This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Neither of us are writing a white paper. This needs some careful study and to then convince some Turkeys to vote for Christmas. I realise that central offices try to parachute their preferred voting sheep into seats, but it is still the local parties that make the choice. My own MP, who is a Tory, is very local, has strong connections with the area, and works hard. She has helped me a lot, writing to Ministers on my behalf. I have a meeting with her in a few weeks time. This local connection I want to see as the normal. I want to see the Party an MP belongs to become less relevant than their character. David Penhaligon was the local MP for 12 years, local and hugely popular amongst voters of every party. He happened to be a Liberal and could easily have led them had he not died in a car accident. We cannot avoid the party system completely, but I want to see Parliament asserting its authority when it chooses to do so, and not allowing itself to be whipped quite so readily by the party machines. I favour PR, with smaller parties gaining representation through a single transferrable vote. Doubtless coalitions would result, but these would have the benefit of stopping large variations in approach happening.
Who knows whether PR will take over from FPTP, I wouldn't think so but if you had said to me ten years ago that footballers would be kneeling at matches I'd have thought you mad. So let's just hope all of us are around in another ten years to see what's changed. Edited by Stirlingsays (28 Jul 2022 12.07am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| deleted 25 |
|
|---|---|
|
. Edited by Vincehair (28 Jul 2022 8.20am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
This is nonsense, which I suppose is only to be expected given its source. Moderate politics has nothing to do with the status quo! You can see the need for change from a "moderate" perspective, at least as well as from any other, probably better. Seeing the need for tolerance, compromise and respect and to do things with careful thought, good management and trying to bring everyone along with persuasive argument doesn't mean no change. Or, indeed, for decisive and urgent change. Taking a consistent middle road, with no wild swings from left to right, consuming time and energy when making corrections by one side or the other, is much more efficient and ultimately delivers a better result. You can see the benefits all over Europe. Populism is not just "what most people want". People want good government. They might think they want something else, but when you scratch below the surface, most people aren't stupid. They know 2 +2 = 4, and money doesn't grow on trees. Populism is pandering to instant gratification and the desire to win and hold onto office. It serves only the politicians who use it. That the wealth gap is continuing to widen is undoubtably true, but not because of some conspiracy involving governments, business, the media, food suppliers, pharma and central bankers. Having just returned from a week's holiday, my first abroad since Brexit, and visiting Spain, France and Italy during my trip, the contrast between the average citizen in those countries and ourselves is stark. They might be living with "ever increasing draconian legislation enforced by surveillance and control" but they look fitter, appear better educated, are more polite and respectful, have better behaved children, eat more sensibly and seem generally happier. They are doing something right, which we aren't. You want to blame some illogical groups who are only trying to operate within the boundaries we set for them. I blame Brexit and the Eurosceptics among us. The fact you simply can't see it is really your problem. You have a point. Have you not noticed how most autocratic states preach radical change but have, as their true modus operandi, an intense conservative zeal to maintain the status quo. Indeed, they are in power for the very purpose of unpleasantly suppressing the very changes that country no doubt desperately needs.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
You have a point. Have you not noticed how most autocratic states preach radical change but have, as their true modus operandi, an intense conservative zeal to maintain the status quo. Indeed, they are in power for the very purpose of unpleasantly suppressing the very changes that country no doubt desperately needs. Yeah, we really needed the higher crime rates, lower social cohesion and lower living standards and higher wealth inequality that neo and social liberalism has given the majority. Edited by Stirlingsays (28 Jul 2022 10.46am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
But the system in place is that preferred by those we supposedly elect to make decisions for us. Is it? I think it is preferred by those who currently control the party system. Give the MPs a free vote and we might be surprised.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
| W12 28 Jul 22 1.09pm | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Is it? I think it is preferred by those who currently control the party system. Give the MPs a free vote and we might be surprised. MP's rarely get a free vote on anything significant due to the whipping system. That's your "democracy" at work.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Is it? I think it is preferred by those who currently control the party system. Give the MPs a free vote and we might be surprised. Are they the elites?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Yeah, we really needed the higher crime rates, lower social cohesion and lower living standards and higher wealth inequality that neo and social liberalism has given the majority. Edited by Stirlingsays (28 Jul 2022 10.46am) This constant blaming of all our ills on "social liberalism" is an obsession without an actual basis. Do our Continental neighbours, and the Nordic countries, manage themselves using social democratic principles at their core? Are they more socially liberal than us? Are they more prosperous and happier than us? The answer to all must be yes! Do these countries suffer higher crime rates, lower social cohesion, lower living standards and higher wealth inequality than we do? The answer is clearly no. So it isn't "social liberalism" that causes this. Indeed, I would argue precisely the opposite. That the answer is to introduce real social liberalism into our country, with the aim of increasing opportunities, reducing discrimination, closing the wealth gap and raising living standards. Do that and the crime rate will fall. Our problem is not social liberalism. It's having both our major parties with feet of clay, and either unwilling or unable to reform themselves to ensure they are fit for purpose in today's world. We need social liberalism. We haven't yet got it.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by W12
MP's rarely get a free vote on anything significant due to the whipping system. That's your "democracy" at work. No it isn't! It's the current system at work, which requires a root and branch overhaul to become truly democratic.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Are they the elites? Not unless you regard Union bosses alongside multi-millionaire funders as elites. For me, it's a systemic failure which needs to be thrown away. I would severely limit the funding any individual, or organisation, could donate to a party. Buying influence is not acceptable. I would restrict the power of local parties to the selection of their candidate. I would fund political parties centrally, by raising specific taxes on large companies and VAT on luxury items. It would not be a lot in the scale of things. How that gets allocated is something that needs to be studied. Currently, small parties, without special interest backing, are disadvantaged and this needs to be rectified. How it gets spent needs to be controlled, with limits set so that it is the arguments that win, and not the funding.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
This constant blaming of all our ills on "social liberalism" is an obsession without an actual basis. Do our Continental neighbours, and the Nordic countries, manage themselves using social democratic principles at their core? Are they more socially liberal than us? Are they more prosperous and happier than us? The answer to all must be yes! Do these countries suffer higher crime rates, lower social cohesion, lower living standards and higher wealth inequality than we do? The answer is clearly no. So it isn't "social liberalism" that causes this. Indeed, I would argue precisely the opposite. That the answer is to introduce real social liberalism into our country, with the aim of increasing opportunities, reducing discrimination, closing the wealth gap and raising living standards. Do that and the crime rate will fall. Our problem is not social liberalism. It's having both our major parties with feet of clay, and either unwilling or unable to reform themselves to ensure they are fit for purpose in today's world. We need social liberalism. We haven't yet got it. Continental countries and Nordic countries before large scale immigration didn't have high crime rates and much higher social cohesion and the rest of it....Yes, everything I said is true for them as well. Compare the diverse areas with the non diverse areas for all those statistics.....or you know, continue to live in fantasy land. How about you move from non diverse Cornwall to Brixton and experience the reality. It's like listening to a communist say, 'real communism hasn't really been tried'. Up is down and left is right. Edited by Stirlingsays (28 Jul 2022 4.43pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| W12 28 Jul 22 3.40pm | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Continental countries and Nordic countries before large scale immigration didn't have high crime rates and much higher social cohesion and the rest of it....Yes, everything I said is true for them as well. Compare the diverse areas with the non diverse areas for all those statistic.....or you know, continue to live in fantasy land. How about you move from non diverse Cornwall to Brixton and experience the reality. It's like listening to a communist say, 'real communism hasn't really been tried'. Up is down and left is right. Edited by Stirlingsays (28 Jul 2022 2.29pm) I'm sure bringing millions of people from the middle east, pakistan, Afghanistan etc will help introduce "true" social liberalism. You know, because of our magic water and all that.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Continental countries and Nordic countries before large scale immigration didn't have high crime rates and much higher social cohesion and the rest of it....Yes, everything I said is true for them as well. Compare the diverse areas with the non diverse areas for all those statistics.....or you know, continue to live in fantasy land. How about you move from non diverse Cornwall to Brixton and experience the reality. It's like listening to a communist say, 'real communism hasn't really been tried'. Up is down and left is right. Edited by Stirlingsays (28 Jul 2022 4.43pm) My feet are firmly on the ground and my eyes wide open. I can see what the realities are, whilst you wish for an imaginary world that never actually existed. Why you continue to believe that me living in Cornwall makes any difference beats me, any more than you living in Wisbech, as I used to, does. I completely understand that different areas have different characters, that some are in transition. Since Brexit we have seen a huge increase in immigration here, particularly of health workers from Africa, replacing those from the EU who have returned to their home countries. I bet that is something you really wanted to happen! Measuring crime rates isn't simple and depends on what you decide to measure and whether the statistics can be trusted. Bringing out your favourite hobby horse of immigration to make unsubstantiated claims is therefore nonsensical. There simply isn't any evidence to support a causal link. Whilst the picture varies a little, my original statement is completely accurate. On average, the Continental European and Nordic countries are performing better than we are. Not only on crime rates, but in almost every other way. Having been in Spain, France and Italy in the past week I have seen this for myself, albeit on a tiny scale. I was in a seedy area of Naples for a few hours, full of immigrants from North Africa, crowded and suffering intense heat. Nevertheless, it didn't feel threatening. The people seemed to respect one another, communicated with each other, laughed together and seemed generally happy. Everyone knew they were needed. They are doing something right, which we aren't.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
My feet are firmly on the ground and my eyes wide open. I can see what the realities are, whilst you wish for an imaginary world that never actually existed. Why you continue to believe that me living in Cornwall makes any difference beats me, any more than you living in Wisbech, as I used to, does. I completely understand that different areas have different characters, that some are in transition. Since Brexit we have seen a huge increase in immigration here, particularly of health workers from Africa, replacing those from the EU who have returned to their home countries. I bet that is something you really wanted to happen! Measuring crime rates isn't simple and depends on what you decide to measure and whether the statistics can be trusted. Bringing out your favourite hobby horse of immigration to make unsubstantiated claims is therefore nonsensical. There simply isn't any evidence to support a causal link. Whilst the picture varies a little, my original statement is completely accurate. On average, the Continental European and Nordic countries are performing better than we are. Not only on crime rates, but in almost every other way. Having been in Spain, France and Italy in the past week I have seen this for myself, albeit on a tiny scale. I was in a seedy area of Naples for a few hours, full of immigrants from North Africa, crowded and suffering intense heat. Nevertheless, it didn't feel threatening. The people seemed to respect one another, communicated with each other, laughed together and seemed generally happy. Everyone knew they were needed. They are doing something right, which we aren't. If people in London gave their opinions on trawlermen or farming they'd be told they don't understand the problems but apparently everybody can explain city life.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
If people in London gave their opinions on trawlermen or farming they'd be told they don't understand the problems but apparently everybody can explain city life.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Returning to the subject matter, A YouGov poll found Conservative members backing Liz Truss by a margin of 24 points, so Sunak badly needs everything to go right. Members will receive ballot papers in the coming week.Members like Conservative voters at large, have a tendency to vote with some alacrity and typically just over half return by post.By and large minds have been made up and Sunak only has a short period to turn the tide. It's difficult to see Sunak getting the Members vote. While I have no time for either candidate, it was refreshing to see that Truss is to outlaw wolf whistling. It's not often a politician gets behind a cause that doesn't affect them personally
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
It's difficult to see Sunak getting the Members vote. While I have no time for either candidate, it was refreshing to see that Truss is to outlaw wolf whistling. It's not often a politician gets behind a cause that doesn't affect them personally
Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry. |
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
It's difficult to see Sunak getting the Members vote. Truss has seemingly an unassailable lead. I have actually been in conversation with a plethora of members, across an array of constituencies, and there is precious little support for Sunak. Heseltine famously said: "He who wields the knife never wears the crown." .There is a small but powerful sense Sunak backstabbed Boris Johnson whereas Truss is viewed as being loyal to him by not resigning. Edited by Willo (29 Jul 2022 10.10am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Truss has seemingly an unassailable lead. If Truss becomes our next Prime Minister I will vote Liberal at the next General Election for the first time in my life. One of her claims is that if she promises something she always carries it out yet she promised to be faithful to her husband yet didn't manage to carry that one through. Every time I think of her I think of cheese or pork so I can't really take her seriously
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.