This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| MrWhyNot |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
As a matter of interest, what is your view on the abortion amendment in the Public Order Bill? It was supported by the overwhelming number of MPs from all parties. I wouldn't like to think we'd go the way of the US, with such an obsessive and polarised view of issues. Many of those very passionate about all but banning abortion there even in cases of rape, care not a jot post birth, or indeed about the Mother. It's easy to hold a 'principle' that costs you nothing. On the flipside, it's certainly possible to go too far in the other direction too and treat a serious matter like a nothing decision. The only point of debate here should be the number of weeks at which an abortion can happen. I would tend to be conservative on that front, and base it on the science, as that largely cancels out the noise on both sides. That being the case, women should have the right to visit abortion clinics without feeling intimidated or harrassed for doing so. It's a personal decision within a family, not one that strangers you've never met get to decide. Edited by MrWhyNot (01 Jan 2023 7.02pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Helmet46
Interesting case this one. The message they refused to put on the cake was ‘support gay marraige.’ If they were gay cake makers and refused to put a message on that said ‘don’t support gay marraige’ would that receive the same level of noise, do you think? Or, would the same people that were so upset at the stance taken by the cake makers be so outraged that someone dare try to get the reverse message on a cake that you’d all be after the people that asked for the message rather than the cake maker? Surely your concern should be with discrimination against any one not just minorities as I believe that the law should be there to protect us all shouldn’t it?
I think your example would have provoked an identical response. Whilst any kind of negative discrimination ought to be of concern certain minorities have suffered more than others. Hence the legislation.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
There was guest house in Cornwall that tried to do just that. For religious reasons they. disapproved of homosexuality but knew they couldn’t openly ban it. So they refused double rooms to same sex couples. That ended in a Court case which they lost. They refused to change so had to close their business. Not the same thing and they were wrong not to honour the booking. As we have pointed out repeatedly the cake shop owners were happy to sell a cake but not with that message. The equivalent to the guest house would be the guests demanding that they be allowed to hang a banner from their bedroom window supporting gay rights, in which case I would support the owners right to say no. You say a lawyer found a loophole (implying its a bad thing) well that's exactly what appeals are all about they nearly always turn on a specific point of law sometimes, you win sometimes you lose. When the SC found against Boris you were all over here supporting them now you don't like what they did in the cake case.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I think your example would have provoked an identical response. Whilst any kind of negative discrimination ought to be of concern certain minorities have suffered more than others. Hence the legislation. Sadly I’m pretty certain it wouldn’t. I accept I’m very cynical (but also a realist) about these things, believe that we are at risk of going too far the other way and balance is being lost. You’re response articulates that to a certain degree. That some have suffered more in the past does not mean that we have to turn the screw past centre and positively discriminate in an attempt to atone for that past. I completely agree, by the way, that many minorities have suffered and we absolutely do need to ensure that doesn’t happen, it’s just the way to do that is not to over-compensate and start behaving with prejudice towards others, in my opinion. What over-compensation can do is to start to turn the silent majority against whatever group it is that they feel are getting better treatment and that is of no benefit to anyone and has the potential to be a huge backward step. The law should be equal for all, regardless of the past.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Not the same thing and they were wrong not to honour the booking. As we have pointed out repeatedly the cake shop owners were happy to sell a cake but not with that message. The equivalent to the guest house would be the guests demanding that they be allowed to hang a banner from their bedroom window supporting gay rights, in which case I would support the owners right to say no. You say a lawyer found a loophole (implying its a bad thing) well that's exactly what appeals are all about they nearly always turn on a specific point of law sometimes, you win sometimes you lose. When the SC found against Boris you were all over here supporting them now you don't like what they did in the cake case. We know why the cake bakers refused to sell the cake. We also know that, on a point of law, the Supreme Court, agreed. I don't argue with the Supreme Court. They must find on the law that is, and not as it might have been intended to be. Many were disappointed and wanted Parliament to ensure that discrimination of this type was included in the legislation. Johnson was also upset at the ruling against him. The difference being that it would have been extremely unlikely for him to get what he wanted through Parliament, whilst amending the discrimination laws ought to sail through. It is discriminatory. Just not, at the moment, unlawfully discriminatory. Your analogy doesn't work. The guest house is owned by the religious objectors, just as the bakery is. Any banner put on display there is on their premises, and would indicate their support or at least compliance. The cake was not going on display. They had no responsibility for, or any interest in, it. They were just carrying out a task they had been contracted to do.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Helmet46
Sadly I’m pretty certain it wouldn’t. I accept I’m very cynical (but also a realist) about these things, believe that we are at risk of going too far the other way and balance is being lost. You’re response articulates that to a certain degree. That some have suffered more in the past does not mean that we have to turn the screw past centre and positively discriminate in an attempt to atone for that past. I completely agree, by the way, that many minorities have suffered and we absolutely do need to ensure that doesn’t happen, it’s just the way to do that is not to over-compensate and start behaving with prejudice towards others, in my opinion. What over-compensation can do is to start to turn the silent majority against whatever group it is that they feel are getting better treatment and that is of no benefit to anyone and has the potential to be a huge backward step. The law should be equal for all, regardless of the past. Of course. I am as against positive discrimination as I am against negative. A level playing field is the aim. Your example would though still be seen as negative in the context you set it.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
We know why the cake bakers refused to sell the cake. We also know that, on a point of law, the Supreme Court, agreed. I don't argue with the Supreme Court. They must find on the law that is, and not as it might have been intended to be. Many were disappointed and wanted Parliament to ensure that discrimination of this type was included in the legislation. Johnson was also upset at the ruling against him. The difference being that it would have been extremely unlikely for him to get what he wanted through Parliament, whilst amending the discrimination laws ought to sail through. It is discriminatory. Just not, at the moment, unlawfully discriminatory. Your analogy doesn't work. The guest house is owned by the religious objectors, just as the bakery is. Any banner put on display there is on their premises, and would indicate their support or at least compliance. The cake was not going on display. They had no responsibility for, or any interest in, it. They were just carrying out a task they had been contracted to do. The only discrimination in these cases is in your fevered imagination.
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
The only discrimination in these cases is in your fevered imagination. Coming from someone who has demonstrated both a total lack of understanding, and the urge to constantly repeat claims that have been completely debunked, the idea that anyone else has a "fevered imagination" is quite amusing.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by MrWhyNot
I wouldn't like to think we'd go the way of the US, with such an obsessive and polarised view of issues. Many of those very passionate about all but banning abortion there even in cases of rape, care not a jot post birth, or indeed about the Mother. It's easy to hold a 'principle' that costs you nothing. On the flipside, it's certainly possible to go too far in the other direction too and treat a serious matter like a nothing decision. The only point of debate here should be the number of weeks at which an abortion can happen. I would tend to be conservative on that front, and base it on the science, as that largely cancels out the noise on both sides. That being the case, women should have the right to visit abortion clinics without feeling intimidated or harrassed for doing so. It's a personal decision within a family, not one that strangers you've never met get to decide. Edited by MrWhyNot (01 Jan 2023 7.02pm) There is a general acceptance among those who feel that abortion must be available in certain circumstances that this should be set at the point of viability. This is the time when any foetus could not survive outside the womb no matter what level of support was made available. That time has been creeping down as science improves.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
There is a general acceptance among those who feel that abortion must be available in certain circumstances that this should be set at the point of viability. This is the time when any foetus could not survive outside the womb no matter what level of support was made available. That time has been creeping down as science improves. I have a child born at 27 weeks.
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrWhyNot
I wouldn't like to think we'd go the way of the US, with such an obsessive and polarised view of issues. Many of those very passionate about all but banning abortion there even in cases of rape, care not a jot post birth, or indeed about the Mother. It's easy to hold a 'principle' that costs you nothing. On the flipside, it's certainly possible to go too far in the other direction too and treat a serious matter like a nothing decision. The only point of debate here should be the number of weeks at which an abortion can happen. I would tend to be conservative on that front, and base it on the science, as that largely cancels out the noise on both sides. That being the case, women should have the right to visit abortion clinics without feeling intimidated or harrassed for doing so. It's a personal decision within a family, not one that strangers you've never met get to decide. Edited by MrWhyNot (01 Jan 2023 7.02pm) Presumably that means you agree with the amendment. Thanks
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
There is a general acceptance among those who feel that abortion must be available in certain circumstances that this should be set at the point of viability. This is the time when any foetus could not survive outside the womb no matter what level of support was made available. That time has been creeping down as science improves. Has this thread become three merged into one? If not, is it about the nuisance's arrest, abortion or homosexual baking?
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
There is no confusion or hypocrisy. The thing you are ignoring is the presence of a discriminatory intention that is unlawful. You are not allowed to discriminate by such as age, sex, colour, religion or sexual orientation. Discriminating by other matters is ok. You may want to check the 2010 equalities act. I working in mental health and disabilty services can be discrimiataed against. Sex based law, single sex spaces, right to carers of the same sex are forms of discrimination.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Pembroke
You may want to check the 2010 equalities act. I working in mental health and disabilty services can be discrimiataed against. Sex based law, single sex spaces, right to carers of the same sex are forms of discrimination. Could you explain that again as I don't understand the point you are making. Are you working in the provision of mental health and disability services?
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Could you explain that again as I don't understand the point you are making. Are you working in the provision of mental health and disability services? As somebody currently just perusing on an otherwise very quiet post Xmas evening, I'd just like to say I was none the wiser either WE although I often attribute that to either my own poor eyesight, lack of concentration or, and most likely, idiocy.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
As somebody currently just perusing on an otherwise very quiet post Xmas evening, I'd just like to say I was none the wiser either WE although I often attribute that to either my own poor eyesight, lack of concentration or, and most likely, idiocy. As the spirit of seasonal goodwill has not yet evaporated and the glow of a 2-0 away win still fresh let me reassure you, you are far from an idiot. Long-winded and annoying sometimes but never an idiot. I may disagree with you, but you are polite and not personal.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
As the spirit of seasonal goodwill has not yet evaporated and the glow of a 2-0 away win still fresh let me reassure you, you are far from an idiot. Long-winded and annoying sometimes but never an idiot. I may disagree with you, but you are polite and not personal. Oh I can ramble for England! I do have bipolar though so whilst abhorrent to blame it on that and perhaps offend others diagnosed similarly I do often read back and consider the possible benefits the effects of stronger medication might have. I am also guilty of posting comments just for my own amusement but well, see aforementioned. Gracias apropos my cognitive capability, compliment returned and Happy New Year sir.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Pembroke
You may want to check the 2010 equalities act. I working in mental health and disabilty services can be discrimiataed against. Sex based law, single sex spaces, right to carers of the same sex are forms of discrimination. Yes, there are cases where you can discriminate. A simple example is restaurants where you can hire for the same ethnicity as the food. Also if you have a strong enough reason along the lines of having a very out of balance workforce. Like aiming to hire more young people when much of your workforce is heading for retirement age. Such dispensations are notoriously hard to justify and are not much used. Care is an area where they do sometimes get used, personal care is usually given by the same sex as the resident. My mother used to say having personal care from a female was disgusting though, she liked the men.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Come on now. The question has to be asked. Would you? Anti Catholic and mysogynistic, just the traits you want in the author of your diversity policy Happy New Year everyone
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Yes, there are cases where you can discriminate. A simple example is restaurants where you can hire for the same ethnicity as the food. Also if you have a strong enough reason along the lines of having a very out of balance workforce. Like aiming to hire more young people when much of your workforce is heading for retirement age. Such dispensations are notoriously hard to justify and are not much used. Care is an area where they do sometimes get used, personal care is usually given by the same sex as the resident. My mother used to say having personal care from a female was disgusting though, she liked the men. Sh1te law. So let's get this right. A production company can hire a black woman to play Ann Boleyn and anyone objecting to this historical abuse gets called a 'racist' and has to tread carefully. But if an 'ethnic' restaurant doesn't want whitey serving up their grub that's totally fine? Man, this country is frigging hilarious. Edited by Stirlingsays (02 Jan 2023 12.51am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.