This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by ex hibitionist
Bairstow grounded his bat in the crease before he left it straight after Carey had caught the ball, the square leg umpire was walking too - gamesmanship is one thing, this is more like footballers playing on during an injury, doesn't have the safety implications but there is a professional understanding - it should never have been given out. I think so too imo the ball is dead once the bat is grounded in the crease.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
I think so too imo the ball is dead once the bat is grounded in the crease. As a former cricketer and then umpire, I agree with you on this, my friend. It's as clear as day that Bairstow made a point of demonstrating that he was returning to the crease before then departing to confer with his colleague. Play should have been deemed to have stopped at that point. The fact that BOTH umpires at that point had basically stopped umpiring - the square leg man staring his journey to the stumps and the bowler's end umpire turning towards the bowler - make it even more bizarre that someone in the stands managed to decree that the ball was still in play.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
I concur. If Bairstow hadn't been so casual, the opportunity wouldn't have existed. The issue for me is that No-one(including the umpires) gave the aussies enough time to 'finish the ball'. Carey caught it and threw it almost immediately back to the stumps, which he's allowed to do.
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
The reaction in Australia was probably the same when the substitute fielder (Gary Pratt?) ran out Ponting in 2005 when the convention was to stick a sub out somewhere on the boundary. I'm sure that the substitute fielder for Nathan Lyon was close fielding
|
|
|
As Bairstow is the wicket keeper he will be looking for any opportunity to "mankad" an Aussie in the next Test so they need to be careful
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
I'm sure that the substitute fielder for Nathan Lyon was close fielding Yes but the convention in 2005 was to keep them as far away as possible.
|
|
|
|
|
|
A cricket war crime, and must be referred to the International war crimes tribunal. Don't be vague, send it to the Hague.
|
|
|
Originally posted by JRW2
Thanks for clarifying that. But I didn't suggest the rules couldn't be changed, simply that IMO it would be very difficult to reword the existing rule to ensure that what you rightly called yesterday's "nonsense" couldn't happen again. I've given up trying. One has to ask why a batsman needs to touch ground with his bat when he has crossed the line with both feet. Surely that is sufficient to be in, and a new rule could make that so. The other stumping that is absurd is when a batsman is moving down the wicket as the bowler is running in.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
A cricket war crime, and must be referred to the International war crimes tribunal. Don't be vague, send it to the Hague.
Crikey, you are older than I thought!
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
One has to ask why a batsman needs to touch ground with his bat when he has crossed the line with both feet. Surely that is sufficient to be in, and a new rule could make that so. The other stumping that is absurd is when a batsman is moving down the wicket as the bowler is running in. That is sufficient to be "in", but I suppose the issue is that Bairstow then left the crease again, believing it had been established that the ball was dead. This happens all the time in all forms of cricket, but suddenly the Australians have weaponised it. A minor point that in no way diminishes your final sentence is that what you describe is actually a run-out rather than a stumping.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by YT
That is sufficient to be "in", but I suppose the issue is that Bairstow then left the crease again, believing it had been established that the ball was dead. This happens all the time in all forms of cricket, but suddenly the Australians have weaponised it. A minor point that in no way diminishes your final sentence is that what you describe is actually a run-out rather than a stumping. Yes, that's correct. The key point here is that once the ball is dead and the batsman has been in, then that should be it until the bowler has bowled the next ball. It's fairly obvious, without the pedantry. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (04 Jul 2023 3.54pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Yes, that's correct. The key point here is that once the ball is dead and the batsman has been in, then that should be it until the bowler has bowled the next ball. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (04 Jul 2023 3.54pm) Well since you've taken offence in your characteristics style to a well-intended comment, it's not a matter of pedantry but one of accuracy. Furthermore the laws pertaining to a run-out are completely different to those pertaining to a stumping. Also you've now merged your two examples into one, but in the one involving the bowler, the ball is live throughout so "once the ball is dead" has no meaning.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Yes, that's correct. The key point here is that once the ball is dead and the batsman has been in, then that should be it until the bowler has bowled the next ball. It's fairly obvious, without the pedantry. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (04 Jul 2023 3.54pm) From memory the bowler can't start his run up until the umpire has said "play". Once he's done so the ball is live unless something happens like him dropping the ball before bowling or the batsman pulls away for some reason and the umpire signals a dead ball.
|
|
|
Originally posted by YT
Well since you've taken offence in your characteristics style to a well-intended comment, it's not a matter of pedantry but one of accuracy. Furthermore the laws pertaining to a run-out are completely different to those pertaining to a stumping. Also you've now merged your two examples into one, but in the one involving the bowler, the ball is live throughout so "once the ball is dead" has no meaning. I have not taken offence. I am trying to stick to the point, which is that once a batsman has been in, he should not be able to be stumped until the next ball is bowled. I see nothing confusing about that. On the separate issue of a bowler knocking off the bails because the batsman has strayed from his crease in anticipation of a run, then what ever you call it, that is also something that the game does not need. Change the rules for both. Sorted.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.