You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread
November 16 2026 4.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Benteke thread


Page 165 of 166 < 161 162 163 164 165 166 >
Glazier#1 Flag 03 Jun 21 2.39pm

The contract's invalid - his signature missed the dotted line.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 03 Jun 21 4.36pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


Doesn't matter if new manager wants him or not he is an asset by signing him again means he has value otherwise he walks for free.

I believe new manager has already had handshake deal done with the club and the SP will hold of on announcement until he sees it as best time to gain from it maybe same time new kit is launched.

Regarding Benteke I said it the whole time and over 90% on here just kept saying I was wrong he is useless etc well a large % of that 90 have sure changed their tunes.

You can have the best striker in the world if you do not give them service and a few others things they wont do anything look at Messi at International level.

Edited by grumpymort (03 Jun 2021 2.01pm)


Agree with you on this GM. Benteke is an asset and now that he's stressing that he's fit and free of injury, he's delivering and it's not just been the last 4 games. He had a good couple of games before Christmas prior to that ridiculous sending off at W Ham for daring to jump for the ball twice and has been good since coming on for the Brighton winner. I'm hopeful he will pick up where he left off BUT he needs the right balls into the box.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 03 Jun 21 4.54pm

On one hand Benteke is an asset with transfer market value of course, which we have now protected. On the other hand but he is also a cost, even at reduced wages (if that's the case).

The third aspect, and the way I look at it, is that to replace Benteke (which we would have to do if he left) would have a cost, and we have now avoided that.

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 03 Jun 21 7.40pm

Let's just hope Benteke rewards us by continuing to play like he has in the last few months and not in the last few years...

I have my doubts...

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 03 Jun 21 11.35pm

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

Let's just hope Benteke rewards us by continuing to play like he has in the last few months and not in the last few years...

I have my doubts...

Lets hope so Kenny, I think an injury free Benny will thrive if the new manager makes him the main man, now wilf wants out.Feed the beast and he will deliver, but like any top striker he needs to be fed!Well done on new contract Christian, glad to have you signed!

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 04 Jun 21 10.47am

If we get the Benteke of 2021 then it’s a no brainer. Trouble is I fear he will revert to the Benteke of the previous 3 seasons now he has a fat contract for another 2 years.

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 04 Jun 21 12.09pm

Originally posted by rednblueblood

My question is why are we giving him a contract extension with no manager in place, what’s the point if the new head honcho doesn’t fancy him and never plays him. Is this a case of our new manager has already agreed terms and wants Big Ben in his plans.....,,, I think I may have answered my own question.

I think because regardless of who the new manager is, a new striker costs >£20m. Abraham is being touted at £35m.

If we spend that, we don't fix the defence properly which will see us relegated. There's no-one else on a free as good as Benteke, and no-one who will do so much more than Benteke that spending >£20m on the difference is good business. We therefore never really had a choice to do anything other than extend Benteke and let him fight it out with Mateta to be the main striker next year.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 04 Jun 21 12.40pm

Originally posted by ambrose7

I think because regardless of who the new manager is, a new striker costs >£20m. Abraham is being touted at £35m.

If we spend that, we don't fix the defence properly which will see us relegated. There's no-one else on a free as good as Benteke, and no-one who will do so much more than Benteke that spending >£20m on the difference is good business. We therefore never really had a choice to do anything other than extend Benteke and let him fight it out with Mateta to be the main striker next year.


100% this for those who still wonder why we've extended Benteke's contract. We can now focus whatever transfer/loan fee budget we have on fixing other parts of the squad where we are desperate e.g. CB and midfield.

Extending Benteke's contract was a sensible pragmatic decision given our situation.

 

GujiRascal Flag Lambeth 05 Jun 21 3.23pm

Given our predicament we were left with little choice.

It is yet to be seen if Tekker's end of season exploits can be carried into next season. I have been and still am sceptical whether he still can be what he should be. That is a 15 goal a season striker.

That said, I'll settle for 10. Is that worth the money? Given the alternatives I would have to say yes.

At the end of the day, we had little choice.

 


Glass half full.

Den1923 Flag 07 Jun 21 11.27am

Originally posted by doombear


100% this for those who still wonder why we've extended Benteke's contract. We can now focus whatever transfer/loan fee budget we have on fixing other parts of the squad where we are desperate e.g. CB and midfield.

Extending Benteke's contract was a sensible pragmatic decision given our situation.[/quote]

We need a new ''lame duck'' to replace Wickham in orer to keep Parish happy!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Jun 21 11.38am

Originally posted by GujiRascal

Given our predicament we were left with little choice.

It is yet to be seen if Tekker's end of season exploits can be carried into next season. I have been and still am sceptical whether he still can be what he should be. That is a 15 goal a season striker.

That said, I'll settle for 10. Is that worth the money? Given the alternatives I would have to say yes.

At the end of the day, we had little choice.

Benteke scored a goal in his last 4 games, in fact he scored 5 goals in his last 7 games. Prolific !

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 07 Jun 21 11.53am

Originally posted by Willo

Benteke scored a goal in his last 4 games, in fact he scored 5 goals in his last 7 games. Prolific !


His record over the whole season was a goal very 182 minutes which equates to a goal every 2 games which most top strikers would be happy with.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Jun 21 12.00pm

Originally posted by doombear


His record over the whole season was a goal very 182 minutes which equates to a goal every 2 games which most top strikers would be happy with.

Thank you Doombear.I do like a good stat !

I believe that in the main,supporters were pleasantly surprised at how Benteke turned around his fortunes and let's hope he carries on the good work next season.

 

Den1923 Flag 07 Jun 21 2.46pm

Originally posted by doombear


His record over the whole season was a goal very 182 minutes which equates to a goal every 2 games which most top strikers would be happy with.

or 31 goals in five season at a cost of nearly 2mil per goal, great value!

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 07 Jun 21 4.48pm

Originally posted by Den1923

or 31 goals in five season at a cost of nearly 2mil per goal, great value!


He now has 2 seasons to show that his recent form is no flash in the pan. If he does then it will have been worth extending his contract rather than letting him go and forking out £30m on a new striker, money that would be better used on other more pressing needs. Also, if he performs next season, other clubs may even want to buy him for a decent fee, which we might choose to accept if Mateta shows he can do the business.

 

Den1923 Flag 07 Jun 21 7.48pm

Originally posted by doombear


He now has 2 seasons to show that his recent form is no flash in the pan. If he does then it will have been worth extending his contract rather than letting him go and forking out £30m on a new striker, money that would be better used on other more pressing needs. Also, if he performs next season, other clubs may even want to buy him for a decent fee, which we might choose to accept if Mateta shows he can do the business.

Tell that to Brentford who have found two strikers Watkin/Toney) that cost no where near 30mil that you are suggesting. Benteke is not a modern day striker he has no pace lacks ability and vision or the desire to press defenders off the ball and he also lacks the necessary ground skills and workrate to be succesful striker in the modern game. No body in the English pl has showing any interest in him and rightly so. He is another white elephant just like Wickham. I respect your views but on this occasion we have to disagree!

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 07 Jun 21 10.11pm

Originally posted by Den1923

Tell that to Brentford who have found two strikers Watkin/Toney) that cost no where near 30mil that you are suggesting. Benteke is not a modern day striker he has no pace lacks ability and vision or the desire to press defenders off the ball and he also lacks the necessary ground skills and workrate to be succesful striker in the modern game. No body in the English pl has showing any interest in him and rightly so. He is another white elephant just like Wickham. I respect your views but on this occasion we have to disagree!


Sorry Den but I'm not quite sure what we are disagreeing about. I agree that over the 5 years he's been here Benteke has NOT been good value. However, IMO, given that we really need any transfer funds we have to strengthen and rejuvenate our central defence and midfield, it seems a sensible decision to keep Benteke for the time being now that he has shown a return to some kind of decent form.

As for Watkins and Toney, Brentford bought them to play in the Championship, not in the PL. Although Watkins has done well at Villa (after a £30m move), was he really ready for PL football when he joined Brentford two years earlier? I doubt it. As for Toney, it remains to be seen whether he can hack in the PL, although I was disappointed we didn't go for him ourselves last summer when he was rumoured to be linked with us. Mitrovic at Fulham has shown how scoring lots of goals in the Championship can be very deceptive when it comes to being a PL striker. And as for the £20m Brewster at Sheff U, the less said the better.

 

Den1923 Flag 08 Jun 21 6.35pm

Originally posted by doombear


Sorry Den but I'm not quite sure what we are disagreeing about. I agree that over the 5 years he's been here Benteke has NOT been good value. However, IMO, given that we really need any transfer funds we have to strengthen and rejuvenate our central defence and midfield, it seems a sensible decision to keep Benteke for the time being now that he has shown a return to some kind of decent form.

As for Watkins and Toney, Brentford bought them to play in the Championship, not in the PL. Although Watkins has done well at Villa (after a £30m move), was he really ready for PL football when he joined Brentford two years earlier? I doubt it. As for Toney, it remains to be seen whether he can hack in the PL, although I was disappointed we didn't go for him ourselves last summer when he was rumoured to be linked with us. Mitrovic at Fulham has shown how scoring lots of goals in the Championship can be very deceptive when it comes to being a PL striker. And as for the £20m Brewster at Sheff U, the less said the better.

Dear doombear, it's great to know that we are mainly on the same page. My concern is that Parish has extended the contract of Benteke without knowing who our next manager is likely to be, if it is Nano as the press are suggesting then I'm concerned that like Klopp before him, Benteke is not going to suite the way he wants to play as Benetke is very limited and really is not mobile enough for the modern game. I agree that we do need to strengthen in both defence and midfield but we do also need a proven goalscorer with pace and vision whether J-P Mateta is that player I do not know, we have not seen enough of him to form an opinion as yet. Like you I agree money is going to be tight and not much of it, coupled with a board where 2 out three of the main player want out the future is somewhat uncertain and of concern!

 

Mstrobez Flag 08 Jun 21 6.40pm

Originally posted by Den1923

Dear doombear, it's great to know that we are mainly on the same page. My concern is that Parish has extended the contract of Benteke without knowing who our next manager is likely to be, if it is Nano as the press are suggesting then I'm concerned that like Klopp before him, Benteke is not going to suite the way he wants to play as Benetke is very limited and really is not mobile enough for the modern game. I agree that we do need to strengthen in both defence and midfield but we do also need a proven goalscorer with pace and vision whether J-P Mateta is that player I do not know, we have not seen enough of him to form an opinion as yet. Like you I agree money is going to be tight and not much of it, coupled with a board where 2 out three of the main player want out the future is somewhat uncertain and of concern!

Yep. If Nuno is our guy, I'm not sure where Benteke fits into that. Jimenez is a ruthless & aggressive striker. Benteke is not.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

silvertop Flag Portishead 08 Jun 21 6.40pm

Then we will sell him with a 2 year contract and visibly improved form.

 

Page 165 of 166 < 161 162 163 164 165 166 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread