You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Coronavirus and the impact of Lockdown policy
November 21 2026 10.14pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Coronavirus and the impact of Lockdown policy


Page 18 of 174 < 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 >
Bobby216 Flag 05 Mar 23 11.38pm

The argument about legitimacy doesn't hold water due to the uncovering of these messages being in the public interest. It clearly is in the public interest for the reasons stated previously. As for not knowing what would happen if we hadn't continued our lockdown both in 2020 and at various times during 2021 and nearly locking down for Xmas 2021 / 2022, yes we do. You only need to look at the differing response in Sweden, Florida and to a lesser extent Japan to see an alternative response to the same "threat" in comparable Western countries that was far more proportionate. The difference was that in these districts / countries they had strong leaders that were willing to go against the tide instead of being caught up in the panic and hysteria as we were here. Although some benefit of the doubt can be given in the initial months of the pandemic due to understandably not knowing how deadly the virus was or how it behaved, it was clear by May and June 2020 the virus was nowhere near as deadly as the government and media were making out. Anyone with the inclination could have gone on to the office for national statistics and looked for themselves. The problem was no one was bothering to look.

Unfortunately it will take decades for a proper reflection and fair analysis of what has happened. It is likely the enquiry won't take into the account the affect of lockdowns and an intense focus of the virus above all else on peoples lives. This includes but is in no way limited to the tens of thousands of people missing cancer diagnoses. Indeed my neighbour had his chemo stopped in April 2020 to make space for covid patients whilst everyone was clapping and banging their saucepans. He died in early 2021 of cancer. I also heard of the blanket DNR's (Do not resuscitates) placed on vulnerable individuals. Considered less important than Covid patients. We lost a sense of our humanity in a quag mire of fear perpetuated by government policy that has now been highlighted by these WhatsApp revelations.


That would only be true if she had uncovered these documents legitimately but even then the newspaper would be still be guilty of titillation by publishing selected extracts out of context.

She was given them in confidence, and even signed a non-disclosure agreement. That is disgusting behaviour, whatever the extracts are. I find nothing in them which is particularly surprising. It was a chaotic time, with decisions being taken under great pressure. That some stupid exchanges took place is only to be expected, especially given who was in charge.

Short, sharp lockdowns were the preferred answer in most major countries, supported by advice from both the WHO and our own experts. How they were delivered was the job of the politicians.

That some disagreed then, and still do now, doesn't mean it was wrong. It just means some disagreed. There are always some who disagree with every policy. It's also true that whilst we all know how difficult the lockdowns were and how economically costly, we don't know what would have happened had we not had them. What we have are a bunch of know-it-alls who think they know. The same group who always know better about everything.

We need to wait for the enquiry for a truly objective assessment.

 

Bobby216 Flag 05 Mar 23 11.40pm

The argument about legitimacy doesn't hold water due to the uncovering of these messages being in the public interest. It clearly is in the public interest for the reasons stated previously. As for not knowing what would happen if we hadn't continued our lockdown both in 2020 and at various times during 2021 and nearly locking down for Xmas 2021 / 2022, yes we do. You only need to look at the differing response in Sweden, Florida and to a lesser extent Japan to see an alternative response to the same "threat" in comparable Western countries that was far more proportionate. The difference was that in these districts / countries they had strong leaders that were willing to go against the tide instead of being caught up in the panic and hysteria as we were here. Although some benefit of the doubt can be given in the initial months of the pandemic due to understandably not knowing how deadly the virus was or how it behaved, it was clear by May and June 2020 the virus was nowhere near as deadly as the government and media were making out. Anyone with the inclination could have gone on to the office for national statistics and looked for themselves. The problem was no one was bothering to look.

Unfortunately it will take decades for a proper reflection and fair analysis of what has happened. It is likely the enquiry won't take into the account the affect of lockdowns and an intense focus of the virus above all else on peoples lives. This includes but is in no way limited to the tens of thousands of people missing cancer diagnoses. Indeed my neighbour had his chemo stopped in April 2020 to make space for covid patients whilst everyone was clapping and banging their saucepans. He died in early 2021 of cancer. I also heard of the blanket DNR's (Do not resuscitates) placed on vulnerable individuals. Considered less important than Covid patients. We lost a sense of our humanity in a quag mire of fear perpetuated by government policy that has now been highlighted by these WhatsApp revelations.

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

That would only be true if she had uncovered these documents legitimately but even then the newspaper would be still be guilty of titillation by publishing selected extracts out of context.

She was given them in confidence, and even signed a non-disclosure agreement. That is disgusting behaviour, whatever the extracts are. I find nothing in them which is particularly surprising. It was a chaotic time, with decisions being taken under great pressure. That some stupid exchanges took place is only to be expected, especially given who was in charge.

Short, sharp lockdowns were the preferred answer in most major countries, supported by advice from both the WHO and our own experts. How they were delivered was the job of the politicians.

That some disagreed then, and still do now, doesn't mean it was wrong. It just means some disagreed. There are always some who disagree with every policy. It's also true that whilst we all know how difficult the lockdowns were and how economically costly, we don't know what would have happened had we not had them. What we have are a bunch of know-it-alls who think they know. The same group who always know better about everything.

We need to wait for the enquiry for a truly objective assessment.

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 06 Mar 23 12.24am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Yep, I think a lot of boomers and some Gen Xers in the west fear dying much more than previous generations. I mean it's hardly a popular activity but previous generations had more of an acceptance of its inevitability.

I think the rise in the effectiveness of modern medicine and the commonality of lots of people living relatively well to a grand old age has created a kind of unreality with mortality.

Add to that the feminisation of society in general and the almost disappearance of stoicism and stiff upper lip culture and you have a cocktail that was just waiting to spill over when something like a virus turned up.

Society's reaction to covid over these last two years could be compared to bad break outs of new viruses of the past....68 for example.

It's night and day.

The country that produced the kind of people who died with honour on the Titanic had degenerated in a little over a century later into scared and embarrassing parody.

Edited by Stirlingsays (05 Mar 2023 10.53pm)

I believe that the discovery of medicine has created this as an unintended consequence. Gender realignment is deemed acceptable, even though the person cannot actually become another gender and naturally reproduce. We now keep people alive even if they wish to die. People have needless cosmetic surgery, organ transplants, joint replacements, corneal implants.... but we struggle to feed the world.

And all the scientists had to do was to scare them into it, which got a huge nudge in 2020.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Stirlingsays Flag 06 Mar 23 12.58am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3779914]

I believe that the discovery of medicine has created this as an unintended consequence. Gender realignment is deemed acceptable, even though the person cannot actually become another gender and naturally reproduce. We now keep people alive even if they wish to die. People have needless cosmetic surgery, organ transplants, joint replacements, corneal implants.... but we struggle to feed the world.

And all the scientists had to do was to scare them into it, which got a huge nudge in 2020.

Yep, modern medicine and the delusions of transhumanism by those who think their biology is negotiable.....When you look behind its mask it has worryingly high levels of funding.

In my view there is certainly an illusion of kindness in emboldening and in effect mainstreaming, what is in reality mental illness, and we are already seeing significant societal problems with mental health.

It's going to be difficult filling the jobs in our mental health institutions because it's going to be fruitcake city.....which isn't good as seemingly some (or at least the management) of those working in those institutions are fruit and nut themselves.

Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Mar 2023 1.00am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 06 Mar 23 1.06am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Yep, modern medicine and the delusions of transhumanism by those who think their biology is negotiable.....When you look behind its mask it has worryingly high levels of funding.

In my view there is certainly an illusion of kindness in emboldening and in effect mainstreaming, what is in reality mental illness, and we are already seeing significant societal problems with mental health.

It's going to be difficult filling the jobs in our mental health institutions because it's going to be fruitcake city.....which isn't good as seemingly some (or at least the management) of those working in those institutions are fruit and nut themselves.

Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Mar 2023 1.00am)

Scary times to come I'm afraid. This current trend of victimhood should hopefully pass in a generation. Or two at the most. Fingers crossed...

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Stirlingsays Flag 06 Mar 23 1.24am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3779916]

Scary times to come I'm afraid. This current trend of victimhood should hopefully pass in a generation. Or two at the most. Fingers crossed...

Indeed mate.

Turbulent times.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Eden Eagle Flag Kent 06 Mar 23 6.51am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Stresses always find the weakest points first. Of course, it's unfortunate, but a great deal of support was given, and I suspect many of those that closed were going to fail anyway. This just hastened it.

The long term impact on schooling could be significant, and not all of it negative. My two youngest grandchildren are doing OK, having done a lot of online learning. I don't dismiss the impact on some, but again, people can catch up remarkably.

More “tone deaf” commentary from you WE - supporting the crushing lockdowns whilst drawing your pension and income from your buy to let property portfolio whilst others lost everything.

My daughter is a teacher and the impact from nearly 2 years of lost face to face lessons is still being felt today. You also supported mask wearing for children in schools despite the serious impact this had on the education of tens of thousands of children with hearing difficulties who rely on lip reading.

That you still support your fanatical lockdown views now when there is so much evidence to counter the effectiveness of this “policy” is staggering but not surprising.

Even during the CV times it was proven in the US where some states adopted stringent lockdowns and others no lockdowns that lockdowns did not work.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards berlinpalace Flag berlin 06 Mar 23 7.40am

Everyone banging on about how well Sweden coped might like to read the Swedish review of their Covid response. If they could do it again they’d do it differently and stricter. Worth noting that by the time of the second wave the ‘freedom loving Swedes’ were enacting new Pandemic laws.

[Link]

 

Matov Flag 06 Mar 23 7.57am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays


The country that produced the kind of people who died with honour on the Titanic had degenerated in a little over a century later into scared and embarrassing parody.

Edited by Stirlingsays (05 Mar 2023 10.53pm)

Quite. When you realise that some of the richest people alive at that time had the opportunity to get on a life-boat and declined to do makes you wonder who amongst our current 'elites' would do similar.

The West has zero nobility anymore. In every sense of the word

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 06 Mar 23 7.58am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3779890]

How true. I still see people wearing surgical style masks, and avoiding others not wearing them, even though they have no benefit whatsoever. They still believe the lie. I said right from the beginning that they were of no use in a viral situation. I even questioned the use of ffp2/n95 mask efficiency for a virus too, but was shouted down by the lockdown advocates. There are reports out now, but as usual, there will be silence from the COVID restrictions aggressors.

Cochrane report [Link]

Edit: I found an advocate of mask wearing admitting he was wrong on YT [Link]

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (05 Mar 2023 9.26pm)

If wearing a mask is a "lie" why then does my wife, who is a nurse in our local hospital, wear one at all times when facing patients? Is she wasting her time, and our money? Or is she protecting herself, or her patient, from the possibility of a cough or a sneeze overloading the environment close to her? She knows it isn't perfect, but she and her colleagues all wear them without complaint, and they are all trained medical professionals. Are they fools? What do you know better, and what qualifications do you have that have enabled that knowledge?

If my wife, and those she is in contact with derive benefit, why won't others when in contact with other people? She isn't from a unique species.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 06 Mar 23 8.06am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Let's hope so. We would all be much better off if such views remained as unacceptable as they deserve to be. So long as they are just on videos, which can be ignored, and only viewed by the like-minded, little harm is done.

I just love the way that people who think the way you do believe that the kind of ridiculous insults you use to describe the "establishment" impresses anyone outside the group you are part of. It's just each of you confirming your biases.

By the way I believe it's much better to be awake, and aware of the need for change to address long-standing unfairness and prejudices, than asleep and unaware, or just ignorant and uncaring. I am proud that our shared humanity today means we are no longer thinking in the small-minded, selfish way which we used to.

Spoken like a true supporter of the undemocratic EU, supporter of secrecy in our parliament, supporter of the arrest of people silently praying, supporter of businesses being forced to carry political slogans on their products, supporter of the persecution of anyone with views you disagree with – a true Woke Freedom Fighter. Do you send lists of ‘enemies of the people’ to the HOL moderators to get them cancelled? What will you guys do when you run out of targets – turn on yourselves of course.

[Link]

Edited by georgenorman (06 Mar 2023 8.53am)

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 06 Mar 23 8.15am

Originally posted by Eden Eagle

More “tone deaf” commentary from you WE - supporting the crushing lockdowns whilst drawing your pension and income from your buy to let property portfolio whilst others lost everything.

My daughter is a teacher and the impact from nearly 2 years of lost face to face lessons is still being felt today. You also supported mask wearing for children in schools despite the serious impact this had on the education of tens of thousands of children with hearing difficulties who rely on lip reading.

That you still support your fanatical lockdown views now when there is so much evidence to counter the effectiveness of this “policy” is staggering but not surprising.

Even during the CV times it was proven in the US where some states adopted stringent lockdowns and others no lockdowns that lockdowns did not work.

What I support is doing things that the consensus of expert opinion suggests is the best at the time. Then holding a thorough, objective investigation afterwards to see what lessons can be learned in preparation for similar events.

What I don't support are self-opinionated know-it-alls claiming that their opposition has been proved right, when then enquiry has yet to be even started. It might be, but that doesn't mean that we made mistakes at the time. We must always do what appears to be best, even if some disagree.

I know there were casualties, and that there are residual impacts. That's inevitable and would have been whatever strategy was adopted. If the anti-lockdown advocates had had their way they would still exist, but they would just be different. Whether better, or worse, cannot be known, because we have no evidence. All we have are the claims of the know-it-alls, who rely on events elsewhere when environments and circumstances don't replicate ours.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Stirlingsays Flag 06 Mar 23 8.27am

In general nurses are nurses because they do as they are told. You don't get to that position if you're a rebel. The same way footballers did the roman salute or kneel today.

Masks are more part of the medical uniform. High court lawyers use to wear wigs, it's part of the culture.

Masks are largely performative in terms of success. The totality of research has been saying this for a long time now. Only the strongest types make any difference at all and only in specific instances not over time.....Proof of the absurdity of the whole episode was the fact that the vast majority of masks were in effect just cloth over your face and in effect ridiculous.....yet you had to wear one.

It was all about social compliance, all about showing you supported the madness and hysteria. A void of critical thinking.

What happened with masks was nothing short of a totalitarian disgrace.

Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Mar 2023 8.28am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 06 Mar 23 8.35am

While I'm quite well known for being anti getting into wars now....which as a former neo con goes against my former form....it is really quite something just how scot free the Chinese got away with this whole thing.

In terms of criticism I think they are fully deserving of the blame for this whole event yet they escaped pretty much everything....you couldn't even call the virus the normal naming convention because the woke jokes in place at the institutions wanted to virtue signal.

Of course, some could also say that who funds ends up being who runs.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 06 Mar 23 8.37am

Originally posted by georgenorman

Spoken like a true supporter of the undemocratic EU, supporter of secrecy in our parliament, supporter of the arrest of people silently praying, supporter of the persecution of anyone with views you disagree with – a true Woke Freedom Fighter. Do you send lists of ‘enemies of the people’ to the HOL moderators to get them cancelled? What will you guys do when you run out of targets – turn on yourselves of course.

[Link]

You make me laugh. No matter how hard I try to explain that the EU is democratic, but just in a different way, that I don't want parliament to be secret, just the voting of its members to be done in private, that "silent praying" is fine, but intimidation is not and that whilst persecution is never acceptable, nor is restricting the rights of people not to hear, or give space to, things if they choose not to. Deciding you no longer want to represent someone, or cancelling their booking, is not persecution. It's the precise opposite. It's freedom.

I have been watching "Rise of the Nazis" on iPlayer. There are several episodes. Whilst the events themselves are all pretty well known this is a detailed exploration of the motivations and psychological mind sets of the senior Nazis, explained by some very well qualified experts.

There are chilling parallels to some attitudes around today, providing lessons which ought never be forgotten.

Why do I mention this? If you haven't seen it then take some time and do. It's well worthwhile. Then, perhaps, you will understand.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 06 Mar 23 8.49am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

In general nurses are nurses because they do as they are told. You don't get to that position if you're a rebel. The same way footballers did the roman salute or kneel today.

Masks are more part of the medical uniform. High court lawyers use to wear wigs, it's part of the culture.

Masks are largely performative in terms of success. The totality of research has been saying this for a long time now. Only the strongest types make any difference at all and only in specific instances not over time.....Proof of the absurdity of the whole episode was the fact that the vast majority of masks were in effect just cloth over your face and in effect ridiculous.....yet you had to wear one.

It was all about social compliance, all about showing you supported the madness and hysteria. A void of critical thinking.

What happened with masks was nothing short of a totalitarian disgrace.

Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Mar 2023 8.28am)

All of the above can be summarised with just 2 letters. BS.

That nurses are disciplined doesn't mean they cannot think, and I haven't encountered one yet, and because of my wife I have met many, who doesn't think they are a sensible precaution.

It is just common sense that restricting a heavy viral load being expelled in a concentrated way is better than not doing so.

Whilst the wearing of simple cloth coverings were more to do with reassurance than impact in the early days, those days are behind us.

I would love to see you debate your approach with not only the nurses but the specialist consultants I know. They would tear you to pieces.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Teddy Eagle Flag 06 Mar 23 9.07am


[Link]

 

eaglesdare Flag 06 Mar 23 9.23am

All us "Conspiracy theorists" continue to be proved correct with each passing day.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 06 Mar 23 9.44am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

In general nurses are nurses because they do as they are told. You don't get to that position if you're a rebel. The same way footballers did the roman salute or kneel today.

Masks are more part of the medical uniform. High court lawyers use to wear wigs, it's part of the culture.

Masks are largely performative in terms of success. The totality of research has been saying this for a long time now. Only the strongest types make any difference at all and only in specific instances not over time.....Proof of the absurdity of the whole episode was the fact that the vast majority of masks were in effect just cloth over your face and in effect ridiculous.....yet you had to wear one.

It was all about social compliance, all about showing you supported the madness and hysteria. A void of critical thinking.

What happened with masks was nothing short of a totalitarian disgrace.

Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Mar 2023 8.28am)

Nonsense

There has been far more recent research

A large, randomized trial led by researchers at Stanford Medicine and Yale University has found that wearing a surgical face mask over the mouth and nose is an effective way to reduce the occurrence of COVID-19 in community settings.

2021

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 06 Mar 23 9.45am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

You make me laugh. No matter how hard I try to explain that the EU is democratic, but just in a different way, that I don't want parliament to be secret, just the voting of its members to be done in private, that "silent praying" is fine, but intimidation is not and that whilst persecution is never acceptable, nor is restricting the rights of people not to hear, or give space to, things if they choose not to. Deciding you no longer want to represent someone, or cancelling their booking, is not persecution. It's the precise opposite. It's freedom.

I have been watching "Rise of the Nazis" on iPlayer. There are several episodes. Whilst the events themselves are all pretty well known this is a detailed exploration of the motivations and psychological mind sets of the senior Nazis, explained by some very well qualified experts.

There are chilling parallels to some attitudes around today, providing lessons which ought never be forgotten.

Why do I mention this? If you haven't seen it then take some time and do. It's well worthwhile. Then, perhaps, you will understand.

Looking for tips?

“War is peace. Freedom is slavery. Ignorance is strength.”
"Threats to freedom of speech, writing and action, though often trivial in isolation, are cumulative in their effect and, unless checked, lead to a general disrespect for the rights of the citizen."
Orwell could have been writing about the likes of you.

Edited by georgenorman (06 Mar 2023 9.50am)

 

Page 18 of 174 < 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Coronavirus and the impact of Lockdown policy