You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Max Meyer thread
November 16 2026 6.33am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Max Meyer thread


Page 18 of 27 < 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 >
Username Flag Horsham 02 Apr 19 12.26pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Sick and tired of watching the mismanagement of Max Meyer.

I hope he leaves Palace asap and gets his career back on track, and perhaps in years to come Roy will understand what he has done.

Hodgson could write an essay on how to NOT properly integrate foreign signings into the side. Patchy game time, deployed in the wrong position and system, and the only player all year to be subbed off at half time I believe. Talk about destroying a player's confidence completely and utterly.

The whole team was rubbish in the first half on Saturday, as we sleep walked through yet another first half at home. Schlupp had a far worse half, yet it is Meyer who gets subbed and now carries the can for how bad that half was, totally unfairly.

Why on earth did we sign the player in the first place when he is too lightweight for Roy and Hodgson plays long ball tactics half the time.

We were hoofing the ball up to Batshuayi and bypassing the midfield way too often.
Michy is not good enough in the air and its yet another example of the wrong setup by Hodgson. It finally started to work once Benteke was in there.

Meyer is a high class player, Roy seems incapable of playing to his strengths and prefers to deploy him in the incorrect position and with a job of work to do that he is no good at.

Let him leave and get his confidence back at a team managed by someone who takes the shackles off and lets players express themselves, and backs them, not puts a target on their back with the earliest substitution all year.


Yes, because our ball playing midfielder was nowhere to be found. We were playing the ball around and getting nowhere, and then going long because that was the only option.

Luka was essentially being man-marked, Meyer should have had plenty of space to move into and provide another option and he didn't do it.

When he did get the ball, he was far too quick to just roll it straight back to someone without taking a touch and looking for other options.

I've mentioned it before, but the moment when he got the ball in the No.10 spot, with the opportunity to play in Zaha was the moment for him to show what he can do. Instead he just passed it to Schlupp who was two yard to his left, and it was up to Schlupp to attempt a much more difficult pass which then just ran straight through to the keeper.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Painter Flag Croydon 02 Apr 19 1.18pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Sick and tired of watching the mismanagement of Max Meyer.

I hope he leaves Palace asap and gets his career back on track, and perhaps in years to come Roy will understand what he has done.

Hodgson could write an essay on how to NOT properly integrate foreign signings into the side. Patchy game time, deployed in the wrong position and system, and the only player all year to be subbed off at half time I believe. Talk about destroying a player's confidence completely and utterly.

The whole team was rubbish in the first half on Saturday, as we sleep walked through yet another first half at home. Schlupp had a far worse half, yet it is Meyer who gets subbed and now carries the can for how bad that half was, totally unfairly.

Why on earth did we sign the player in the first place when he is too lightweight for Roy and Hodgson plays long ball tactics half the time.

We were hoofing the ball up to Batshuayi and bypassing the midfield way too often. Michy is not good enough in the air and its yet another example of the wrong setup by Hodgson. It finally started to work once Benteke was in there.

Meyer is a high class player, Roy seems incapable of playing to his strengths and prefers to deploy him in the incorrect position and with a job of work to do that he is no good at.

Let him leave and get his confidence back at a team managed by someone who takes the shackles off and lets players express themselves, and backs them, not puts a target on their back with the earliest substitution all year.


A high class player can play anywhere in midfield and impose himself on the game. Meyer is obviously not anywhere that standard.
It was always a bit odd that he came on a free, if he was so highly rated, none of the top clubs were interested, now we know why.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 02 Apr 19 4.30pm

Still think there's a fantastic player there but Saturday was abysmal and must have been a career low for him.

He starred as a sub for Schalke in that pre season friendly if I remember right? Palace have a long and proud history of signing players who play well against us.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

radsyrendot Flag From Coventry now in Leicester 02 Apr 19 5.08pm

Don't get me wrong he is a quality player touches of genius..BUT...HE needs the play at he's potential keep playing him ..he needs to adapt

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Apr 19 5.24pm

Originally posted by Painter

A high class player can play anywhere in midfield and impose himself on the game. Meyer is obviously not anywhere that standard.
It was always a bit odd that he came on a free, if he was so highly rated, none of the top clubs were interested, now we know why.

I made similar sentiments a while back.I think he was a 'Free' because he never wanted to sign another contract with Schalke but I could be wrong on this matter.Despite being on a 'Free', there never appeared to be a great clamour for his services.

He has done nothing for us to suggest he is a quality player who just needs to settle.

 

pieceofcake Flag Cell 36,HMP Albany 02 Apr 19 5.35pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Sick and tired of watching the mismanagement of Max Meyer.

I hope he leaves Palace asap and gets his career back on track, and perhaps in years to come Roy will understand what he has done.

Hodgson could write an essay on how to NOT properly integrate foreign signings into the side. Patchy game time, deployed in the wrong position and system, and the only player all year to be subbed off at half time I believe. Talk about destroying a player's confidence completely and utterly.

The whole team was rubbish in the first half on Saturday, as we sleep walked through yet another first half at home. Schlupp had a far worse half, yet it is Meyer who gets subbed and now carries the can for how bad that half was, totally unfairly.

Why on earth did we sign the player in the first place when he is too lightweight for Roy and Hodgson plays long ball tactics half the time.

We were hoofing the ball up to Batshuayi and bypassing the midfield way too often. Michy is not good enough in the air and its yet another example of the wrong setup by Hodgson. It finally started to work once Benteke was in there.

Meyer is a high class player, Roy seems incapable of playing to his strengths and prefers to deploy him in the incorrect position and with a job of work to do that he is no good at.

Let him leave and get his confidence back at a team managed by someone who takes the shackles off and lets players express themselves, and backs them, not puts a target on their back with the earliest substitution all year.


Do you think Roy needs more experience with overseas players?

After all he's only managed Halmstad, Oddevold, Orebro,Malmo,Neuchatel,Inter Milan, Grasshoppers, Copenhagen,Udinese and Viking.

Apart from managing the national teams of Switzerlan,UAR and Finland.

But maybe you're right.

 

pieceofcake Flag Cell 36,HMP Albany 02 Apr 19 5.56pm

Like many on this site,I really wanted Meyer to shine.I wasn't really worried about his stature.He is about the same height as Cabaye,and Huddersfield's Alex Pritchard(who I thought was their best attacker on Saturday).Or put another way,Meyer is 7cm taller than the great Billy Bremner,who played in a more physical era and could certainly dish it out.


Maybe Meyer isn't being played in the best position;maybe the EPL doesn't suit his style.I don't know.


What I do know is that he was not able to make an impression against the worst team the EPL has seen for many years.


However,I do hope he stays for another season to try and regain the form he showed at Schalke.

 

PatrickA Flag London 02 Apr 19 6.25pm

It is valid to say that very good players can adapt and play different roles, and Meyer has not demonstrated to date that he can do this in his limited opportunities.
However, I have some sympathy with him as many of us have cried out for him to play in an advanced central midfield role with Kouyate and Luka behind him.
Meyer’s mandate would be to get us morning the ball quicker in the final third where he can link up with Wilf and other attacking players.
In fairness I don’t think he has been tried in this position and I don’t believe Roy would even necessarily try this.
I hope that when we’re mathematically safe Roy will show a little more tactical flexibility with a view to seeing what players can do.

 

Johng Flag 14 Apr 19 8.29pm

The young man did good when he came on today. His vision is exceptional. Opportunities opened up as soon as he came on. I, for one, will be well pissed off if he's not at the club next season.

 

gerry theagle Flag newbury 14 Apr 19 9.09pm

Don't think he made any difference today tbh, in fact I can't remember him being really involved at all. If he'd have been playing instead of Jimmy Mac then we would have been beaten by a lot more. At the moment he is not a 90 minute player for us, not saying that he is useless but he needs to add strength and toughness to his skills but being a vegan I can't see how he can add these attributes to his game.

 

Alex1991 Flag Ashford 15 Apr 19 12.19am

Originally posted by gerry theagle

Don't think he made any difference today tbh, in fact I can't remember him being really involved at all. If he'd have been playing instead of Jimmy Mac then we would have been beaten by a lot more. At the moment he is not a 90 minute player for us, not saying that he is useless but he needs to add strength and toughness to his skills but being a vegan I can't see how he can add these attributes to his game.

Pretty sure with the nutritional experts these players work with he'll be fine. Probably has a far more balanced diet than 99 percent of the population.

 


"Brighton are talking about how they're coming for us. And it's like, we've been waiting in the Premier League for you for ages." Wilfried Zaha, 2017.

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 15 Apr 19 6.05am

Said it before, say it again - Max Meyer is 1st class footballer. How he has to sit on the bench With likes of Schlupp and Macca (Yeah, I know his industry) on the Pitch, is Beyond me.
Play him behind Wilf With Luka and Kouyate covering rest of midfield. Not for ten, fifteen minutes or one game - give the lad a couple of games in starting line up.
He will shine...100%!

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 15 Apr 19 7.59am

Meyer is a curious case because he looks so good when he’s got the ball it may disguise the fact that sometimes he’s not actually doing very much. Presumably his strength can be worked on because he’s not actually that small; not to compare them beyond the physical but he’s the same height as Eden Hazard and could give Messi a couple of inches. There’s an open goal for somebody.

 

butascratch Flag Nottingham 15 Apr 19 8.51am

I really want Meyer to do well. The promise of a young, gifted, international from the continent is really exciting and seems like the kind of signing we should be making to kick on. However they don't seem to deliver...
Reideweld, Rakip, Campana, even Jach all had similarly exciting back stories.

I thought Macca was the only one trying to get the ball done and play first half. Players looked scared of being open for a pass. We were better with Meyer on but I think that some of that is coincidence. We were pushing for an equaliser and Wilf had swapped wings etc.

 


I read this board everyday but never write anything; except this.

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 15 Apr 19 8.55am

Should play every week along side Kouyate with Luka behind holding.

Simple as that.

 

gbox82 Flag Meols, Wirral 15 Apr 19 9.17am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Should play every week along side Kouyate with Luka behind holding.

Simple as that.

Certainly against the weaker opposition, this would be my preferred line-up. One for next season maybe?

Jimmy Mac still has a lot to offer though, particularly in a game where we spend the vast majority without the ball

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 15 Apr 19 10.48am

I think I can recall Meyer playing one 15 yard squarish ball yesterday. I can't think of much else. To be fair most of our play yesterday was forgettable though.
I would point out that it was Jimmy Mac's surging run that won the free kick for the goal. I do think he comes in for so unfair criticism.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 15 Apr 19 1.00pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

I think I can recall Meyer playing one 15 yard squarish ball yesterday. I can't think of much else. To be fair most of our play yesterday was forgettable though.
I would point out that it was Jimmy Mac's surging run that won the free kick for the goal. I do think he comes in for so unfair criticism.

It hit its mark though, unlike the others who repeatedly punt four yard passed straight to the opposition.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 15 Apr 19 1.01pm

Originally posted by gbox82

Certainly against the weaker opposition, this would be my preferred line-up. One for next season maybe?

Jimmy Mac still has a lot to offer though, particularly in a game where we spend the vast majority without the ball

Not knocking Macca, everyone loves a guts and thunder player.

Him OR Luka for me though. Perfect player to inject some stamina in the latter stage of games from the bench.

 

Rogers Don Flag Horsham 13 May 19 11.35am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Max Meyer' by bexleydave

I thought he was superb yesterday. It shows what he can bring to the side if he is played in a forward position.

 


Let's keep the ball this season!

Page 18 of 27 < 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Max Meyer thread