You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread
November 20 2026 5.19pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Benteke thread


Page 17 of 166 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 >
spartakev2 Flag Anerley 17 Jan 18 9.27am

He's a 30m striker who's scored 1 goal all season. If he was in any other team in the premiership he'd be dropped.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Jan 18 9.38am

Originally posted by spartakev2

Not if you spend that 30m on a striker who can score goals....plus crouch has scored three more goals than Benteke in a lot less playing time...

Easy to say "Spend that on a £30 Mill striker" but every club is after a striker who can score goals and it just isn't that easy to get a quality striker in this 'Window'.Could end up with losing Benteke, getting in Crouch and struggling to find a suitable striker.

I admit Benteke has been a disappointment but he is a far better player than he has shown and could well get back to the player who scored 15 PL goals for us last season.And in recent games he has been improving so hopefully this will translate into goals.

Edited by Willo (17 Jan 2018 9.40am)

 

Beastie Flag 17 Jan 18 9.41am

Originally posted by spartakev2

He's a 30m striker who's scored 1 goal all season. If he was in any other team in the premiership he'd be dropped.

What’s his price got to do with whether or not he should be dropped? You can criticise his form but one thing I’ll never understand is the way some fans will give less support to anyone seen as expensive.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 17 Jan 18 9.45am

Originally posted by Beastie

What’s his price got to do with whether or not he should be dropped? You can criticise his form but one thing I’ll never understand is the way some fans will give less support to anyone seen as expensive.

Totally agree. Although feel it works the other way too. Because he cost 30m, people think he cant or wont be dropped. If we had another out and out striker he would have been dropped like its hot a long time ago.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 17 Jan 18 9.53am

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

Totally agree. Although feel it works the other way too. Because he cost 30m, people think he cant or wont be dropped. If we had another out and out striker he would have been dropped like its hot a long time ago.[/quote]

Only if that striker was playing well , contributing to the team scoring goals and scoring goals himself.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 17 Jan 18 9.58am

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

Totally agree. Although feel it works the other way too. Because he cost 30m, people think he cant or wont be dropped. If we had another out and out striker he would have been dropped like its hot a long time ago.[/quote]

Only if that striker was playing well , contributing to the team scoring goals and scoring goals himself.

What like Benteke you mean? So at worst a like for like replacement. Just think if we had say Frazier Campbell for example he would have had a run in the team by now. I think we have all lowered our expectations of what we expect from a striker. Just because he knocks a ball on, wins some headers we think he has contributed enough. I just dont think it is enough. He has been seriously disappointing.

Edited by MonsterMunch (17 Jan 2018 10.01am)

Edited by MonsterMunch (17 Jan 2018 10.01am)

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 17 Jan 18 10.03am

Originally posted by Beastie

What’s his price got to do with whether or not he should be dropped? You can criticise his form but one thing I’ll never understand is the way some fans will give less support to anyone seen as expensive.

Because when you pay that much, and he earns that much, you expect more. Simple really.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Jan 18 10.13am

Originally posted by spartakev2


Because when you pay that much, and he earns that much, you expect more. Simple really.

He did score 15 PL goals for us last season in a team that only secured safety right at the end of the season so this was no mean feat.

Of course this season has been different but we did get off to a torrid start and he had been out injured.Besides in recent games he has improved - setup MacArthur for his goal at Southampton, provided that good pass to Sako on Saturday and whilst he didn't score has got into good positions in the box to head the ball.

We know what he is capable of so it is all the more frustrating that he hasn't performed to his usual standards this season.Despite this I certainly wouldn't want a situation whereby Crouch is our main striker with Benteke at another club !

Edited by Willo (17 Jan 2018 10.30am)

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 17 Jan 18 10.14am

Originally posted by spartakev2

Because when you pay that much, and he earns that much, you expect more. Simple really.

This

 

Beastie Flag 17 Jan 18 10.23am

Originally posted by spartakev2

Because when you pay that much, and he earns that much, you expect more. Simple really.

So if he was on less money, you wouldn't drop him? Glad you've thought it through.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 17 Jan 18 10.32am

Originally posted by Beastie

So if he was on less money, you wouldn't drop him? Glad you've thought it through.

They were 2 seperate statements, hence the full stop.
1. He's a 30m striker who's only scored 1 goal all season. (Surely we should expect more)
2. If he was at any other premiership club he'd have been dropped.(no matter what we paid for him)
Understand now?

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 17 Jan 18 10.33am

Originally posted by spartakev2

They were 2 seperate statements, hence the full stop.
1. He's a 30m striker who's only scored 1 goal all season. (Surely we should expect more)
2. If he was at any other premiership club he'd have been dropped.(no matter what we paid for him)
Understand now?

this.

 

Beastie Flag 17 Jan 18 10.40am

Originally posted by spartakev2

They were 2 seperate statements, hence the full stop.
1. He's a 30m striker who's only scored 1 goal all season. (Surely we should expect more)
2. If he was at any other premiership club he'd have been dropped.(no matter what we paid for him)
Understand now?

“He's a 30m striker who's scored 1 goal all season. If he was in any other team in the premiership he'd be dropped”

It’s a statement and a conclusion. Clearly you were implying that that a return of 1 goal, for that money means he should be dropped. Good that you’ve realised your mistake though.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 17 Jan 18 10.41am

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

What like Benteke you mean? So at worst a like for like replacement. Just think if we had say Frazier Campbell for example he would have had a run in the team by now. I think we have all lowered our expectations of what we expect from a striker. Just because he knocks a ball on, wins some headers we think he has contributed enough. I just dont think it is enough. He has been seriously disappointing.

Edited by MonsterMunch (17 Jan 2018 10.01am)

Edited by MonsterMunch (17 Jan 2018 10.01am)

Well yes he would have to play well but score goals of his own.
For instance Glen Murray has five goals for Brighton but they are now below us.
I would rather be playing like we are with Benteke struggling to score because he can start scoring again and we will be even better.
Will Glen get five more goals this season and if he does will those goals keep them up ?
What if Brighton got a better quality front man that scored less than five goals but enabled the team to play more cohesive and enabled others to score more ?
It's a conundrum.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 17 Jan 18 10.46am

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Well yes he would have to play well but score goals of his own.
For instance Glen Murray has five goals for Brighton but they are now below us.
I would rather be playing like we are with Benteke struggling to score because he can start scoring again and we will be even better.
Will Glen get five more goals this season and if he does will those goals keep them up ?
What if Brighton got a better quality front man that scored less than five goals but enabled the team to play more cohesive and enabled others to score more ?
It's a conundrum.

Yes I take you point. My rebuttal to that would be... the main differentiator is we've got Zaha!

Edited by MonsterMunch (17 Jan 2018 10.47am)

 

youngpalacefan111 Flag 17 Jan 18 10.52am

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Well yes he would have to play well but score goals of his own.
For instance Glen Murray has five goals for Brighton but they are now below us.
I would rather be playing like we are with Benteke struggling to score because he can start scoring again and we will be even better.
Will Glen get five more goals this season and if he does will those goals keep them up ?
What if Brighton got a better quality front man that scored less than five goals but enabled the team to play more cohesive and enabled others to score more ?
It's a conundrum.

I think you are massively overstating bentekes impact on the team. There have been games where it felt like we were playing with 10 men. Zaha is our main man without him we'd of been dead and burried a long time ago.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 17 Jan 18 10.56am

Originally posted by youngpalacefan111

I think you are massively overstating bentekes impact on the team. There have been games where it felt like we were playing with 10 men. Zaha is our main man without him we'd of been dead and burried a long time ago.

Never a truer word said.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 17 Jan 18 1.19pm

Originally posted by Beastie

“He's a 30m striker who's scored 1 goal all season. If he was in any other team in the premiership he'd be dropped”

It’s a statement and a conclusion. Clearly you were implying that that a return of 1 goal, for that money means he should be dropped. Good that you’ve realised your mistake though.

Is picking holes in the wording the best response you've got. How sad.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 17 Jan 18 1.28pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

They were 2 seperate statements, hence the full stop.
1. He's a 30m striker who's only scored 1 goal all season. (Surely we should expect more)
2. If he was at any other premiership club he'd have been dropped.(no matter what we paid for him)
Understand now?

We are the only club in the bottom 10 with a £27m striker, only the top clubs have more expensive strikers. They can drop them, as they have more than one striker of that value or above.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 17 Jan 18 1.30pm

Originally posted by youngpalacefan111

I think you are massively overstating bentekes impact on the team. There have been games where it felt like we were playing with 10 men. Zaha is our main man without him we'd of been dead and burried a long time ago.

That is just your opinion, you do not know and neither do I. I see the team playing well with him in it and I see him involved in goals. So do you but that is not enough for you.
I would like to know what are you blaming Benteke for and why given the players we have we would do better with him not in our team.
All you got so far is you think he is lazy and he doesn't play like you want him to .
But the team are doing well.

 

Page 17 of 166 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Benteke thread