You are here: Home > Message Board > General Talk > Cricket Thread
November 19 2026 5.11pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Cricket Thread


Page 17 of 30 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 >
Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 03 Jul 23 9.29am

It always takes a ridiculous exploitation of existing rules to get an over-due review.
It's a shame this Ashes will be over-shadowed (whatever the result) by the stumping incident in this game. England gave it some wellie, but I still don't think they're good enough against the Aussies.

And now instead of applauding the better side, there's a simmering under-current of "cheats, cheats, cheats"

It's just not cricket,...but then again ,..it is

Edited by Forest Hillbilly (03 Jul 2023 9.31am)

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 03 Jul 23 9.29am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Within the rules maybe, but
not how cricket should be played in 2023 at the highest level.

I feel a rule change is needed to avoid this kind of nonsense.

Two things:

First, a rule change which would have meant Bairstow wasn't legally out would be extremely hard, if not impossible, to frame.

Second, I don't think that that incident will be repeated for many years, if ever. As someone said, it was a "brutal lesson", which will have been learnt throughout the game.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 03 Jul 23 9.38am

Originally posted by JRW2

Two things:

First, a rule change which would have meant Bairstow wasn't legally out would be extremely hard, if not impossible, to frame.

Second, I don't think that that incident will be repeated for many years, if ever. As someone said, it was a "brutal lesson", which will have been learnt throughout the game.

OK, so in specific terms, why was he out?

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 03 Jul 23 9.52am

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

It's a shame this Ashes will be over-shadowed (whatever the result) by the stumping incident in this game. England gave it some wellie, but I still don't think they're good enough against the Aussies.

We lost by just 43 runs and Bairstow who was our batsman of the year last year was out for 10.

It's quite conceivable that he could have got a half century which means that we would have won so it's a shame that the whole match was decided by an unsportsmanlike gesture

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 03 Jul 23 9.54am

on the other hand, the Aussie wicket keeper noticed Bairstow had a tendency to leave his crease early for the previous few overs. He saw an opportunity and capitalised on Bairstow's casual approach, might be another way of looking at it.

Edited by Forest Hillbilly (03 Jul 2023 9.55am)

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

YT Flag Oxford 03 Jul 23 10.06am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

We lost by just 43 runs and Bairstow who was our batsman of the year last year was out for 10.

It's quite conceivable that he could have got a half century which means that we would have won so it's a shame that the whole match was decided by an unsportsmanlike gesture

Whereas in football, where it happens all the time, it's never a shame; in fact it's widely celebrated.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 03 Jul 23 10.23am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

We lost by just 43 runs and Bairstow who was our batsman of the year last year was out for 10.

It's quite conceivable that he could have got a half century which means that we would have won so it's a shame that the whole match was decided by an unsportsmanlike gesture

It’s a shame Crawley, Pope, Root or Brook, who got less than 30 between them didn’t contribute more, then the whole incident might not have been such an issue.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 03 Jul 23 10.31am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

OK, so in specific terms, why was he out?

You know why he was out. I'm sorry, I genuinely don't understand the question.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 03 Jul 23 10.49am

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

on the other hand, the Aussie wicket keeper noticed Bairstow had a tendency to leave his crease early for the previous few overs. He saw an opportunity and capitalised on Bairstow's casual approach, might be another way of looking at it.

Edited by Forest Hillbilly (03 Jul 2023 9.55am)

That's a fair way of looking at it.
It's like "Mankading" where the non-striker is run out by the bowler, although in that case the batsman is trying to gain an advantage which Bairstow wasn't. It seems unsporting but is within the laws.
Would Bairstow have done the same thing to Steve Smith? I suspect he would.
Personally I think it's unsporting to bowl bouncers at a number 11 rather than look for an easy wicket but that happens frequently.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 03 Jul 23 11.12am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

That's a fair way of looking at it.
It's like "Mankading" where the non-striker is run out by the bowler, although in that case the batsman is trying to gain an advantage which Bairstow wasn't. It seems unsporting but is within the laws.
Would Bairstow have done the same thing to Steve Smith? I suspect he would.
Personally I think it's unsporting to bowl bouncers at a number 11 rather than look for an easy wicket but that happens frequently.

Cricket needs to work on its rules. Catching has become unclear and unsporting behaviour is as much as ever - I don't agree with the mankad, nor Barstow's type of dismissal. I thought it interesting that he clearly makes his ground and both umpires are walking away. On the other hand, also interesting that Carey did it almost instantaneously. Almost - there is a thinking pause.
I think people have a point when they say Cummins could have withdrawn the appeal.
I've seen the same not given in matches I've played. I did it once as a slip fielder and was just laughed at and the game continued. Yes, I'm over competitive - I hear it all the time. And that's what this was. The Aussies with ball tampering and win at all costs are not helping the game. Far from it - it's dying out there as much as anywhere else, except the sub continent 20/20. Winning is all well and good but it shouldn't come at a price ala Man U under Ferguson. The Aussies are probably worse cheats and have been called out and caught more often than Rooney's had grannies.

 


Red and Blue Army!

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 03 Jul 23 11.25am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

We lost by just 43 runs and Bairstow who was our batsman of the year last year was out for 10.

It's quite conceivable that he could have got a half century which means that we would have won so it's a shame that the whole match was decided by an unsportsmanlike gesture

It's also conceivable that Stokes would not have attacked quite so much had Bairstow been alongside him, and may have gotten out himself for a lot less.

It is all distracting from the real issue, and giving us an excuse as to why we were hard done by. It's all so England (in all sport!). Up to that point Australia were giving us a lesson in Test Cricket; Adapting to the situation and demonstrating how to play. Would we have gone Short if it wasn't already tried so successfully by the Aussies?

'Bazball' is simply playing 50 over cricket over 2 innings. It might be exciting and will give the odd good win, but Test Cricket it is not.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 03 Jul 23 11.37am

As a slight aside, I know a friend of mine waited nearly 20 years on the waiting list to join the MCC. (he didn't pull any strings). He was so ecstatic when he got membership, that he went to as many events as possible. I even went as his guest to an evening of dinning, and I can say the MCC members I met were a very different breed to the working class.
So when I see 'young' MCC members giving grief (and some who look old enough to know better), it makes me wonder. The young 'uns can't be full members, as they'd know how to behave and wouldn't risk their membership.

So, for the MCC to say they've suspended members pending an investigation is quite a massive step. Losing your membership and being out of the MCC would be almost life-changing for a few.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Midlands Eagle Flag 03 Jul 23 12.01pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Would Bairstow have done the same thing to Steve Smith? I suspect he would.

Perhaps he would but I think that Stokes would have withdrawn the appeal

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 03 Jul 23 12.11pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Perhaps he would but I think that Stokes would have withdrawn the appeal

He may have but given the option of potentially making the series 1-1 rather than 0-2 he might have been happy to take the wicket.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 03 Jul 23 1.09pm

Originally posted by JRW2

You know why he was out. I'm sorry, I genuinely don't understand the question.

Yes, but what I'm getting at is why, as suggested, you cannot change the rules.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (03 Jul 2023 1.09pm)

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 03 Jul 23 2.50pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Yes, but what I'm getting at is why, as suggested, you cannot change the rules.

Change it how? The rule states that an over is over when the umpire calls over and you can't get clearer than that

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 03 Jul 23 2.54pm

Unfortunately the cheating colonial did the England team a favour, as everyone is now wrapped up in glorious outrage at the Bairstow stumping, rather than the absolutely appalling amateur hour that preceded.

4 top order Batsmen dismissed in under 9 overs for less than 30 runs is pathetic test cricket.

Crawley 3 Runs Overs faced 1
Pope 3 Runs Overs faced 1.4
Root 18 Runs Overs faced 5.4
Brook 4 Runs Overs faced .3

So while the dismissal of Bairstow is at best bad sportsmanship, and at worst outright cheating. the fault for the loss does not lay with the uppity colonials, but with our top order batsmen, who bar Duckett have been utterly shi1t.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 03 Jul 23 3.13pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Yes, but what I'm getting at is why, as suggested, you cannot change the rules.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (03 Jul 2023 1.09pm)

Thanks for clarifying that. But I didn't suggest the rules couldn't be changed, simply that IMO it would be very difficult to reword the existing rule to ensure that what you rightly called yesterday's "nonsense" couldn't happen again. I've given up trying.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 03 Jul 23 5.44pm

Bairstow grounded his bat in the crease before he left it straight after Carey had caught the ball, the square leg umpire was walking too - gamesmanship is one thing, this is more like footballers playing on during an injury, doesn't have the safety implications but there is a professional understanding - it should never have been given out.

 

YT Flag Oxford 03 Jul 23 6.33pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

Bairstow grounded his bat in the crease before he left it straight after Carey had caught the ball, the square leg umpire was walking too - gamesmanship is one thing, this is more like footballers playing on during an injury, doesn't have the safety implications but there is a professional understanding - it should never have been given out.

100% agree. I do wonder if the 'VAR' person accidentally pressed the wrong button.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Page 17 of 30 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > General Talk > Cricket Thread