This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
With the greatest of respect, the thread is about the 'Run In' and all I did was to post the remaining fixtures of the relegation candidates which I am sure you will conclude is relevant to the debate. What you've done is posted the same conclusion over and over again without showing how you've come to this conclusion when the world out there gives us about a 10% chance of going down. Others have debated with substance and proof. If you're going to post the same position in a thread, at least show why. I cannot see many people away from an Internet forum but in actual real life being able to go about this subject in the way you have and having any credibility given how you don't or cannot answer the questions. Have a think how this stance and conversation would look in a real life situation. And you said at least you had the courage to air your opinion on here. Really.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by dp
This was a good thread. People were coming on and talking about the likelihood that we would stay up / go down, backed up with limited analysis (but that is all that is required). The thread has been derailed because people (a person!) has come on with some fairly contentious views and alluding to having carried out analysis (that they wont share), and generally enjoying winding everyone up. I try and avoid people who argue like this in the pub. So I am going to do the same thing on here. If we all do the same then we can hopefully get the thread back on track. So, for once and for all, can we stop with all of these "Willo" posts. Hear, hear. If the Mods won’t shut down a troll then we have to get on with it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dp
This was a good thread. People were coming on and talking about the likelihood that we would stay up / go down, backed up with limited analysis (but that is all that is required). The thread has been derailed because people (a person!) has come on with some fairly contentious views and alluding to having carried out analysis (that they wont share), and generally enjoying winding everyone up. People have asked for the supporting analysis enough times. We can't engage with the subject without it. It is clear that it is not coming. So continuing to discuss the run-in with these people is not going to (for me) be much fun. I try and avoid people who argue like this in the pub. So I am going to do the same thing on here. If we all do the same then we can hopefully get the thread back on track. So, for once and for all, can we stop with all of these "Willo" posts. What on earth is contentious about predicting we will be relegated ? We are a point off the drop-zone and will slip into it if Southampton beat Chelsea tomorrow. As for the analysis - I do get the impression that far from wanting the details others on here are just using it as an excuse to try and antagonise me and further their agenda against a fellow supporter.At the end of the day the 'Bottom line' is that my predictions have us relegated and I really don't need to detail all the factors which I took into consideration relating to each and every game and why I reached at each and every conclusion.Rather long-winded and inconsequential in terms of this debate. I really don't think I need to respond to those who demand details, posters who seek every opportunity to hurl brickbats in my direction. I certainly don't exist here to raise any hackles - I have given my honest opinion (Which might well prove wrong) and tried to keep this debate on-track.So maybe rather than use this thread as a vehicle for further ordure,posters can actually concentrate on the subject matter which I tried to do by listing the forthcoming fixtures.
Edited by Willo (13 Apr 2018 11.42am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
What on earth is contentious about predicting we will be relegated ? We are a point off the drop-zone and will slip into it if Southampton beat Chelsea tomorrow. As for the analysis - I do get the impression that far from wanting the details others on here are just using it as an excuse to try and antagonise me and further their agenda against a fellow supporter.At the end of the day the 'Bottom line' is that my predictions have us relegated and how I got to that is somewhat irrelevant. I really don't think I need to respond to those who demand details, posters who seek every opportunity to hurl brickbats in my direction. I certainly don't exist here to raise any hackles - I have given my honest opinion (Which might well prove wrong) and tried to keep this debate on-track.So maybe rather than use this thread as a vehicle for further ordure,posters can actually concentrate on the subject matter which I tried to do by listing the forthcoming fixtures.
Its really not.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
What you've done is posted the same conclusion over and over again without showing how you've come to this conclusion when the world out there gives us about a 10% chance of going down. Others have debated with substance and proof. If you're going to post the same position in a thread, at least show why. I cannot see many people away from an Internet forum but in actual real life being able to go about this subject in the way you have and having any credibility given how you don't or cannot answer the questions. Have a think how this stance and conversation would look in a real life situation. And you said at least you had the courage to air your opinion on here. Really. It takes a certain amount of fortitude to state an honest opinion in the knowledge that it might receive some virulent criticism, not only in the present but in the future if by chance we survive. My judgement is my honest and genuine assessment of our prospects and certainly NOT manufactured to attract an adverse reaction. I really think that WILLO v The Rest is not best serving this thread so I shall play my part in trying to keep it on track by patently NOT responding to any further goadings.In actual fact I believe it is probably best I refrain from any further postings on this thread. Edited by Willo (13 Apr 2018 11.52am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
*think
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Willo
What on earth is contentious about predicting we will be relegated ? We are a point off the drop-zone and will slip into it if Southampton beat Chelsea tomorrow.
Only if we lose to weed. Is the rest of your "analysis" equally correct?
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
What on earth is contentious about predicting we will be relegated ? We are a point off the drop-zone and will slip into it if Southampton beat Chelsea tomorrow. As for the analysis - I do get the impression that far from wanting the details others on here are just using it as an excuse to try and antagonise me and further their agenda against a fellow supporter.At the end of the day the 'Bottom line' is that my predictions have us relegated and how I got to that is somewhat irrelevant. I really don't think I need to respond to those who demand details, posters who seek every opportunity to hurl brickbats in my direction. I certainly don't exist here to raise any hackles - I have given my honest opinion (Which might well prove wrong) and tried to keep this debate on-track.So maybe rather than use this thread as a vehicle for further ordure,posters can actually concentrate on the subject matter which I tried to do by listing the forthcoming fixtures.
Quote of the decade.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
Only if we lose to weed. Is the rest of your "analysis" equally correct? Southamption kick-off ay 12.30 and if they win we will slip into the 'Bottom Three' on goal difference.
|
|
|
Yawn !!!!!!!!!
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Southamption kick-off ay 12.30 and if they win we will slip into the 'Bottom Three' on goal difference. Exactly the sort of quibbling, pedantic, pathetic little academic point I expected you to make. The fact that the games are played at different times that day has absolutely no bearing on the standings at the end of the season whatsoever. And the assertion you're purporting to back up is to do with the standings at the end of the season, not at 2.30 tomorrow afternoon. So, is the rest of your "analysis" equally correct? Edited by chateauferret (13 Apr 2018 12.13pm)
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
Exactly the sort of quibbling, pedantic, pathetic little academic point I expected you to make. The fact that the games are played at different times that day has absolutely no bearing on the standings at the end of the season whatsoever. And the assertion you're purporting to back up is to do with the standings at the end of the season, not at 2.30 tomorrow afternoon. So, is the rest of your "analysis" equally correct? Edited by chateauferret (13 Apr 2018 12.13pm) For "Quibbling", "Pedantic" etc etc read FACT. The fact is that should Southampton beat Chelsea in the 12.30 KO we will be in the 'Bottom Three'.My analysis on this is 100% correct.I made no reference to any bearing at the end of the season nor was I purporting as such.etc etc.
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Willo
For "Quibbling", "Pedantic" etc etc read FACT. The fact is that should Southampton beat Chelsea in the 12.30 KO we will be in the 'Bottom Three'.My analysis on this is 100% correct.I made no reference to any bearing at the end of the season nor was I purporting as such.etc etc. Exactly. In other words, the technicality you quoted proves absolutely nothing of any worth. I think I've satisfied myself now that your "analysis" as regards our prospects of survival or relegation is totally bogus and is either so confused as to be worthless or else does not exist at all. Your final sentence above admits as much. Quod erat demonstrandum.
============ |
|
|
This is why he should be ignored. In fact the whole thread has little left to be said on it until there's a game played.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
Exactly. In other words, the technicality you quoted proves absolutely nothing of any worth. I think I've satisfied myself now that your "analysis" as regards our prospects of survival or relegation is totally bogus and is either so confused as to be worthless or else does not exist at all. Your final sentence above admits as much. Quod erat demonstrandum. Hardly a technicality, it is FACT. As of "Nothing of any worth", perhaps being in the 'Bottom Three' could be psychologically more damaging to our players as they play Brighton.Possibly,who knows ? Anyhow, I really don't think there is anything to add on this subject. Edited by Willo (13 Apr 2018 12.49pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
It takes a certain amount of fortitude to state an honest opinion in the knowledge that it might receive some virulent criticism, not only in the present but in the future if by chance we survive. My judgement is my honest and genuine assessment of our prospects and certainly NOT manufactured to attract an adverse reaction. I really think that WILLO v The Rest is not best serving this thread so I shall play my part in trying to keep it on track by patently NOT responding to any further goadings.In actual fact I believe it is probably best I refrain from any further postings on this thread. Edited by Willo (13 Apr 2018 11.52am) Didn't think that would last long
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.