This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Performance of the new government
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
cryrst The garden of England 28 Jul 24 9.16am |
|
Originally posted by orpingtoneagle
Depends on the union...I am a senior union rep as well as everything else (so leftie liberal woke etc.) Some reps are the most corporate people I have met. In my union role I have on too many times to remember supported dismissal for all.sorts of reasons. These days to get the job done we can't carry passengers. (But totally accept that is not always the case especially in some areas.)
Thanks orpie. I do believe a thread has some middle ground from both sides. I think you are lucky personally with your pension and fair play. You must be on the index linked version. Did this get canned a few years ago as it was too much ?
|
beak croydon 28 Jul 24 5.26pm |
|
Originally posted by orpingtoneagle
Depends on the union...I am a senior union rep as well as everything else (so leftie liberal woke etc.) Some reps are the most corporate people I have met. In my union role I have on too many times to remember supported dismissal for all.sorts of reasons. These days to get the job done we can't carry passengers. (But totally accept that is not always the case especially in some areas.)
The employer hires people that are not up to it and then don't like the union putting up a robust defence and rely on the workers to do extra overtime to settle the deficit caused.
|
cryrst The garden of England 29 Jul 24 8.00am |
|
|
[Link]
The tories had to do the very same thing but selective memory loss will be prevalent in some !
|
HKOwen Hong Kong 29 Jul 24 9.03am |
|
|
Labour really don't have to care about anything for the next four years, the manifesto will be long forgotten by then
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.
|
orpingtoneagle Orpington 29 Jul 24 9.08am |
|
Originally posted by cryrst
[Link]
The tories had to do the very same thing but selective memory loss will be prevalent in some !
Agreed, I reckon this will be the state of politics now. It's really easy in opposition to promise the earth. It's even easier for a party that knows realistically it stands zero chance of government to chuck in the moon and stars as well.
When we have seen the party of government change in recent times (Conservative to Labour back to conservative and now back to labour it has been pretty clear that there was going to be political change.
This has made it all to easy for government to kick the can down the road and leave a mess for others to clear up.
|
silvertop Portishead 29 Jul 24 9.41am |
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Well I can certainly tell you that not many companies in the private sector would buy all the flexy time but. Also playing the system happens in both environments. The difference is in the private sector once found out your gone but in the public sector the unions have a lot of sway to keep mr useless in his job.
Not as much as you think. And most of the old guard for whom that work culture was institutionalized were pensioned off at the austerity hurdle.
The new public sector is more private sector ruthlessness with public sector pay.
|
The Dolphin 29 Jul 24 11.52am |
|
Originally posted by orpingtoneagle
Why is it ok for say someone who works in the private sector to work at home and not a civil servant? I am a civil servant and work from home 2 days a week. On office days I probably work an 8 hour day. At home more likely to be 9. I don't know anyone it any of the teams I work in who spends all day shopping or down the pub. There is zero evidence that home working is less productive and as the last government shut all the offices, if we all went in there would not be enough room for everyone to actually work.
Just because certain political figures like to pedal the myth all civil servants are lazy sods does not make it true. Like any job there are good and bad.
I took a day off last week to go to The Oval. It was full of folks out on corporate jollys getting bevvied in the sun. Probably on expenses. They were all probably 'at work.'
Sorry for the late response and no personal insult intended. I believe that if you work in the Public Sector that you should work in your office or other place of work, unless there are very good reasons not to. Not all Civil Servants or Public Sector workers are lazy sods but many are and I have the misfortune to have to deal with some of them, so my views are probably tarnished. Not being at their place of work, uncontactable except by email but because you can't call them, you often don't get an email response for days. Generally - Public Sector life is easier than the private sector with a nice pension, more holidays than most and pay almost on a par now as well. Forgive me if you don't agree but that is how I see it. There are exceptions to every rule but I personally do not see the point in the proposed inflation busting pay rises, allowing WFH to be more commonplace and increasing the numbers of public sector workers, when, with efficiencies numbers could be reduced.
|
The Dolphin 29 Jul 24 11.54am |
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I think we need to differentiate between various types of jobs . There are some jobs which can be done anywhere, but need management and supervision to function. Back offices or call centres being examples. There are others which can be done from home but need occasional group meetings, some remote, others personal. There are others where some functions can be accomplished at home whilst others need to be in the office, or in the field with customers.
So if a civil servant living in Surrey whose Ministry is in central London can function most of the time at home, but needs to be in the office a couple of times a month, they can manage it and be efficient in doing so. Not though if they were 3000 miles away.
The best way to work is with other people around you. People to bounce ideas off, people being in the same building where you can go and talk to them face to face. We are social animals as much as anything and interaction is good for the soul.
|
orpingtoneagle Orpington 29 Jul 24 12.17pm |
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
Sorry for the late response and no personal insult intended. I believe that if you work in the Public Sector that you should work in your office or other place of work, unless there are very good reasons not to. Not all Civil Servants or Public Sector workers are lazy sods but many are and I have the misfortune to have to deal with some of them, so my views are probably tarnished. Not being at their place of work, uncontactable except by email but because you can't call them, you often don't get an email response for days. Generally - Public Sector life is easier than the private sector with a nice pension, more holidays than most and pay almost on a par now as well. Forgive me if you don't agree but that is how I see it. There are exceptions to every rule but I personally do not see the point in the proposed inflation busting pay rises, allowing WFH to be more commonplace and increasing the numbers of public sector workers, when, with efficiencies numbers could be reduced.
No offence taken. Sadly even if it was made compulsory to work in an office 5 days a week, it is impossible as the last government shut offices and sold premises off wholesale. Now there is simply not enough space available for full time office working.
The contact point is interesting and not unique to public service. It is impossible to contact many organisations on the phone these days as you either don't have an option or you get caught in the endless circle of the automated call?
I don't agree on pay, You cannot use basic pay as a comparator most public service workers may have seem basic pay gaps narrow but very few workers in the public service get any meaningful bonus payments. If the jobs were that great everyone would want one.
But hey good and bad in every organisation.
We need public services but for many years no government has been willing to invest in them
|
HKOwen Hong Kong 29 Jul 24 1.03pm |
|
|
Civil servants have no right to criticise the working habits of the private sector.
If you don't have access to the members bar at the Oval the drinks are so expensive you meed to be on expenses.
Edited by HKOwen (29 Jul 2024 1.04pm)
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.
|
HKOwen Hong Kong 29 Jul 24 1.09pm |
|
|
Back on topic, Reeves has zero credibility in feigning surprise at the financial state of things . She and Labour knew all the numbers well before the elections.
Now come the cuts for the unfunded extras like the junior doctors pay hike for which no provision was made in the " costed " manifesto.
One Labour minister claimed they had discovered 300 million of undeclared cost for the Rwanda scheme, that may well be but it's insignificant to a " 20bn black hole"
They're coming for your pensions and capital gains tax on mpre and more.
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.
|
orpingtoneagle Orpington 29 Jul 24 2.10pm |
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
Back on topic, Reeves has zero credibility in feigning surprise at the financial state of things . She and Labour knew all the numbers well before the elections.
Now come the cuts for the unfunded extras like the junior doctors pay hike for which no provision was made in the " costed " manifesto.
One Labour minister claimed they had discovered 300 million of undeclared cost for the Rwanda scheme, that may well be but it's insignificant to a " 20bn black hole"
They're coming for your pensions and capital gains tax on mpre and more.
I assume you can demonstrate this by evidence as opposed to your usual level of dog whistle political statements
|
cryrst The garden of England 29 Jul 24 2.35pm |
|
Originally posted by orpingtoneagle
I assume you can demonstrate this by evidence as opposed to your usual level of dog whistle political statements
Orpie you may have jumped in a bit quick I’m afraid. I reckon that tax is a coming with it being the tories fault!
|
The Dolphin 29 Jul 24 3.05pm |
|
|
The Junior Doctor's pay rises are mind boggling. Someone said - might not be true - that they got between 11% and 32% back in 2017 and there have been other rises since. The pension/NI contribution made by the taxpayer is 23.4% on top of that. So - using an easy figure of £100k - an 11% rise this year and another 11% on top of that next year actually works out as 13.53% this year including the uplift and a15.36% uplift in a years time - plus back pay as well apparently. So £100k now - without the uplift for pensions etc - will be £123,210 in 12 months time plus overtime etc. I accept that £100k is near the top of pay but it gives an example. The rest of the public sector are going to get just over 5% by the time this is over as well. Two things - they will come back for more and threaten strikes in 2 years time and Rachel Reeves black hole is absolute rubbish - she just wants to spend our money without any fight or discussion. If the OBR didn't point out the black hole then they should be sacked - but they did and they won't be. She is a bare faced liar.
|
orpingtoneagle Orpington 29 Jul 24 3.17pm |
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Orpie you may have jumped in a bit quick I’m afraid. I reckon that tax is a coming with it being the tories fault!
Of course we will see a blame game. I suspect(but of course can not prove it that any deficit however big will be at least in part arise from what we have seen a lot in recent years, kick the can down the road and worry about it later.
|
Runningman Keston 29 Jul 24 4.05pm |
|
|
Winter fuel allowance for pensioners cut. Unless in receipt of pensions credit.
Let’s hit the poorest to fund above inflation pay rises for public sector workers.
Talk about levelling up !
|
Hrolf The Ganger 29 Jul 24 4.10pm |
|
|
Same old Labour. A ridiculous pay rise for junior doctors and then a lot of codswallop about 22 billion black holes.
It's sad that we have to endure another 5 years of Labour tax and waste before another generation realises why Labour don't get to be a government very often.
|
DANGERCLOSE London 29 Jul 24 4.11pm |
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Same old Labour. A ridiculous pay rise for junior doctors and then a lot of codswallop about 22 billion black holes.
It's sad that we have to endure another 5 years of Labour tax and waste before another generation realises why Labour don't get to be a government very often.
Agreed
|
The Dolphin 29 Jul 24 4.17pm |
|
Originally posted by Runningman
Winter fuel allowance for pensioners cut. Unless in receipt of pensions credit.
Let’s hit the poorest to fund above inflation pay rises for public sector workers.
Talk about levelling up !
That one is really bad. People on a basic pension will no longer receive winter help but the NHS and public sector will be having a field day and their gold plated pensions will rise. Labour is about to get a short sharp shock - not that they need worry about it. Feed the beast as in the public sector and Unions and all will be well.
|
DANGERCLOSE London 29 Jul 24 4.25pm |
|
Originally posted by Runningman
Winter fuel allowance for pensioners cut. Unless in receipt of pensions credit.
Let’s hit the poorest to fund above inflation pay rises for public sector workers.
Talk about levelling up !
Labour are s***e
|