This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
The feeling of anger against Tory party policies and their blatant disregard for ordinary people trying to scrape a living and afford a decent place to live is high. Perhaps these people are relatives of those that have died at the hands of Tory cuts. Perhaps some are doctors or nurses fed up with what is happening with the NHS. What a load of bollocks.
|
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Oh dear
|
|
|
Originally posted by serial thriller
I don't necessarily disagree with you but think about what this says of our political system. Brexiteers' main argument, supposedly, is to win back national sovereignty. But in what way can we be sovereign? Already we have an unelected head of state, an unelected second legislative chamber, and then to compile the misery, when a major party proposes a manifesto which even slightly veers away from an austerity agenda, it is widely viewed as impossible to implement because of non-elected organisations like the ECB, IMF and World Bank. You either have to accept that we are living under tyranny or you have to fight for democracy. But the idea that we will have any more sense of sovereign empowerment because we leave the EU, I'm sorry to break it to you, is idealism divorced from reality. This country borrows now.....it's national debt increases every day...we have just had our credit rating lowered and you produce a statement like, 'then to compile the misery, when a major party proposes a manifesto which even slightly veers away from an austerity agenda, it is widely viewed as impossible to implement because of non-elected organisations like the ECB, IMF and World Bank.' I think like the Labour front bench....you'd see the the wealth flow out of this country quicker than water out of your hot tap. As for your view on the EU. I put it to you that the use of the word tyranny to describe the British system is a misuse of the word tyranny. If you were to say, 'do we have the best system?'. Well, we would agree, though I'd imagine our points of difference on what a better system would be would differ. We have an unelected head of state with no political nor legislative power.....though they have privileges. We have an unelected second chamber, who have no ability to propose legislation......I would change some aspects but I wouldn't have an elected second chamber in a month of Sundays...terrible idea....The second chamber is far too political as it is. Our first chamber that proposes legislation is entirely elected. If you disagree, you have a tiny say in voting someone in or out. The EU's legislation proposing arm is unelected. For you to even talk about what is and isn't sovereign when you would have been happy to continue with this state of affairs makes your viewpoint moot to me. I think you should look at what the EU is doing in centralizing power....what it's doing supporting Spain's crackdown on democracy today and ask yourself if you actually truly care about these matters.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
This country borrows now.....it's national debt increases every day...we have just had our credit rating lowered and you produce a statement like, 'then to compile the misery, when a major party proposes a manifesto which even slightly veers away from an austerity agenda, it is widely viewed as impossible to implement because of non-elected organisations like the ECB, IMF and World Bank.' I think like the Labour front bench....you'd see the the wealth flow out of this country quicker than water out of your hot tap. As for your view on the EU. I put it to you that the use of the word tyranny to describe the British system is a misuse of the word tyranny. If you were to say, 'do we have the best system?'. Well, we would agree, though I'd imagine our points of difference on what a better system would be would differ. We have an unelected head of state with no political nor legislative power.....though they have privileges. We have an unelected second chamber, who have no ability to propose legislation......I would change some aspects but I wouldn't have an elected second chamber in a month of Sundays...terrible idea....The second chamber is far too political as it is. Our first chamber that proposes legislation is entirely elected. If you disagree, you have a tiny say in voting someone in or out. The EU's legislation proposing arm is unelected. For you to even talk about what is and isn't sovereign when you would have been happy to continue with this state of affairs makes your viewpoint moot to me. I think you should look at what the EU is doing in centralizing power....what it's doing supporting Spain's crackdown on democracy today and ask yourself if you actually truly care about these matters. I'm not pro-EU Stirling by any means. I'm just pointing out that arguing for sovereignty against the EU and refusing to see how un-democratic our political system is ridiculous. You say that the second chamber shouldn't be elected as it would make it more political. Well how can passing laws not be a political act? How could you have a non-political legislator, when the whole point of politics in a liberal democracy is to propose and enact laws? As for our national debt. Before 2008, it stood at around half a trillion. Already an eyewatering figure, but since then it's up to over £1.8 trillion. So what has our government been spending these loans on? Well it evidently isn't the public, as welfare, schools, hospitals and local authority has seen crippling, devastating cuts to their budgets. So where did the money go? Well, £500 billion went on our initial bailout of the banks, which now continue to receive government subsidies whilst paying little or no tax. Other private companies are also reaping in huge government subsidies, from rail to energy, despite their services often being shoddy at best. Whilst 99% of the country are experiencing the effects of austerity, of a shrinking of the public economy, the elites are being bankrolled despite causing one of the biggest economic crashes in modern times. The EU are one of the biggest culprits of this kind of cronyist reverse-Robin Hood policy, but our own government is more than happy to follow along.
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4 |
|
|
Originally posted by serial thriller
I'm not pro-EU Stirling by any means. I'm just pointing out that arguing for sovereignty against the EU and refusing to see how un-democratic our political system is ridiculous. You say that the second chamber shouldn't be elected as it would make it more political. Well how can passing laws not be a political act? How could you have a non-political legislator, when the whole point of politics in a liberal democracy is to propose and enact laws? As for our national debt. Before 2008, it stood at around half a trillion. Already an eyewatering figure, but since then it's up to over £1.8 trillion. So what has our government been spending these loans on? Well it evidently isn't the public, as welfare, schools, hospitals and local authority has seen crippling, devastating cuts to their budgets. So where did the money go? Well, £500 billion went on our initial bailout of the banks, which now continue to receive government subsidies whilst paying little or no tax. Other private companies are also reaping in huge government subsidies, from rail to energy, despite their services often being shoddy at best. Whilst 99% of the country are experiencing the effects of austerity, of a shrinking of the public economy, the elites are being bankrolled despite causing one of the biggest economic crashes in modern times. The EU are one of the biggest culprits of this kind of cronyist reverse-Robin Hood policy, but our own government is more than happy to follow along. I'm sorry, but you have to start somewhere. And that start is bringing the entire legal and judicial framework and competence back to where we can chuck it out if we don't like it. Next stop, indeed: the House of Lords and electoral reform. But what's the point in reforming the Lords when more and more of our law-making is done outside of the UK? Do you think the Lords have EVER, in the past 40 years, debated an EU regulation in their house? No. It goes straight into law. No oversight. Do you think they EVER returned an EU directive bill back to the Commons? Then, what's the point in changing the way we elect our politicians when they can just point to Brussels and say "sorry, our hands are tied: your argument is the them". No. It is an onion. Work on the outer layer, and then tackle the issues deeper within our country when our political system is actually accountable to us voters. Well, that's pretty much what most waycists, zennofobig, low-edukation Brexit bigguts thought, anyway.
|
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by davenotamonkey
I'm sorry, but you have to start somewhere. And that start is bringing the entire legal and judicial framework and competence back to where we can chuck it out if we don't like it. Next stop, indeed: the House of Lords and electoral reform. But what's the point in reforming the Lords when more and more of our law-making is done outside of the UK? Do you think the Lords have EVER, in the past 40 years, debated an EU regulation in their house? No. It goes straight into law. No oversight. Do you think they EVER returned an EU directive bill back to the Commons? Then, what's the point in changing the way we elect our politicians when they can just point to Brussels and say "sorry, our hands are tied: your argument is the them". No. It is an onion. Work on the outer layer, and then tackle the issues deeper within our country when our political system is actually accountable to us voters. Well, that's pretty much what most waycists, zennofobig, low-edukation Brexit bigguts thought, anyway. Shame that legislation is being carried out by Tory heavy commities rather than being put before the democratically elected sovereign parliament. Who knew that taking back control would be so rigged?
|
|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
Shame that legislation is being carried out by Tory heavy commities rather than being put before the democratically elected sovereign parliament. Who knew that taking back control would be so rigged? Better that than wrecked by Labour. And as the repeal bill white paper was published on the 30th March of this year, the voting population evidently agree. Given that this bill encompasses solely legislation enacted by the EU, I find it very interesting you decide take an interest NOW in all the laws that have been enacted outside the Commons. Where have you been all these years? Any idea what Labour's Brexit policy is today? No, me neither. Clowns.
|
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by davenotamonkey
Better that than wrecked by Labour. And as the repeal bill white paper was published on the 30th March of this year, the voting population evidently agree. Given that this bill encompasses solely legislation enacted by the EU, I find it very interesting you decide take an interest NOW in all the laws that have been enacted outside the Commons. Where have you been all these years? Any idea what Labour's Brexit policy is today? No, me neither. Clowns. What s the Tories Brexit policy, not just today but ever? No, me neither.
|
|
|
Originally posted by serial thriller
I'm not pro-EU Stirling by any means. I'm just pointing out that arguing for sovereignty against the EU and refusing to see how un-democratic our political system is ridiculous. You say that the second chamber shouldn't be elected as it would make it more political. Well how can passing laws not be a political act? How could you have a non-political legislator, when the whole point of politics in a liberal democracy is to propose and enact laws? As for our national debt. Before 2008, it stood at around half a trillion. Already an eyewatering figure, but since then it's up to over £1.8 trillion. So what has our government been spending these loans on? Well it evidently isn't the public, as welfare, schools, hospitals and local authority has seen crippling, devastating cuts to their budgets. So where did the money go? Well, £500 billion went on our initial bailout of the banks, which now continue to receive government subsidies whilst paying little or no tax. Other private companies are also reaping in huge government subsidies, from rail to energy, despite their services often being shoddy at best. Whilst 99% of the country are experiencing the effects of austerity, of a shrinking of the public economy, the elites are being bankrolled despite causing one of the biggest economic crashes in modern times. The EU are one of the biggest culprits of this kind of cronyist reverse-Robin Hood policy, but our own government is more than happy to follow along. I agree that our system could be fairer and more democratic. I've always viewed the second chamber as a good idea precisely because the concept is that its inhabited by experts in legislation and various fields. The idea being, as we all know, that the overt political tribalism of the first chamber with its occasional habit of producing the odd rushed bad bill can be bounced back and improved....in theory by that second chamber oversight. But your point about political identities in that second chamber is a good one..... but this is a point that could be countered by balancing out party representation. We want an apolitical chamber as much as possible. I think that's possible....but it requires the will to do it....parties and their political games make that end result a pipe dream at the moment. You of course are right to speak of the wrongs of a system that caused the banking crises and taxpayer bail out. It's a cycle that capitalism treads out every few decades. However, I'm not sure a criticism on the ills of regulated capitalism....still the best, if flawed, system we know....is going to get us anywhere.....We could have let the whole system collapse....It's not like that's a better answer either. But yes...there was zero fairness in the whole thing Regulated capitalism has many ills but keeping wealth in the country is vital to paying for the socialistic elements of the state such as schools and hospitals. It's a symbiotic relationship.....darkness and light so to speak. Rather than electing marxists into the mix I regard a far better and more realistic change in this dynamic as coming from the coming advancement of technology and its automation. Automation will inevitably result in gradual universal basic incomes and will change capitalism and society far far more than the old era political cats amongst the birds that Corbyn and co represent. That automation will happen everywhere in the first world at the same time...so it won't have the same affect as scaring away capital. Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Oct 2017 5.35pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
What s the Tories Brexit policy, not just today but ever? No, me neither. Leave the single market. Leave the customs union. Regain legal sovereignty and supremacy from the ECJ. More details in the Lancaster House speech, the Conservative election manifesto, the f***-tonne of position papers they have published, and most recently the Florence speech. There, not so difficult, was it? Perhaps Labour could give it a try. Or at the very least hold the same position for more than a week or two. Maybe you should be a little more informed and stop reading the left-wing trash you keep posting on here. It rots your brain, you kno.... oh, never mind. I don't doubt you'll want to argue the minuate, or indeed the ISSUES ARISING from the policy (as opposed to the policy itself), but to tell you the truth gusset - I'm utterly bored with you.
|
|
|
Originally posted by npn
She's proper scum isn't she? I'm normally pretty ambivalent about the royals, but this gave me the screaming hump - I almost went on Twitter to vent my spleen at her, but decided to deny her the attention. Labour say she's entitled to her opinion. Of course she is, but she's not entitled to slander - this isn't an opinion, it's spouting cr@p as fact. And apparently "everyone knows" Prince Philip has affairs - well I must have missed that newsflash, too, but I'm sure they'd be informing a no-mark like her as a priority. Besides, does she really think that the co-pilot of an attack helicopter "sits there going vroom vroom"? Ignorant piece of sh*t! Is the correct answer
"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'" |
|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
The feeling of anger against Tory party policies and their blatant disregard for ordinary people trying to scrape a living and afford a decent place to live is high. Perhaps these people are relatives of those that have died at the hands of Tory cuts. Perhaps some are doctors or nurses fed up with what is happening with the NHS.
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
|
Originally posted by serial thriller
I'm not pro-EU Stirling by any means. I'm just pointing out that arguing for sovereignty against the EU and refusing to see how un-democratic our political system is ridiculous. You say that the second chamber shouldn't be elected as it would make it more political. Well how can passing laws not be a political act? How could you have a non-political legislator, when the whole point of politics in a liberal democracy is to propose and enact laws? As for our national debt. Before 2008, it stood at around half a trillion. Already an eyewatering figure, but since then it's up to over £1.8 trillion. So what has our government been spending these loans on? Well it evidently isn't the public, as welfare, schools, hospitals and local authority has seen crippling, devastating cuts to their budgets. So where did the money go? Well, £500 billion went on our initial bailout of the banks, which now continue to receive government subsidies whilst paying little or no tax. Other private companies are also reaping in huge government subsidies, from rail to energy, despite their services often being shoddy at best. Whilst 99% of the country are experiencing the effects of austerity, of a shrinking of the public economy, the elites are being bankrolled despite causing one of the biggest economic crashes in modern times. The EU are one of the biggest culprits of this kind of cronyist reverse-Robin Hood policy, but our own government is more than happy to follow along. Lloyds has now been released back into the wild with the tax payer getting more than was used to support it back...that aside, you, Stirling and davenotamonkey should be applauded for the debating on this thread...well done lads...all very interesting and some good / valid points from both sides. Edited by Lyons550 (03 Oct 2017 2.15pm)
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
An interesting piece on the conference.
|
|
|
About as interesting a watching red paint dry.
|
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
About as interesting a watching red paint dry. Thanks for that insight.
|
|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
Thanks for that insight. Next pointless lefty link? I know you will be the man to supply it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dannyh
I've read with interest the last 10 pages or so, and far from the left being the next government elect, I think it's followers are slowly realising that actually their party (much like the Tory's they despise) is full of amoral b******s, with nothing but self interest at heart. Politics eh Anyhow see this mouth piece is gobbing off again. But its OK she called someone a liar "but was only poking fun" Horrible horrible woman soon to be moaning no doubt about nasty people being horrible to her, much like the maligned Diane Abbott, who recently appeared on the Rusell Howard hour on SKY 1 blubbing about the nasty abuse she got for being a total waste of skin. You honestly couldn't make it up. It seems that Corbyn has a few female MP's that are not very nice "Ladies" and need to toe the line but we cannot expect their leader to have words with them as he comes out with a load of boll0cks most of the time too and god help us IF he ever got into Number 10 we would be utterly f*cked well and truly.
Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.