You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Another black man shot by police in USA
November 22 2026 12.23am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Another black man shot by police in USA


Page 17 of 36 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 25 Jul 16 1.09pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston


No? She (and her child) had just watched her boyfriend get shot by police during a routine traffic stop. 7mins then proceeded to diminish her suffering by calling into question her behaviour in the immediate aftermath.

That's victim blaming, and it's never appropriate.

Quite correct, its drawing the focus away from the involvement of the primary party, to speculate on the motives of witnesses to insinuate through syntax that that they are immoral, responsible or involved - and thus undermine their contribution to the situation, without addressing the evidence they provide.

And yes, she is a 'victim' in that her husband was shot to death in front of her. She is a primary witness and its a common form of shaming to undermine a witness 'for what they did or did not do' rather than their evidence.

I think we're all pretty sure that even if the shooting was justified, her husband was not drawing a gun or intending to shoot the police officer and at best the situation is a tragic accident.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 25 Jul 16 1.16pm

Originally posted by dannyh


Just because you can have a gun does not mean you should. As the great Chris rock once said " you can drive a car with your feet if you want to, It's bad bad f***ing idea but you can."

How about a prejudice free society that don't target and kill policeman for no other reason than they are coppers ?

Edited by dannyh (25 Jul 2016 1.05pm)

I think it depends, if you have a concealed carry permit, its a bit different. Of course driving a car with your feet is reckless endangerment. People carrying guns illegally, of course play into a situation where its certainly understandable why they might be shot.

Of course its not always enforced the same way - Here are some very unconcealed firearms.

[Link]

The US, definitely has a problem with guns. The moment you have people taking assault rifles to dinner with them, you know you need serious gun control.

I'd certainly imagine that a white guy with an assault rifle slung over his back is much more of a noticeable threat, than say a black man with a pistol in his pocket....

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 25 Jul 16 1.22pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston

Should we read anything into the fact that the cop shot the black guy - who was lying on the ground with his hands raised - not the white guy who was sitting up holding an unknown object? Nah!

The police were just doing their job. They turned up to a scene where someone was threatening to shoot themselves and were not going to leave until someone had been shot.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 25 Jul 16 6.49pm

Originally posted by dannyh

Why would you be carrying a gun on day to day business, why would you photograph your self giving it large with a pistol ?

I'm not saying the Police officers actions were correct far from it, I have a wee bit of firearms training myself.

My point which seems to be as per usual misconstrued to suit others own agenda, is that if he didn't have a gun on him then he doesn't get shot. It really is that simple.


Your post above shows your fundamental misunderstanding of everything going on here.

1) This is 'Merica! Having a gun, and posing with it for photographs, are constitutionally protected rights.

2) In many states (I believe a majority of the 50), walking down the street strapped with handguns and/or long guns - including the controversial AR-15 - is not only legal, it requires no license.

3) If you think that not carrying a gun will mean you will not get shot means that you're not paying attention. The original outcry was over unarmed black men getting shot but it's recently morphed to including legally-armed black men. So the common denominator is not "armed" or "unarmed", it's "black man".

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Jul 16 9.30am

Originally posted by dannyh


How about a prejudice free society that don't target and kill policeman for no other reason than they are coppers ?

Edited by dannyh (25 Jul 2016 1.05pm)

I think for that to occur, the police would first have to be held accountable for use of excessive against Black people. The prejudice that often in the US has lead to black groups targeting the police, has its origins in the way that the police have 'controlled' black areas in the US.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

7mins Flag In the bush 27 Jul 16 3.53am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I think for that to occur, the police would first have to be held accountable for use of excessive against Black people. The prejudice that often in the US has lead to black groups targeting the police, has its origins in the way that the police have 'controlled' black areas in the US.

The only lives that matter apparently are the lives that were lost in a manner that can be manipulated to weave a race-baiting narrative.&#65279;

 

7mins Flag In the bush 27 Jul 16 3.54am

.


Edited by 7mins (27 Jul 2016 3.55am)

 

7mins Flag In the bush 27 Jul 16 3.54am

.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 27 Jul 16 3.55am

The only lives that matter apparently are the lives that were lost in a manner that can be manipulated to weave a race-baiting narrative.&#65279;

[Link]

Edited by 7mins (27 Jul 2016 3.55am)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 27 Jul 16 9.48am

Originally posted by 7mins

The only lives that matter apparently are the lives that were lost in a manner that can be manipulated to weave a race-baiting narrative.&#65279;

Apparently so, because neither the US public or the Police seem to give a s**t about the ones that aren't black.

Turns out, ordinary law abiding black people care more about their own people than white people seem to. Where is the campaign for poor white people killed by the police - there isn't one, because no one's been paying attention and raising the issue.

Don't expect other people to fight for your rights, you have to fight for them yourself.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Buzzcock Flag In an underground lair near Bright... 27 Jul 16 10.05am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721


Where is the campaign for poor white people killed by the police - there isn't one, because no one's been paying attention and raising the issue.


There isn't one as they would be immediately called racists and vilified, as you well know I'm sure.

 


In the woods there grew a tree. And a fine fine tree was he.

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 27 Jul 16 11.34am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Apparently so, because neither the US public or the Police seem to give a s**t about the ones that aren't black.

Turns out, ordinary law abiding black people care more about their own people than white people seem to. Where is the campaign for poor white people killed by the police - there isn't one, because no one's been paying attention and raising the issue.

Don't expect other people to fight for your rights, you have to fight for them yourself.

It is because the vast majority are poor. When the police behave like this with middle or upper class people, there is a huge fuss. BLM are able to use these shootings because they are able to tap into a broader narrative of historical oppression. Poor white people, particularly in the south, are part of the problem for the part of the political spectrum that claims to care.

All this has been highlighted by the fact that many blue collar white people are voting for Trump, or for Sanders, as they have both offered an alternative to the mainstream which, in turn, has rejected them for having the audacity to stay poor (Republican), or for have the gall to remain poor and white (Democrat).

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 27 Jul 16 11.37am

Originally posted by Buzzcock

There isn't one as they would be immediately called racists and vilified, as you well know I'm sure.

I don't know, then again we have people pointing out that BLM are racist, so maybe you're right.

Of course the issue isn't then that white people are in the same situation, but that the Police are killing poor people with relative impunity.

I'd recommend focusing on the poor, rather than the white aspect, associate it with the issue of police brutality of black and Hispanics, and maybe build a coailition.

The real issue here is the impunity of the police, not the ethnicity of the victim. There will always be those who believe otherwise, but if you stick to the key issue, police brutality against the poor, and cover black as well as white, you'll move forwards more than some people will try to push you back.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

nairb75 Flag Baltimore 27 Jul 16 1.59pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

It is because the vast majority are poor. When the police behave like this with middle or upper class people, there is a huge fuss. BLM are able to use these shootings because they are able to tap into a broader narrative of historical oppression. Poor white people, particularly in the south, are part of the problem for the part of the political spectrum that claims to care.

All this has been highlighted by the fact that many blue collar white people are voting for Trump, or for Sanders, as they have both offered an alternative to the mainstream which, in turn, has rejected them for having the audacity to stay poor (Republican), or for have the gall to remain poor and white (Democrat).

the recent one in minnesota (wifey was filming it) was especially impactful b/c it wasn't a poor, young black man in a crap neighborhood. he was in a good neighborhood. had a 4yo in the back seat. wife in the front seat. tail light was out in the car.

cop was all worked up b/c he was black. i feel bad for the cops here - never know who has a gun (there's one by where i grew up where the cop gets shot at just walking up to the car).

but in the instance of minnesota, it was just trigger happy. that doesn't usually happen to white people in a decent neighbhorhood. actually never does.

over a tail light.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 27 Jul 16 2.03pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I don't know, then again we have people pointing out that BLM are racist, so maybe you're right.

Of course the issue isn't then that white people are in the same situation, but that the Police are killing poor people with relative impunity.

I'd recommend focusing on the poor, rather than the white aspect, associate it with the issue of police brutality of black and Hispanics, and maybe build a coailition.

The real issue here is the impunity of the police, not the ethnicity of the victim. There will always be those who believe otherwise, but if you stick to the key issue, police brutality against the poor, and cover black as well as white, you'll move forwards more than some people will try to push you back.

Black people are being killed with impunity, but not by cops. Every 14 hours a black male is murdered in Chicago. Shall we speak about that, will Fox News have phone ins? Will politicians condemn it? Will people march in the streets?

No,(mainly) white liberals don't seem to care... White people get held to a higher standard than some black dude from the ghetto. White man kills a black guy= criminal, put him in jail. Black guy kills another black....nothing,it's like we think ah well... What do you expect?

We should all be held accountable for our actions, and as long as the white liberal puts the bar so lo for black people, they will continue to kill each other.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 27 Jul 16 2.16pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Black people are being killed with impunity, but not by cops. Every 14 hours a black male is murdered in Chicago. Shall we speak about that, will Fox News have phone ins? Will politicians condemn it? Will people march in the streets?

I believe that these are for the most part dealt with, by the criminal justice system in the US, with the perpetrators usually ending up in prison? I don't think there is a problem there. System generally seems to be working.

Originally posted by 7mins

No,(mainly) white liberals don't seem to care... White people get held to a higher standard than some black dude from the ghetto. White man kills a black guy= criminal, put him in jail. Black guy kills another black....nothing,it's like we think ah well... What do you expect?

Or they don't know. I don't see how this relates to police use of lethal force. See, the reality of how politics work is that you have to escalate issues with the system. The media etc won't do it for you.

Its f**king absurd to claim that white people are held to a higher standard, given the increased likelihood of a black suspect receiving a custodial sentence for the same crime as a white guy.

Originally posted by 7mins

We should all be held accountable for our actions, and as long as the white liberal puts the bar so lo for black people, they will continue to kill each other.

I don't see how this relates to Police officers killing people with excessive force. You seem to have a divergent view that thinks that the Black Civil Rights movement should do what you want, rather than its own remit.

And Black Civil Rights movements are very big on the issue of black on black murder and gang violence. Just not this one.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 27 Jul 16 3.03pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Black people are being killed with impunity, but not by cops. Every 14 hours a black male is murdered in Chicago. Shall we speak about that, will Fox News have phone ins? Will politicians condemn it? Will people march in the streets?

No,(mainly) white liberals don't seem to care... White people get held to a higher standard than some black dude from the ghetto. White man kills a black guy= criminal, put him in jail. Black guy kills another black....nothing,it's like we think ah well... What do you expect?

We should all be held accountable for our actions, and as long as the white liberal puts the bar so lo for black people, they will continue to kill each other.


When black people kill black people, the cops investigate and the perpetrators are mostly brought to justice. This is one of the reasons why America's jails are disproportionately chock full of black men.

When cops kill black people, it's rarely investigated and, when it is, the cops almost always walk free.
[Link]

You're failure to recognise this fundamental difference between these two problems can only be, at this point, deliberate.

Edited by Ray in Houston (27 Jul 2016 3.04pm)

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

7mins Flag In the bush 27 Jul 16 3.11pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I don't see how this relates to Police officers killing people with excessive force. You seem to have a divergent view that thinks that the Black Civil Rights movement should do what you want, rather than its own remit.

And Black Civil Rights movements are very big on the issue of black on black murder and gang violence. Just not this one.


When questioned about the black on black crime, BLM said that wasn't their priority right now. It's absurd to me that BLM won't speak about the far greater numbers of black people killed by black people. Maybe they should rename their ideology (I won't call it a organisation).

*Blacks are 200x more likely to commit crime against whites, than whites are against blacks
Source: National Crime Victim Survey

Why isn't there a White lives Matter... the stats prove they are more likely to be victims of crimes from blacks?

Also in 99% of the cases, if you comply with the police, then nothing happens

 

7mins Flag In the bush 27 Jul 16 3.24pm

Why do people cherry pick stats...
More blacks make up the prison population...
Well, blacks commit more crime...aghhh you're racist!

It's almost impossible to have a adult discussion on it.

dude resists arrest, he is armed and reaches for gun, police shout warning, then shoot him.
Seems fair enough to me.
White Graphic Designer in Surrey says "nooooo, they shouldn't have killed him, the guy shot is the victim" Even thou he resisted arrest, was armed and already threatened to kill someone.

It's utter bulls***...i'm all for being liberal, but this is getting f***in pathetic.

Just look at the numbers... don't watch the news where FOX/CNN/SKY sensationalise it, so they get viewing figures to bump up their advertising profits, look at the stats, be brave enough to spk your mind without fear or favour, try to find what is the root cause and try to affect change, or at least have a opinion that is informed. Be prepared to have your views changed, be prepared to hear some uncomfortable truths, avoid biased viewpoints

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 27 Jul 16 3.28pm

Originally posted by 7mins


When questioned about the black on black crime, BLM said that wasn't their priority right now. It's absurd to me that BLM won't speak about the far greater numbers of black people killed by black people. Maybe they should rename their ideology (I won't call it a organisation).

Because other groups are focused specifically on that. It may seem absurd to you, but it seems pretty sensible, to focus on areas where there are no pre-existing groups.

BLM is their name, not their mission statement.

Originally posted by 7mins

*Blacks are 200x more likely to commit crime against whites, than whites are against blacks
Source: National Crime Victim Survey

And they're also likely to be properly investigated by the police, and pursued by the criminal justice system. Which means, system in place, works (and in their favour).

Originally posted by 7mins
Why isn't there a White lives Matter... the stats prove they are more likely to be victims of crimes from blacks?

Because you're reducing the entire campaign of BLM to their name, not the issue?

Originally posted by 7mins

Also in 99% of the cases, if you comply with the police, then nothing happens

Hahahahhhahahhah hahhahahaha that's the most naïve view of the police I've ever heard. Even in the UK, as a white man, I find that to be absurdly untrue, and as a football fan utter nonsense.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 17 of 36 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Another black man shot by police in USA