You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Window Summing Up
November 16 2026 7.58am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Transfer Window Summing Up


Page 17 of 18 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 >
Spiderman Flag Horsham 02 Feb 18 2.24pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I think it was as simple as he was our second choice and when it became apparent that Guaita wasn't going to get over the line in this window we turned our attention to Ronnow but too late. To be honest buying both wouldn't be a bad shout but it may be that they thought Amadou was going to go through and money was an issue, so they were juggling balls and unfortunately dropped them!

That was the point I tried to make earlier but apparently I was being naive. It is apparent Ronnow wanted to join, we had tried to get him in the summer (again too late), Guiata deal was always going nowhere so why oh why leave approaching Brondby to the last knockings when we had a whole month (several if you include the attempt in the summer)

 

Griffish Flag Croydon 02 Feb 18 3.45pm

I think the signings have been fine and it's nice to see this kind of approach to transfers of signing young prospects. Sorloth sounds like he's going straight into the match squad so hopefully he can get some minutes on Sunday

Still massively disappointing, and extremely poor from the board to not sign a keeper. IMO, only Watford and Newcastle have a worse first choice goalkeeper than us in the league.

Also, with the Sako injury confirmed today, if Wilf or Townsend get injured, we have no wing cover which is utterly baffling. Watford have two decent wingers now on loan in Carrilo and Deulofeu, so surely we could have looked at a similar deal for a similar player from abroad.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 02 Feb 18 3.46pm

Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan

Based on what?
I agree it seems massively overpriced for an unproven player who has only very briefly done something in a lowly rated league. However: sellers know the PL is where the money is, so they ask for excessive fees. For instance Feyenoord wanted 22m for Jorgensen, that is almost 40 percent of last season's Turnaround!! Unbelievable figures but English clubs are getting pressurized in overpaying huge fees, simply because they have the spending power and everybody knows it.


Based on a gut feel. Holland is a better league than Denmark and Jorgensen (unlike our guy) has cut it there. You can find ways to justify most things but the bottom line for me is that 16m or 17m looks too high for a player with an unexceptional (and VERY short) scoring record playing for a top side in a third tier league.

But only gut feel and I won't pretend otherwise. just feel 7.5m up front rising to 12m all in sounds more realistic.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 02 Feb 18 4.56pm

Originally posted by alaneagle1

Midlands what is the latest on this lad ?
Has he signed a pre-contract.?

Yes, he joins Palace on 1st July. Being reported on SSN, Advertiser & many other places - apparently Roy confirmed it in the non-broadcast section of his press conference this afternoon.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Den1923 Flag 02 Feb 18 7.09pm

I really do not understand why our ability to have a decent transfer window seems to be beyond us. In this window we seemed to spend a considerable amount of time trying to sign players that were not and never were going to available to play for us in the second half of this season. Whoever is responsible for identifying targets should be fired as we.never seem to have a plan,, hence no real improvement in quality proven players for the squad!

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 02 Feb 18 10.40pm

Oi, we have 3 in our squad you know....

Originally posted by spartakev2

Let's just look at transfera into teams around us...Bournemouth bought no one.
BHA broke their transfer record for Locadia, and we know what fans on here think of Dutch players, and Ulloa who can't get in the Leicester team and hasn't played much this season
Swansea have brought back Ahew, who seems to be injured.
Newcastle have got slamani, who can't get a game for Leicester, has yet to prove himself and seems to be injured.
WBA have got Sturridge who is a huge injury risk and has hardly played this season.
And Burnley have got Aaron lennon...
All in all, I'd rather have our new Danish player than most of those to be honest...

 

Medway Eagle Flag Whitstable Kent 02 Feb 18 11.04pm

Originally posted by Den1923

I really do not understand why our ability to have a decent transfer window seems to be beyond us. In this window we seemed to spend a considerable amount of time trying to sign players that were not and never were going to available to play for us in the second half of this season. Whoever is responsible for identifying targets should be fired as we.never seem to have a plan,, hence no real improvement in quality proven players for the squad!


-----------------------------------------------------
The only constant in all of our recent poor transfer dealings is Steve Parish others have come and gone, But unfortunately he remains in total charge

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 03 Feb 18 4.03am

Originally posted by alaneagle1

Well for a club that does not know how to do transfers we currently sit unlucky for some 13th.
The highest we will get in the foreseeable future is 7th.
So in my book we are doing ok.
And yes I would support your Gran,hopefully she doesn’t moan as much as her Grandson.

If you would support my gran in goal, we would lose every game 25 nil and would get relegated out of the league system before long.

Personally I would like us to stay in the Premier League, above blindly supporting any human being as our preferred keeper.

Will tell my gran about your confidence in her, she will be chuffed.

The last 2 transfer windows show we don’t know what we are doing re transfers.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Maine Eagle Flag USA 03 Feb 18 4.13am

Originally posted by Den1923

I really do not understand why our ability to have a decent transfer window seems to be beyond us. In this window we seemed to spend a considerable amount of time trying to sign players that were not and never were going to available to play for us in the second half of this season. Whoever is responsible for identifying targets should be fired as we.never seem to have a plan,, hence no real improvement in quality proven players for the squad!

The scouting is not the issue. The issue is how we go about trying to sign those players. Not getting a keeper signed is not down to the scout - he dug up Guaita. It’s down to our p*** poor approach to negotiations, and lack of focus on solving key problems.

The keeper situation has been going on for years, literally. We only have 2 and the gaffer doesn’t fancy either of them.

Until TFM came in we didn’t really have a right back to challenge ward.

We have loaned 2 premier league players we have absolutely no chance of buying.

We have loads of players out of contract at the same time at the end of this season, including our 2 current goalkeepers.

We failed to sign a striker in the last window leaving us with one recognized forward. Thankfully we actually addressed that finally in this window.

If zaha gets injured we are totally screwed as we don’t have a player who is remotely similar and could even give us 50% of his output.

We cannot ever seem to sell our deadwood.

We leave critical negotiations to the last minute of the window leaving deals open to collapse with no chance to react - Niasse for example.

We play stupid games and put false narratives out there and mess around for weeks on end - Mamadou for example.

The list goes on, it’s amatuer hour.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Den1923 Flag 03 Feb 18 4.23am

Originally posted by Medway Eagle


-----------------------------------------------------
The only constant in all of our recent poor transfer dealings is Steve Parish others have come and gone, But unfortunately he remains in total charge

I''m think you are spot on,!

 

europalace Flag Europe 03 Feb 18 5.47am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

The last 2 transfer windows show we don’t know what we are doing re transfers.

er, no. What it shows is that you have no idea about what it takes to scout, research, approach and negotiate a transfer, unless of course you have a direct line to the club and are a part of the negotiation team. Otherwise, you are basing your opinion simply on press releases which are nearly always unreliable and always launched way after any team has started any negotiations.

Edited by europalace (03 Feb 2018 5.48am)

 

phillanth Flag London 03 Feb 18 9.13am

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Maybe one or two of these players will come good. I wouldn't bet on it with our past record though. Only established players seem to have come in and done adequately. Some of them have been pretty poor too. The last 'unknown' I can remember coming good is Ian Wright. Ward has been decent and wasn't much money - that's about it. Seems he is off to wherever Pulis is at the end of the season anyway.

I'd never heard of Milivojevic until this time last and he has been fantastic.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 03 Feb 18 11.17am

Originally posted by europalace

er, no. What it shows is that you have no idea about what it takes to scout, research, approach and negotiate a transfer, unless of course you have a direct line to the club and are a part of the negotiation team. Otherwise, you are basing your opinion simply on press releases which are nearly always unreliable and always launched way after any team has started any negotiations.

Edited by europalace (03 Feb 2018 5.48am)

We didn’t sign a striker in the last window - we had one fit striker of premier league class, who got injured, and we had to play 2 wingers up top. We blew the Tosun deal according to his agent, then left Niasse so late that when it crumbled we had no time to sort someone else out, and didn’t replace Mandanda = fail.

This time around we messed around and played chicken on Guaita, ballsed that up, then didn’t have time to get the Ronnow deal done. Our manager said 50 times we needed to have 3 goalies = fail.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 03 Feb 18 8.32pm

Originally posted by silvertop

If you can furnish evidence to prove that we only approached at the 11th hour then you will win this mini argument. If not, then you will not.

My guess: we try to do business under the radar given the number of poaches we suffer. I suspect Dougie et al have been forced to sweat for months waiting to see if the hoped linked deal will come off at Brondby. For no fault of our own it did not.

Perhaps the recent statements from the Brondby Manager and President about Palace's conduct both this window and the Summer, may suggest I have not lost this argument this one appears to be all our fault.

 

chateauferret Flag 03 Feb 18 10.28pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Perhaps the recent statements from the Brondby Manager and President about Palace's conduct both this window and the Summer, may suggest I have not lost this argument this one appears to be all our fault.

And that reinforces the view I expressed earlier, which is that whilst Parish doesn't need to "sell the club and f*** off", he does need to hand over the management of transfer dealings to someone who is good at it. He isn't, he isn't getting in the players we need, he's jaopardising our retention of coaching staff and managers, and he's not presenting the club in a good light by doing it the way he is or as a hobby alongside the "real" job of running the club, which is a complicated enough business as it is and will only get more complicated when we start rebuilding stands.

He did have a decent window a year ago when we got Sakho on loan, Milivojevic, Schlupp and van Aanholt, and last time he should have had de Boer on board but he threw his toys about and f***ed off, but this time he's had a DoF and a top manager to support and advise and we've ended up making an arse of it. Not too bad from the point of view of prospects for the future but from the point of view of securing our future in the Premier League: f***ing s***e.

So as well as a Director of Football we need a Director of Playing Staff who deals with all this s*** and keeps it away from Parish.

This has to be sorted out before the next window comes along. And no I don't mean that t*** from Wet Spam who spent the whole window trying to hijack our purchases then got himself sacked by sending that ridiculous tweet.

Edited by chateauferret (03 Feb 2018 10.33pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 03 Feb 18 10.40pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

And that reinforces the view I expressed earlier, which is that whilst Parish doesn't need to "sell the club and f*** off", he does need to hand over the management of transfer dealings to someone who is good at it. He isn't, he isn't getting in the players we need, he's jaopardising our retention of coaching staff and managers, and he's not presenting the club in a good light by doing it the way he is or as a hobby alongside the "real" job of running the club, which is a complicated enough business as it is and will only get more complicated when we start rebuilding stands. Our windows look like Microsoft's.

So as well as a Director of Football we need a Director of Playing Staff who deals with all this s*** and keeps it away from Parish.

This has to be sorted out before the next window comes along.

IMO this isn't about competence but more SP wanting to rip the ar5e out of every deal.

 

radicalsteve Flag ottawa 03 Feb 18 11.43pm

I believe I recall Roy saying on a prematch interview in December that we needed 4 players, especially a goal keeper and a forward - and he said "they all have to be improvements over the current squad to raise the bar" and they all have to hit the ground running, or words to that effect. SO, we got one out of four ..... 25% ... some folks should not be getting their year end performance bonuses then, as they didn't hit the stated objectives ????

 

Flash Flag Lampeter 03 Feb 18 11.52pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

IMO this isn't about competence but more SP wanting to rip the ar5e out of every deal.

This may not have been a great transfer window, but it's been reasonable. (B- in Merson's opinion)
We were primarily looking to sign a keeper & a striker. Injuries required a CB & CMF to be added to the list.
So now the window has closed we'll have to make do with 2 keepers until the summer when we get what appears to be a quality keeper on a Bosman. We've also signed a CB, a box to box MF & a striker without it seems eating into next summer's transfer budget.
The signings look promising to me, and I'm certainly not going to prejudge either them (or the guys that signed them) until I've seen them play.
I'm grateful to have someone like SP in charge of our club. As Simon Jordan said, Be Careful What You Wish For.

 

chateauferret Flag 03 Feb 18 11.52pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

IMO this isn't about competence but more SP wanting to rip the ar5e out of every deal.

If he's wanting to rip the arse out of every deal how is that competent?

You mean he knows how to do it but doesn't have the right mindset or attitude, which may be the case, but either way it means he's not the right person.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Flash Flag Lampeter 04 Feb 18 12.08am

Originally posted by radicalsteve

I believe I recall Roy saying on a prematch interview in December that we needed 4 players, especially a goal keeper and a forward - and he said "they all have to be improvements over the current squad to raise the bar" and they all have to hit the ground running, or words to that effect. SO, we got one out of four ..... 25% ... some folks should not be getting their year end performance bonuses then, as they didn't hit the stated objectives ????

How do you know the signings aren't an improvement? Time will tell. They may not be able to hit the ground running, but it's surely an unreasonable ask (if indeed Roy did ask it) to require 4 quality players in match-ready condition at today's prices.

 

Page 17 of 18 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Window Summing Up