You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Brighton vs. Crystal Palace match thread
November 16 2026 2.46am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Brighton vs. Crystal Palace match thread


Page 17 of 17 << First< 13 14 15 16 17
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 04 Feb 24 2.24pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


People have the right to express how they feel and banners are not an issue confronting players is not good I agree but it's not those fans who have done this if a player is approaching them that is player at fault.

How do you know it wont help the cause?

Protests are not a new thing and throughout history not just sports have helped.

Correct not everything can be managed but your next part is BS.

How did we manage before having Eze/Olise as regulars this is not first year in this league over a decade now.

Edouard is our top scorer with very poor service.

Eze/Olize are not forwards

Could the injuries be related to the training and medical staff I believe it is which comes down to amateur setup we have and if a player has just returned you ease them in we don't do that.

You really do not understand much about football do you.

Signed two good players you do not know this yet (I expect both will)

We wont sack Roy he will leave at end of season unless he calls it a day I dont see that happening unless he has personal issue.

Lets say he did go Paddy would take charge we wouldn't get anyone in Palace take ages to do anything.

And the club have the right to cancel their tickets.

I'll tell you what I understand.

Negativity achieves nothing in football and you are the king of negativity.
Those at the club will be keener than anyone to improve things.

We have lost Zaha, Doucoure and now Eze and Olise, not to mention Joel Ward of late.
That is the primary reason why we have struggled. You can argue about summer transfers and tactics but they are not the primary causes.
Talking about the medical staff is just conjecture. You have no idea what goes on.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Feb 24 2.29pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

And the club have the right to cancel their tickets.

I'll tell you what I understand.

Negativity achieves nothing in football and you are the king of negativity.
Those at the club will be keener than anyone to improve things.

We have lost Zaha, Doucoure and now Eze and Olise, not to mention Joel Ward of late.
That is the primary reason why we have struggled.
You can argue about summer transfers and tactics but they are not the primary causes.
Talking about the medical staff is just conjecture. You have no idea what goes on.

I agree with the general trust of these sentiments, in relation to Zaha,Doucoure,Eze and Olise.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 04 Feb 24 2.40pm

We've had striker problems for years, but the last couple of seasons our defence has been pretty good and we have been genuinely hard to beat. However, the last few games, our defence has been pretty awful and keeping Henderson in goal is truly puzzling.

 

bright&wright Flag 04 Feb 24 3.04pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I wouldn't be surprised or particularly bothered if the idiot(s) holding up banners were barred from attending. Idiots confronting players need to grow up.

None of this will help our cause.

There are some things in football that cannot be managed, and when your two best forward players are constantly injured, there isn't much that can be done. This put pressure on the defence, which is then likely to concede more goals. It also damages confidence.

We have signed two good players and we have to quickly develop a system to grind out results. We need 4 more wins.

Sacking Hodgson is a very risky move. It might work, or it might be disastrous. Who replaces him? Without Eze and Olise, it don't see how we win games with any manager.

We have to get them back on the pitch.


I don't like it when people have different opinions to me. Ban them for life. Clap along and be nice or don't come at all.

Roy, is that you?

 


'We are going to make a little bit of history here’ Mr. J. Ertl.

Cornwall Eagle Flag 04 Feb 24 4.06pm

Like many I have been a strong Roy supporter, and his win against Man U early in the season was brilliant. However, he has struggled to balance the team this year and stalwarts like Schlupp have become less effective. It is true that we have injuries but Olise and Eze have largely got us out of jail when we are struggling. The defence ( previously Roy’s strongpoint) has been found out too often and we are conceding too many set piece goals. We do need a change.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Feb 24 4.10pm

Originally posted by Cornwall Eagle

Like many I have been a strong Roy supporter, and his win against Man U early in the season was brilliant. However, he has struggled to balance the team this year and stalwarts like Schlupp have become less effective. It is true that we have injuries but Olise and Eze have largely got us out of jail when we are struggling. The defence ( previously Roy’s strongpoint) has been found out too often and we are conceding too many set piece goals. We do need a change.

I have been in communication with a few supporters today and to a man they believe that a change is necessary.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 04 Feb 24 4.59pm

Originally posted by Willo

I have been in communication with a few supporters today and to a man they believe that a change is necessary.

That's the easy bit. Do any of them suggest who should replace him?

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 04 Feb 24 5.20pm

Originally posted by Willo

I suspect the most effective protest would be to stay well clear of Selhurst Park. Rows and rows of empty seats would send a powerful message and the 'Optics' would not look good.
Not that I am advocating this course of action.


I would agree if people was paying for just the ticket but they are not most will hold season tickets meaning the club is getting your money anyway.


Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

And the club have the right to cancel their tickets.

I'll tell you what I understand.

Negativity achieves nothing in football and you are the king of negativity.
Those at the club will be keener than anyone to improve things.

We have lost Zaha, Doucoure and now Eze and Olise, not to mention Joel Ward of late.
That is the primary reason why we have struggled. You can argue about summer transfers and tactics but they are not the primary causes.
Talking about the medical staff is just conjecture. You have no idea what goes on.


No the club needs valid reasons to just cancel tickets and even if they do they will need to offer refund.

Who would want to pay to watch that rubbish it's why I stopped going.

Ward such a massive loss that guy is world class as I said you are clueless.

Did I say only medical staff NO

Again go and get educated on how football works its a team game and not just the 11 on the pitch the team is all the staff as well this works like a business does.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

thegreatlardino Flag crawley/selsey 04 Feb 24 5.30pm

i dont think henderson has been at fault for any of the goals in the last 2 games, especially the sheff utd game, one deflection the other was guehi and richards fault..yesterday 2 headers, our CB's seem to have forgotten to head the ball.

 


Sometimes I set out for Ludlow
Sometimes I end up in Chepstow

palace chick Flag South Croydon 04 Feb 24 5.37pm

Originally posted by thegreatlardino

i dont think henderson has been at fault for any of the goals in the last 2 games, especially the sheff utd game, one deflection the other was guehi and richards fault..yesterday 2 headers, our CB's seem to have forgotten to head the ball.

I prefer Johnstone because his distribution is better than Henderson. He also looks in control and the defence seems calmer when he plays? I do think that Henderson is a good goalkeeper though but still don’t understand why he was purchased instead of a cheaper but good backup to Johnstone?

 

XKudu Flag The Midlands, England 04 Feb 24 5.49pm

Many on here said yesterday when we were 3-0 down that it would be crazy to bring on Olise unless we scored 2 goals in first 30 mins of second half. Only then would the gamble be proportionate as he would only have 20 mins to navigate and we would have a real sniff of getting something.

I was head in hands when he came on beginning of second half when we were still 3-0 down. It was asking for trouble and odds on a hiding to nothing.

An odd decision from Roy and one of his big gaffs.

Edited by XKudu (04 Feb 2024 5.53pm)

Edited by XKudu (04 Feb 2024 5.54pm)

 

PatrickA Flag London 04 Feb 24 5.58pm

About the only positive thing from yesterday was Mateta's excellent headed goal, which I don't think anyone has mentioned.
Clutching at straws I know, but impressive nonetheless.
With minus 14 GD we need all the help we can get.

 

Houston Eagle Flag Houston 04 Feb 24 6.18pm

Originally posted by palace chick

I prefer Johnstone because his distribution is better than Henderson. He also looks in control and the defence seems calmer when he plays? I do think that Henderson is a good goalkeeper though but still don’t understand why he was purchased instead of a cheaper but good backup to Johnstone?

I was going to type an essay but this echos my thoughts

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 04 Feb 24 8.16pm

Originally posted by thegreatlardino

i dont think henderson has been at fault for any of the goals in the last 2 games, especially the sheff utd game, one deflection the other was guehi and richards fault..yesterday 2 headers, our CB's seem to have forgotten to head the ball.

The little box within the bigger box is the keeper’s domain. They are supposed to control that area. Neither Johnstone or Henderson do but Johnstone is marginally better.

Henderson looked glued to the spot whenever the ball was crossed, so I can’t agree that he was entirely without blame for two of the goals. Even if he can’t get there himself he should be directing the defence but he looks like a young kid rather than a dominant keeper.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 04 Feb 24 9.05pm

Originally posted by Uphill

I don't think Henderson was particularly to blame for the 4 goals but he has now conceded 11 in the last 3 games. His appointment (and high wages) is a sorry condemnation of Parish/Freedman's mind set. I would much prefer Johnstone who, after all, is a current England international.

Parish should stay until an orderly buy out is achieved. Where he stands indicted is his reluctance to take action over the manager.

I have to say Hodgson has lost it. He picks the same line-up match after match so that the opposition know exactly how we will play and take full advantage of it. He has no offensive ambition or idea, is reluctant to drop his favourites who have been proven inadequate. He does have younger talent but patently mistrusts them. His decision to risk Olise was incomprehensible and he has rightly been criticised in the press (and by us - but we don't count) His deluded belief that 'heart and effort' will suffice is
pathetic.

In his dotage he still feels he can rectify the decline but it will take some doing with our confidence shattered.


Yep. Good post

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 05 Feb 24 7.22am

Originally posted by Uphill

I don't think Henderson was particularly to blame for the 4 goals but he has now conceded 11 in the last 3 games. His appointment (and high wages) is a sorry condemnation of Parish/Freedman's mind set. I would much prefer Johnstone who, after all, is a current England international.

Parish should stay until an orderly buy out is achieved. Where he stands indicted is his reluctance to take action over the manager.

I have to say Hodgson has lost it. He picks the same line-up match after match so that the opposition know exactly how we will play and take full advantage of it. He has no offensive ambition or idea, is reluctant to drop his favourites who have been proven inadequate. He does have younger talent but patently mistrusts them. His decision to risk Olise was incomprehensible and he has rightly been criticised in the press (and by us - but we don't count) His deluded belief that 'heart and effort' will suffice is
pathetic.

In his dotage he still feels he can rectify the decline but it will take some doing with our confidence shattered.

It certainly was.

If the medical team said that they felt Olise could manage 45 minutes, he should have been properly warmed up pre match and started the game.

Bringing him on with the game already done made no sense.

As soon as Olise pulled up on the halfway line, I left the stadium, I was so angry.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

silvertop Flag Portishead 05 Feb 24 9.31am

And it is going to get worse, with the critical injuries, confidence shattered and rudderless management.

Truthfully, I heard an interview on R5 and there was considerable sympathy for Roy. With Eze and Olise playing together, we are lethal. Without one or both we are toothless. They have hardly played together through injuries to both.

That is not wholly Roy's fault. The dearth of available payers is the owners and they are only now seeking to rectify that.

However, what that should have produced was a staunch, never die attitude from those available to play. It isn't there. And what causes greatest concern to me is the fact that Roy is known for his defence. we lose, sure, but don't get stuffed. However, we have shifted 11 goals in 3 matches with the same 4 defenders we had before.

Something is very wrong.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 05 Feb 24 10.01am

Originally posted by PatrickA

About the only positive thing from yesterday was Mateta's excellent headed goal, which I don't think anyone has mentioned.
Clutching at straws I know, but impressive nonetheless.
With minus 14 GD we need all the help we can get.

Wasn't it just. Especially as he was outside the front post. Really great header.

Shame we don't cross the ball more.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 05 Feb 24 10.40am

Originally posted by NEILLO

It certainly was.

If the medical team said that they felt Olise could manage 45 minutes, he should have been properly warmed up pre match and started the game.

Bringing him on with the game already done made no sense.

As soon as Olise pulled up on the halfway line, I left the stadium, I was so angry.

if he had a hamstring issue he shouldn't have played at all.

If he was ok to play i wonder if he didn't warm up properly. To feel something so early, after less than 10 minutes, suggests the muscle wasn't fully warmed up

 

Page 17 of 17 << First< 13 14 15 16 17

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Brighton vs. Crystal Palace match thread