by Trump and this is another, very dangerous, manifestation of that side of his hugely flawed character.

Whether Waters should have responded like that is an open question. I wouldn't, but I am not a political opponent of Trump trying to deal with him in the weird world he has created.

The Guardian article contains some good points. The biggest I picked up was how Trump's determination to abandon the traditional leadership of the USA in international peacekeeping roles, among others, is throwing the door open for China to walk through. The consequences of that can only be guessed at but are unlikely to be beneficial to the western world.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Teddy Eagle Flag 18 Apr 20 4.01pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

No Trump wasn't wrong for sending PPE to China if he genuinely believed there was no risk to the USA. If the medical experts were warning him that there was a risk, and he ignored it, then yes he was wrong. Which do you think was true?

He is certainly wrong to blame them for the situation. It's much to early to apportion blame and pretty stupid to do at any time. No-one wants this kind of thing do they? Read the link provided by samprior. We are all in this together. There is far too much divisiveness created by Trump and this is another, very dangerous, manifestation of that side of his hugely flawed character.

Whether Waters should have responded like that is an open question. I wouldn't, but I am not a political opponent of Trump trying to deal with him in the weird world he has created.

The Guardian article contains some good points. The biggest I picked up was how Trump's determination to abandon the traditional leadership of the USA in international peacekeeping roles, among others, is throwing the door open for China to walk through. The consequences of that can only be guessed at but are unlikely to be beneficial to the western world.

Or the equipment was sent as a humanitarian gesture to help people who were at risk and suffering.
Wrong to blame the country in which the virus started and which has subsequently reopened, with WHO support, the wet markets thought to be responsible.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 18 Apr 20 4.14pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Or the equipment was sent as a humanitarian gesture to help people who were at risk and suffering.

I don't think it's wrong at all to help others but I can understand those who, in his own country do, if they believe he knew an outbreak in the USA was likely.

Wrong to blame the country in which the virus started and which has subsequently reopened, with WHO support, the wet markets thought to be responsible.

When there's no discernible benefit to anyone, or anything, other than his own chances of re-election then blaming anyone is stupid. Especially when there is no actual proof that the wet markets were actually responsible. There is loads of innuendo and finger pointing, so that it seems this has now become an established fact in many people's minds. The truth though is that innuendo is not evidence and the truth is not yet known, and may never be known. Read that article from "The Conversation"!

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 18 Apr 20 4.42pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

China’s total is rising.

[Link]

Apparently they realised the abacus wasn't working correctly. I still take that number with a pinch of salt.

Edited by Badger11 (18 Apr 2020 4.43pm)

 


One more point

Teddy Eagle Flag 18 Apr 20 4.52pm

Providing help to contain the outbreak at source makes as much, if not more, sense than stockpiling in case the infection spreads.
Calling attention to the origin, and falsifying of evidence, will work if it prevents a future virus from spreading.

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 18 Apr 20 5.05pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I found it mainly to be 'meh'.

However in the conclusion it made two points I feel should be pushed back on.

'Preserving ecosystems and restoring natural habitats can ensure animals don’t need to forage near where humans live. Risky behaviours that expose people to pathogens can be reduced – not by imposing harmful bans on wild meat – but through community engagement that’s respectful of different livelihoods and cultural practices. '

The first point would result in a population increase in animals, which means the exact opposite of its suggestion.

On the second point. while 'community engagement' is fair enough, if you're going to push cultural relativism then these practices are ultimately going to continue....So it's nothing but waffle. The Chinese government need to ban these markets or regulate them tightly on animal welfare....which is almost a joke to say.

Perhaps the British should have pushed 'community engagement' on Hindu widows being sacrificed on the burning funeral pyres of their dead husbands rather than outright banning the practice....as we rightly did.

Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Apr 2020 3.07pm)

Not necessarily, in their own natural habitat and preserved ecosystem, nature has developed a pretty decent mechanism for keeping things in balance. Go to any large area of nature and you'll find it's coping pretty well at keeping the equilibrium unless we've introduced a foreign species into the environment.

Community engagement is key but as you say it's pretty hard to administer. It's certainly not a quick fix but that doesn't mean we should just give up. It's one area the when performed correctly will have a major and lasting effects.

I spent 9months in SEasia last year (yes I know lucky me - and no I didnt eat bat, but did meet a few people hunting them in rural areas) and got to witness a lot of the issues we've been speaking about first hand when visiting some of the more remote areas. I've listed below one of the projects I visited who are working so hard to combat a lot of the issues discussed.
[Link]

I've not got the writing skills to convey quite how eye opening the experience it was. A huge problem in this area was the poaching of wild animals to be sold on the black market to China particularly the Tiger. Almost eradicating the apex predator from the area has had a major knock on effect. But obviously making it illegal does not stop it happening as it's hard to stop the locals from potentially earning a lifetimes wage with one catch. Hence highlighting the importance of these kinds of initiatives that works with, informs and rewards locals.

I think anyone who points the finger at China for these issues is absolutely right to do so, but only when they are also doing everything in their power to sort their own backyard out at the same time. Just one relevant example that immediately springs to mind are the figures presented the insane 'The Tiger King' documentary, which stated there are currently double the amount of tigers in US captivity than there are in the wild in the rest of the world.

So I think animal welfare in China and the rest of the world should definitely be one of our priorities going forward, but maybe that's just because I'm a quinoa eating hippy.

The issues we are facing with this virus is so complex and nuanced that offering simple solutions or pretending that a simple solution can be found, put simply, is a waste of time.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 18 Apr 20 5.14pm

Originally posted by samprior

Not necessarily, in their own natural habitat and preserved ecosystem, nature has developed a pretty decent mechanism for keeping things in balance. Go to any large area of nature and you'll find it's coping pretty well at keeping the equilibrium unless we've introduced a foreign species into the environment.

Community engagement is key but as you say it's pretty hard to administer. It's certainly not a quick fix but that doesn't mean we should just give up. It's one area the when performed correctly will have a major and lasting effects.

I spent 9months in SEasia last year (yes I know lucky me - and no I didnt eat bat, but did meet a few people hunting them in rural areas) and got to witness a lot of the issues we've been speaking about first hand when visiting some of the more remote areas. I've listed below one of the projects I visited who are working so hard to combat a lot of the issues discussed.
[Link]

I've not got the writing skills to convey quite how eye opening the experience it was. A huge problem in this area was the poaching of wild animals to be sold on the black market to China particularly the Tiger. Almost eradicating the apex predator from the area has had a major knock on effect. But obviously making it illegal does not stop it happening as it's hard to stop the locals from potentially earning a lifetimes wage with one catch. Hence highlighting the importance of these kinds of initiatives that works with, informs and rewards locals.

I think anyone who points the finger at China for these issues is absolutely right to do so, but only when they are also doing everything in their power to sort their own backyard out at the same time. Just one relevant example that immediately springs to mind are the figures presented the insane 'The Tiger King' documentary, which stated there are currently double the amount of tigers in US captivity than there are in the wild in the rest of the world.

So I think animal welfare in China and the rest of the world should definitely be one of our priorities going forward, but maybe that's just because I'm a quinoa eating hippy.

The issues we are facing with this virus is so complex and nuanced that offering simple solutions or pretending that a simple solution can be found, put simply, is a waste of time.

Excellent points and very well made.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 18 Apr 20 5.30pm

Originally posted by samprior

Not necessarily, in their own natural habitat and preserved ecosystem, nature has developed a pretty decent mechanism for keeping things in balance. Go to any large area of nature and you'll find it's coping pretty well at keeping the equilibrium unless we've introduced a foreign species into the environment.

Give an example.

Originally posted by samprior

Community engagement is key but as you say it's pretty hard to administer. It's certainly not a quick fix but that doesn't mean we should just give up. It's one area the when performed correctly will have a major and lasting effects.

I'm not against 'community engagement' however again, you could give an example of it working better than laws and regulations.


Originally posted by samprior

So I think animal welfare in China and the rest of the world should definitely be one of our priorities going forward, but maybe that's just because I'm a quinoa eating hippy.

The issues we are facing with this virus is so complex and nuanced that offering simple solutions or pretending that a simple solution can be found, put simply, is a waste of time.

Laws are not 'simple solutions', they are consequences for actions that if drafted effectively work over time far better than cultural relativism.

A well written post though.

Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Apr 2020 5.36pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

samprior Flag Hamburg 18 Apr 20 6.08pm

Originally posted by samprior
Not necessarily, in their own natural habitat and preserved ecosystem, nature has developed a pretty decent mechanism for keeping things in balance. Go to any large area of nature and you'll find it's coping pretty well at keeping the equilibrium unless we've introduced a foreign species into the environment.

Give an example. - I mean just take a look round wherever the closest woodland is to you.

Originally posted by samprior
Community engagement is key but as you say it's pretty hard to administer. It's certainly not a quick fix but that doesn't mean we should just give up. It's one area the when performed correctly will have a major and lasting effects.

I'm not against 'community engagement' however again, you could give an example of it working better than laws and regulations. - I don't think it necessarily works better but will be equally important to any laws and regulations being put in place. The example of the project I gave was one where it is having a positive effect in the area where before the law was just regualarly flouted.

Originally posted by samprior
So I think animal welfare in China and the rest of the world should definitely be one of our priorities going forward, but maybe that's just because I'm a quinoa eating hippy.

The issues we are facing with this virus is so complex and nuanced that offering simple solutions or pretending that a simple solution can be found, put simply, is a waste of time.

Laws are not 'simple solutions', they are consequences for actions that if drafted effectively work over time far better than cultural relativism.

Certainly on some issues but I'm more skeptical of their effectiveness in isolation (however well implemented) in regards to illegal trade. The war on drugs has the clearest, strictest laws imaginable but have very little overall effect. If you're not working with the communities at each end of the trade then I've very little faith in laws having much of an impact. Where there's demand the supply will always find a way.

A well written post though. - cheers but I'll never work out how to do the multiple quote/response thing. Matteo did once try to explain it to me.


Edited by samprior (18 Apr 2020 6.10pm)

Edited by samprior (18 Apr 2020 6.11pm)

 

Page 163 of 753 < 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic