This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Statues
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
SE9 EAGLE 16 Feb 14 12.29pm |
|
Quote Beastie at 16 Feb 2014 9.36am
Let's be honest, we haven't had any players who are worthy of a statue. We've had very few great players, even fewer at the peak of their career and no one has ever lifted a major trophy for us. Surely to be 'legendary' enough to warrant a statue, it would need to be a recognisable figure in the world of football outside of CPFC.
Absolute bollox.Jim Cannon every time.You sir are a knob....
|
Eagles-Mad Romford Essex 16 Feb 14 2.12pm |
|
|
Geoff Thomas
|
hdoust43 Msidstone 16 Feb 14 2.19pm |
|
Quote DubaiEagleCPFC at 16 Feb 2014 4.46am
We should just have two shiny slapheads of Lombardo and Aj. Then we can all queue up and spam them for good luck before a game.
This is brilliant
|
Beastie 16 Feb 14 2.26pm |
|
Quote SE9 EAGLE at 16 Feb 2014 12.29pm
Quote Beastie at 16 Feb 2014 9.36am
Let's be honest, we haven't had any players who are worthy of a statue. We've had very few great players, even fewer at the peak of their career and no one has ever lifted a major trophy for us. Surely to be 'legendary' enough to warrant a statue, it would need to be a recognisable figure in the world of football outside of CPFC.
Absolute bollox.Jim Cannon every time.You sir are a knob....
Thanks mate. I have to say, Jim Cannon was before my time but as far as I can make out the argument for him is that he played for us for a long time. I don't think that says great things about our club if that's the greatest achievement we can look for. Compare that to other clubs;
Billy Wright Tom Finney Bobby Moore Best/Law/Charlton Alex Ferguson Peter Osgood Brian Clough Billy Wright Bobby Robson Alf Ramsey Stanley Matthews Gordon Banks Thierry Henry Billy Bremner Don Revie Dixie Dean Bill Shankly Jock Stein Jackie Milburn Emlyn Hughes Nat Lofthouse
If we had to do this, I would say it should be Wright & Bright, who were at least iconic in a small way - but I don't think we should do it for the sake of it.
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 16 Feb 14 2.44pm |
|
|
Jim Cannon, Peter Simpson (maybe) or Arthur Waite. Although the latter does have a stand named after him. A statue should be as much a symbol to contribution and achievement, as an individual honour.
All of those three people symbolise something exceptional about Crystal Palace, Football and what the fans experience now.
Certainly Jim Cannon and Arthur Waite are iconic in Palace history. One represents everything we believe a player should be, the other transformed the club itself, as well as embodying the ideal of our club as a local club and part of a community
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
PsychoPaul 16 Feb 14 3.10pm |
|
|
Terry Venables (Drill a hole in the top of his head & pour the molten bronze in!)
|
big_palace_fan 16 Feb 14 3.17pm |
|
|
We should wait for someone who has done something especially spectacular on a larger scale, eg, won a cup, played a lot for their country etc.
I wouldnt want people turning up to Selhurst and seeing a statue outside of an absolute nobody to everyone else except palace fans (have any non palace fans ever heard of Jim Cannon?). It would give ammunition for other fans to be degrading of our history IMO
It would have to be a household name IMO, and we havent had too many of those.
I am really up for things like the wright and bright bar, and Speroni's restaurant, and would like to see this extended (see no reason why it wont be either) but I dont think yet we've had anyone quite at the level to get a statue.
Geoff Thomas, (footballing and his overcoming of his cancer) would get my vote if we had to have a statue.
|
SE9 EAGLE 16 Feb 14 5.44pm |
|
Quote Beastie at 16 Feb 2014 2.26pm
Quote SE9 EAGLE at 16 Feb 2014 12.29pm
Quote Beastie at 16 Feb 2014 9.36am
Let's be honest, we haven't had any players who are worthy of a statue. We've had very few great players, even fewer at the peak of their career and no one has ever lifted a major trophy for us. Surely to be 'legendary' enough to warrant a statue, it would need to be a recognisable figure in the world of football outside of CPFC.
Absolute bollox.Jim Cannon every time.You sir are a knob....
Thanks mate. I have to say, Jim Cannon was before my time but as far as I can make out the argument for him is that he played for us for a long time. I don't think that says great things about our club if that's the greatest achievement we can look for. Compare that to other clubs;
Billy Wright Tom Finney Bobby Moore Best/Law/Charlton Alex Ferguson Peter Osgood Brian Clough Billy Wright Bobby Robson Alf Ramsey Stanley Matthews Gordon Banks Thierry Henry Billy Bremner Don Revie Dixie Dean Bill Shankly Jock Stein Jackie Milburn Emlyn Hughes Nat Lofthouse
If we had to do this, I would say it should be Wright & Bright, who were at least iconic in a small way - but I don't think we should do it for the sake of it.
More bollox!
|
SE9 EAGLE 16 Feb 14 5.53pm |
|
Quote big_palace_fan at 16 Feb 2014 3.17pm
We should wait for someone who has done something especially spectacular on a larger scale, eg, won a cup, played a lot for their country etc.
I wouldnt want people turning up to Selhurst and seeing a statue outside of an absolute nobody to everyone else except palace fans (have any non palace fans ever heard of Jim Cannon?). It would give ammunition for other fans to be degrading of our history IMO
It would have to be a household name IMO, and we havent had too many of those.
I am really up for things like the wright and bright bar, and Speroni's restaurant, and would like to see this extended (see no reason why it wont be either) but I dont think yet we've had anyone quite at the level to get a statue.
Geoff Thomas, (footballing and his overcoming of his cancer) would get my vote if we had to have a statue.
The idea of a statue is not to show off to away fans imo.And if you are waiting for a Cup winning captain or great international player we could be hanging on forever after all we havent had one in over 100 years! To see a clenched fist Jim Cannon,maybe the pose when he scored at Millwall in the last minute would galvanize our fans on arrival at the ground.Over 650 games remember that and even in our worst era his head never dropped.True legend....
|
cols123 beckenham 16 Feb 14 6.13pm |
|
Quote big_palace_fan at 16 Feb 2014 3.17pm
We should wait for someone who has done something especially spectacular on a larger scale, eg, won a cup, played a lot for their country etc.
I wouldnt want people turning up to Selhurst and seeing a statue outside of an absolute nobody to everyone else except palace fans (have any non palace fans ever heard of Jim Cannon?). It would give ammunition for other fans to be degrading of our history IMO
It would have to be a household name IMO, and we havent had too many of those.
I am really up for things like the wright and bright bar, and Speroni's restaurant, and would like to see this extended (see no reason why it wont be either) but I dont think yet we've had anyone quite at the level to get a statue.
Geoff Thomas, (footballing and his overcoming of his cancer) would get my vote if we had to have a statue.
You sir are a modern football fan... having statue outside your ground is not about pleasing or showing off to fans outside our club its about representing our history and should have absolutely f*** all to do with what other people think.
We have had loyal servants to our club over our many years and many candidates that we could honour. Your attiude is that of the modern football fan and everything that is wrong about football today.
Charlton and Southampton have statues of people who could only be known within their clubs history. Pisses me off that you get idiots who think you have to be messi to be honoured. For me that shows a complete lack of understanding of what it means to be a palace fan
|
MKCPFC Spain/MK 16 Feb 14 6.43pm |
|
|
Jim Cannon . No explanation required.
|
Beastie 16 Feb 14 6.57pm |
|
Quote SE9 EAGLE at 16 Feb 2014 5.44pm
More bollox!
F*cking hell you're clever.
If you're going to immortalise a sportsman in bronze it has to be to celebrate achievement. Anything else is an embarrassment and it has nothing to do with modern football.
|
big_palace_fan 16 Feb 14 7.17pm |
|
Quote cols123 at 16 Feb 2014 6.13pm
Quote big_palace_fan at 16 Feb 2014 3.17pm
We should wait for someone who has done something especially spectacular on a larger scale, eg, won a cup, played a lot for their country etc.
I wouldnt want people turning up to Selhurst and seeing a statue outside of an absolute nobody to everyone else except palace fans (have any non palace fans ever heard of Jim Cannon?). It would give ammunition for other fans to be degrading of our history IMO
It would have to be a household name IMO, and we havent had too many of those.
I am really up for things like the wright and bright bar, and Speroni's restaurant, and would like to see this extended (see no reason why it wont be either) but I dont think yet we've had anyone quite at the level to get a statue.
Geoff Thomas, (footballing and his overcoming of his cancer) would get my vote if we had to have a statue.
You sir are a modern football fan... having statue outside your ground is not about pleasing or showing off to fans outside our club its about representing our history and should have absolutely f*** all to do with what other people think.
We have had loyal servants to our club over our many years and many candidates that we could honour. Your attiude is that of the modern football fan and everything that is wrong about football today.
Charlton and Southampton have statues of people who could only be known within their clubs history. Pisses me off that you get idiots who think you have to be messi to be honoured. For me that shows a complete lack of understanding of what it means to be a palace fan
Season ticket for 15 years, very modern
|
Bekken 16 Feb 14 7.20pm |
|
|
Special mention to Itzik Zohar, Ade Akinbiyi, Thomas Brolin but for me id like to see Mr Marange forever remembered at Selhurst
|
Mr Palaceman 16 Feb 14 7.21pm |
|
|
Your all wrong.....
Staffie....
Palace Leadge.. I've watched nearly every game this season, even though I've only managed to get to 4.
"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"
Stan Laurel
|
merganser 16 Feb 14 10.10pm |
|
|
What about Wilf? As I recall, he was quite useful. But then again, so was Dougie.
|
PA Bedfordshire 16 Feb 14 10.51pm |
|
|
Dave Madden
|
seeweedhater London 17 Feb 14 12.03am |
|
|
Jolly Rodger.
|
Percy of Peckham Eton Mess 17 Feb 14 12.14am |
|
|
If we can only honour one man then it has to be Jim Cannon!!!!
Denial is not just a river in Egypt!
|
serial thriller The Promised Land 17 Feb 14 12.51am |
|
|
Stuart Green.
Or the Fulham route, get one of Otis Redding. Great voice.
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4
|