This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
You make me laugh. No matter how hard I try to explain that the EU is democratic, but just in a different way, that I don't want parliament to be secret, just the voting of its members to be done in private, that "silent praying" is fine, but intimidation is not and that whilst persecution is never acceptable, nor is restricting the rights of people not to hear, or give space to, things if they choose not to. Deciding you no longer want to represent someone, or cancelling their booking, is not persecution. It's the precise opposite. It's freedom. I have been watching "Rise of the Nazis" on iPlayer. There are several episodes. Whilst the events themselves are all pretty well known this is a detailed exploration of the motivations and psychological mind sets of the senior Nazis, explained by some very well qualified experts. There are chilling parallels to some attitudes around today, providing lessons which ought never be forgotten. Why do I mention this? If you haven't seen it then take some time and do. It's well worthwhile. Then, perhaps, you will understand. The EU are worse than FIFA
|
|
|
Originally posted by eaglesdare
All us "Conspiracy theorists" continue to be proved correct with each passing day. What a good joke! The only thing that gets proved by conspiracy theorists is that they can spread ever more ridiculous conspiracy theories.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ouzo Dan
Surgical masks exist to stop spittle from landing on a patient. Anything more is cope. As saliva can contain infectious material it makes sense to practise good hygiene. That though is not the only reason they are worn. Coughs and sneezes can pass viruses both ways. Restricting that also makes sense.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
What a good joke! The only thing that gets proved by conspiracy theorists is that they can spread ever more ridiculous conspiracy theories. The difference between conspiracy theorist and the truth is about 6-9 months. Everything has come true that the "Conspiracy theorists" have said about covid. The only thing the Covid Zero / lockdown Zelots are good for is spreading mis-information Edited by eaglesdare (06 Mar 2023 2.35pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
As saliva can contain infectious material it makes sense to practise good hygiene. That though is not the only reason they are worn. Coughs and sneezes can pass viruses both ways. Restricting that also makes sense. Cope
The mountains are calling & I must go. |
|
|
Originally posted by eaglesdare
The difference between conspiracy theorist and the truth is about 6-9 months. Everything has come true that the "Conspiracy theorists" have said about covid. The only thing the Covid Zero / lockdown Zelots are good for is spreading mis-information Edited by eaglesdare (06 Mar 2023 2.35pm) Is just more bs! The enquiry will look at all the evidence, in its context, and determine what lessons are there to be learned should anything similar be faced again. I will be very surprised if it shows that, on balance, not locking down would have likely produced an overall better result. Until then, I reserve my opinion, but believe that in the circumstances at the time, given the knowledge at the time, it was an entirely appropriate decision.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ouzo Dan
Surgical mask weave below Viruses carried on saliva particles
Restricting the distance and spread of a heavy viral load doesn't imply stopping it completely. It means what it says on the tin. It restricts it. Which is better than not restricting it at all. Having to wear a mask during the peak of the pandemic, before people were protected by vaccination, was a small price to pay for any benefit to be obtained. Not least the reassurance it gave to others.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
Masks and hand sanitising were important steps to make in areas of highest concentration of persons. It brought out a lot of the bad/selfish characteristics in people. Which continue, if you read some of the comments here. It wasn't perfect but it was better than not doing it.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Restricting the distance and spread of a heavy viral load doesn't imply stopping it completely. It means what it says on the tin. It restricts it. Which is better than not restricting it at all. Having to wear a mask during the peak of the pandemic, before people were protected by vaccination, was a small price to pay for any benefit to be obtained. Not least the reassurance it gave to others. Completely false, it means exactly what it says on the box. Surgical masks made propagandists like yourself feel better about your choices re Covid.
The mountains are calling & I must go. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ouzo Dan
For the absolute last time Viral particles travel through surgical masks with impunity. If you want to protect yourself & others wear a fully sealed NBC suit with the correct filter for your respirator. Correct re. surgical, although it would of course stop some level of it eg. large droplets with lots of delicious virus. But to your point it wouldn't really make that much difference as they're so porus. Always made me laugh people walking about with cloth masks on. Absolutely useless. However, there always seems to be a lot of confusion when this is discussed because for some reason people decide that because better quality masks don't stop all of the virus, then all masks are useless. This is of course, nonsense. It's more or less impossible to stop ANY of it getting out or through unless you do decide to go full specimen and wear and NBC suit as you describe. But, something like an N95 mask, properly worn and sealed does provide a significant benefit to those around you if you have an infection, or if there are viral particles in the air. Why? Masks like that will lower the amount of viral load expelled or inhaled, which also means reduction in the liklihood of you or others catching something (depending on time spend in the vicinity of course, if you're stuck on a busy train for 2 hours then you're screwed either way) or at the very least getting a big hit of it and therefore getting more sick as a result (basically no/light symptoms vs. heavy symptoms). The other thing people fail to take into account is the behavioural aspect of mask wearing combined with the actual mask wearing itself – it became a signal of caution and awareness that this thing was knocking about and to take a bit more care than usual. If they hadn't of been temporarily adopted then I'd assume infection rates would have been much higher – if we're referring to the latest global studies a lot of the numbers back this up. This was covered ages ago in the old thread, but ultimately it's wrong to claim 'masks don't stop (all) of the virus therefore masks are pointless'. Edited by SW19 CPFC (06 Mar 2023 6.23pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ouzo Dan
For the absolute last time Viral particles travel through surgical masks with impunity. If you want to protect yourself & others wear a fully sealed NBC suit with the correct filter for your respirator. If within droplets they don't travel so far, do they? Some will be trapped by the mask. Fully sealed are better, but any barrier, even a hand or a sleeve is better than nothing. SW19 CPFC has given you a much more comprehensive answer.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Correct re. surgical, although it would of course stop some level of it eg. large droplets with lots of delicious virus. But to your point it wouldn't really make that much difference as they're so porus. Always made me laugh people walking about with cloth masks on. Absolutely useless. However, there always seems to be a lot of confusion when this is discussed because for some reason people decide that because better quality masks don't stop all of the virus, then all masks are useless. This is of course, nonsense. It's more or less impossible to stop ANY of it getting out or through unless you do decide to go full specimen and wear and NBC suit as you describe. But, something like an N95 mask, properly worn and sealed does provide a significant benefit to those around you if you have an infection, or if there are viral particles in the air. Why? Masks like that will lower the amount of viral load expelled or inhaled, which also means reduction in the liklihood of you or others catching something (depending on time spend in the vicinity of course, if you're stuck on a busy train for 2 hours then you're screwed either way) or at the very least getting a big hit of it and therefore getting more sick as a result (basically no/light symptoms vs. heavy symptoms). The other thing people fail to take into account is the behavioural aspect of mask wearing combined with the actual mask wearing itself – it became a signal of caution and awareness that this thing was knocking about and to take a bit more care than usual. If they hadn't of been temporarily adopted then I'd assume infection rates would have been much higher – if we're referring to the latest global studies a lot of the numbers back this up. This was covered ages ago in the old thread, but ultimately it's wrong to claim 'masks don't stop (all) of the virus therefore masks are pointless'. Edited by SW19 CPFC (06 Mar 2023 6.23pm) What was wrong was being dishonest with the public and treating them like children and scaring the living sh1t out of the gullible ones.....some of whom went on to cause grief to anyone who wasn't so easily fooled. In fact the knock on effects were much worse but for brevity I'll stick to this narrow point. What was wrong was allowing the impression to be given that masks were far more effective than the reality. Even surgical masks can only be worn once and then aren't considered effective....can't be touched etc. What was wrong was arresting and fining people or restricting people for not wearing masks. Truth dies when the floor is knowingly left to certain voices who only care about their desired outcomes rather than the actual truth. Everyone was going to get this virus: mask or no mask and lies were told without any consequence.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
What was wrong was being dishonest with the public and treating them like children and scaring the living sh1t out of the gullible ones.....some of whom went on to cause grieve to anyone who wasn't so easily fooled. In fact the knock on effects were much worse but for brevity I'll stick to this narrow point. What was wrong was allowing the impression to be given that masks were far more effective than the reality. Even surgical masks can only be worn once and then aren't considered effective....can't be touched etc. What was wrong was arresting and fining people or restricting people for not wearing masks. Truth dies when the floor is knowingly left to certain voices who only care about their desired outcomes rather than the actual truth. Everyone was going to get this virus: mask or no mask and lies were told without any consequence.
As you know very well, or certainly ought to know, this was never the point. The point was to delay the spread, using every way that could be imagined, to ensure that the NHS wasn't overwhelmed and whilst the vaccines were being developed. Once that had been achieved the brakes came off and all of did get the virus, some of us several times. The vaccines that protected us from severe disease were then boosted by the effects of the infection.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
As you know very well, or certainly ought to know, this was never the point. The point was to delay the spread, using every way that could be imagined, to ensure that the NHS wasn't overwhelmed and whilst the vaccines were being developed. Once that had been achieved the brakes came off and all of did get the virus, some of us several times. The vaccines that protected us from severe disease were then boosted by the effects of the infection. I won't speak on the vaccines for brevity's sake, as it's a different if related point. Ok, I'll answer this debunked NHS point yet again....no doubt you will continue to state it but this point is so irritating it's worth it. But before I do I'll say that looking at the statistics from when masks were first mandated they made no difference to the spread. So your suggestion that they 'delay the spread' doesn't relate to reality (no change there). Anyway, the NHS was never going to be overwhelmed for covid provision.....No, what happened was that everything else practically stopped....which is some of the reason so many have and are dying later. We built several new hospitals just for Covid. The amount of provision was based upon high numbers of severely ill that were never reached. Ok, lets imagine in an alternative universe these numbers were hit then guess what genius. More hospitals and provision would have been provided....covid had an open cheque book in excess of its medical impact. Let me state it again, just in case you weren't taking it in. The NHS was never going to be 'overwhelmed' by this virus. The very word suggests something that is so annoyingly misleading it deserves the 'overwhelming' contempt I feel for it. Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Mar 2023 9.26pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
What was wrong was being dishonest with the public and treating them like children and scaring the living sh1t out of the gullible ones.....some of whom went on to cause grief to anyone who wasn't so easily fooled. In fact the knock on effects were much worse but for brevity I'll stick to this narrow point. What was wrong was allowing the impression to be given that masks were far more effective than the reality. Even surgical masks can only be worn once and then aren't considered effective....can't be touched etc. What was wrong was arresting and fining people or restricting people for not wearing masks. Truth dies when the floor is knowingly left to certain voices who only care about their desired outcomes rather than the actual truth. Everyone was going to get this virus: mask or no mask and lies were told without any consequence.
Yes and no Definitely agree that giving the impression that pieces of cloth and flimsy surgical masks were more effective than they actually were wasn't honest. Also agree that arresting people for not wearing them (did this actually happen? and if it did, en masse?) was too far. Fines, sure. If you need to maintain control in such an unprecedented scenario unprecedented steps will be taken. Scrutiny can then be applied later. There's no time for mollycoddling or meekly fiddling while Rome burns. However I can imagine a scenario where the psychological and behavioural impact of mask wearing also came into the decisions around enforcement at the time – when you're in a corner and you need to think fast, sometimes you've got to make controversial calls that you think will make a difference. 'Everyone was going to get this virus: mask or no mask and lies were told without any consequence.' Everyone was going to get this virus. Yep, agree. Don't agree on the 'without any consequence' assuming you mean mask wearing and all other preventative measure had no positive impact. Quite a statement... and quite clearly mask wearing and the behavioural impact of restrictions and enforcements such as lockdowns that went with it were designed to slow rate of infection down, and reduce severity of infection until such time as a vaccine was well adopted enough to take up the slack. Sure, you can debate the ethics of how those rules were decided upon and enforced, whether lockdowns should have lasted as long as they did – all valid, and again should be properly scrutinised to the next time this happens we're able to make better choices... but to suggest none of these things worked? Not sure how you can reach that conclusion. Ultimately it was decided that the impact of doing nothing far outweighed the temporary impact economic, ethical or otherwise, in a fast moving scenario when 'wait and see' and 'make up your own mind, you're on your own, but your rights are intact so all good' really wouldn't have cut it. Unique scenario, unique approach. Edited by SW19 CPFC (06 Mar 2023 9.54pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.