You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread
November 16 2026 7.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Roy Hodgson thread


Page 19 of 65 < 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 >
Straightbackup Flag Crystal Palace 22 Dec 18 7.32pm

I don’t like to post negative stuff about fellow fans, but for you idiots calling for his head after the Brighton game, you can now sit down and shut up. We won today because of is tactical nous and experience, simple as that.
He’s a superb coach and I for one think we are very lucky to have him.

 


'Impulse' advert- Advertising campaign whose slogan is expected to change in the light of Rajiv Gandhi's assassination: 'If someone you don't know suddenly offers you flowers- run like f***!'

gerry theagle Flag newbury 22 Dec 18 7.48pm

On my way back from the match, agree 100% with Stirling, he had City well stuffed and the players carried out his instructions perfectly.

 

gerry theagle Flag newbury 22 Dec 18 7.50pm

Oops not Stirling, Straight backup.

 

davehuggins Flag 22 Dec 18 7.54pm

Roy really has done wonders for us, not just today. He has got us playing as a unit and to a degree very good and attractive football. Our results this season have not until today reflected our performances. For me, he is by far the best we have had in charge for a very long time. So, happy Christmas Roy and thanks for making mine!!

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Dec 18 9.12pm

Originally posted by timmyb

Overheard a bloke at Selhurst last week saying Roy had one game to save his job.

He'd heard a whisper Roy had lost the dressing room.

Which goes to show what utter tosh people talk at football.

Well done all at cpfc today.

That never looked the case but the lack of in game management and same thing every week with lack of ideas and players not really playing in their natural positions was a real concern. Well done to anyone who never doubted him but most with experience and knowledge of the game would have because there were some serious things that you can’t be sure to survive if they aren’t addressed.

 


COYP

gerry theagle Flag newbury 22 Dec 18 10.34pm

Addressed well today Rudi.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 22 Dec 18 11.41pm

18 points from 18 games with no striker is not to be sniffed at. Doing a good job with what he's got.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 23 Dec 18 12.32am

Utter madness that people were calling for his head after the Brighton game. It’s embarrassing how short sighted some people are. Some seem to expect success over night, but sadly that’s the reality for many modern day fans.

It’s clear that he has been doing an excellent job with limited resources for a long time. Performances have been consistently good but we haven’t had the results. Today over 90 minutes City were the better team but we took our chances exceptionally well and had a bit of luck on our side.

Congratulations Roy, you’ve deserved a result. This will keep the wally’s quiet until our next defeat.

Win against Cardiff and the pressure is off. Hopefully we can push for a cup run.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 23 Dec 18 1.09am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

That never looked the case but the lack of in game management and same thing every week with lack of ideas and players not really playing in their natural positions was a real concern. Well done to anyone who never doubted him but most with experience and knowledge of the game would have because there were some serious things that you can’t be sure to survive if they aren’t addressed.

No you mean people like you who think they know more than Roy find every excuse to have a go at him ,
Those with experience and any knowledge of the game do not doubt him actually watch the games and see he week in week out puts the best available team to him out on the pitch and gives them the best possible game
Plan to get something out of any given game.
Sometimes the luck goes against you, as in Brighton given a two goal start ,and sometimes like today all is perfect.
We are not sure to survive anyhow just like 12 other teams because some of it is down to luck , but we have the best possible manager for us in charge to give us our best possible chance .

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Dec 18 9.23am

Originally posted by MKCPFC

No you mean people like you who think they know more than Roy find every excuse to have a go at him ,
Those with experience and any knowledge of the game do not doubt him actually watch the games and see he week in week out puts the best available team to him out on the pitch and gives them the best possible game
Plan to get something out of any given game.
Sometimes the luck goes against you, as in Brighton given a two goal start ,and sometimes like today all is perfect.
We are not sure to survive anyhow just like 12 other teams because some of it is down to luck , but we have the best possible manager for us in charge to give us our best possible chance .

People like me? Do you even watch football or know what you’re talking about?

And no, what Roy was doing was what England managers have done in recent history. He was picking the best players and shoe horning them into positions they don’t suit. When subs are needed, even just rest legs, Roy was preferring to use none. Think Chelsea away for the best example. We thought originally it was because he had nobody on the bench to put on but since seen he doesn’t put them on at all, or maybe for a 10 minute run out when it’s too late.

I never called for his head, but I did say concerns were growing. We’ve been playing well but there were still issues of what we were doing in the final 3rd. We beat a poor Burnley and Leicester for that matter at home but when we faced a challenge at Brighton we were pathetic again. Versus Man City we were fortunate that for a change we took all of our chances and they missed theirs to get a result.

Not taking anything away from Roy and the team because they’ve dug themselves out of it but please don’t try and pretend there weren’t and probably still aren’t causes for concern. Or do so if you like. Our current methods will be found out by others, as happens at this level, and there will be tests of unavailable players in the front 6. What will Roy do then? Admit defeat by playing people out of position in the permanent 4-4-2, rather than change it up a bit to deal with the selection limitations, or be a bit flexible?

You may be suffering with a bit of memory loss going by the posts of people losing enthusiasm or interest earlier this season. It certainly was dour stuff but hopefully we can kick on from here because although we’re on a high after that result, the team must remember they beat 2 poor teams at home and took their chances from 22% of possession vs Man City but then when faced with an equal battle vs Brighton we crumbled to pieces. They kind of looked like they were complacent, believing their own hype vs Brighton. Do that again and we will get beaten convincingly.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (23 Dec 2018 9.26am)

 


COYP

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 23 Dec 18 10.09am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

People like me? Do you even watch football or know what you’re talking about?

And no, what Roy was doing was what England managers have done in recent history. He was picking the best players and shoe horning them into positions they don’t suit. When subs are needed, even just rest legs, Roy was preferring to use none. Think Chelsea away for the best example. We thought originally it was because he had nobody on the bench to put on but since seen he doesn’t put them on at all, or maybe for a 10 minute run out when it’s too late.

I never called for his head, but I did say concerns were growing. We’ve been playing well but there were still issues of what we were doing in the final 3rd. We beat a poor Burnley and Leicester for that matter at home but when we faced a challenge at Brighton we were pathetic again. Versus Man City we were fortunate that for a change we took all of our chances and they missed theirs to get a result.

Not taking anything away from Roy and the team because they’ve dug themselves out of it but please don’t try and pretend there weren’t and probably still aren’t causes for concern. Or do so if you like. Our current methods will be found out by others, as happens at this level, and there will be tests of unavailable players in the front 6. What will Roy do then? Admit defeat by playing people out of position in the permanent 4-4-2, rather than change it up a bit to deal with the selection limitations, or be a bit flexible?

You may be suffering with a bit of memory loss going by the posts of people losing enthusiasm or interest earlier this season. It certainly was dour stuff but hopefully we can kick on from here because although we’re on a high after that result, the team must remember they beat 2 poor teams at home and took their chances from 22% of possession vs Man City but then when faced with an equal battle vs Brighton we crumbled to pieces. They kind of looked like they were complacent, believing their own hype vs Brighton. Do that again and we will get beaten convincingly.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (23 Dec 2018 9.26am)


Yes you , and yes I do and more so than you.

No further debate required as you will argue black is white in any disagreement.

Merry Christmas.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Dec 18 10.43am

Originally posted by MKCPFC


Yes you , and yes and I think I know more so than you but have nothing to say.

No further wanted because I haven’t a clue about what I’m watching.

Merry Christmas.

EFA

 


COYP

Aray Flag South London 23 Dec 18 1.25pm

I have criticised Roy in recent weeks - the poor use of substitutions is one particular bugbear of mine. But managers are assessed on the results.

Roy should take the plaudits for bringing in Schlupp who did well - much to my surprise. That said I was at the Fulham game and he has got a mean shot. He was at his dynamic bustling best.

Top management.

 

Simbo2703 Flag Sayers common 28 Feb 19 12.06pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'boring tactics' by Midlands Eagle

How many times are we only level or behind at home,at half time, Hodgson is so negative and even gives the lesser teams far too much respect, the full backs aren't give freedom / midfielders not given freedom to get in the box, and hence most times we are chasing games,Hodgson have a look at what solskjaer did - let the players off the leash, I'm so fed up watching 'boring football'in the first 45.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 28 Feb 19 12.28pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'boring tactics' by Midlands Eagle

Totally agree. It's like he tells them to wait 20=30 mins to see how the games going then gradually work our way into the game. It's the same every game. We play no different wether home of away. I could sort of understand it if after 20-30 mins and things weren't going great he tries a different formation, or our non existent plan B. Ladt night was a classic example. It was basically a free hit. Utd knew exactly the team we would put out and how we would play. Why not suprise them and play 442 with Benteke upside thd new guy and really go at thd first 20 mins. At least it would have given thd fans something to get excited about

Edited by spartakev2 (28 Feb 2019 12.29pm)

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 28 Feb 19 1.14pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'boring tactics' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by Simbo2703

How many times are we only level or behind at home,at half time, Hodgson is so negative and even gives the lesser teams far too much respect, the full backs aren't give freedom / midfielders not given freedom to get in the box, and hence most times we are chasing games,Hodgson have a look at what solskjaer did - let the players off the leash, I'm so fed up watching 'boring football'in the first 45.

Totally agree. With RH I suspect he will always be happier with a 0-0 than a 1-1 or a 2-2. The problem with playing for a 0-0 (and some recent games I have had the sneaking suspicion that this is what has been played for) is that when the opposition inevitably score first due to our passive, negative tactical approach, we have to find another gear. We should be in that gear from the off!

 

leejaneagles Flag 28 Feb 19 2.12pm

I think the 'free-hit' is the best way to describe last night and why it was so wrong.

Away at Leicester it made some sense. It's really hard to try and argue against a 4-1 win so I won't and say he got it right, even if we did look awful first half and I tihnk the result flattered us.

But United at home knowing the teams below dropped points? Max Meyer scored against Doncaster recently but also was probably the best player at Old Trafford earlier in the season when we got a 0-0.

Horses for courses is also an expression Roy doeesn't seem aware of. He prefers Schlupp to Kouyate at the moment in midfield, that's his opinion whether some fans agree or not is irrelevant.

What isn't irrelevant is that last night we had to mark Pogba in the midfield and Kouyate could have out-jumped him. Some times it's not just about form or best player, it's who is right for a specific job.

We don't have a plan B as someone else mentioned and that's so infuriating in these games. We shipped 3 goals anyway and it was bloody hard for a lot of people to get to the ground after work on a Wednesday night. I'd rather us have lost 3-0 with Benteke up-top with Batshuyi and Max Meyer trying to forward at all times. We weren't likely to ship more than 3 anyway and at least we could have been entertained.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 28 Feb 19 2.24pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

I think the 'free-hit' is the best way to describe last night and why it was so wrong.

Away at Leicester it made some sense. It's really hard to try and argue against a 4-1 win so I won't and say he got it right, even if we did look awful first half and I tihnk the result flattered us.

But United at home knowing the teams below dropped points? Max Meyer scored against Doncaster recently but also was probably the best player at Old Trafford earlier in the season when we got a 0-0.

Horses for courses is also an expression Roy doeesn't seem aware of. He prefers Schlupp to Kouyate at the moment in midfield, that's his opinion whether some fans agree or not is irrelevant.

What isn't irrelevant is that last night we had to mark Pogba in the midfield and Kouyate could have out-jumped him. Some times it's not just about form or best player, it's who is right for a specific job.

We don't have a plan B as someone else mentioned and that's so infuriating in these games. We shipped 3 goals anyway and it was bloody hard for a lot of people to get to the ground after work on a Wednesday night. I'd rather us have lost 3-0 with Benteke up-top with Batshuyi and Max Meyer trying to forward at all times. We weren't likely to ship more than 3 anyway and at least we could have been entertained.

Could you explain what a plan B is? Isn’t that making substitutions.

 

PatrickA Flag London 28 Feb 19 6.02pm

The next three games are against Burnley, Brighton and Watford.
These are three physical and direct teams who use set pieces and try and win battles all over the field.
Roy needs to amend his ‘one size fits all ‘ approach and take into account the opposition we are facing.
A case could be made for the inclusion of Dann, Kouyate and even Benteke for these games.
I don’t want a repeat of Lukaku’s second goal yesterday where we lost three challenges in succession.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 28 Feb 19 6.38pm

Originally posted by Painter

Could you explain what a plan B is? Isn’t that making substitutions.

Sometimes. Sometimes it's about changing tactics or formation. If a lone striker isn't working, go to 442. If he's not getting much service through the middle, push up one of your midfielders. If passing the ball around isn't working, stick benteke on and play high balls into him (don't put him on and carry on passing around thd floor). Lots of ways to change thd game, Roy plays the same way and in most cases subs are like fof like.

 

Page 19 of 65 < 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread